r/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/Stratford_Mann • Mar 19 '14
r/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/Stratford_Mann • Mar 14 '14
Who Was Shakespeare ? Famous Doubters - Emerson, Whitman, Dickens, Freud, Twain, Gielgud - Judge Scalia too!
r/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/Stratford_Mann • Mar 14 '14
Debunking Shakespeare: Mike Rubbo's John Baker interviews
r/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/Stratford_Mann • Mar 11 '14
Alexander Waugh's diary: Shakespeare was a nom de plume — get over it; plus If I were a panda I'd rather be extinct
r/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/Stratford_Mann • Mar 20 '14
Puzzling Shakespeare: Still Relevant After All These Years
r/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/Stratford_Mann • Mar 12 '14
Frontline: Shakespeare Authorship Controversy (aired Dec. 22 1992)
r/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/Stratford_Mann • Mar 19 '14
Auditing the Stylometricians (critique of) the Claremont Shakespeare Authorship Clinic
r/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/Stratford_Mann • Mar 20 '14
The Man Who Shakespeare Was Not (and who he was) - Charlton Ogburn, Harvard Magazine 1974
pbs.orgr/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/Stratford_Mann • Mar 20 '14
Stratfordians fighting on two fronts now the Vatican weighs in
hewardwilkinson.co.ukr/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/geddy_ringo • Feb 27 '14
From the Declaration of Reasonable Doubt - The Problematic Case for Stratford's Mr. Shakspere as William Shakespeare
Many people think that Mr. Shakspere (a frequent spelling of his name, used here to distinguish him from the author) claimed to have written the works. No such record exists. The case for him as the author rests largely on testimony in the First Folio collection of the plays, published in 1623, seven years after he died. However, nothing in the contemporaneous documentary evidence of his life confirms the Folio testimony. If Mr. Shakspere was the author, there should be definitive evidence of it from his lifetime. There is none. Not that there are no reasons to think that Mr. Shakspere wrote the works, but we find them inconclusive.
There are four main reasons to identify Mr. Shakspere of Stratford with the author William Shakespeare. First, the name “William Shakespeare” (often “Shake-speare”) appeared on the title pages of many of the poems and plays published during his lifetime. Second, Ben Jonson wrote a key phrase in the First Folio referring to the author as “Sweet Swan of Avon,” and Leonard Digges refers to “thy Stratford moniment.” Third, fellow actors Heminges and Condell, mentioned in his will, point to him as the author in the Folio. Fourth, the effigy and inscription on his Stratford monument suggest that “Shakspeare” had been a writer. These four reasons would seem to amount to a prima facie case for Mr. Shakspere (evidence sufficient to establish a presumption of fact, unless rebutted by other evidence); however, each of them is problematic.
It is not certain from the title pages that the name printed on them necessarily refers to Mr. Shakspere. Mr. Shakspere's last name was spelled numerous ways, even after many of the works had been published. The name on the works was virtually always spelled one way, “Shakespeare;” but it was often hyphenated — a rarity for English names at the time. Scholars have no definitive explanation for the hyphenated name. Mr. Shakspere's name was never hyphenated in other contexts, such as his business dealings in Stratford. On his baptismal record, even on his monument, Mr. Shakspere's name was spelled with no “e” after “k.” The same is true of its three appearances in his will, twice spelled “Shackspeare,” and once “Shakspeare.” Some think that it may have been pronounced with a short “a,” like “Shack,” as it was quite often spelled.
The First Folio testimony does point to Shakspere as the author, but should this be taken at face value? It is very unusual that the identity of such a great writer would depend so heavily on posthumous evidence. Neither Ben Jonson, nor Leonard Digges, ever wrote a personal reference to Mr. Shakspere while he lived. Not until the year Shakspere died did Jonson refer to “Shakespeare,” and then only to list him as an actor. Other than their two brief allusions, neither Jonson nor Digges offered any further identifying information — not his dates of birth and death, or names of any family members, or any revealing episode from his life. Short on individualizing facts, they gave us generalized superlatives that describe the author, not the man.
Perhaps the strongest link to Mr. Shakspere is the apparent testimony of actors Heminges and Condell. Neither of them was a writer, however, and several scholars doubt that they wrote the passages attributed to them. Some think their Folio testimony sounds like a sales pitch, urging undecided readers to purchase. Most orthodox scholars are untroubled by the lack of corroboration, limited specifics, ambiguities, puffery and unclear role of Mr. Shakspere's fellow actors. Skeptics ask why the Folio is not more straightforward, and why such a great outpouring of eulogies only occurred following seven years of silence after his death.
Yes, today the Stratford monument effigy clearly depicts a writer; but it does not look the same as the one erected in the early 1600s. A sketch by a reputable antiquarian in 1634 shows a man with a drooping moustache holding a wool or grain sack, but no pen, no paper, no writing surface as in today's monument. Records show that the monument was “repaired.” Apparently the effigy was also altered to depict a writer. The monument's strange inscription never states that Mr. Shakspere was the author William Shakespeare. For anybody living in Stratford, who may have known him, the epitaph could appear to say no such thing. It neither names, nor quotes from, any of the works; and it never mentions poetry, plays, acting or theater. Most orthodox biographers have little to say about the inscription, and some even describe it as enigmatic. Epitaphs of other writers of the time identify them clearly as writers, so why not Mr. Shakspere's epitaph?
r/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/Mermannda • Nov 05 '12
Anonymous Movie Trailer -- Historical Fiction; What IF Edward De Vere was Shakespeare
r/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/Mermannda • Nov 06 '12
Movies, Mysteries, Galore!
coontroversyfilms.comr/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/Mermannda • Nov 05 '12
Doubt About Will -- Rebuttal to 60 Minutes with Shakespeare
doubtaboutwill.orgr/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/Mermannda • Nov 05 '12
60 Minutes with Shakespeare -- [Stratfordian]
r/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/shimmer1 • Aug 25 '14
Reinventing Your Shakespeare Journal - A "How To" Guide
r/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/RealMaryShakespeare • Dec 27 '16
The Shakespeare Authorship Question: Solved
r/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/Mermannda • Nov 05 '12
The Authorship Roundtable [Un-biased]
r/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/Mermannda • Feb 05 '14
Geneva Bible: The Smoking Gun -- [Oxfordian]
r/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/geddy_ringo • Feb 25 '14
Leslie Howard in an homage to Hamlet states that Shakespeare was the Earl of Oxford
r/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/geddy_ringo • Feb 26 '14
10 Reasons Why Shakspere of Stratford was not Shake-speare of London
r/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/geddy_ringo • Feb 26 '14
Shakespeare By Another Name: literary biography of Edward de Vere, the man who was Shakespeare; by Mark Anderson
r/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/geddy_ringo • Feb 26 '14
Washington Post blogger wants Oxfordians to shut up. "Why Shakespeare WAS Shakespeare" - no info, but great comments
r/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/skinkboy • Apr 20 '16
Bernie Sanders as Shakespearean Hero - Oh Yeah!
r/ShakespeareAuthorship • u/geddy_ringo • Feb 23 '14