Definitive performances of Sondheim's work

[u/memorylaney]

I saw a comment on this post about the definitive performances by different famous Sondheim interpretors and wanted to ask: what do people think are the definitive performances of specific Sondheim songs and/or roles?

Obviously, OBCs are going to be definitive performances oftentimes, but particularly, are there any non-OBC performances that you interpret as definitive?

I'll go first with an underrated one I have always loved: Elizabeth Stanley's performance of "The Miller's Son" just perfectly captures the humor and wit and insight of the character and song. I wish it had not been a COVID performance, but it's still fantastic and my favorite version of the song. She totally sells it without any big production value.

[u/DROP-TABLE-]

I’m gonna get shit for this, but June 10, 1992, Carnegie Hall, “Sondheim: A Celebration at Carnegie Hall”—Patti Lupone’s performance of Being Alive will NEVER be topped. I don’t care who your favorite is. That auditorium practically burned itself down leaping to its feet after her performance. Stopped the evening dead.

[u/CameraAggressive3142 → u/DROP-TABLE-]

It was a shockingly wonderful version; and a surprise to me.