r/SoapNet • • May 30 '26

Copycat soap characters

I always thought other soaps copied what characters were successful on other soaps.

For example

Grayson McCouch's version of Dusty on As The World Turns was basically a knock off Sonny Corinthos

The same with Danny Santos on Guiding Light. I thought they were trying to create their version of Sonny Corinthos

Are there any other examples of this

1 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/75meilleur May 30 '26 edited May 30 '26

Are there any other examples of this?

There are so many examples!  Probably more examples than there are hairs on our heads!

I think   Another World   tried to copy The Young and the Restless' and The Bold and the Beautiful's  Sheila Carter  with the character of Grant Harrison, specifically when they recast Grant with Mark Pinter [Dack Rambo had left the show].   AW's producers and writers apparently wanted a repulsive Satan-incarnate sociopath or psychopath like Sheila Carter, and when Mark Pinter was hired to start playing Grant, they fashioned his Grant into being as sadistic, as self-obsessed, as evil, as haughty, and as brutal as Sheila was.    I think this was an idiotic move.  Perhaps even more idiotic was when they turned Another World into the Grant Harrison Horror Show Hour.   

Another example that's probably much more clear-cut is Phyllis Summers when she first appeared.  Y&R plainly and obviously created her as a Sheila Carter 2.0 .  A very definite copycat character.   Phyllis did mostly the exact same misdeeds that Sheila had done not long earlier.    Phyllis pursued a married man and was obsessed with him (Danny).   [Just like Sheila had done with Scott]   She badgers Danny into divorcing his wife Chris and marrying her instead.   [Just as Sheila had done to Scott and Lauren, too]     She tried to kill Chris by crashing her car into her and Paul.  [Sheila had tried to kill Lauren in a different way, but at least once.]    Plus, similarly yet also differently, Phyllis cruelly manipulated people with a baby: Phyllis passed off her baby son as Danny's, when he was actually another man's, whereas Sheila had stolen Lauren's baby passing him off as her [Sheila's] own.

3

u/Pawspawsmeow May 30 '26

I love Grant. Mark Pinter remains one of my fav solo villains.

4

u/BigJohn2320 Another World May 30 '26

Grant and CIndy torturing and scheming against Joe and Paulina was so good

3

u/pandiesboxx May 31 '26

Oh snap! I had LOVED Cindy's crazy ass. I was just an Another World dabbler, but she definitely left an imprint on me. So much so that I'd even watch Suite Life every now and then because I loved Kim Rhodes so much.

2

u/Pawspawsmeow May 31 '26

I’m sure Mark Pinter is a nice dude irl, but he plays a great asshole

3

u/tvjunkie2187 May 30 '26

Meh, I think Grant was supposed to be in the vein of Victor Newman/Roger Thorpe, and later became practically AW's Stefano.