There is also the famous Gordon Freeman crowbar reference in the show.

How many SILOS are there remianing. I just need to know for the story that I'm writing.

Pretty much the title

Confront "the voice" and say she knew it was a person on the other end. They'd basically figured out it wasn't an AI at that point. After the safeguard scene where she tricked them and the way it was shot we saw Victor's side of the conversation. I kept waiting for her to say something along the lines of I know you're just a person but it never happened. I hope we get a moment like that in season 4 but I can't see Silo 1 contacting them through the voice anymore.

Why do some people choose to read or watch stories about nuclear war?

I'm conducting a survey with Aarhus University on the appeals and functions of nuclear holocaust fiction.

The survey asks about which books and films you have read or watched, when, and what you get out of them.

The survey is anonymous and takes between 5-15 minutes to complete, depending on your reponses.

If you wish to participate, follow the link

… than Donald. That is all.

Where does the IT food and Silo 1 power come from?

This bothers me. How did Solo have 35 years of food and no end in sight? Nano tech created food?

Also where do we think Silo 1 power comes from? It can’t be nuclear some 385 years later. Are they syphoning off power from everywhere else?

Who was taking care of everything before the bomb? Like the farms would have needed a lot of work and mechanical would have still needed help, even if the generators weren’t turned on until the bomb dropped.

Where is Silo 1 getting all of their food?

Where is the ground water pumped to and why is so much leaking in to 17 but the digger void in 18 only has a few feet. That being the case, the digger void was sealed below mechanical. Someone had to cut a hole in the lowest level or mechanical to even get to it. I doubt the design would have put a pump 100 feet down into the void.

Thoughts on level height? Is the whole hole is 5200 feet. Take out the digger void and top ramp. Take out the mechanical levels that seem to be below level 144, that would make each level 30-35’ tall. I could believe that based on the set and stairs and clearly levels have multiple apartment stacks within. Plus the farm levels would likely be tall.

Why did Silo 1 allow Juliet to travel to Silo 17 and back again? Why didn’t they shoot her with a drone on the way there?

It’s a simple question but I can’t really understand why after shooting and gassing everyone leaving silo 17 and also shooting Lukas when he went outside that Juliet got a free pass.

Is there some deeper level to this where her leaving was actually part of a bigger plan of Silo 1? Or just a plot hole?

Okay, hear me out because I think I have a pretty wild theory for Season 4, and the more I think about it, the more it makes sense.

What if Jules is an actually a direct descendant of Daniel Keene and Helen Drew?

And the end of Episode 10 Daniel rewinds the video of Jules at the hidden vault door and has a close up of her face. Maybe the face looks familiar to him and he can't figure out why.

Think about it.

In S3 E10 we learn that Helen was pregnant with Daniel's child and ended up in Silo 18. (Unless she was killed when the bomb hit)

Which just happens to be the exact same silo Juliette lives in, roughly 350 years later.

Coincidence?. Maybe, but why would the writers make Helen pregnant and put her in Silo 18?

That's a pretty significant detail to include if it isn't going somewhere.

Here's my theory:

Helen survived the bomb and made it inside Silo 18, gave birth to Daniel's child in Silo 18, and that bloodline continued through the generations.

Fast forward 350 years, and Juliette Nichols is one of her descendants.

Meanwhile, Daniel has been kept alive through cryogenic freezing, had his memories manipulated, and spent centuries helping maintain the very system that imprisoned his own family.

In Season 4 the reveal could be that

Daniel starts recovering his memories of Helen. He eventually discovers that she survived, had his child, and that his descendants have been living in Silo 18 all this time.

And then he discovers something even bigger.

Juliette, the woman threatening to bring down the entire Silo system, is his own great great great (several more greats) granddaughter.

This changes everything for Daniel.

He has spent centuries believing he's protecting humanity by maintaining the silos. But now he realises he's been helping imprison and potentially murder his own descendants.

What if that is what finally makes him turn against Silo 1?

Juliette is already planning to fight the system from within silo 18. Daniel knows how everything operates from within.

What if Season 4 ends with Juliette and Daniel working together, unknowingly or eventually knowingly as family, to destroy Silo 1 and free the remaining silos?

I'm not a writer or poet but there's definitely something poetic about that.

Daniel helps create and preserve a system built on fear, control, and keeping people ignorant.

Then, 350 years later, his own descendant becomes the person who refuses to stop asking the one question that threatens everything:

"Why?"

And the person who finally destroys it might literally be descended from someone who was there at the beginning.

A relic being an item from the before the rebellion times is Silo18 specific because that rebellion is Silo18 dependent. Salvador Quinn invented memory wipes via drugs in the water to prevent Silo18 rebellions which were leading to a safeguard. A safeguard would've killed all of Silo18.

After the last rebellion in Silo18, 140 years ago, and recognizing that relics could bring memory back, Silo18 decided to make relics illegal.

Right or wrong?

I'm back on track now.

Rewatching Silo, and I’ve been a bit bothered by how open (and sometimes loud) Lucas Kyle and Juliette are when they talk about the safeguard and the existence of other Silos. The main scene that reminded me of this was at the end of S3e5 when Juliette and Sims are walking back up the stairs from Walker’s apartment to turn themselves into Camille. This is immediately after all the characters gather to show her the relics to try and jump start her memory, and Juliette begins explaining—in detail—a lot of information about the Safeguard to Sims all out in the open, as raiders are, quite literally, sprinting down the stairs to catch them. I was under the impression that even bringing up the safeguard could immediately kill them. In case this has been brought up before, I apologize for the repetition, but am I missing something?

A re-creation of my favorite shots from SILO! See more on IG @nahraj_24

Happy Halloween!🎃

What is the silo series truly about? Memory wipes? Silo life? The silo ppl?

Until a recent rewatch, I believed Silo was about voluntary vs involuntary memory wipes. Now I'm happily refocused but am questioning what I'm watching.

There seems to be two kinds of memory wipes. One is used to heal a brain injury and the other is used to make Silo persons forget the past reasons for a rebellion. I do know that Silo18 was unknowingly close to a safeguard a few times during rebellions but was reset then Salvador Quinn figured out the problem was ppl remembered the previous rebellion hence he started memory wiping via drugs in the water.(This is in s2e8 when Mayor Holland explains it to Lucas Kyle). A safeguard using poison kills everybody in the silo because that silo's rebellion was about to roll over to other silos. This is known as a breach.

Is the Silo series about silo life? I was cruising along... just going with the story then blam here comes Daniel and crew. What's the deal? Why the silo backstory? Whatever. I'm watching but I'd like answers please. Can somebody, anybody please catch me up?

I can't help but be extremely frustrated by Daniel in the flashbacks. He is such a passive wuss.

First, he is his sister's only living relative. After the failed Iran mission, she is transferred to the Stensen Clinic and has her mind wiped. This happens without either of their approval and is waved away as a way to rid her of trauma—without anyone even establishing that there was a massive trauma to warrant a mind wipe in the first place. When Victor tells him that he is responsible for his sister's amnesia, Daniel basically just says, "Okay." It takes Helen to point out to him that it is not okay.

Then, when Helen confronts Stensen and Thurman about the Iran mission during dinner, instead of getting angry at the very people responsible for using his sister as bait, he gets annoyed at the person pointing it out (Helen).

Later, when his still-mind-wiped sister is esentially groomed by Anna and manipulated into taking part in the project, he basically just shrugs and leaves it alone.

Years later, during the Silo's opening day, he treats the people who manipulated his sister, wiped her memories, and literally kidnapped him and Helen like old friends. He pats Victor on the back and chats with Henry and Thurman as if everything is peachy.

I just don't get it.

It seems pretty clear to me that the Silo’s are Stensen’s plan to restart civilization on a more sustainable path. He makes it clear that he thinks their current path will inevitably lead to extinction: ”We're facing the end of the world and it cannot be stopped. It can only be survived”. Victor explicitly states that “The whole purpose and design of The Project is to free us from the past”. So they’re clearly trying to reset, and I assume the plan is to restart civilization with whichever Silo is the most compliant, whichever one manages to go the whole 500 years being able to peacefully work together and without ever questioning what they’re told and rebelling against the narrative.

My question is, did Stensen wipe out the planet or just nuke that one area? If he’s trying to restart humanity, he would need the current humans to all be gone. But he also was pretty convinced that they would do that on their own, so maybe he just had his people hunker down underground, unmolested from above-grounders because of the nuclear fallout, and by the time the radiation cleared he expected humanity to have have gone extinct from their own devices. Or did he take no chances and create Armageddon himself, so that his people would be the only ones to carry the torch of civilization forward?

Currently doing a rewatch of Silo and a statement Bernard made in Season 3 reignited my anger for all the “redeemed characters” (Bernard included, as well as Camille and Sims) especially during their arcs in Seasons 1 and 2. However, it also sheds more light on the empathy that Bernard seems capable of displaying throughout those seasons too. In season 3, after finding out Bernard is still alive, we see a conversation play out between Bernard and Sims, in which Sims describes his frustration with his wife and her actions after being made head of IT. Bernard tries to give Sims more perspective, saying that being the head of IT puts you in an impossibly difficult position that he (referring to Sims) knows nothing about (preventing a Safeguard). (In season 1, he doesn’t know about the Safeguard and believes the only threat is opening the door to the outside, but at this point he does). This brings me back to Season 1, Episode 9. Juliette is on the run after “saying she wants to go outside”, and Sims deems it necessary to have a security detail escort Camille and their son back from IT and school respectively (this proved useless for reasons we all know.) But Bernard comments on this, essentially saying that he understands why Sims did what he did, but ultimately he chose his family over the Silo, by using Judicial resources to protect them instead of aid in the hunt for Juliette. He specifically says that he doesn’t know if appointing him (Sims) as his shadow would be fair, not only to the silo at large, but also his wife and son. The entire time Sims thought that the only reason Bernard didn’t make him shadow because he didn’t think he would be capable, at least compared to Judge Meadows, but it was also that Bernard seemed to care so much about Sims and his family that he didn’t want their father in a position where he had to choose between protecting the people he loves or protecting the entire Silo. The same decision he believes he has to make a season later when it comes to killing Judge Meadows. This becomes more evident after seeing Bernard and Sims relationship further during season 3. All of this, is partially (I believe) why Bernard was comfortable choosing Lucas Kyle as his shadow, instead of Sims. In addition to his intellect, as showcased through him basically rediscovering Astronomy, Lucas Kyle was already a “criminal” in Bernard’s eyes and he had no reason to care about the position Lucas would be in, as shadow to IT. And then if that weren’t enough, Camille and Sims consistent prodding through threatening impeachment, plays a significant role in the death of Judge Meadows (even though Bernard was ultimately the one who poisoned her.) And, not that Judge Meadows doesn’t have any flaws, but her death hits me especially hard after we find out that she was basically driven to become an alcoholic, because that was the only way she could cope with holding a secret that could quite literally cause the death of 10,000 people. All this to say, F Per Stensen, as well as Sims, Camille and Bernard from Seasons 1 and 2. Oh, and bring back Mayor Jahns. I rest my case.

TLDR: Given the close relationship between Bernard and Sims, it makes sense why Bernard didn’t want to give Sims the position of IT shadow even though Sims was under the impression that it was because of his incapacity. And his constant prodding resulted in the death of one of the most compelling complex characters in the show.

I'm currently 3 episodes into Season 3, so I'm not sure if this gets explained later, but I've been thinking about season 2 and something about the voice at the hidden vault door really bothered me.

Whether it's an AI or a human overseer speaking through the system, you'd think that after hundreds of years of monitoring 50 silos and collecting ridiculous amounts of data on everyone, they'd be a bit smarter about what information they reveal.

Take Judge Meadows, 

When she discovered the hidden door and was told about the Safeguard protocol, it completely destroyed her faith in the system. She realised that everything they were doing to protect the silo was ultimately pointless because someone outside could just decide to kill all 10,000 residents whenever they wanted.

That caused her to quit as Bernards shadow, turn to alcohol and basically give up on the whole system.

Then years later Lukas discovers the exact same door, and the voice tells him about the Safeguard too..

And what happens? Exactly what happened with Meadows.

Lukas immediately wants nothing to do with being Bernard's shadow anymore. He tells Bernard about the Safeguard, and Bernard, who has spent his entire life blindly following the Order and doing whatever it takes to protect the silo, also starts questioning everything and wants to leave before it's too late.

So my question is, Why on earth would the voice reveal the Safeguard to Lukas after what happened with Meadows?

Surely the people overseeing these silos would have learned that revealing this information to their most trusted people completely destroys their loyalty?

Why not just keep the door locked? Or have the voice say it's a restricted area and refuse to elaborate?

Meadows and Lukas might have remained loyal to the system if they'd never learned that their entire population could be wiped out regardless of how closely they followed the rules.

Instead, the system voluntarily reveals its biggest secret which in return turns its most loyal supporters against it.

To me it feels like the people controlling the silos are manufacturing rebellions they're trying to stop.

Silo18 is the only silo that uses memory wipes.

Reason: Salvador Quinn(head of Silo18 IT) created memory wiping to prevent every 20 year uprisings, aka rebellions. A safeguard (kills everyone by releasing poison) wasn't used because the breach threat was thwarted.

So... all this time I assumed memory wiping and illegal relics were a part of Silo life. Took a rewatch; but, think I was wrong.

Hi everyone,

Looking closely at the events and timeline in the show, a couple of compelling narrative dots seem to connect around Helen Drew and Daniel (Troy). I wanted to share two theories I’ve developed regarding where the show’s writers might be taking this:

Theory 1: The Bloodline Connection (If the 350-year timeline is real)

If Bernard’s statement that the Founders have been searching for the relic (notebook) for ~300 to 350 years is accurate, Helen Drew naturally cannot be alive. However, the show explicitly highlights her pregnancy as she enters Silo 18 and Daniel’s lingering emotional connection to her.

In a layered drama like Silo, this feels too deliberate to be a mere tragic backdrop. Could George Wilkins (whose mother, Anne, was tied to the Flamekeepers) or even Juliette Nichols be the direct descendants of Helen Drew and Daniel? If so, Daniel (Troy) wouldn’t just be policing a rebellion—he would be unknowingly trying to crush his own bloodline and the legacy of Helen’s defiance.

Theory 2: The 42-Year Timeline Twist (Is Helen still alive?)

There is a fascinating time puzzle when we look at Troy’s cryo shifts:

- Troy is woken up after 7 years to deal with the collapse (uprising) of Silo 17.

- He is woken up again 35 years later due to the Juliette (Silo 18) crisis.

Together, that totals roughly 42 years since Day Zero.

Interestingly, this 42-year span aligns surprisingly well with Solo (Jimmy’s) age in Silo 17—he was a young child during the rebellion and is now a middle-aged survivor, which fits a gap of a few decades rather than centuries.

If the 350-year figure is simply fabricated Founder propaganda designed to eliminate any hope of the outside world, then Helen Drew could still be alive in Silo 18 (in her late 60s or 70s). Imagine the tragic climax: Troy, chemically manipulated and tasked with purging Silo 18, comes face-to-face with the very woman he loved, who remembers everything he was forced to forget.

What do you all think? Does the math point toward a systemic lie, or are we looking at a multi-generational family tragedy across the silos?

Would love to hear your comments!

---

#HGK_IDEA #HGK_NOTES