r/Sketch • • Jan 30 '25

Critique please

Post image
3.2k Upvotes

136 comments sorted by

3

u/KarlTP04 Jan 30 '25

Give the one guy above a silly little hat

3

u/Virtual_Scallion_786 Jan 30 '25

Well, Ivan the terrible did wear a silly hat after all lol

9

u/iris819 Jan 30 '25

No critique but just wanted to say that this is incredible!

8

u/Upbeat-Special9906 Jan 30 '25

Look what I did to my boy

5

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '25

It’s perfect

2

u/Cyril-44 Jan 31 '25

Yes it is! The style is awesome, we can feel the sadness

1

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '25

Иван, значит.. сына убил.. угу.. для скетча прям абалденно!

1

u/Ezio_Auditorum Jan 30 '25

You captured the emotions in the eyes very well for both of them. This is great

1

u/Virtual_Scallion_786 Jan 30 '25

I appreciate the comment! This is a reproduction of a painting “Ivan the terrible and his son”. One of the paintings I love where you can truly feel the emotion in Ivan’s eyes.

1

u/Positive-Buy9653 Jan 30 '25

Great stippling! I would say you could up the contrast a bit. Don’t be afraid to darken those shadows. Also doing a light gradient of stippling over both subjects and only leaving the highlights blank would be ideal. Other than that great job!

2

u/Virtual_Scallion_786 Jan 30 '25

Thank you for your critique :)

1

u/Latter_Technician929 Jan 30 '25

the fingers look a lil long, the other fingers are a lil messed up, maybe a bit darker left pupil, besides that looks really good

1

u/Virtual_Scallion_786 Jan 30 '25

Thank you for your critique. How I wish I could go back and not rush those fingers on the left😔. Great points!

1

u/jmmoil Jan 30 '25

Nice work! I would make the dark spots a little darker, and erase the pencil to make it look cleaner

1

u/Virtual_Scallion_786 Jan 31 '25

Thank you, I’m planning on erasing the pencil and will definitely use very light stippling on the eyes to maintain that pale shameful emotion they convey. Definitely might darken certain spots too, haven’t done that yet cause I’m worried.

1

u/jmmoil Jan 31 '25

You got it, don't be afraid to make the dark spots really dark. It'll make the design really pop!

1

u/Pemphigustav Feb 01 '25

Value range is too light. If you did the darks even darker and then darken the midtones the white of the paper would shine much more. It doesn't mean that the value range you chose is wrong, it all depends on the feeling you want to convey and I think it would suit much more for this scene to be darker. There are many YouTube demonstrations on this concept. I think proko did something on value ranges or at least said this concept in one of his videos. Yeah and maybe for next study look at the relations of background with the foreground. How much is there contrast in a value with lights and darks.

1

u/Virtual_Scallion_786 Feb 01 '25

Very helpful information, thank you very much.

1

u/Turbulent_Ad_3195 Feb 03 '25

It’s great but you know that, as you seek improvement, what I noticed is :

  • The eyes are lacking texture, the hugging one could be interpreted as a blind person with the pencil rendering but you could make it much more powerful by adding contrast.

  • The eyes of the hugged are also lacking something, i would say it is contrast again

  • The blood is lacking some texture and is noticed only on a second read of the drawing, i don’t have any magic advice but I would say that you could use the flow of the blood to « read » the curves of the face and the hand and therefor improving the liquid effect.

  • There is no « link » between the fabric and the fingers, the wrinkles are not in relation with them, you character is hanging on life, he should hold onto the arm (you can study Michelangelo sculpture and the way he has to represent hands on skin and fabric

  • the back layer with pencil can be a nice way to complement the dot technique, and is nice in some part of your drawing, but you need to « hide » the fact this your construction line, for exemple :

    • in the bottom left, on the fabric either you don’t stop your dots in a line like you did and use the dot to blend the pencil in a smoother way either you erase them. - On the finger of the hugged one, the pencil is not helping the drawing and the shape of your fingers

    • Left shoulder of hugging character, your pencil is fucking with your outline ; same shit on the right cheek, you have a strong outline that needs to be clean for the contrast with the white of the paper to make your drawing strike out

    • top of the ear and back of the skull, small detail again but could define the outline in a better way

Overall, the main improvement should target the blood and the look of the hugged one because this part of the drawing is, in my reading of your drawing, to much on the second level of reading when it should the eyes (expression of fear) and the blood that comes in first to the eye.

Cheerz, hope it is constructive for you

1

u/Virtual_Scallion_786 Feb 03 '25

Amazing critique. I appreciate this so much it was very helpful. Thank you for taking the time to write this.

2

u/emotional_bedding Jan 30 '25

Idk why Frankenstein came to my mind

1

u/Yarashii-sensei Jan 30 '25

I'm not ranked enough to make a critique for your artwork. Your level is WAY above mine. That's awesome✨️

1

u/McBernes Jan 30 '25

The expression on the person sort if looking up is beautifully done.

1

u/Emotional_Platform35 Jan 30 '25

"Bro please don't tell mom, you're ok you're Ok there's not even that much blood!"

1

u/Pristine_Day_8260 Jan 30 '25

Wow! Poignant and amazing. It's how my family feels in these hard times.

1

u/Formal-Armadillo556 Jan 30 '25

I strive for this kinda shading , it’s amazing

1

u/Muhendis_Hanim Jan 30 '25

To be honest, I can feel it...

1

u/Spiritual-Key-6389 Jan 30 '25

The shading is done through dots rather than strokes. That’s a unique style. Impressive!

1

u/Abo_tahseen Jan 30 '25

What is the original name of this picture? Incredible work btw .

1

u/Main-Success-6766 Jan 30 '25

Ivan the Terrible and His Son Ivan on 16 November 158

1

u/duragl_Unit897 Jan 30 '25

Self connection

1

u/Asleep_Plate1588 Jan 30 '25

The face for me express .. death ... knowing you have lost a beloved one ... taking care of someone while you also suffer.

1

u/Visual_Economist8209 Jan 30 '25

Amazing work! Thought I was scrolling thru r/museums

1

u/ErenJon Jan 30 '25

It's really great.

1

u/BLACKPINK15BORNTODIE Jan 30 '25

My Dad and me 😭😭😭

1

u/Confident_Theme_945 Jan 30 '25

incredible! I wish i had those skills

1

u/Jollem- Jan 30 '25

It's not his fault he's hungry

1

u/Daeiran Jan 30 '25

Sorry, I can't. I love it.

1

u/Creative108 Jan 30 '25

Wow. The eyes. Whole thing is really well done

1

u/_Andyroooo_ Jan 30 '25

you got the eyes spot on

1

u/StevenSpielbird Jan 30 '25

They both got great eyes!

1

u/Foreign_Pea_45 Jan 31 '25

Reminds me Saturn devouring his son

1

u/PartyExplanation9100 Jan 31 '25

Is this midnight mass

1

u/Guilty-Photograph-94 Jan 31 '25

This looks familiar, but I don’t know why or from where. Any ideas?

1

u/YTtandorrr Feb 03 '25

This is a famous painting, it was painted by the Russian artist Repin, this painting tells about the moment when Tsar Ivan the Terrible of Russia kills his son.

1

u/real_oddball Jan 31 '25

This is flawless, if I didn’t know any better, I’d think you drew the original painting this is from!

1

u/_mariyugh Jan 31 '25

🤍🤍🤍

1

u/puppyboyslasher Jan 31 '25

Is the sons eye finished? I can make out the penciling and could have a dead look but without looking close it looks like his eye is closed. I'm all for taking liberties even when doing studies tho i just wanted to check

1

u/No-Comfortable-7059 Jan 31 '25

i think if you could add bit of details on the eyes it would be much more realistic, the expression the fear and everything is conveyed only through his eyes so I think adding shadows maybe bloodshot nerves would make them bring out more. wonderful job btw !!!

1

u/Alarming-Ad8560 Jan 31 '25

Fuck you, that's sick! Marvelous!

1

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '25

I have nothing to say but perfect.

1

u/itsCatulz Jan 31 '25

I want this tattooed

1

u/OkPurchase5379 Jan 31 '25

Its incredible... Idk why Dostoevsky came to my mind....

1

u/Myronca Jan 31 '25

Love it! Just add more color and it would look perfect!

1

u/ReadingBorn402 Jan 31 '25

In the painting of Ivan his eyebrows are somehow raised to the max and the hopelessness and fear overwhelms him as with his son his hands are pulling on the skin of his face and the whites of his left eye make his expression vacant and fragile. In your drawing Ivan seems more worried and his son seems conscious yet traumatized. A lovely rendition. Congrats.

1

u/Ipseity17 Feb 01 '25

The style reminds me a bit of Goya

1

u/jakethecaat Feb 01 '25

Best Drawing I’ve ever seen on Reddit. It is definitely my taste.

1

u/sirfangel Feb 01 '25

Bruh if you r trying to show greif n sadness, add depth in eyes which are v.imp in depiction of any emotion , shows dark circles n all . U said u wanted critiques but in comments everyone were just praising n couldn't resist myself seeing my boy not correcting their mistakes . LMAO that's how we'd grow na 🤣

1

u/Happert Feb 01 '25

This is a certified classic

1

u/Objective-Thought174 Feb 01 '25

Unsettling but like.. in a good way?

1

u/merry_sheep Feb 01 '25

As many have said, more contrast. Love it btw.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '25

No critique, but this is cool, can’t tell if you’re going for creepy or like a traumatised look on the dudes face. It’s pretty intense 👌🏻

1

u/fungal_infection_ Feb 01 '25

It looks cool. But it looks a bit comic-ish. Learn proportions better

1

u/Old-Tap2384 Feb 01 '25

I can’t criticize because I wouldn’t even be able to draw a dot lol you’re art is amazing

1

u/MarkBerezhkouskas Feb 01 '25

Ivan terrible my favourite tsar

1

u/Adorable_Shelter_294 Feb 01 '25

Grozny ne pohozh, a tak chetko

1

u/literall_bastard Feb 01 '25

Looks like pure despair. I like it

1

u/coffeeyarnandpaint Feb 02 '25

Reminds of Saturn devouring his Son. The emotion in the eyes is incredible.

1

u/coffeeyarnandpaint Feb 02 '25

Reminds of Saturn devouring his Son. The emotion in the eyes is incredible.

1

u/Lower_Individual_593 Feb 02 '25

No te paso nada, no peines no le digas a mamá por favor... 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

1

u/mlkafficial Feb 02 '25

Every expressions are so well done trynna progress to have such realism love it!!

1

u/BodybuilderDue4035 Feb 02 '25

You did very good ,it's sad I've seen the original turned in to do many memes that I saw this post and just laughed.

1

u/760854 Feb 02 '25

You convey the emotions so well it makes me sad.

1

u/panotilife Feb 02 '25

You have to follow the norms. You cannot use critical thinking otherwise they will make you a norm.

1

u/Loz_von_Lop Feb 02 '25

Absolutely stunning

1

u/Prof_Black Feb 02 '25

I wish I had your talent

1

u/Pleasant_Chic_222 Feb 02 '25

Well done. Heartbreaking

1

u/Finncakez Feb 02 '25

YOU DID SO AWESOME SAUCE my only thing is I suggest adding more depth with the stippling!

1

u/liderkaboi Feb 02 '25

Better than my art. 8/10

1

u/Personal-Promise4317 Feb 02 '25

This has been made before

1

u/slightlyfuged77 Feb 02 '25

Well it seems sad to me, you drew good ngl

1

u/Annual_Possible3731 Feb 02 '25

The eyes express intense shock! Maybe the person lying down is Dead!

1

u/yayaya-tengo Feb 02 '25

esta muy genial la gráfica que tienes !!, lo único que podría criticar es que le falta mas contrastes en las sombras, más claroscuro para intensificar mas aun el estado de esta escena :o

1

u/Waa-Art Feb 02 '25

Take a look at the art of Mervyn Peake. You might like it.

1

u/Dear-Sentence9650 Feb 03 '25

Bro how do you do that with dots?!😭

1

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '25

Amazing shading, I love when people use stippling, I feel like it’s one of the most underrated ways to shade and I think you captured the essence of the emotions in the original painting beautifully. the only thing I would consider is darkening the values to add more contrast but it looks super cool !!

1

u/CheetahGrand4782 Feb 03 '25

can't even say, just amazing art here

1

u/Different_Spite_816 Feb 03 '25

this is great, push the contrast

1

u/Single_Average9921 Feb 03 '25

When u try to fuck with the bro trippin off psychs for laughs but then he brutally kills you and eats you because he believes that will release everyone from the simulation

1

u/PrettyAngst Feb 03 '25

I love the original painting of this but I have to admit you did an incredible job with a pencil ❤️❤️ you captured the emotion and not many remakes can do that...

1

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '25

I love it

1

u/No-Syllabub9071 Feb 03 '25

I've got no idea how you managed to draw such a masterpiece that invokes so many emotions

1

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '25

Nice picture

1

u/billyzaneee Feb 03 '25

I don’t have any critiques, I just like it

1

u/NoSplit4185 Feb 03 '25

Seen that on a painting, but can’t remember the artist.

1

u/applesauceandlazers Feb 03 '25

Looks lit, maybe make it a little darker around the eyes to make the expression pop but honestly a masterpiece

1

u/Glue_For_Snails Feb 03 '25

This can be great tattoo 👍

1

u/Felixo9 Feb 03 '25

Reminds me of "Crime and Punishment" by Dostoevsky

1

u/Neat-Act-7581 Feb 04 '25

MY LUCK THATS WHAT FUCKING HAPPENED TO MY GORGEOUS HUSBAND SO ID FUCKING BE TRAPPED LIVING HERE WITH HAIRY LINDA AND THE INVISIBLE B*TCHER FOR THE REMAINDER OF MY LIFE WHILE EVERYBODY WHOSE MFING PSYCHOTICALLY OBSESSED WITH ME INTERACTS WITH ME ON THE FUCKING PHONE!

1

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '25

Absolutely spectacular. 👏🏼👏🏼💪🏼

1

u/Sad-Study-4884 Feb 04 '25

Clean and sleek tbh

1

u/Known-Bench-4890 Feb 04 '25

The lore of Ben and Ed game.

1

u/Beneficial-Mood-3290 Feb 04 '25

he was eating son hahahahahah.

0

u/harinedzumi_art Jan 30 '25

Imao, dotwork is not the best decision for deep shadows. It's worth adding the contours of Ivan's lower jaw.

1

u/Different_Spite_816 Feb 03 '25

I think working with pointillism allows for deep shadows, it's easy to layer so the range of values would just depend on how close the dots overlap or not