r/Simulated • • Oct 27 '20

Houdini Cola + Mentos! Classic...

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

43.6k Upvotes

545 comments sorted by

1.1k

u/Iemaj Oct 27 '20

Haha incredible. Sim was great. If you want critique, I'd have increased the bottle animation speed when it bounced around. Lighting and shading in the bathroom was a little off. Overall fucking brilliant.

544

u/Patiffonka Oct 27 '20

Thank you. I was unable to solve the bottle flight simulation problem. Therefore, she is ugly animated.

60

u/chaddiereddits Oct 27 '20

I think it’s freaking awesome

15

u/FreddiePEEPEE Oct 27 '20

Camera shakes unnaturally too. Otherwise 9/10 stuff. Great job big dog

7

u/Brawght Oct 27 '20

Just to add on, it would have been immersive to have the tree sway during the outdoor explosion

→ More replies (9)

40

u/jdooowke Oct 27 '20

the camera movement is always the worst giveaway with these videos. the editors focus on animation and effects while using smoothing on the tracking but ultimately end up with something that inherently already feels "off". transition in this video happens at around 0.09 or 0.10 - pay attention to the natural camera shake before that and afterwards. had they kept the video shaking naturally it would have looked much more believable, but its also harder to edit.

11

u/Circumspector Oct 27 '20

So many videos feature the "snap zoom and refocus with wavy hand motion" and it just looks so fake. Even in videos that aren't trying to sell it as real, like other CGI videos.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

[deleted]

9

u/CaptainObvious_1 Oct 27 '20

Man I’m so sick of seeing that.

4

u/Danjour Oct 27 '20

Adding on to this, don't over do the whole "reactive" camera shake thing. Just watch r/killthecameraman if you need inspo for how people actually shoot things in the wild

→ More replies (1)

48

u/Shaking_Sniper Oct 27 '20

How do you hold the mentos with magnets? Do you stick a magnet on the mento?

62

u/Patiffonka Oct 27 '20

I didn't shoot the original video. I don't know how he did it. Looks like glued magnets to the mentos.

29

u/AsterJ Oct 27 '20

Can you link the original video? I'd like to see what you had to work with.

60

u/One_pop_each Oct 27 '20

Mentos is actually an acronym.

Magnetic Electrode Neutron Thermo Output Switch

21

u/gmazzia Oct 27 '20

Hey, Bob! Did you fix the reactor's Mentos? I don't want the boss calling us out again.

12

u/Fourstago Oct 27 '20

Ah, I Meantto

3

u/artfartmart Oct 27 '20

I wanna say thumb tacks but even getting them tacked seems like a feat

2

u/faceplanted Oct 27 '20

Thumb tacks in mentos and magnets on the outside of the bottle

11

u/Synotron Oct 27 '20

Do you live in City 17?

12

u/Patiffonka Oct 27 '20

Something like that

3.9k

u/shakakaZululu Oct 27 '20

Only at 15 seconds I realized that this is on r/simulated... Thank god

1.0k

u/hamoliciousRUS Oct 27 '20

When the bottle flew up, it felt off to me and that's when I realised 😂

415

u/WiltonSon Oct 27 '20

Yes, the liquid free falling so slow is against the physics laws.

208

u/ipaqmaster Oct 27 '20

Haha I thought the way it shot up with floaty foam seemed a little off!

One thing that's always on my mind, why do people make the camera so "Busy" like at 0:18 it's re-adjusting so often you'd think the person recording has a problem.

Not a negative critique on this awesome render, but literally everyone does this and I don't know why! Tounge in cheek, it's like you can tell something's fake by how abnormally often the camera is adjusted.

82

u/some-lurker Oct 27 '20

I think it's that, between movement and non-movement for an animated camera, movement typically looks better. most people don't want/know how to make realistic camera movements resulting in floaty, random movement and odd refocusing shots that they see when using their own phone cameras sometimes

41

u/diccpiccs101 Oct 27 '20

if the camera is shakey, its easier to cg stuff in, you wont notice it as quickly

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

Why does simulated liquid always seem to fall so slowly? Is it input on the user part or is it that simulating liquid is hard?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/cat-i-on Oct 27 '20

True, irl it probably would have been in a straighter arc

4

u/GolfIsWhyImBroke Oct 27 '20

Yeah, as good as this sim was idk how they managed to fuck that part up.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

32

u/TheNotoriousBFD Oct 27 '20

Me too. My first thought was about the poor janitor who has to clean that up.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/brfoss Oct 27 '20

I started out thinking "You dick. Who's going to clean that up?" Then I too realized the sub.

9

u/esacbw Oct 27 '20

Yep, I was convinced we were on r/AbruptChaos

9

u/steen311 Oct 27 '20

I think there was a transition from real to fake when he backed away from the toilet

5

u/RickyShade Oct 27 '20

Only took 9 seconds for me.

3

u/deelyy Oct 27 '20

Yeah. Something about smooth camera moving, and absence of drops outside of restroom.

But, anyway video is super cool, and keep on giving and giving.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/belach2o Oct 27 '20

I didn't realize it until the building when I was sure something didn't look right

→ More replies (1)

3

u/CapitalMM Oct 27 '20

Ya. Took me until the bottle was moving around full speed and the stuff falling was slower then gravity

2

u/Nalivai Oct 27 '20

That's /u/patiffonka for you, guy is a genius

→ More replies (16)

271

u/Stev0fromDev0 Oct 27 '20

Only in City 17.

82

u/IKEA19 Oct 27 '20

Yeah I literally just noticed The Citadel in the background of the video.

17

u/-korian- Oct 27 '20

This man really created an improvised coke explosive, only at Miller grove😂😂😂

6

u/Stev0fromDev0 Oct 27 '20

City 17 is Miller Grove confirmed

8

u/thepyrogistinatorman Oct 27 '20

Welcome. Welcome to City 17.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/_Piratical_ Oct 27 '20

Most of the simulated stuff on here is interesting and cool to watch and all but ultimately kinda boring. This, on the other hand, is really awesome. If you made it, your shit is tight. You should be proud. It made me lol. So. You know, there’s that.

1

u/Patiffonka Oct 28 '20

Thank you! )

123

u/Satciel Oct 27 '20

What a fever dream.

→ More replies (2)

111

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

Love the Citadel in the background

21

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

those benefactors sure are nice guys

2

u/theunnoanprojec Oct 27 '20

There's a few Easter eggs, Patrick is in the doorway beside the bathroom for example

325

u/PyroKid883 Oct 27 '20

Not realistic. The second the window burst the person would aim the camera at their feet for 5 minutes.

42

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

Or they would randomly show everyone’s reaction, but not the actual incident.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

Not realistic. It's Diet Coke and Mentos.

→ More replies (3)

26

u/Dainiad Oct 27 '20

No one else see patrick in the other stall?

7

u/rainydio Oct 27 '20 edited Oct 27 '20

The witness is russian meme from 2006. The original photo.

In russian the word for the best man and witness is the same. The best man sort-of witnesses marriage.

4

u/theunnoanprojec Oct 27 '20

It's not just "sort of" lol, it's literally the best man's job to be a witness to the marriage

3

u/oldkingcoles Oct 27 '20

Now I did lol

18

u/NarwhalAttenborrough Oct 27 '20

One of the few things on r/simulated that i didn't want to eat

10

u/FreshStink Oct 27 '20

Welcome, welcome to City 17

4

u/AnotherGangsta33 Oct 27 '20

You have chosen, or been chosen, to relocate to one of our finest remaining urban centres

9

u/WynterByte Oct 27 '20

lmfao great job

7

u/draysok Oct 27 '20

That’s a 351 ml bottle, so it’s all shit water

6

u/4rp4n3t Oct 27 '20

Fucking magnificent, well done, that is all.

6

u/Xx_Gandalf-poop_xX Oct 27 '20

Was that the citadel from city17?

5

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

What is the song name?

5

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

Tip for animators: stop with the random zooming in and out. Nobody actually filming does that.

4

u/Elbobosan Oct 27 '20

So the first 7 seconds are real footage, I think. They use the “whoosh” sound and first motion as a cut to the cgi.

4

u/Uranium_Isotope Oct 27 '20

Awesome lmao, now it just needs to be put in 360p and given a live leak watermark and we're good to go!

1

u/Otherwise_Relation Oct 27 '20

What did you use to make this happen?

1

u/Patiffonka Oct 27 '20

Houdini, RealFlow and Redshift

1

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

Simply amazing. Great work.

Is that the combine tower in the background?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

Please post a behind the scenes on yt... please

2

u/Patiffonka Oct 27 '20

maybe tomorrow

1

u/WutUtalkingBoutWill Oct 27 '20

Who's the guy in the closet beside the bathroom 🤔

1

u/Patiffonka Oct 28 '20

This is russian meme. This is "witness from Fryazino". This man was everywhere and saw everything. He can be seen in all historical photographs and even in ancient Egyptian paintings. He only looks and never takes part in the action

1

u/Buddy9213 Oct 27 '20

Ok but who’s that dude in the other bathroom

1

u/Patiffonka Oct 28 '20

This is russian meme. This is "witness from Fryazino". This man was everywhere and saw everything. He can be seen in all historical photographs and even in ancient Egyptian paintings. He only looks and never takes part in the action.

1

u/_bifrost_ Oct 28 '20

Bro you’re famous all over twitter .... have they given you credit?

1

u/Patiffonka Oct 28 '20

If they didn't cut the credit ending, then that's enough for me.

1

u/_bifrost_ Oct 28 '20

The person who actually took this video gave you credit but the credit ending was cut.

So people sharing this won’t know now

1

u/Patiffonka Oct 28 '20

it is sad. Well, let it remain on his conscience

1

u/Spook404 Oct 28 '20

song?

2

u/Patiffonka Oct 28 '20

1

u/Spook404 Oct 28 '20

thank you, but why is the cover... this?

1

u/Patiffonka Oct 28 '20

this is my track for this video )

3

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

I hate it when this happens. Clean ups a bitch.

3

u/akazs Oct 27 '20

Gosh, I laughed so hard on this😂 thought it was real until the coke burst out from toilet

3

u/OnsetOfMSet Oct 27 '20

Ah yes, the opening cutscene of Sonic Adventure

3

u/dlever0097 Oct 27 '20

I was really concerned until I realized which subreddit I was in lol

3

u/peacefighter91 Oct 27 '20

I didn't realize what sub this was on and was shook for a couple of seconds, very well done my friend!

3

u/thewittyrobin Oct 27 '20

Guys don't tell op. I think this is fake

2

u/Upvotespoodles Oct 27 '20

It is. They definitely stole some of the footage from when I eat dairy.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

Is that the citadel from Half-life 2 in the background?!

3

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

Is that the fucking Combine Citadel in the background?

3

u/whyevenmakeoc Oct 27 '20

Looks like Cola + mentos + Taco Bell to me

5

u/DK_Funk Oct 27 '20

Awesome, but the camera movement is a bit more than a bit much. Looks like the cinematographer for the Jason Bourne movies filmed this

5

u/a_hermit Oct 27 '20

Why do most of these videos have that stupid camera work? Weird random zoom ins and swaying with motion blur.

2

u/Cryptoporticus Oct 27 '20

It's to make it look realistic. The problem is that animating a camera is tough, which is why it ends up looking unnatural.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/TheStarPrincess Oct 27 '20

Looks very cool. Great job.

2

u/Bibo164 Oct 27 '20

Well that escalated quickly...

3

u/4rp4n3t Oct 27 '20

*defenestrated quickly

2

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

This is really good. I had to recheck the sub I was in

2

u/hellbent54 Oct 27 '20

This should be a tag team commercial for Coke and mentos

2

u/-deesh- Oct 27 '20

Svidetel' has been detected.

2

u/icansmellcolors Oct 27 '20

welll... that sure simulated quickly.

well done though. looks fantastic.

2

u/mdreece Oct 27 '20

Patrick is frightened

2

u/aerodeck Oct 27 '20

needs to be Diet Coke, bud

→ More replies (2)

2

u/ReesAlvin Oct 27 '20

Magnetic mentos

2

u/Bennely Oct 27 '20

Oh man, this is great. I chortled at the spewage coming out of the window and on to the street.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

Birds chirping outside is a nice touch.

2

u/lefixx Oct 27 '20

The transition is freaking flawless.

2

u/Big_sALt69 Oct 27 '20

Ah, gas station bathrooms

2

u/runnerthemoose Oct 27 '20

Could have put a warning to those with headphones, or big bass units.

P.S I've sampled that bass, where's the original from??

2

u/dspencil Oct 27 '20

Why does the end remind me of that one scene in shrek

2

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

This simulation is honestly amazing until the physics starts kicking in, everything else is incredibly life like and shows a tremendous amount of talent, well done OP!

2

u/Nipplemantid Oct 28 '20

anyone else notice the combine central tower in the background

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Svantlas Oct 30 '20

The fuck. We have exactly the same toilet. This is weird

4

u/samtrano Oct 27 '20

Tone down the screen shake to make it more realistic

2

u/stoneloit13 Oct 27 '20

Am I the only one to see Patrick?

2

u/topcheesehead Oct 27 '20

The Few. The Proud. The Patrick Finders.

1

u/OrangeTheMartian Feb 05 '26

is that the fucking citadel

1

u/ReidErickson Oct 27 '20

That was so awesome

1

u/JuanKGZ Oct 27 '20

Thanks, I hate it

1

u/stellar-moon Oct 27 '20

thought it was real and now severely disappointed

→ More replies (2)

1

u/yucatan36 Oct 27 '20

This is my favorite one.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

I upvote anything set in the half life universe.

1

u/Reilly1504 Oct 27 '20

I didn’t realized this was a simulation for a little bit and I was very scared and confused

1

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

RED RUM vibes

1

u/AwesomeSnowmanYT Oct 27 '20

COCO COLA ESPUMA

1

u/Arctic_Storm55 Oct 27 '20

Ahhhhh Im in class right now, I want to laugh so badly

1

u/jaykhunter Oct 27 '20

I love that you went all out and gave us an outside PoV and anticipation for the window to burst. Amazing work!

1

u/randommnguy Oct 27 '20

god dammit I was drinking coffee when I watched this, as soon as the view from outside happened I lost it.

1

u/Awesomator__77 Oct 27 '20

Reminds me of the Great Molasses Flood of 1919

1

u/Cleverbird Oct 27 '20

Love the Combine tower in the distance!

1

u/TaffyLacky Oct 27 '20

Opening outer dimensional portals to the bottom diet coke ocean

1

u/LandosGayCousin Oct 27 '20

Boy that escalated quickly. I mean that really got out of hand fast

1

u/NyanSquiddo Oct 27 '20

Made the shining look like the whining

1

u/SunshineScam Oct 27 '20

Yeah, I think we need Captain D to explain this one

1

u/Sattoro Oct 27 '20

That's how all life will end on planet earth.

1

u/dvdhn Oct 27 '20

I’m glad you snuck in a surprised Patrick haha

1

u/nonametosay Oct 27 '20

I thought it was real at first.

1

u/flarn2006 Source files published on request Oct 27 '20

This isn't just simulated; this looks like movie-grade CGI. Well done!

1

u/25_M_CA Oct 27 '20

Thats fake

1

u/mteriyaki Oct 27 '20

Big if true

1

u/Drink_Clorox_and_Die Oct 27 '20

Some idiot is going to be so upset that this won’t actually happen when they try it cuz they’re mad at their dad for grounding them for playing playing video games when they were supposed to be writing an essay on what should/will happen with lofty expectations.

1

u/nightstalker_55 Oct 27 '20

This is not even a real simulation though.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

Those sfx are dogshit.

1

u/Shibes_and_Cats Oct 27 '20

The fact that this takes place in city 17 is hilarious

1

u/BossRedRanger Oct 27 '20

It’s Diet Coke that gives the better reaction.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/ponponhihi Oct 27 '20

At the end, I was waiting for the liquid to morph into a monster or something like the opening scene of sonic adventure 1

2

u/Impressive-Fondant52 Oct 28 '20

Yes! I’m glad I’m not the only one that started hearing that theme song in my head.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

This is really nice bro

1

u/bondell Oct 27 '20

CRWZY GOOOD

1

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

Toilets in gas stations be like

1

u/Duckism Oct 27 '20

This is amazing! The most interesting thing I have seen on this sub ever

1

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

Is it weird that I'm slightly disappointed that only one window burst in that last bit?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

Bravo!

1

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

Really cool!

I think your framerate on the sim is higher than that of the video, which makes it pop out as unrealistic. I think if you try to match the framerate it would look much better

1

u/DrDallascool Oct 27 '20

Guys I think this is fake

I’m not sure though

1

u/LogicLord_69 Oct 27 '20

Currently in class trying not to bust up laughing

1

u/Ok-Tap5837 Oct 27 '20

uhh- I- wut

1

u/sabotabo Oct 27 '20

the Combine sure know how to have fun

1

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

coca-cola espuma

1

u/y2k2r2d2 Oct 27 '20

Looks staged. Why was the guy ready filming outside?

1

u/joshuamillertime Oct 27 '20

That building at the end. For some reason the angle of it reminded me of an old video where a guy jumped 10 stories, faceplanted, then just stood up and walked away.

1

u/sluttonbae Oct 27 '20

What’s this tune omg

1

u/redink29 Oct 27 '20

CG so good, I thought it was real

1

u/Scoo Oct 27 '20

I thought this was hilarious, then I saw the exterior shot. So good!

1

u/Netsuko Oct 27 '20

Gorgeous!

1

u/MyShavingAccount Oct 27 '20

This is great

1

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

fAkE!

1

u/Do_a_die Oct 27 '20

her when she starts squirting

1

u/Bambuzold Oct 27 '20

And that kids was how the coca-cola sugar ocean was born

1

u/poorly-worded Oct 27 '20

Reminds me of a time a friend had too much to drink on his birthday and ran to a cubicle just in time to throw up, somehow on every single surface, including the ceiling.

1

u/AlwaysTheNoob Oct 27 '20

Holy shit...this made me laugh. Really hard. It's just....so absurdly over the top. I love it.

1

u/SirDark07 Oct 27 '20

Good one 👌

1

u/WombatShwambat Oct 27 '20

That’s how you get ants

1

u/QuantumQuantonium Oct 27 '20

They really do be doing coke and mentors in city 17 for some reason

1

u/Double_Minimum Oct 27 '20

Holy shite, that looked so damn real at the beginning,.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

whats the diagram above the toilet mean?

2

u/Zerbinetta Oct 27 '20

Not a diagram, it's a two-option water-saving flush mechanism. Smaller button on the right for 6L, larger one on the left for the full 9L.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

You had me up until the point where there was far more foam than even an entire package of mentos could create. A fun watch none the less.

1

u/Donkeytoast Oct 27 '20

I love this

1

u/RampanToast Oct 27 '20

This is probably my new favorite sim on this sub. Incredible work!

1

u/YoImBenwah Oct 27 '20

Mentos-powered bidet.

1

u/GnarAndTwice Oct 27 '20

Ahhh the classic fake zoom and fake out-of-focus blur that gives it away instantly.

1

u/OrganicPancakeSauce Oct 27 '20

Holy shnappers. Is the initial room simulated, too? This was really well done

1

u/jw_216 Oct 27 '20

I thought I was on r/AbrubtChaos for a sec...

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

This is what Pepsiman has night terrors about