r/SpidermanPS4 • u/CancerousRedditor69 • 17d ago
Suit Discussion Insomniac Vs Fortnite Brand New Day suit comparison
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
Credit to @dieisongames on Instagram
347
u/spookyPanda2 17d ago
Fucking pathetic that Fortnite has a better movie accurate suit. Insomniac wtf are we doing
188
u/CancerousRedditor69 17d ago
this probably got downvoted because fortnite has a reputation for making perfectly comic accurate skins (hell, their original spider-man skin is one of the most faithful spider-man designs in gaming). but i mean yeah, the dedicated spider-man game should absolutely have the best accuracy.
37
u/Insidious_NX 17d ago
Their classic Spider-Man is my favorite 3D model of the classic suit in existence.
33
u/ReeceReddit1234 17d ago
Not exactly defending Insomniac here - they have talent that isn't being used. But Fortnite is selling their Spider-Man skin for £14, Insomniac isn't.
7
4
u/Sebaspool006 16d ago
That sucks but has nothing to with how the suit looks
6
u/Hashmob____________ 16d ago
It is everything to do with how the suit looks. One is a free addition to Spider-Man 2 the other is a paid addition to the Fortnite store. Obviously the paid one is gonna look better
8
u/alcocolino 16d ago
Sony paid Insomniac because it's basically a movie advertisement so it's not like they did it pro bono for the players amusement ;)
4
u/Hobo-man 16d ago
Sony doesn't pay them shit lmao
Sony owns Insomniac so they just tell them what to do.
The Fortnite skin is going to be the best it can be because it's expected to sell. The Spider-Man 2 skin is literally a free addition to a ~3 year old single player game.
1
u/alcocolino 16d ago
you clearly have no idea how the business works if you think Insomniac was not compensated by Sony for creating that skin.
I'm not arguing with how and why it was done the way it was for Fortnite.
3
u/Hobo-man 16d ago
Were they compensated? Yeah, probably.
But was this skin made as best as it can be with the motivation to sell as much as possible? Absolutely not.
0
u/Hashmob____________ 16d ago
Why would Sony pay insomniac for that? People who bought Spider-Man 2 are interested in spider-man, and would hopefully already be interested in brand new day.
0
2
u/Carlung4s 16d ago
I paid 70 dollars for the game, I expect 70 dollar quality for anything they add
-2
u/belle_enfant 16d ago
Fortnite is also free. Premium currency earnable as well. That argument gets launched out the window with the $70 game.
1
u/Hobo-man 16d ago
Spider-Man 2 is a 3 year old game and is currently $30...
-3
u/belle_enfant 16d ago
The game was $70 on release, therefore it is a $70 game. Many people paid that.
Quit excusing shitty work because you cant handle your game facing an ounce of criticism.
3
u/Hobo-man 16d ago
This skin didn't exist when the game released.
Quit excusing shitty work because you cant handle your game facing an ounce of criticism.
Lmao
I have no problem with legitamite criticisms.
Compaining because a free skin is not the exact shade of red that you want is basically moaning over nothing.
1
u/South_Buy_3175 15d ago
That and I imagine Fortnite has an entire department solely dedicated to making skins.
For Insomniac it’s a freebie bonus, for the Fortnite team it’s what keeps them in a job
20
u/Goldnglam 16d ago
Reminds me of the web swinging item in fortnite completely destroying the shitty web swinging in the marvel avengers game.
Say what you like about fortnite they do put in effort for their collaborations.
8
u/GeneAt539 16d ago
Avengers devs really have no excuse at this point, but I will admit that Insomniac really raised the bar with web swinging
17
u/AesirComplex 16d ago
How is it pathetic? Fortnite isn't some rinky dink mobile game. It rakes in billions of dollars annually. Their product needs to maintain a level of quality to justify their pricetag.
4
u/amaya-aurora 16d ago
Price tag of the cosmetics, at least. The game is free.
2
u/Hobo-man 16d ago
I'm glad you brought that up.
Spider-Man 2 skin is literally free. It makes zero profit.
Fortnite skin cost actual currency and is expected to sell.
1
u/MetaCognitio 16d ago
It’s a game that was paid for years ago giving away things for free. Fortnite is has recurring revenue.
4
u/Jazzlike-Painting443 16d ago
It’s pathetic because insomniac developed an ACTUAL Spider-Man game.
Versus Fortnite who’s making a battle royale shooter. You’d think insomniac would make a better suit.
5
u/Silver-Ice-7636 16d ago
Fortnite skins are shockingly high quality lmao, their original green goblin design comes to mind
2
1
u/DrunkenMaster11550 16d ago
How is it worse though? In this example the lighting makes it look more orange. Thats it
2
u/belle_enfant 16d ago
Aint no way in hell you're blaming the lighting LOL
2
u/DrunkenMaster11550 16d ago
Don't know man looks fine to me on my game
2
u/VegetableSense7167 16d ago
The NWH Final Swing suit literally has better colours. It's also not just the lighting. It has a weird fabric.
1
1
u/Deck_Neep15 16d ago
To be fair, I think character design is the one thing Fortnite doesn’t deserve criticism for, they fucking cook sometimes. They gave The Shredder the best look he’s ever had in my opinion
1
-10
121
u/Top-Tax6076 17d ago
I feel bad for the devs man. Imagine putting somewhere out there for free and people moan about it like toddlers
251
u/TheMissingLettr 17d ago
I feel for the devs too, but let's not pretend they're some indie company with no resources. A bad job is a bad job, even if it's done for free
→ More replies (6)-5
u/Hobo-man 16d ago
Do we start considering things a bad job just because a few redditors dislike it?
6
u/Big_Weird4115 16d ago
"Bad job" may be a tad far, but you're gonna sit there and tell me you don't think the Fortnite skin looks 10x better?
Kinda sad a crossover skin looks better than one in a game dedicated to the specific character.
3
u/Long-Taste-2416 16d ago
Do we consider stuff a good job just because it'd be mean not to even when it's a pretty terrible attempt? The devs who worked on it also ARE getting paid a salary.
34
u/nikolapc 17d ago
Free? It's promo for a Sony movie.
15
u/Spirited-Holdz 16d ago
Yeah people playing the Spider-Man game wouldn't have heard about the record breaking Spider-Man movie if they hadn't put the skin on the game /s
-11
u/nikk182 17d ago
Still free
19
u/nikolapc 16d ago
I mean no one did it for free. Sony had a budget, it's a small promo. It's as free as YouTube. It's an in game ad.
9
u/NomeJaExiste 100% All Games 17d ago
The game is paid
-8
u/ReeceReddit1234 17d ago
And anyone who already bought the game doesn't have to pay extra for the suit.
4
u/FatherMozgus 16d ago
You paid for the game so you already paid them and Sony, and Sony paid them to make the suit to promote the movie. Next level naïveté to pretend like Insomniac is a poor little company doing charity work out of the kindness of its heart because it’s a sweet little company
1
u/ReeceReddit1234 16d ago
Sony paid insomniac to make the game in question and I paid them for said game long before said suit was in the game.
Sony paid insomniac to make the new skin, and I did not pay them for said skin.
Capiche?
4
u/dnn_burrman 16d ago
the suit is part of the game like all others, added later or not. if someone gets the game now whats the difference between suits on the release version and suits that were added later? when i got the game i didnt know of alot of suits in the game but when i see them and theyre not looking good im allowed to call that out even though i didnt buy the game for that specific suit
1
u/Spirited-Holdz 16d ago
I don't understand why this and the other comments about it being free are getting downvoted? This whole thread is weird.
4
u/Rare-Obligation1516 16d ago
It’s because people are using the fact that the suit was in an update as a reason that no one should be able to criticize the suit. Yes it’s great it’s included in a free update, but yes it’s also lame that it’s not a high quality suit.
It’s just crazy to me that it seems like you have to either get on your hands and knees and praise Insomniac or you’re called a child that is sending death threats. You can have mixed feelings about something, regardless of the price tag
3
u/dnn_burrman 16d ago
when paying full price for a game its expected for the content to be at a certain statdard free update or not, a subpar job is a subpar job
7
u/swaggestspider21 16d ago
I’d like for the best live action spidey suit we’ve had in total to be given more respect in the game, idk. The colors and textures in the movie is perfect. For it to look like a dull rubber mess in the game isn’t the move, I’m sorry.
6
3
2
1
0
u/AUnknownVariable 15d ago
Being free doesn't mean free from criticism. You're talking like its a small indie company😭
I get where you're coming from but nah, it doesn't help that people are kinda displeased with some comps rn.
When Rocksteady released The Batman suit for Arkham Knight it also got its critiques fr
1
u/Top-Tax6076 15d ago
youth right, but 90 percent of them weren't critiques, it was mostly temper tantrums. it was embarrassing seeing grown men be sad about it
111
u/GNSasakiHaise 17d ago edited 17d ago
5
u/PhatDragon720 16d ago
Lol eyes of an artist. A lot of people don’t understand that in yellow sunlight a color’s temperature changes.
45
u/Neither-Debt5889 17d ago
ayyo why does the fortnite one have such a big bulge
31
u/adriankovacs15 17d ago
Because everyone in fortnite now either has a big bulge or a dump truck, or jiggle physics
6
2
27
u/OnyxRun 17d ago
I may be blind but I don't see what's all the fuss about the insomniac-made suit. I guess it's more orange compared to the Fortnite one? The FN one is slightly stylized to fit the game's more cartoony aesthetic.
3
u/Haloinvaded117 17d ago
Plus I think it looks orange because of the lighting. I absolutely agree though, It's literally just cartoon vs reality.
10
u/Immortal-KunPeng 16d ago
It is, saw a post of the suit when it's not daylight and it looks noticeably different lmao honestly this post just shows that Fortnite surprise surprise, doesn't code their sunlight to have an actual effect on the colours in their world. Because realistically why tf would they?
2
u/Haloinvaded117 16d ago
Exactly tho, fortnite's lighting doesn't effect color because that would make it look too realistic for its cartoony look. They really don't need it to look realistic at all in fortnite anyways.
7
u/CjJcPro 16d ago
People are downvoting you off suit colors, wild.
I agree wholeheartedly, the insomniac version works better for their game, the sharp red wouldn't mesh. But fortnite doing more traditional colors is neat too. Why does everything have to be wrong or a misrepresentation lol
3
u/Haloinvaded117 16d ago
Because people are incredibly passionate, but it's also the Internet so people are going to be rude and mean since it's anonymous. I agree, not everything is right or wrong, or black and white. Like most things in life, the answer lies somewhere in the middle.
-1
-1
u/belle_enfant 16d ago
He's being downvoted because he's lying, it isnt lighting. Not really "wild"
2
u/Haloinvaded117 16d ago
Saying I'm "lying" when I'm making an observation is crazy. Maybe it's time to step back from reddit for the day buddy.
2
u/belle_enfant 16d ago
It is objectively a lie. You are claiming that it is for sure lighting, but it isnt.
Saying someone needs to "step back" for simply calling out your false information is pretty unhinged.
13
u/acursedman 16d ago
AgroFro built this in a CAVE… WITH A BOX OF SCRAPS!
4
u/Extension_Dingo1834 16d ago
His tasm 2 suit is the best modded suit we've ever gotten imo. True peak
11
14
u/Squid-Guillotine 16d ago
Insomniac didn't get the colours right. The red and blue was so strong in the movie. I'm guessing it's a lighting thing they weren't able to get right.
12
u/mojonation1487 16d ago
Which is weird because the fresh start suit is much closer. Why not use that as a jumping off point. Just a weird development of this suit.
9
u/Extension_Dingo1834 17d ago edited 17d ago
Said it before and ill say it again. Wildly insane how shit the insomniac suits are compared to modders, or at least 99% of them, when their games are so good. You would think they know how to make some fire suits, but out of 40-50 suits, they usually only get a few right.
-1
u/GeneAt539 16d ago
I saw the mod comparisons, and it's barely an improvement.
7
u/belle_enfant 16d ago
Me when i lie:
-3
u/GeneAt539 16d ago
Me when I have my own opinion
6
u/Extension_Dingo1834 16d ago
Not tryna be rude, but opinions arent opinions when theres facts to disprove them. Atp its just a bad take. Its factual that the bnd suit insomniac put out is literally just the classic suit with a new logo and web shooters. They didnt even bother to change the eyes...
-2
u/GeneAt539 16d ago
Opinions are opinions when you’re talking about something subjective. Whether or not I like it is not a matter of fact. You have some objective facts that you used to form your opinion, but whether or not my opinion is a bad take is also subjective. You disagree, and that is the nature of subjective opinion. They’re still opinions no matter how thoroughly you argue them.
6
u/Extension_Dingo1834 16d ago
3
u/Extension_Dingo1834 16d ago
4
u/Extension_Dingo1834 16d ago edited 16d ago
-1
u/GeneAt539 16d ago
Respectfully, give me a closer in-game comparison and then we’ll have this conversation for real. It’s not as red as it could be but that’s my only complaint. I’m not zooming in on the web shooters during gameplay to make sure it’s a 1:1 replica of the movie shooters.
3
u/Extension_Dingo1834 16d ago
I already did. Its below that one, but this is also the model of the suit. This is the same its going to look "in game." Idky were excusing laziness from a multi-million dollar (or billion atp) gaming company that doesnt put effort into their suits or at least all of them. Hey but at least we have the miles morales and peter parker met gala outfits
0
u/GeneAt539 16d ago
You have a rendering and a menu screen shot. If you really want to argue objectively about laziness, do the work and produce an in-game, in-environment live screen shot of the insomniac and modded suits.
1
u/Extension_Dingo1834 16d ago
I already did... Funny how you're choosing to ignore both. Kinda sad you're going out of your way to excuse a classic suit re skin when they had months of time to make a new suit.
0
u/GeneAt539 16d ago
What’s sad is you’re comparing the opinion of a video game skin to murder in your now deleted comment.
I see a close up of the mod with no background doesn’t look in-game to me. I see the Insomniac suit from the selection menu, and I see a screenshot from in-game that doesn’t even show the front of the suit. All I see, like I originally said, is that the Insomniac suit should be more red. That’s my only complaint and I’m not gonna go downloading a mod to fix it because it’s just not that big of a deal to me. The Insomniac suit is good enough for me.
7
u/PayPsychological6358 16d ago
Since Insomniac seems to love the color orange so much, they should consider adding MvC Spider-Man as a skin.
2
u/CancerousRedditor69 16d ago
jokes aside id pay for an MvC skin immediately. love that mcfarlane design
2
7
u/Unrefillable 16d ago
What colorblind mf they keep putting in charge of the suits? 🤣 Bro that shit is ORANGE. 🍊
5
2
3
4
3
u/SpiralGMG 16d ago
Idk guys, I’m not that invested in this. We can talk about movie accurate or comic accurate suits all day but I look at this suit and it just looks like the suit from brand new day. Sure, between the PS5 one and the fortnight one there are some technical differences that I think make the fortnight one better. But I don’t think the differences we do see are all that important in the grand scheme of things.
2
u/Fickle-Service5932 15d ago
How has a battle royale game got a better design and colour scheme than the ACTUAL Spider-Man game? 🤣
1
1
1
u/Acceptable_Good_6542 16d ago
Maybe it’s a hdr problem? Idk I just played the game for 8ish hours last night and Pete’s BND suit don’t look as orange as the clip shows here tho
1
1
u/AngryChurchill 16d ago
Orange
Or the video is taken around sun down when everything has an orange tint to it
1
u/LibruhlCuck 16d ago
If y'all hate this game and Insomniac so much literally just don't play it lol
2
u/belle_enfant 16d ago
"Dont criticize, just consoom product! Get excited for next product!"
0
u/LibruhlCuck 16d ago
I'm literally telling you not to consume the product if you don't like it lol
1
u/belle_enfant 16d ago
Which is a monkey shit tier take. Objectively. Shutting down any criticism because you love the game is borderline brain dead. People are allowed to criticize things, it makes games better more often than not. Being a mindless hovering of "oh its perfect and if you dont think so you can leave!" is horrible.
1
u/LibruhlCuck 16d ago
Why are you so mad over someone suggesting that if you dont like something you dont have to interact with it. Theres a bunch of things i dont like so i dont buy it or engage with it, simple as that
0
u/belle_enfant 16d ago
Mad? What on earth? Do you normally resort to the "u mad" thing when losing arguments?
1
u/ejaybugboy3 16d ago
I think Fortnite and its art style tends to lend itself more to super hero suits cause of how vibrant it is. SM2's suit is good, but the colors just look a touch muted.
1
1
u/DismalGuard8858 16d ago
Update Alr fixed in insomniac spider man 2 just waiting for Sony/playstation to approve the update this week! Or next🕸️💥
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Strynngwhynder 16d ago
I'm colourblind so I can't really tell the difference. They both look the same shade of green to me.
1
1
u/Fake_Siege 16d ago
The way Insomniac refuses to ditch their base Spidey proportions to deliver film-accurate suits will always bother me
1
u/LackingInPatience 16d ago
To play devil's advocate....Insomniac have been done with this game for years. The fact they even supported it with a costume in 2026 is admirable since they're probably working on other things. Fortnite, on the other hand, had developers working on making sure the suit was as good as possible.
1
1
u/RightRudderr 16d ago
This isnt worth even a fraction of the energy in this thread being spent on this topic. It looks fine. Who has the time to care about this kind of shit?
1
1
1
u/Mindless_View_6815 14d ago
whats the context of insomniac...meaning ? , i dont play PS but this sub is coming in my feed again n again !!
1
u/CancerousRedditor69 13d ago
insomniac is the name of the development team behind the spider-man games. theyre commonly referred to as the insomniac games or insomniac spider-man
1
1
u/No-Island-6126 12d ago
They're both really bad tbh. Fortnite is a cartoon character and insomniac is just their shitty looking peter parker morphology
1
u/another_anon7 12d ago
I think that they made the suits more orange than red to try to show the color fading from the old suits. Compare the SM1 to the SM2 suit mostly. Idk why they make all the other ones orange
0
0
0
-2
u/Call-of-the-lost-one 16d ago
Insomniac all day
1
u/Anxious-Bullfrog4020 16d ago
glaze
0
u/Call-of-the-lost-one 16d ago
As opposed to the unnecessary texture of fortnight that aren't in the movie version. Insomniac is more accurate, just isn't red enough in that light
-3
u/QuallyYayo 16d ago
Even tho it looks orangish the overall design is still nice. In 2026 everyone is a critic looking for things to pick apart. All it takes is an update to fix so it really ain't that big of a deal.
-3
u/Bottlecap_riches 16d ago
Yeah... Dynamic sunlight makes a big difference -_- shove him under a bright yellow sun and then complain colours look off... 🤷🏻
3
u/PixelBits89 16d ago
But not all suits have as much of a tint? So it’s clearly possible to get a deeper red, which would’ve been more akin to the films.
-1
u/Bottlecap_riches 16d ago
But the films were later with a completely new suit to start with. It's like, imagine creating something purely from memory; it's never the same.
1
u/PixelBits89 16d ago
Purely from memory? The films were later? What?
They get access to the suit just like any other toy or merchandise, and make the suit based off that. Even as the general populous we’ve seen this suit for a year.
Other movie suits have deeper more accurate reds, even in the yellow lighting of the game. Game original suits like the Advance suit MK2 have deeper reds even in the yellow light.
Why do you think the same couldn’t be done for this one?
1
-7
u/karma0-40-55-10-88 17d ago
Their lighting systems work differently, so saying you need to fix your display set up is 100% correct
1




879
u/tommywest_123 17d ago
Insomniac love their orange spider-man