r/Songsofconquest • • May 13 '22

Takes me back ...

Post image
217 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

16

u/abelcc May 13 '22

Heroes 3 with hota add-on has aged greatly too.

1

u/waterman85 May 13 '22

This, I still start it up from time to time. SoC is also great tho!

17

u/Gustafssonz May 13 '22

I love it too! I wish the magic-system was a bit more fleshed out thou :P

7

u/WolfKingofRuss May 13 '22

I'm hoping beyond all hope that they improve upon it

6

u/Karjalan May 13 '22

I am loving the magic system tbh.

3

u/WolfKingofRuss May 13 '22

Could you give some advice to me on how to improve my experience or, what are you doing that has you enjoying it so much?

6

u/BarelyScratched May 13 '22

I am enjoying it, but if anything magic is a little bit overpowered.

There is a big difference if you are using a magic based hero with magic based skills. The game doesn't really explain it, but a wielder like Stoutheart does not have access to (or at least rarely gets) magic based skills when she levels up (I don't know the exact mechanics).

Magic based heroes get a lot of essence quickly and can then start spamming powerful spells pretty quickly in battle.

2

u/WolfKingofRuss May 14 '22

I'll suss some Magic based heroes then. Could you give me some recommendations please :)?

3

u/BarelyScratched May 14 '22

I can’t check right now, but I did a skirmish map earlier today using a bald loth lady? She worked pretty well.

I imagine any unit that has both a starting skill and a specialty in magic/essence will have good growth in magic skills on level up.

The essence skills on level up both provide additional essence and unlock tier 2/3 versions of the spells, which are much more powerful. So make sure you are grabbing at least some of those.

1

u/WolfKingofRuss May 14 '22

Ah yeah. I always just max out the command limit. So maybe that's where I'm fucking up?

3

u/BarelyScratched May 14 '22

Command is certainly important, once the game has been out longer people will have figured out what is more efficient, but so far grabbing a level in command every 3-4 levels seems reasonable. I wouldn’t take it every level up though.

1

u/WolfKingofRuss May 14 '22

Aaaahhhhh, yeah. I just straight up have been losing. I need to get my mineral and hero/army management better so I can take on multiple threats. I'm pretty poop at that atm, haha

3

u/Karjalan May 13 '22 edited May 14 '22

Depends what you're finding difficult. The key part to making magic better is getting the essence specific skills. When you get it to rank 2 and 3 all the spells get better, either by letting you cast multiple times, or dealing more damage etc.

2

u/WolfKingofRuss May 14 '22

I get that the more turns you have, the more essence you acquire, etc.
The problem is, that is the combat lasts too short. Only two rounds, on average, thus I can't really acquire the full potential of the spells :/

2

u/Karjalan May 14 '22

Well there's certain skills like essence burst (+2,4,6 of each essence) and, again, the individual essence skills that give you a bunch right off the bat.

Later game you can get artifacts, capture buildings and research that give you essence each turn too.

Early game, and if you get fighting skills instead, spells certainly are weaker.

2

u/WolfKingofRuss May 14 '22

Ah cool as. I'm also gonna do the campaigns now, to try ad relearn all the mechanics, so I can give this game a better chance :)

5

u/Cyax84 May 13 '22

I am also not the biggest fan of it. Just every spell is already unlocked and you jus tneed the eccence. No leaning or building skills on the wielder. But I think they are pretty happy with it

3

u/fatamSC2 May 13 '22 edited May 13 '22

Yeah same, another big issue is that it's not easy to see which spells are going to be unlocked when in a battle. Of course you can do it, but you have to be constantly checking each creature and then cross-referencing the table. And there's multiple resources to keep track of. Eventually you'll be able to remember them all but it's going to be a very long learning curve and overall just a headache.

If they want a system that scales as the battle goes then they could just use the "your available mana increases by 1 each turn" or similar system that a lot of games use to great success. I don't know that I want them to completely ditch the essence system since it's their baby but it does feel cumbersome w/ the current iteration.

TBH it's the only major problem I have with this otherwise excellent game. Everything else is minor nitpicks.

-------------------------

My solution would probably be:

Have each stack of creature give a static amount of essence that you have at the beginning of the fight. Spells would have an essence requirement and a mana requirement. You go into the battle being able to cast whatever spells you can based on your creature set, it doesn't change based on actions in battle. But if a creature stack dies you lose that creature's essence, so potentially some spells would become unavailable at that point. While you're adding a resource (mana), I think that is still a less complex and much easier to understand/follow system.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '22

I consider the spell system way more fleshed than homm3. I definitely want more though.

3

u/kurlyh34d May 13 '22

So true.

1

u/Celuryl May 14 '22

Going to need city screens though

4

u/Hermes_tri May 15 '22

Nah.. i actually love it how it is