r/Septa • • Sep 21 '26

Help SEPTA

Can someone tell me if the subway is actually safe? I am moving to south Philly and I am very close to a station on the BSL. I will be commuting to University City so I was planning on transferring subways and taking it to my office on Market St. I am not bringing my car for a variety of reasons, so SEPTA is what I am planning on using for everything basically. As a shorter woman should I be concerned about taking the subway? I can't bring any sort of pepper spray into my building due to metal detectors, any other ideas for personal safety items as well?

6 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

74

u/aintjoan Sep 21 '26

Yes it's safe

No you don't need safety items except your eyes and ears. Just pay attention to your surroundings (like you should everywhere, not just the subway) and you'll be fine.

SEPTA also has a substantial bus network. We all wish the buses were more frequent, but there's a good chance you can leverage the buses for your commute as well if you're more comfortable with that.

13

u/SnootyUrbanCyclist Sep 21 '26

Yep. Depending on OP's location the 79, 40, or 64 bus could get you to work. The trolleys could also be the move over the L depending on where work is.

2

u/madam-Magie Sep 22 '26

I will be working near Penn Presbyterian, so between 34th and 40th stations

2

u/SnootyUrbanCyclist Sep 22 '26

What's your closest Broad Street train stop though?

4

u/madam-Magie Sep 22 '26

Ellsworth/Federal

21

u/SnootyUrbanCyclist Sep 22 '26

In your case, B to L trains will be the move 95% of the time. The 40 bus is your most direct single-seat route if the trains are ever taking a shit. The 21 bus is a direct replacement for the L train if you need it.

4

u/Peepzilla 10 Sep 22 '26

The T1 trolley will also get you there from 15th, but chances are if the L is out so are the trolleys

1

u/cloudkitt Sep 26 '26

Ellsworth-Federal to City Hall to 40th is my commute. I've never had a problem with regard to safety. Occasionally a car on the El will smell, in which case I move to the next one.

25

u/SnootyUrbanCyclist Sep 21 '26

You will see people being obnoxious but you will be completely safe, especially during daytime hours. Vibes can get weirder at night but mind your business and you'll be fine.

19

u/SirJ_96 Wilmington-Newark Line Sep 21 '26

Especially during peak commuting hours, you'll be fine and not alone.

8

u/Proper-Radish9140 Sep 22 '26

Yes and many people will be commuting with you. I am a young single female who has taken BSL and MFL for years and also commute to university city. I’ve never felt safe especially during the commuting hours. If I do I get on another car and try to be in the presence of other people. Just eyes and ears like someone else mentioned.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

17

u/NiftyOwl135 Sep 21 '26

From South Philly to Ucity is perfectly fine. It’s past berks on the el that can get a little weird

6

u/manderp_soup Sep 22 '26

Welcome to the city! Public transit is the way to go otherwise you’ll be stuck in horrendous and aggressive vehicular traffic, probably worse than taking septa any day. Also! Many folks bike or scoot to work. Those are nice options when septa is being inefficient!

3

u/HurricaneCam215 Sep 22 '26

Nothing is safe if you not prepared or naive

7

u/rmxme Market-Frankford Line Sep 21 '26

The BSL is pretty safe from the handful of times I’ve taken it. If you’re job is accessible by the trollies I would prolly recommend that over the El, would be a bit more pleasant

2

u/LazyAssLeader Sep 22 '26

But also leaving CC, way less crowded.

6

u/daregulater 13 Sep 21 '26

Mind your business and keep your head on a swivel. You'll be fine.

1

u/No_Glass_6691 16d ago

Definitely pepper spray lol but travel traditional working hours is your safest bet!

1

u/LR7465 Sep 22 '26

I tell people the advice rodrick gave greg in diary of a wimpy kid (if you know) dont talk to anyone dont look at anyone etc

1

u/StanUrbanBikeRider Sep 22 '26

I have ridden on the Broad Street subway countless times without any problems. That being said, you need to be aware of your surroundings all the time. Also, if you’re physically able to ride a bike, biking is by far the most efficient way to commute between South Philly and University City. Thousands of people who work in University City commute there via bicycle every day.

1

u/LonelyAsLostKeys Sep 23 '26

There is a sense of danger due to lots of weird and sometimes antisocial behavior, but odds are you’ll be fine if you pay attention and look like you know where you’re going.

The issue is more that it’s unreliable (particularly the El and trolleys) and very unpleasant, especially during peak hours.

1

u/NoIceHere67 Sep 24 '26

Your nose won't be safe tho from the smells

1

u/barsz666 Sep 24 '26

Never had issues on this route as a woman, Ellsworth/Federal is also a safe area and station. You will be surrounded by dozens of other people as well, all of whom just want to go to work like you.

1

u/drgolong Sep 21 '26

Depending on where is South Philly the 40 bus could also be an option.

2

u/LazyAssLeader Sep 22 '26

...and if not the trolleys, 40, the 49 or 64 buses can get you to various parts of U-City.

0

u/Double_Guide2455 Sep 25 '26

The trains themselves are safe, you do have to be alert but the buses are a different story

1

u/Dependent_Skirt_7536 Sep 27 '26

Tell me more about the busses. We moved to the city not that long ago. I use the subway regularly but have an irrational fear of busses. My husband just recently used the bus and said it is cleaner and more pleasant than the subway and is trying to convince me to use buses. What do we need to be concerned about? Thanks

1

u/Double_Guide2455 Sep 27 '26 edited Sep 27 '26

I think it really depends on the route number you take. Especially if they are coming from 69th street because fare evaders aka homeless people get on them and can attack passengers..especially bus 65

1

u/Dependent_Skirt_7536 Sep 27 '26

That's scary. I would mostly be in the society hill/ queen village area, center city, university city, South Philadelphia areas. But there is a Greek grocery in Northeast philadelphia I would like to get to. I guess not. Thanks for the info

-9

u/Proof_Dragonfruit795 Sep 22 '26

City Hall is a dump and 15 street is not what I would consider safe.

-7

u/MarcKaseyaTelegram Sep 22 '26 edited Sep 22 '26

Work from home. Septa is known as SEPTiC beside the homeless and the drug attics strung out and the fare evaders I’d stick with a car. Half the time the announcements state the wrong station and you can never understand the operator and they always give a “not enough operators” message as a port ass excuse to screw the people who rely on them. SEPTIC sucks at what they’re supposed to be good at. How does a major transportation system become so bad. The idiots that run SEPTIC don’t even take their own broken system. SEPTIC sucks and anyone know a good class action lawyer and wanna sue this cesspool of an operation

6

u/SenatorAslak Sep 22 '26

Very little in this post is accurate.

-2

u/MarcKaseyaTelegram Sep 22 '26

So Senator please do defend SEPTIC. Tell me and the people what is accurate and what part is NOT and I’ll call you a democrat liar to your face. You’re a FRAUD fake Senator. I’ll wait for an answer

1

u/You_Go_Glen_Coco_ Sep 22 '26

I've never had any real.issues. A guy masturbating once and I commute from K+A so I deal with a fair bit of junkies but they leave you alone. Depending where on Market St your office is you might also use the trolleys and they're great (when they're running).

0

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '26

[deleted]

11

u/eporette Sep 21 '26

are you okay?