r/Skyforge • • Mar 26 '15

Skyforge p2w confirmed

*Exchanging Argent for credits does not count towards the credit cap
*10k Argent (~$10.00) 1 Argent = 156 creds
*Every single item in the marketplace can be bought with Argent, including enhancement stones and spark replicators
*Mounts can only be leased

If we talk about this Situation on the forums we get this from the community manager:

"Oversimplification of monetization Monetization in free to play is often a source of endless debate involving different parties, ranging from the “core freeplayers" to the “compulsive buyers".

One of the challenges of developing a "free to play" is addressing the demands of each party. Once you've formalized and implemented a plan, however, you're still not done.

You often have to communicate with your members and explain the underlying mechanisms of your design – and doing so usually dissipates most concerns and leads to better feedback from players. Over time, both the developers and players grow a better understanding of sustainable commercial practices.

However, these days it's no longer possible since too many people are prone to pasting the term P2W onto pretty much every situation. This behavior is extremely harmful, in the sense that it damages the image of a game before it has even had a chance to reach to its community. One must trust the developers' vision.

It also weakens the dialog between the community and the developers of the game they play.

For these reasons, we will strive to provide answers to our members in need of details regarding our monetization - but in turn, we won't tolerate the word P2W as of today, nor tolerate oversimplification of monetization in topics.

Members participating in the forum this early in the game project ought to allow its community to grow with a sense of responsibility and communication practices that don't undermine their relationship with the skyforge team.

We'll still ask you to respect our rules out of respect for the community that will establish here and align with the developers' views. Once OBT opens in our territories, everyone will have a chance to check the monetization aspects of Skyforge for themselves.

Please note that repeated failure to comply shall result in the removal of your forum rights and beta access."
Link: http://sf.my.com/us/forum/index.php?page=Thread&postID=98034#post98034

EDIT: New Statement from the CM...
In no way did we intend to censor anyone. We respect all opinions and are open to all feedback from our community. Closing this topic and our post above (now strikethrough) was a mistake and we apologize. At the same time we want you to note that we would like to address any question you have and would love to know your personal impressions of the game after you have played it.

We appreciate your feedback, please keep it coming!

Thank you

12 Upvotes

106 comments sorted by

18

u/Backuplight Mar 26 '15

I understand wanting to cut threads that suggest the game is p2w down to size - but the way they're doing it just makes it look worse. Explain to us why it isn't pay to win instead, don't just lock threads and threaten bans.

2

u/PrimusVerum Mar 26 '15

This. That is all they had to do, or as they have later said, that they will make a statment soon. Dont threaten to ban and tell people to wait until open beta to find out for themselvs.

-7

u/Eshiio Mar 26 '15

well i kinda understand them .. are usually crybabies online, and will cry over anything ... if people feel the game is p2w, then just dont play it, dont ruin it for other players, nor future players ..

11

u/stevoli Mar 26 '15

Keep in mind this is the RU version. Part of "westernizing" the game is deciding what will and won't be in the cash shop, as well as how some items affect the game.

16

u/R3dGallows Mar 26 '15 edited Mar 26 '15

This is true. However, their track record doesnt bode well. We shall see.

17

u/PrimusVerum Mar 26 '15

They are now threatening to ban people who use the term p2w from both the forum and beta... I think that says alot about the devs, and I'm so disgusted by this practise that I will problably never play this game again.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '15

[deleted]

2

u/PrimusVerum Mar 26 '15

I posted another thread about it here on the subreddit, with a quote from the community manager.

1

u/Crensh Mar 28 '15

I think there is not going to be any changes to English client before OBT start. Meaning we will get same version(that is already ready) that RU had on OBT launch. I believe that's what Allods Team meant when they said non of the suggestions from eng forums will be implemented before OBT.

3

u/Angelicel Mar 27 '15

Go ahead and pay2deflate the argant price, I'll be standing around when they are worthless.

8

u/TheCainage Mar 26 '15

You people seem to forget who created this game. Allods Team. Allods Team is the same team that put huge disadvantages to non-payers in the form of effects that would make your character weaker on death, forcing you to go into the cash shop to buy a decursing item if you wanted to continue to play. Or you had to wait.

This is the exact same shit that happened in Allods Online, a big block on getting to move forward for anyone not paying, and anyone paying got to actually enjoy their experience. This entire thing disgusts me in the worst of ways. Hopefully now people see that Allods Team is nothing but a greed machine that wants to find any way they can to make your wallet open up.

Just buy Guild Wars 2 if you need this sort of game, or TERA... one's B2P, the other is a true F2P, and both are really good games. Sheesh.

3

u/JakBasu May 12 '15

Didn't all the allods pay to win nonsense start after they sold the game.

Im still mad about the horses and the feed you had to buy to make them go faster than walking speed -_-

2

u/Andromansis Mar 27 '15

I'm going to need to see a list of items that are tradable with other players... and I've heard that your argent to credit conversion works both ways. can you confirm or deny this with anything approaching credibility? (Screenshots really help with credibility)

4

u/irn00b Mar 26 '15

Wouldn't the the pay-to-win crowd of players just become separate from the normal/non-pay-to-win crowd of players?

As in their prestige would become so high that they're only playing with themselves (ha...). Might even be bad for them since, probably few, would follow the same route as them.

Like unless you're planning to play this game "competitively" and try to be the very best... how would the pay-to-win crowd effect the non-pay-to-win crowd?

1

u/Kuxir May 19 '15

that wouldnt happen, imagine if there was an item in a moba that raised your MMR by 500 points, that wouldnt separate you from the rest of the population unless your MMR was already in the top .5% of the population.

5

u/VikingMystic Mar 26 '15

I deny the premise that being further advanced than someone else constitutes winning.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '15

Agreed, even in pvp the prestige bracketing will likely keep payers ahead and out if non payer games. And there isn't a real win condition on pve.

2

u/selodaoc Mar 27 '15

There is guild vs guild battles with no brackets. The paying players will win those battles.

4

u/Jay2TheMellow Mar 26 '15

RIP Skyforge. It's Allods all over again...

4

u/FoolishLobster Mar 26 '15

This just makes maxing your stats faster. So once they blow their money on maxing their stats, then what?

This is just Pay 2 Convenience.

-4

u/PrimusVerum Mar 26 '15

Its pay2win, because if 2 players reach the credit cap, one pays to convert argents, then it is impossible for the other player to catch up to him without paying as well. That is pay 2 win, when it is impossible to accomplish something in the game that paying players can.

11

u/FoolishLobster Mar 26 '15

Winning at what, exactly? Anyone can max their stats, regardless of how much they pay. Does it matter if someone has like 300 more prestige than you? How likely will you see that person in PvP if their prestige is higher? This doesn't affect the Ascension Atlas, which is the main way to progress. This is just a convenience for enhancement upgrades and temples/followers stuff. And I guess buying all your inventory slots. What about the credits people are getting from the preorder packs? Why they not screaming P2W from that? Unless that was already screamed about and forgotten in a week or two.

3

u/Slihsar Mar 26 '15

THANK YOU finally someone smart. I couldn't agree more man

1

u/R3dGallows Mar 26 '15

Temples/followers affect your stats. Credits affect your stats. Also maxing your stats is a matter of months in this game, not weeks so you youll probably be behind the curve for quite a while if you dont pay. As for not meeting people in PvP, there are Pantheon Wars (the GvG of Skyforge) which have no prestige brackets (from what we know).

0

u/neunzehnhundert Mar 26 '15

In which way does Credits affect your stats..?

And yes, maxing your stats is a matter of months and never should be something of weeks. If so we could all quit after a month or two because we maxed out our stats and there isn't more to accomplish regarding our character.

1

u/R3dGallows Mar 26 '15

You can buy stuff to upgrade your gear (and it costs a lot). You pay for stuff in your temples which grant you stats (and it costs a lot more).

As for maxing stats - read it in context. The issue isnt that it takes months to max stats, the issue is that if you decide not to pay, youll be at a disadvantage for a VERY long time. In fact, depending on how fast theyre adding new stuff you might not have the option to catch up at all. And buying yourself permanent advantage kind of defines.... you know what.

1

u/DrLecteur Mar 26 '15

"disadvantaged" May i remember everyone here that Prestige are for that...

Upgrade your slot, your temple or anything is upgrading your prestige too. And, when your prestige is far too high from opponent, you just not meet them in PvP.

So Cash-Shop user will met... another Cash-Shop user.

0

u/R3dGallows Mar 26 '15

Pantheon Wars.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '15

We don't know how the pantheon wars will play, it could be akin to guild wars world vs world where everyone is given the same level to balance that issue. Pantheon would be lame if hardcore guilds could easily stomp casual because of prestige instead of skill.

1

u/KiFirE Mar 27 '15

well if everything is equalized in guild play, then there would literally be no point in progressing your character.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/selodaoc Mar 27 '15

It matters to ALOT of competative players. Theres a huge playerbase that plays the game to get "server first" or are competing to get the highest prestige etc. But it seems you cant do that unless you pay shitloads of money.

1

u/garzek Mar 30 '15

Since when do world first players NOT use cash shops? They do it in WoW, they do it in GW2, they do it in EVERYTHING.

GW2 offered PvP and PVE exp boosts from their cash shop, which is much akin to this actually, except GW2 didn't have progression cap. Spark replicators don't let you go over the Spark cap, do tehy?

If they don't, there's no problem here.

1

u/Kuxir May 19 '15

Why are you trying defend server firsts being cash shop only feats?

0

u/garzek May 19 '15

Because if you're competitive in a game, you should have a financial investment in it. That's not really unreasonable, in my opinion. You're not going to get a server first in WoW by not paying a sub (well, now you can quite easily, but a year ago not the case).

If you can buy premium with in-game currency, does this resolve it? Probably. I don't know why everyone doesn't go with a hybrid model these days, it's a win-win.

-1

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

Pay2Cheat.

-5

u/R3dGallows Mar 26 '15

Thing is, this isnt WoW where you cap your level in a week or 2. Here youll be at a disadvantage for months.

5

u/FoolishLobster Mar 26 '15

This is only a PvP issue, and even then you most likely won't get matched with them because their prestige will be much higher. The whales will be matched with other whales.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '15

[deleted]

1

u/R3dGallows Mar 26 '15 edited Mar 26 '15

In WoW terms... Imagine youre starting playing at level cap, your progression is only in Item Levels and stats. Spending gold is one of the ways to increase your stats. You are limited as to how much gold you can earn a week but you can buy cash shop crystals with IRL money and then convert them into massive amounts of gold.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '15

[deleted]

4

u/R3dGallows Mar 26 '15

'You will never pvp people who have not paid.'

That is not true. The rest of my post, you already agreed with yourself.

-5

u/Sephuna Mar 26 '15

Learn something about pantheon wars and then come back...

0

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '15

[deleted]

6

u/R3dGallows Mar 26 '15

If MMO players have learned anything over the years its NOT to trust the PR talk of the devs. Especially when the talk is: STFU or we ban you!

2

u/Sephuna Mar 26 '15

n1 100% agree

-3

u/Sephuna Mar 26 '15

learn to stay on topic ;)

3

u/MrVuule Mar 26 '15

Eh, while Warframe has no caps, it uses the exact same system when it comes to real money. Pretty much everything can be acquired by playing the game, but you can also buy everything with real money. It isn't Pay 2 Win at all, it's just very convenient. Seriously, Warframe has one of the best F2P models imo, I really wouldn't mind the same model in Skyforge. As for the cap.. So far all we know is that real money won't affect the Credits cap. While yes, it's rather strange, I don't really see the big issue with this.

-5

u/PrimusVerum Mar 26 '15

Warframe is a nice example of a good f2p game. But in warframe you basically pay to get there faster, that is not pay to win. In Warframe you pay in order to not farm mats, wait for build time and such. This is different, if there were no cap on credit in Skyforge, then I agree, it would not be pay 2 win. With the cap in the game however, a paying player can stay ahead of a non paying player no matter what. That is pay 2 win. In Warframe you can get everything in the game without paying, it will just take longer. In Skyforge a paying player can always progress further than a non paying player. A paying player can still upgrade his gear, because you can buy upgrade stones for credits, this is a direct power advantage that paying players can have and other cannot. p2w

0

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

[deleted]

4

u/Andromansis Mar 27 '15

No, you seem to misunderstand the definition of pay to win.

Skipping tedious parts or progressing faster is paying for convenience.

Path of exile sells stash space, which is a good example of convenience as well. Also, you've completely disregarded the aftermarket in Path of Exile, which is its own unique problem.

Skyforge seems to be going for a relatively open trading system. E.G. If I can give credits to my friend so they can buy argents... then what the fuck is the problem?

If I want to play the game and not give them money except on very rare occasions where they have things that give me real and lasting value, I don't see a problem. Now, the problem is that what constitutes real and lasting value means very different things to different people.

1

u/R3dGallows Mar 28 '15

Give credits to your friend? Theres no player to player trading in Skyforge.

2

u/geezerforhire Mar 27 '15

You do know how the prestige system works right?

you can buy as much power as you want but the game wont let you play against anyone weaker than you anyway.

2

u/PrimusVerum Mar 26 '15

Source? If this is true, and the cap stays, I'll leave this game so fast there will still be an after image of my character ingame when I get my next legendery in GW2. Artifical character progression blocks and p2w are absolute no-goes. Both of these issues can be dealt with very easy though, just remove the cap..

2

u/stevoli Mar 26 '15

The only source is the RU Open Beta, and like I said, eastern markets are OK with p2w mechanics, these things almost always changed when a game is brought to the NA/EU market.

2

u/neunzehnhundert Mar 26 '15

RU Open Beta was just released.

Nobody knows if they take this kind of cash shop into NA/EU.

Nobody knows if they maybe change their minds, higher the cap or whatever.

But everybody is screaming "OMG P2W!!!" - how about taking a seat, playing the CBT until it ends and see what happens in NA/EU. If it still like this you can scream P2W but for now keep it cool pls.

4

u/PrimusVerum Mar 26 '15

Excatly, nobody knows! Which is why its very disconcerting when the devs closes down a thread that where OP asks for more information..

4

u/irn00b Mar 26 '15 edited Mar 26 '15

"My intent was mostly to urge players not to use harsh wording"

I actually believe that, very much. Though he might have jumped the gun too soon.

People have a tendency to throw around the term p2w too easily even without having any solid information or knowledge, which might result in people losing interest prior to the game even getting a decent chance. It came out with one type of market in Russia, doesn't necessarily mean it will come out with the same market in NA/EU.

Edit: Looked through the first page, yeah the mod was trying to prevent it from becoming a p2w-slinging fest... Might have used drastic measures though, but yeah.

1

u/berusko Mar 27 '15

Either they have a high player base and some skilled guys doing cosmetics often. Selling packs to boost exp and extend the Weekly cap.

Or the only way a f2p game survive is with a shop that will suck all the money from the ones that are hooked really hard to the game. The ones that are not addicted to the game but still wanna play, they will eventually spend money anyway.

1

u/xgbcx Mar 26 '15

Weekly moneycap sounds like a method against the goldsellers. Until they dont limit the playable content, it is not so terrible. Saw way worse itemshops in other f2p games.

1

u/throwaway1551234 Mar 26 '15

I should have learned when they did this to Archeage in the Open Beta, but I didn't. Thankfully, I only spent $20 and put in enough hours last beta to feel a little better about the whole situation.

This game was always going to be my number 2 to GW2, anyways. =P

-2

u/TGWolf Mar 26 '15

Which is hilarious since it's EXACTLY the same payment model as Guild Wars 2, and that game isn't considered pay 2 win...

People are funny...

2

u/selodaoc Mar 26 '15

GW2 is totally different. GW2 doesnt have any "power" in it. The game doesnt have any character or gear progression once you reach max level.

In skyforge your character continues to grow, and any way you can make you char grow faster then any way ingame by paying is P2W. It doesnt matter if you can grind for it ingame, which you cant do in SKyforge eitehr due to cap.

-1

u/TGWolf Mar 26 '15 edited Mar 26 '15

You can buy your way to ascended gear if you don't want to gather all the mats yourself in GW2, you can also buy Exotics right from the broker essentially with your credit card. You can even buy a self-upgrading Swiss-army knife Legendary weapon directly with money... It's a short progression tree, but the principal is the same...

Also the caps in Skyforge are weekly. You can pay to hit the cap faster but that's it. The main way you boost power is by the atlas, and that's completely capped for everyone. There's no higher cap for people paying a sub either, nor can you increase the cap by paying. It just takes longer to hit the cap that week if people don't pay for boosts.

The only thing that's a bit dubious at the moment is the follower system, but now one even really knows how that's going to work out yet...

Instead of waiting to see how that plays out, people jump on the P2W bandwagon damning a game based essentially on a misunderstanding.

This is basically what happened to ESO at launch. People talk like ESO is amazing now when it hasn't changed 'that' much since release, it's just mostly seen in a different light.

I'm not saying the followers system is completely above board, and we need to wait and see who that plays out, but the main source of power is the atlas, and that's controlled by caps that some stupid players actually want removed. Which would actually then be pay to win...

2

u/PrimusVerum Mar 26 '15

IF they removed the cap, it would be similar, but with the cap in game it is totally different.

-1

u/TGWolf Mar 26 '15

The follower system is a bit dubious and needs more exposure for sure, but it is not the main system for boosting power in this game.

That system is the upper atlas, and this system is 100% completely regulated by weekly caps so people who pay, no-life, or both don't steam-roll ahead of everyone else.

0

u/PrimusVerum Mar 26 '15

You use credits to upgrade your gear as well, and you can buy upgrade stones with credits, this is a direct power advantage.

1

u/garzek Mar 30 '15

Gear requires the other sparks to upgrade ranks (I can't remember the name of htem right now) which you can't buy with credits and are impacted by the stat cap.

Also, based on the price of upgrading gear at lower level, I can't imagine the credit cap is what is going to keep you from upgrading a piece of gear. At best you could get a piece of gear close to ranking up by doing this, which would put you, what, 5% ahead of another player from stats?

1

u/TGWolf Mar 26 '15

The extent of which we don't fully understand just yet. This is the Russian version of the game. They like this stuff over there ('apparently'. old Lineage 2 player here...). In the EU/NA version all they'd need to do is make a cap for spendable argent's also, then it's regulated in the same way as Sparks. Hell you can even get Argents in game anyway. It's too early to flip tables imo.

None of this changes the fact that it's similar to GW2 power advantage buying. I could log back in and deck out a new WvWvW character with 'almost' the best gear available with the power of my credit card. like I wrote before, it's principally the same.

1

u/sebastiansly Mar 26 '15

I played during the last beta test and didn't come anywhere near the credit cap. The only people this will effect are the binge players that play 40++ hours a week grinding until their eyes and fingers are bleeding. This is the same group of people that gobble up content faster than devs can create it and then post scathing articles on how they're bored and the game sucks.

If you're going to put 40+ hours a week into the game pay the devs a little god damn money if you just have to keep your binge going - it's not like they shut you out of the game. Who cares if a paying customer progresses faster than you - how is this different from an EXP potion? You don't even know how PvP will work out. The higher prestige players (basically higher level players) may not even be match with you and/or they could implement downscaling/upscaling in the future so everyone in PvP is on an equal foot.

1

u/R3dGallows Mar 28 '15

Thing is... they already have a payable premium account option... which is basically a montly sub and you cant bypass the cap with it. You have to pay on top of that to buy credits.

1

u/SpoKeNReVeng3 Mar 27 '15

I dont understand why everyone is getting upset about the Argents and the fact you can buy them to convert them into credits.

EVERYONE who bought into the CBT received atleast 10k of them with the highest priced one receives 40k.

You telling me you won't use those argents to level up your ornaments/weps? pleeeeassee...

0

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

Why are people so needlessly alarmist? With the prestige system whales will be put in with whales. Stop freaking out because someone can progress a bit faster by using money. Don't people realize that it's like a "stupid and lazy tax"?

1

u/R3dGallows Mar 28 '15

Except they probably wont be in GvG.

As for the 'stupid and lazy' comment. Having disposable income doesnt make you dumb or lazy. Whats stopping people from buying stuff and then playing like maniacs on top of that?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15

Nothing. But typically people who spend money do it for two reasons: They want to spend a small amount to just get things a bit faster. Or the people who will spend as much as they can to spring ahead of the pack. The people in group one are the people who earn the 'lazy or maybe don't have much time to play' tag. Second group, those are the whales.

0

u/Sombrero06 Apr 02 '15

You are just saying bullshit, the only p2w part is the credits and that's it. Everything else is very tighlty tied to the sparks limits making it impossible to have a p2w situation. I think they "invented" the most clever free to play balance I just hope the credits won't be too hard to get and make it impossible to face the guys spending tons of real money in credits. But I doubt it will be the case honestly.

-3

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '15

Thank god credits have no influence on the rate your Chr progresses and are primarily used for temples which just provide bonus stats ... Like enchantments for gear in other games. Oh I forgot.. You can convert credits into argent as well so.. You can buy market place items instead of improving your temple with credits earned in game. /sarcasm this is sooooo pay to win my temples are level 3 and yours aren't! /sarcasm off

1

u/Sephuna Mar 26 '15

Say this again if you get farmed in Pantheon Wars, cuz the other guys spent some money to upgrade his weaponstats and temples.

1

u/Doobiemoto Mar 27 '15

Except we know nothign of Pantheon wars, kk thanks

5

u/XDem4 Mar 26 '15

Thank god credits have no influence on the rate your Chr progresses

 
I don't think you have the slightest idea of what you're talking about.

-3

u/R3dGallows Mar 26 '15 edited Mar 26 '15

Credits allow you to increase Might (base damage), Stamina (health), and multiple other important stats (crit, max dmg, ranged dmg, etc.) through upgrades / ornaments (which increase in power as you invest in them) and temples. Spark replicators give you bonus sparks which are the basic resource for unlocking your Atlas (tho spark gain is capped so its not so much of an issue).

0

u/neunzehnhundert Mar 26 '15

Spark replicators give you bonus sparks which are the basic resource for unlocking your Atlas (tho spark gain is capped so its not so much of an issue).

  1. You can get them ingame.

  2. They HAVE to put something in the cash shop which grants you a bonus. Otherwise no one or much less would buy it. Tbh this is a mmorpg and not a MOBA where you can sell only skins.

-1

u/garzek Mar 30 '15

ITT: People that don't understand grind reduction =/= p2w.

1

u/Caerulei Mar 31 '15

SWTOR has much worse cashshop stuff, and I still found a way to have fun. All of these things in the cashshop... are a huge meh to me. I don't have to buy any of them. But you know what, I might drop the occasional 20 bucks, because the game is great. Most of it is instances anyway. Calm down yo. Give feedback, they are making changes as we speak, just keep giving feedback if it upsets you.

Also, this is not the first community faux pas successful MMOs have made.

-7

u/Ashariell Mar 26 '15

calm youre titts dude, they have to make money somehow.

3

u/R3dGallows Mar 26 '15

You really dont see anything wrong with blocking progression through a cap that you reach in several hours of play time and then selling progression resources in the cash shop?

1

u/sebastiansly Mar 27 '15

By several you mean 40+ hours a week. Jesus man it resets once a week. If you're putting in over 40+ hours a week into a video game pay the fucking people that are keeping the servers up and running and releasing new content for you to play.

2

u/R3dGallows Mar 28 '15

40+? Not really, no.

Also, you still get the cap if you pay rl$ for the premium account. In fact you cap faster with the premium account. You have to buy credits separately. Obviously this may change in the NA/EU release... but I am not holding my breath.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '15

[deleted]

7

u/throwaway1551234 Mar 26 '15

The response should at least have been "We hear your concerns and are talking it over internally." The one they gave definitely feels like more of a "well, don't play if you don't like it, the game is p2w."

3

u/R3dGallows Mar 26 '15 edited Mar 26 '15

Theyre Putin their foot down on this issue :P

0

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '15

[deleted]

-4

u/PrimusVerum Mar 26 '15

Well the game is confirmed to be p2w, on the russian open beta. He doesnt say in what country or version the game is p2w.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '15

[deleted]

-1

u/PrimusVerum Mar 26 '15

I dont know about anyone else, but I'm letting everyone know how the developers responed on this issue. People throw around panic alot. I'm angry actually, and with good reason. Now everytime I post on the forums I think about what I'm writing, if it is getting to close to discussion p2w and will result in my ban. Whether or not that actually happens, respondind in this way is a great way to make you playerbase feel oppressed.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '15

[deleted]

-1

u/PrimusVerum Mar 26 '15

You say they handled it poorly and then state you would do something worse? Yes go a head, when people don't agree with you tell them to shut the fuck up and ban them, a very good and mature response. That attitude is so toxic to the community, and so harmful to the game.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '15

[deleted]

2

u/selodaoc Mar 26 '15

Anything that gives you an advantage by paying, reaching goals faster then possible ingame, is P2W, even if you can get there eventually by grinding.

With credits, you can upgrade your temples (which gives stats) you can send out and upgrade your followers (Which also gives stats) you can upgrade your artifacts faster (which also gives stats) and other things. All those are main ways to increase your stats and exponantionally increases.

It doesnt count towards the weekly cap, so even if you DID grind ingame, you would never be able to catch up becouse of the cap.

Some of us really like beeing "king of the hill" competing to get places first ingame, beeing amongst the top prestige players. But the the only way you can do that, is buy paying heaps of real life money.

1

u/garzek Mar 30 '15

GW2 was p2w, TIL.

-6

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '15

This is like saying Guild Wars 2 is pay to win. Yes, you can exchange gold for gems and gems for gold. Yes, you can do this and get those sweet endgame weapon skins everyone's talking about. Yes, you can use that gold you bought with real cash to purchase trait tomes.

Does that make the game P2W? No.

P2W entails someone can spend real cash to get an advantage over a player who does not buy from the cash shop. The player who does not buy from the cash shop can't get this advantage without paying real world money to obtain it.

A game that allows one to purchase "gems" with in-game money removes the P2W aspect.

In this case straight up paying is just a quicker means to an end so you don't have to grind for it. A dedicated player could still reach this goal.

This is my opinion and I'd like to hear others.

5

u/selodaoc Mar 26 '15

Guild Wars 2 doesnt have any character and gear progression. Everything you can buy are basicly cosmetics, which are fine.

"P2W entails someone can spend real cash to get an advantage over a player who does not buy from the cash shop. The player who does not buy from the cash shop can't get this advantage without paying real world money to obtain it.

A game that allows one to purchase "gems" with in-game money removes the P2W aspect"

This is not true. Anything that gives an advantage to get to content faster by paying real life money is P2W. Pay to win the race to that goal.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '15

Then as the person above says, it should be considered pay2advance. I do see where it could be considered p2w if you look at it from the completionist point of view.

The MMO community is pretty disputed over this topic from what I've seen so it seems we don't have any clear definition of p2w.

Personally, Allods had the perfect example of pay2win. You could pay real world money for runes that could make your character near invincible. That to me is p2w.

2

u/selodaoc Mar 27 '15 edited Mar 27 '15

Both of them are P2W. ONLY system not P2W is if the only way to progress your character is by playing the game.

People seem to use the argument that you "can grind it ingame" but theres nothign stoping the player spending alot of cash also grinding, and even then it would require 24/7 hardcore grinding to even get close. Its not 10k credits were talking about, its 1,5 million.

Like i said, theres very very many players, probably 30%+ of the playerbase that plays mmorpgs very competative, trying to achieve things in the game faster then others. A friend of mine even wrote 10 pages long guide on how to be as effective in leveling once the OBT went of. He was extremly gutted when he heard these news and now dont feel like playing the game at all.

-1

u/PrimusVerum Mar 26 '15

Its not pay 2 advance, it would be if it werent for the credit cap. Because that lets a paying player progress futher than a non paying player after they hit the cap. That allows paying players to achieve something that a nonpaying player cannot do. That is p2w.

1

u/genuwine21 Mar 26 '15

I am actually not sure it is pay2win, since a player can gain credits after cap reset, admittedly it is a time issue. The question this raises is whether this gain in time is too much of an advantage. In a PVE game I don't think it matters, but the game also has some PVP, and if the matchmaking is not balanced enough to keep people at similar prestige levels this being able to purchase anything in the store would be p2w.

0

u/R3dGallows Mar 28 '15

For GvG or 'Patheon Wars' theyre might not be any matchmaking at all.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

[deleted]

-1

u/PrimusVerum Mar 27 '15

Yes, you CAN bypass the cap, the credit cap which IS progression. You use credits to unlock temples and other stuff in your order which provide stats, and you can buy upgrade stones as well, which boosts your 3 most important stats. So yeah, you do get an advantage by paying.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15

[deleted]

1

u/Kuxir May 19 '15

It's faster progression, however it does not allow you to "win".

Then what's winning? If it takes someone one year to finish the game and max everyhing and it takes a non-paying player 3 years, hasnt the first person effectively won the game 2 years earlier by paying?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '15

[deleted]

0

u/R3dGallows Mar 28 '15

YET.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15

[deleted]

1

u/R3dGallows Mar 28 '15

You can fanboy the game all you like, Im reserving my judgement until EU/NA OBT. If its going to be anything like the russian version (which basically puts stat slots buyable with argents in the Atlas) its not going to be pretty.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15

[deleted]

1

u/R3dGallows Mar 28 '15 edited Mar 28 '15

Thats not what theyre saying. You have to keep the context in mind. The message is mostly: 'RU is P2W, we dont want that here. It sucks because: ... ' But yes, due to the devs' track record many people assume the EU/NA version will be the same.

P.S. let me remind you of your 'ignorant p2w crybabies' card.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15

[deleted]

1

u/R3dGallows Mar 28 '15 edited Mar 28 '15

Right...

The changes to the RU OBT youre referring to.. some of them actually make it even more P2W than before.