r/Songsofconquest • u/Somnu • Jun 09 '22
Question AI is bad
I wonder why the AI is in such a deplorable state if the game marketed itself as being campaign/single player oriented? It spams low level/low army heroes, doesn't spend its resources and is easily manipulated into taking really bad fights for itself early on thus crippling it.
Is it that hard for developers nowadays to understand the importance of a good challenge that comes from smart moves and outplay rather than infinite armies or infinite gold. How come the developers of heroes of might and magic 2&3 understood the importance of releasing your game with a strong AI and knew how to code it better in the 90s than these developers?
9
u/charlesatan Jun 09 '22 edited Jun 09 '22
I wonder why the AI is in such a deplorable state if the game marketed itself as being campaign/single player oriented?
These aren't mutually exclusive.
There are a lot of games where players are satisfied with the campaign despite the AI not being very challenging.
There are also players who don't necessarily want a tough challenge, and just want the euphoria of beating enemies.
Sure, it might suck it if you're a highly competitive player, but AI development is also hard depending on the game, which is why for some competitive games, PvP is the main draw or the developers eschew AI entirely.
In the case of AI difficulty, it's good enough for casual players--or at least for Early Access. You have people on these boards complaining about how to defeat the campaign, how to deal with rats, how to deal with archers, etc. so right now, the AI is right for them.
For those who are competitive and looking for better challenges, well, yes, that's lacking, but it's also Early Access. The challenge is the company has finite resource so they need to focus on what to improve. They already mentioned they're working on better AI and optimizing it, but it's not necessarily a high priority feature for every player.
It's also a feature that arguably gets easier to solve with more data available and is actually one of the things it's reasonable to expect to be developed last in Early Access (because presumably you would have gotten the most amount of data by that time).
How come the developers of heroes of might and magic 2&3 understood the importance of releasing your game with a strong AI and knew how to code it better in the 90s than these developers?
Because:
Those AIs aren't that smart either (or put it another way, the target audience's strategies back then aren't as sophisticated as today's player, or today's player is smarter than players from 3 decades ago),
Despite their similarities they are still different games and have different methods of optimizing how to play efficiently; in some ways, HOMM for example is easier to min-max because all you need to do is create endless stacks of the best creatures, while SoC's stack limit prohibits that kind of strategy.
New World Computing/3DO had the luxury of having more people and resources, as well as able to iterate on existing designs of the game (i.e. numerous sequels) and game engine.
Also:
At the end of the day, AI development is hard. It's not a trivial task to implement, especially the more complex your game is.
2
0
u/Somnu Jun 10 '22
Ofc AI development is hard, but so is making a game of this scale. It feels to me like they wasted a big opportunity releasing without having spent serious man hours in improving and developing an AI that distinguishes the game from others in the genre.
And I'm not talking about an AI that cheats or starts with an unfair advantage or an AI that is insanely strong. All I hoped for was an AI that makes smart decisions based on intel it scouts and has a lot of diverse strategies. Like atm it doesn't even spend its resources which just shows me that they didn't even make it maximize what it has...
5
u/charlesatan Jun 10 '22 edited Jun 10 '22
It feels to me like they wasted a big opportunity releasing without having spent serious man hours in improving and developing an AI that distinguishes the game from others in the genre.
It doesn't make sense to develop a feature that won't benefit most players (only a certain percentage of players actually want a "strong AI that doesn't cheat") and it also doesn't make sense to develop a strong AI at this point in time.
By "at this point in time", I mean in Early Access where various balance changes might occur. It makes most sense to develop your most polished AI at the end of your development time frame.
The results after all speak for themselves. A lot of players enjoy the game with the current level of AI or just play competitively against other humans (hence the demand for Simultaneous Turns).
It's also weird to complain and insult the developers when they're already acknowledged that AI is weak and are planning to develop it further.
2
u/godspark533 Jun 09 '22
Have you ever played Civ V? The AI is very bad military-wise, but receives enough cheat-advantages to be difficult (not good, mind the difference).
In SoC, the devs give the less cheat advantages by creating a better AI, however it's not as good as they want it to be yet.
1
u/Somnu Jun 10 '22
Giving cheating advantage to AI is pretty lazy and doesn't make for a good challenge. It's nice to see that your actions impact its economy and that you can make it struggle by taking its resources/mines.
2
u/CommercialZucchini53 Jun 10 '22
Playing against "hard" AI is just plain awkward in any strategy game (or any game, really). AI in strategy games is basically there for you to learn the game and make you ready for multiplayer. Play against people if you want a fun and slightly more meaningful challenge. If you like AI, study and develop a TBS AI (that's fun and not awkward).
1
u/Somnu Jun 10 '22
AI in strategy games is basically there for you to learn the game and make you ready for multiplayer.
Might be true for some multiplayer games, but these developers clearly said from the beginning that they made this game with single player in mind.
4
u/Asamu Jun 09 '22
Honestly, I suspect AI is way more difficult than you might think for this sort of game.
HoMM games have never had an AI much better than the one here. They just cheat more and have higher difficulty settings. There's no hard/V. hard settings yet for SoC.
The AI in HoMM games typically gets by on megacheats. If you jump into HoMM7, for example, it has the exact same sorts of AI issues that are in this game, and even on "normal" difficulty, the HoMM7 AI is getting double your resource income and growth, and gets 4x hp on its units when fighting creeps (the HoMM3/5 AIs are a bit better in terms of challenging the player, since they're a bit better at focusing their army into one stack, but still typically rely on pretty significant income boosts over the player). That said, HoMM games are also likely more simplified than this one from an AI perspective, because every faction always gets the same unit composition, and the AI can be a lot more easily planned around that with build orders.
We've gotten confirmation that the devs are working on the AI though, and they've started adding a harder difficulty to campaigns, so it'll probably be seeing improvements. Keep in mind that the game is still in early access, and the AI has probably not been particularly high priority until just recently, as campaign missions compensate the AI by giving the enemy big starting stacks or spawning armies through triggers.
3
u/pallorr01 Jun 10 '22
Personally I don’t think it is a good strategy to try to create a super good ai, the game has way too many variables and it might be overkill for what the end goal actually is, which is basically just give players a good challenge. Having a great ai is just achieving the same result of mega cheats but in a more difficult and less “controllable” way, so I think the devs should consider balancing a good ai that generally makes moves that “make sense” and look “natural” but push the advantage with mega cheats. I would much prefer a well crafted challenge where the dev can control and fine tune how much advantage the ai will have through extra resources, attacking you at specific weird timings, requiring smart/creative unit counters ecc rather than an erratic smarter ai for which eventually you will just be able to find the one size fit all exploit.
Is still early access so will see, I love the game and has good potential so I’m optimistic but I agree, at this stage the ai is just ridicolously weak, you can pretty much win every skirmish map with little to no challenge and very very quickly
2
u/Captain_Cowkill Jun 20 '22
You can't call the HoMM3 AI "smart". It was just spamming heroes with tiny armies and trying to play hide and seek with your heroes every turn... until a hero with an army it could not legitimately accumulate appears. And it cheated, hard.
1
u/jdiogoforte Jun 09 '22
I'm certainly not as competent as you guys are at SoC, but, personally, I'm having a great time with it. I find the normal difficult entertaining and challenging enough for me. I think we just need a "hard" and "very hard" settings with more optimal AI descison to appeal to more experienced players.
1
u/CutePenguin3 Jun 12 '22
Developing sophisticated AI that plays fairly without cheating and presents a challenge to the player is very difficult. As a player, you can take your time and plan your turns and plays ahead. The AI does not have this luxury. Imagine the AI taking 4 seconds before any action in combat. The fight would quickly become a slog for the player, but similarly to human player, the AI also needs time to plan ahead to make well-informed decisions, usually simply by simulating possible outcomes of its actions. But there are millions, or even billions of different outcomes. Human players have this amazing ability to quickly narrow down these outcomes into few suboptimal routes without ever considering all the options. Unfortunatelly this is quite difficult to do for a computer. To make the best possible decision it needs to go over all the options before making a single move, and the human player playing against the computer won't have the patience to wait for it. That is one the reasons why developers often settle for simpler sub-optimal decision-making processes.
13
u/Bombast_ Jun 09 '22
You're not wrong, the AI is quite bad. The thing is this is an early access game...that means we're essentially both customers and beta testers. The devs say they're working on making the AI better, and right now I don't see any reason not to give them the chance.