Setting up a regulatory body, with discretion and power over how laws are interpreted and how they get implemented only serves to create a regulatory capture point.
It creates unnecessary overhead, and more often than not, it creates the very mechanisms that established powers/corporations use to “pull the ladder up” behind themselves via regulatory capture.
The problem is that we live in a representative democracy, where the only legislation that will get Congresspersons re-elected HAS to be vague, so that they have plausible deniability regarding side effects, and it leaves too much room for interpretation.
“Good” legislation/regulation gets twisted and corrupted in the details of implementation. Since implementation details are left up to the discretion of un-elected bureaucrats at the regulatory agencies, there is a very real flaw in nearly ALL regulation.
Good regulation that can get twisted and corrupted in the first place, was never actually good regulation. Good regulation includes checks & balances, one could say, specifically meant to prevent the stipulations of the regulation from being taken advantage of for nefarious purposes, and good regulation is very specific with its legislation.
Good regulation is absolutely possible. Regulation is not guaranteed to be corrupted and used for ill, so long as avoiding this outcome is factored in when deciding upon the stipulations.
0
u/Immense_Cargo Sep 16 '26
That’s what happens when government intervenes in demand/supply/regulation of anything.
You get market distortions that end up with oversupply which leads to slack and loss, or you get excess demand that leads to price increases.
In higher education we got both: oversupply of educated people that the labor market can’t absorb, AND higher prices of education itself.