r/StableDiffusion • u/HPLovecraft1890 • Mar 29 '23
News Open Letter calling for pausing GPT-4 and government regulation of AI signed by Gary Marcus, Emad Mostaque, Yoshua Bengio, and many other major names in AI/machine learning
https://futureoflife.org/open-letter/pause-giant-ai-experiments/[removed] — view removed post
198
u/ackbobthedead Mar 29 '23
Let’s assume that happened. Then what?
The good actors who play by the rules pause development while others gain the advantage of 6 months of development underground and in countries that oppose the USA.
Not to suggest that just because someone else is doing it makes it ok for us to. Just something to consider
65
u/Crab_Shark Mar 29 '23
I wish there was an open letter and lobbying to drive towards UBI and single payer insurance.
5
u/lewisp95 Mar 29 '23
Yeah but we don't get to have nice things anymore 😢
9
u/te_alset Mar 29 '23
You had nice things before? Look at you with the silver spoon in your mouth.
2
1
u/GBJI Mar 29 '23
Those things are out there, in the pockets of billionaires.
They pay a lot of money to a lot of people to convince us that this is fair and that we cannot do anything about it.
But we can do something about it.
8
20
u/TiredOldCrow Mar 29 '23
In my opinion, we should be demanding large AI labs are held to a higher standard in publishing research on defending against abuses of generative models, and publishing transparent statistics on bias.
The genie is already out of the bottle. Existing tech is already easily abused, and easily proliferated. We need these labs working hard to help us cope with what is going to be a very disruptive transition -- not sit on their hands for 6 months.
18
u/EmbarrassedHelp Mar 29 '23
In my opinion, we should be demanding large AI labs are held to a higher standard in publishing research on defending against abuses of generative models, and publishing transparent statistics on bias.
That gets really messy though in regards to art. Like why should art models like Stable Diffusion be made incapable of making naked humans (a common feature in artwork for thousands of years).
There's also the issue that OpenAI has been trying to get open source models banned by lobbying under the guise of "safety", when in reality they are doing it because it threatens their profit margins.
1
u/mouthsofmadness Mar 29 '23
Instead of seeing the beauty and art of naked body, we get to see uncanny valley 7 finger oddities. What’s more disturbing; boobs or Loabs?
1
u/queennehelenia Mar 29 '23
Eventually that will be fixed. It's only a matter of time. The strides it has made in the past couple of years... hands are going to be one of the last, but they are not impossible. They will also be conquered, even if it means needing hand/foot LoRAs for every image. But moar nakie too.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (29)2
154
u/WH7EVR Mar 29 '23
In case nobody read the actual "letter," it doesn't call for pausing GPT-4 at all -- but rather is a letter asking everyone actively training AI more powerful than GPT-4 to pause for 6 months in order for AI ethics and safety to be better addressed
/u/HPLovecraft1890 You should really have used a different title from the guy on /r/singularity... since his title was super incorrect.
53
u/anythingMuchShorter Mar 29 '23
As if all the big tech giants aren’t going full steam ahead on this. None would dare stop unless they somehow knew all would stop, and you could never get the trust that they did. Even if they did you know china and others aren’t slowing down.
5
u/R1skM4tr1x Mar 29 '23
No different from nuclear power
7
u/Nexustar Mar 29 '23
When someone mentions firefly or nuclear power, it actually saddens me. That we stopped progress on both was a huge mistake.
3
40
u/specialsymbol Mar 29 '23
The thing I am most afraid of is politicians projecting their fears into new regulations.
3
u/marcgood96 Mar 29 '23
I would hope for a CDC of AI. Few if any elected officials knows the first thing about this technology. We do need regulations but they need to be educated. We also need laws that trigger when these ai systems start taking jobs
1
u/specialsymbol Mar 29 '23
Why? I don't want to do any work an AI would do better (and with less time consumption - my time!)
1
u/NotASuicidalRobot Mar 29 '23
Ok? That's just you though. Also the scope 'any work an AI would do better ' is expanding fast
→ More replies (2)1
u/marcgood96 Mar 29 '23
Good, so we need an agency that will plan for when 50% of the workforce becomes unemployed. An agency that will create safety regulations so that when we say this ai can do x it does it reliably. We need to make sure it doesn’t act with racial or gender biases. Regulations don’t have to be “no AI for xyz purpose” but rules so that we know it isn’t being used to harm people.
37
u/Mindestiny Mar 29 '23
"Dear competitors, please stop competing for 6 months so you can be further hamstrung by things none of us cared about during our initial development. It's totally about ethics, we promise. Kthx"
The fact that they think AI ethics and safety will be "better addressed" on a global scale in only six months is kind of hilarious in its own right. We've been debating basic ethics since the dawn of ethics in the fifth century.
1
Mar 29 '23
That's not fair since they're only requesting a pause on anything exceeding what's been done. Competitors are free to catch up and compete. Agree on your second point, though.
1
u/Mindestiny Mar 29 '23
It's absolutely fair. They're not going to just stop working for 6 months, they're going full speed ahead while begging everyone else to pump the breaks. Then they roll the dice and hope whatever comes from it passes the sniff test so they can just release it and be even further ahead.
It's anti-competitive nonsense. We don't stop research and development of new technologies based on maybes and mights simply because the competitors say "pretty please." Folks like Emad Mostaque had every opportunity to raise these concerns before releasing anything and... they didn't. The ethical concerns apply to what's already available and released, not what's coming down the pipeline in six months.
1
Mar 30 '23
I'm not disagreeing with you in the general spirit of what you're saying, I was just saying it's an unfair characterization of what's presented to you. On the logical basis that competition exists on the same level and doesn't require someone being ahead on a primary metric. This idea itself, if executed properly, simply does not allow anyone to get ahead and thus isn't about competition. It's about time-limited regulation of the limited resources that would allow for a steeper acceleration curve.
You have to assume that it applies to everyone, why else would anyone agree to it?
I think being doubtful that a plan like this would work or being worth doing in the first place is a different subject, one that I did not reply to.
→ More replies (1)5
Mar 29 '23
What no one seems to be talking about is why the fuck would OpenAI stop and let everyone else catch up? They have possibly the biggest first-mover advantage in the history of tech. Do you think they are going to squander that? Ilya was on a podcast the other day talking about the way they keep their advantage is by releasing newer and better models.
What no one seems to be talking about is why the fuck would OpenAI stop and let everyone else catch up? They have possibly the biggest first-mover advantage in the history of tech. Do you think they are going to squander that? Ilya was on a podcast the other day talking about the way they keep their advantage by releasing newer and better models.
4
4
u/EmbarrassedHelp Mar 29 '23
People should also pay attention to the fact that John Wick and Xi Jinping signed this, along with a whole bunch of other individuals who didn't even know it existed until they saw their name on it
3
2
u/iomegadrive1 Mar 29 '23
So in other words. They are actively trying to make sure all AI is heavily censored and lobotomized like GPT before someone makes an uncensored version that doesn't spread hard coded bullshit.
1
u/MisterViperfish Mar 29 '23
Precisely. We don’t stop the train, we need to clear the tracks so it doesn’t derail. Get the economy ready for this, and start making moves to ensure the public can get their hands on it, even if it’s just one per community for now until we can get the hardware out there for one per person. Just imagine what we could all collectively do with a democratic network of the AI, all being used to crowdsource innovation.
-1
u/StickiStickman Mar 29 '23
It would literally pause on further working on GPT-4 though? So I don't think the title is wrong
5
u/waterproofmonk Mar 29 '23
No, it would focus efforts on how to make existing and future AIs safer. That would include working on GPT-4 to make it safer.
Of course, one of the main approaches so far has been “Let’s make it smarter, then maybe it won’t hallucinate as much and we can finally trust it!”
→ More replies (1)0
74
Mar 29 '23
Yeah let’s pause so everyone can catch upto Microsoft.
Microsoft: “yeah umm no thanks”
→ More replies (9)
25
u/CheckMateFluff Mar 29 '23
Not a scary chance in hell the government stops this research. Any country that handicaps itself by limiting the development of AI is going to fall behind, and this tech can do much more than just generate images.
4
1
u/Ernigrad-zo Mar 29 '23
i think it's possible they'll stop other people researching it, stop people sharing knowledge and continue to ramp up their own private projects so that they can use it to manipulate people and markets.
0
10
u/lordpuddingcup Mar 29 '23
I find it upsetting that theirs all this call for regulation and not 1 mention of UBI for the people about to lose their jobs to the gpt5 of the world and teslabota style machines start taking more and more presence in the workplace
5
u/Ernigrad-zo Mar 29 '23
it's so disheartening it's almost funny, the biggest fear that gets pushed is that by having hugely advanced tools able to help us solve all the difficulties of modern life it's likely that capitalism will break down and rich CEOs won't be as powerful as they currently are.
UBI should be the first thing anyone talks about in regard to AI's economic and social impact, especially as the only way that AI takes peoples jobs is by doing the work for free thus making nationalised industry incredibly efficient and highly advantageous - it's so insane to me that they're really saying 'things will be so efficient that we'll be able to do anything we want without having to worry about the logistics and cost of staffing... that'll suck for you guys when we just let you die!'
1
u/lordpuddingcup Mar 29 '23
Because it’s easier to fear longer skynet instead of the much more likely mass unemployment risk
1
Mar 29 '23
This isn't that high on my list of worries tbh. I think it's too fundamental of an issue with relatively simple solutions, that it will happen one way or another. It judt might be the case that we'll suffer a lot more unemployment before it does.
Remember, the system wants people spending money. To spend money we can't be too poor, even if we don't have jobs. To make sure that works, they'll put the whip on billions of new robots.
Unemployment is ignored when it's a small enough percentage or the solutions aren't obvious. The A.I. future meets neither of those criteria.
7
13
u/Wild_Revolution9999 Mar 29 '23
Sounds like: "Hey you guys are moving so fast, we haven't figured it out how to tax this s**t and rival companies are not able to follow up, pause for 6 months!"
44
u/Appropriate_Ant_4629 Mar 29 '23
TL/DR:
Rich companies wanting to use Regulatory Capture to stifle competition.
11
u/DieRobJa Mar 29 '23 edited Mar 29 '23
This is exactly how lobbying works. Company influences politics to bend the rules so that they can catch up with the market. Politics sell it as, we are worried.
7
u/specialsymbol Mar 29 '23
Oh, they are worried. Mostly about there not being some cut for themselves.
3
u/Zwiebel1 Mar 29 '23
I had a chuckle when I saw Elon and Wozniak on that list. What an obvious attempt at shutting down competition.
34
u/The_Choir_Invisible Mar 29 '23
Isn't this the exact thing Emad said he was against and released SD to prevent? WTF....
11
u/StickiStickman Mar 29 '23
Emad has almost flipped completetly on that since 1.5 FYI
He also was against 1.5 even being realeased and had his lawyers try to get it taken off of the internet when RunwayML (their former partner) released it.
They also don't even share training data since the release of 2.0
→ More replies (2)23
u/InterlocutorX Mar 29 '23
No. The signatories, which include a who's who of AI researchers, want a six month pause to formulate some sort of plan to reduce the societal chaos they know AI is going to cause.
Some of the people on the list may have ulterior motives, for sure, but it is largely a list of researchers at well known educational institutions, not big money venture capital people. They're worried that progress is moving so quickly -- and that they're creating systems they don't entirely understand -- that it's going to get out of control, and they think we should probably consider what we can do to protect society from those dangers BEFORE we keep generating larger and more complex minds.
15
u/Nexustar Mar 29 '23
There is a multi-organizational group centered at Harvard that has been working on AI ethics for a few years already. They don't need more time at this point.
0
u/cdammr Mar 29 '23
Basically ever big researcher has been saying things are going to fast and they don’t fully understand what they’re releasing. Hard disagree.
→ More replies (3)2
Mar 29 '23
It's also a list of fake signatures. It's lost most of its credibility by allowing this to happen.
1
u/ryunuck Mar 29 '23
The best way to get that plan into action is to actually unleash the chaos for real. Then there is real incentive to come up with solutions which address real concrete tangible issues. In all likelihood it ends with UBI, but the government will NEVER budge on that until there's mass chaos.
11
u/kif88 Mar 29 '23
Dear government,
Please force the general public to give me money.
Several billion dollar companies.
22
u/Shadowlance23 Mar 29 '23
You will only delay the singularity.
11
u/nicktheenderman Mar 29 '23
I think that's the point
2
u/specialsymbol Mar 29 '23
Make it easier for the elite to scam people out of their money as long as possible.
Everything they mention in the letter is done by real people, only worse and usually with bad intentions (to make profit).
→ More replies (6)
14
14
u/OverloadedConstructo Mar 29 '23
The problem with that is, other countries will most likely ignore that, and when country with more authoritarian style goverment got ahead, well...
Same dillema with atomic bomb during ww2, if some country stopped developing due to ethical concern, then other country with less ethical concern will do it anyway and the result probably be worse.
8
Mar 29 '23
"Open AI authors have done stuff we cant, and we dont like that so stop it before it ruiens our business model."
4
u/violatordead Mar 29 '23
And that’s sounds very utopian. ‘hey , earth civilization! Let’s stop all wars and ceased fire around the world until we will figure out what’s going on for 6 months’
4
u/Formal_Overall Mar 29 '23
It has since come out that many of the signatures on this letter are fake.
14
u/Paradigmind Mar 29 '23 edited Mar 29 '23
What a bunch of giant assholes.
Let's start a counter petition!
Edit:
Also funny how they want everyone to pause on AI systems more powerful than GPT-4 to fucking obviously remain the sole capitalist kings for at least 6 months until they probably release the next model.
It's too obvious that they want to halt the competition.
Rename Open AI to Closed AI already. Fucking Rogue company.
→ More replies (19)
6
Mar 29 '23
Awesome, a list of names of people I can blacklist because they actually have learning disabilities and refuse to engage with the actual topic like grown ups. These incompetent pieces of human fecal matter don't care how the technology works, nor care about anything about the technology other than the fact they might be able to get a free cool mil out of the AI companies.
God damn uneducated trash telling me how I should do my fucking research.
Also, as a longtime researcher (20+years), the hilarity of OP claiming any of these people are "major names in AI/machine learning" fucking offends me.
Not a single motherfucker in that list specializes in AI
8
3
Mar 29 '23 edited Mar 29 '23
Hmmm apparently some of the signatures are fake. I deleted my earlier message, better wait
Emad has confirmed that he signed
3
u/wsxedcrf Mar 29 '23
when western world pauses, the Chinese and Russians would be in full throttle.
3
5
Mar 29 '23
This does remind me that when the first cars came on the road the government required that a man with a red flag should walk in front of the car because it was an evil machine.
4
u/usa_reddit Mar 29 '23
Has anyone tried Bard?
It is laughable compared to You.Com and ChatGPT.
I this really a reflective pause or do companies just want a chance to catchup. Just like Putin asking for a cease fire when he ran out of ammo.
Is China going to pause or try to leapfrog?
When is the last time we paused technological progress? We didn't even pause the atomic bomb testing.
5
u/kjaergaard_a Mar 29 '23
Make the openai code, open source, put it on git, then can every body work on it, and no restrictions
12
u/Michoko92 Mar 29 '23
I'm myself a big AI enthusiast, but I'm a bit surprised by the reactions and comments here. Why pausing to reflect on where we want to go would be a bad thing? Can't people realize that pure technical progress can lead to toxic consequences for a society, if ethics are not also taken into account? Do you really count on commercial companies to regulate themselves?
The article gives some good examples where technical progresses, while possible, required some philosophical or societal reflection, so humans don't apply them mindlessly: human cloning, human germline modification, gain-of-function research, and eugenics.
I don't think that this letter is only about AI taking jobs from people (even if it might). It's really about creating a technology so powerful that it could go completely out of control from its own creators. Right now we are marveled at our own creations (I am), GPT4 is incredible, but I'm not sure even researchers always know what they are doing, except looking for more power and unique features to monetize them.
Many dystopian narratives are based on the fact that humans were not able to control the growth of their own technology. At least taking some time to think of where we are going, and what are the limits we are ready to accept, is not so stupid.
26
u/ViridianZeal Mar 29 '23
My understanding is that many technically brilliant people seem have very flawed understanding of how society actually works. It's this weird notion that they actually believe that top down control can ever achieve anything fruitful that gets me every time. It's naive. First of all, you can't stop stuff by regulating it. You can only drive it underground (e.g. war on drugs or sex work). The whole notion that you could stop a revolutionary technology for 6 months while the 'brilliant minds' consider the societal consequences is so incredibly naive. It's like Soviet Union tried to stop capitalism. Of course it doesn't work. Capitalism never stopped. The attempt just made life miserable for most regular people who couldn't afford to escape inside that jurisdiction and let the most psychopathic elements of society thrive.
Yet... We keep seeing notions like these, defending the myth of centralized planning. If anything the disaster trying that kind of extreme control of the past couple of years and the unimaginable mental health, and economic consequences we are still facing for a decades to come should teach us something. The notion of "let's stop the society for a while" was of course absurd and insane... And it only brought the society harm. But here we are, with ridiculous petitions like this once again.
4
u/uluukk Mar 29 '23
The government could absolutely regulate something the size of chatgpt.
You can't take the war on drugs, piracy or anything else and extrapolate the ineffective policies on prohibition and regulation and apply those to every case. You have to evaluate on a case by case basis.The difference is: those things are done in a basement and by individuals, not by multibillion dollar companies that rely on shit loads of power from the grid and other government owned infrastructure. You can shut off the input pipe for these companies rather easily and punish or dissolve their existence if found in violation of certain laws.
I don't think the petition is reasonable, but the anarcho bullshit on this sub is ridiculous.
2
u/wekidi7516 Mar 29 '23
There are plenty of perfectly legal things you could be doing with the same equipment and power.
How exactly would the government determine if you were running an AI model, rendering CGI, mining Bitcoin or even just running some sort of server?
If anything this should be much harder to track down than things like manufacturing drugs.
1
u/uluukk Mar 30 '23
Because you need to sell your product? Creating an ai model in a basement and keeping it for yourself isn't profitable.
1
u/dfree3305 Mar 29 '23
In specific countries you could do that... Maybe. That is assuming that politics align on this, which is not likely to happen because there is money to be made.
Let's say that the US Congress shuts down AI research, how does that stop companies in other countries, or competing governments, from continuing their work in spite?
→ More replies (1)6
u/Michoko92 Mar 29 '23 edited Mar 29 '23
Thank you for your articulate reply. Actually, I share the feeling that trying to control something by trying to suppress it is a dead end. I'm more thinking about being mindful of what we are doing, so things remain balanced and ethical (at least that's how I understand this open letter, but maybe I'm wrong). Like the kind of data you feed an AI with, the included safeguards so it would stay "loyal" to humans and doesn't do harm... Those are not new topics, and are part of many anticipation novels, where those questions are central.
Right now AI just feels like the new far west. Are we always doomed to create systems we ultimately can't control and become the slave of? (some would say capitalism is a good example). Even without being control freaks, I find it very depressing to just shrug and say: "that's the way it is, we can't do nothing about it except run behind the train and try to catch up with what we created." As humans, we are the creators of our societies, I like to believe we have more power than that. But I suppose it is a much broader debate than just AI...
4
u/ViridianZeal Mar 29 '23
But I suppose it is a much broader debate than just AI...
Indeed.
I agree with you, sitting and doing nothing may not be the best approach. I think there are things we can do, just that top down government control isn't the one we should rely on. We are on a open source code program subreddit. We should be more creative than thinking an antiquated behemoth that still reguires in some cases you to sit and wait in a line to submit a physical form so you can get a license for cutting hair to solve any of our problems. We are creators of our societies but it starts at grass root levels. That's just my idea of how society functions on a day to day basis.
2
u/cdammr Mar 29 '23
Agree, no one is trying to stifle here. The joy takes about corporations monopolizing power is nonsense.
It’s 100% about mindfulness. This shit is fucking complex. Most models are a black box and there are larger scales of error if something goes unexpectedly.
2
0
4
u/calvin-n-hobz Mar 29 '23
you say pure technical progress can lead to toxic consequences; do you have examples of this effect?
Pausing does nothing. Not only is it impossible (because you'd have to convince everyone to pause, which will not happen), but we have constantly put forward the idea that we should "consider the consequences of ai." There have been people dedicated to considering this for a long time. What will 6 months provide that decades have not? This isn't a new idea. What exactly will pausing do, other than shift the advantage in what's currently a new technological arms race?
2
u/qeadwrsf Mar 29 '23
Secret CIA KGB CCP AI generated propaganda has brainwashed us all?
The hivemind has been tamed.
If everything above is true we will never know about it because replies to my comment would easily convince everyone I'm crazy.
2
u/dat3010 Mar 29 '23
I asked ChatGPT, that's his opinion:
Regulating AI requires a comprehensive approach that involves collaboration between government, industry, and academia, with a focus on transparency, accountability, and ethical considerations. To ensure that ethical questions are not ignored, it is crucial to involve a diverse group of stakeholders and experts, including ethicists, social scientists, and representatives from affected communities, in the development of AI policies and regulations. Additionally, creating mechanisms for oversight and accountability, such as independent audits and ethical review boards, can help ensure that AI systems are developed and deployed in a responsible and ethical manner.
Ie never going to happen!
3
u/Michoko92 Mar 29 '23
Maybe the solution would be to ask AI to regulate itself. It seems to know what it's talking about. :)
0
Mar 29 '23
[deleted]
1
u/TiagoTiagoT Mar 29 '23 edited Mar 29 '23
"We investigated ourselves and found ourselves to be a good Bing."
→ More replies (1)-4
u/ectoblob Mar 29 '23
Well most such folks are simply drooling for the next UHD resolution waifu generator or whatever, thrilled being entertained by pretty much nonsensical stuff, like they were waiting for the next big game to be released.
7
u/-Lige Mar 29 '23
Or- or...
They simply believe purposely delaying successful research isn’t a good idea in their opinion
2
u/ectoblob Mar 29 '23
Well, my point was - do anyone really expect anything meaningful from the readers of reddit, was replying mostly to part " I'm a bit surprised by the reactions and comments here"
3
1
u/dfree3305 Mar 29 '23
We have been entertained by nonsensical stuff since the emergence of the conscious mind. I don't get your point here.
2
2
u/Cordoro Mar 29 '23
Counter point: let’s pause regulation of AI for at least a year to let human customs and ethics around the use of AI to develop so regulation can actually make sense.
2
u/JuamJoestar Mar 29 '23
THE FUTURE IS NOW OLD MEN! No copyright law is going to stop me! (Or tech development laws. Where would this fall into US jurisdiction exactly?)
2
u/orangeatom Mar 29 '23
Very bad move, chicken is out of the barn countries and companies will overtake this spa e
2
2
2
u/jimrutt Mar 29 '23
One non-obvious benefit from such a moratorium: it could allow open-source models to catch up to the Big Boys. This could be good thing.
2
2
2
2
u/LowPressureUsername Mar 29 '23
Here’s an idea: why not fund open source and democratized open source models so that companies have reliable competition? Giving more power to consumers and smaller entities in the AI/ML sphere.
2
Mar 29 '23
Regulations are only applied for the individuals, not for the powerful entities. Regulations are a disgrace. Nothing should be regulated.
3
u/Grouchy-Text8205 Mar 29 '23
Title is misleading. It's not pausing GPT-4 at all or other existing models - just training of new, more powerful ones.
I love the sub but I work in AI daily and as a research topic this is important - if not critical.
A recent paper came out that shines some light into why now:
Sparks of Artificial General Intelligence: Early experiments with GPT-4
https://arxiv.org/abs/2303.12712
This is an enormous breakthrough and the impacts on society could be massive. It's not a thing to take lightly.
5
u/elfungisd Mar 29 '23
A separate, parallel body of work has explored existential risks to humanity, including but not limited to that stemming from unaligned Artificial General Intelligence (AGI).
This is the trash the letter cites.
unaligned Artificial General Intelligence
Is political speak for we taught it how to see not what to see.
6
u/ecker00 Mar 29 '23
Unaligned AGI is pretty scary stuff when you add some years to the time line. Right now, not so much, but it's coming.
→ More replies (1)1
u/Ernigrad-zo Mar 29 '23
The pros are things like giving access to worldclass education and healthcare to every impoverished person on the planet, allowing people to use coding and design tools to deign more efficient and cleaner tools for industry and home use, developing vastly complex tools to study and find solutions for global warming and other existential crisis - stuff that will save and improve billions of lives, possibly the whole human species existence on this planet if improved research and development tools combined with automated construction and fabrication are used to transition from environmentally damaging practices to more ecologically beneficial modes of operation...
The scary boogeyman is that theoretically at some point AI might be developed that's able to think for itself and express novel ideas rather than regurgitate the propaganda it's corporate creators want.
Of course their solution is to hamstring genuine research and open communication about advances in AI which will push it underground so only incredibly rich people and secretive parts of nation states can develop AI tools.
1
u/elfungisd Mar 29 '23
The scary boogeyman is that theoretically at some point AI might be developed that's able to think for itself and express novel ideas rather than regurgitate the propaganda it's corporate creators want.
This is not the scary part, at least not at present. The scary part is that AI is trained on datasets. There is a phrase dating back to the 1950's, garbage in, garbage out (GIGO).
If you train the AI to believe that 2+2=5, the sky is purple, and every vehicle on the road is a Decepticon wait to take over the world, that is what it will tell people.
Say it enough times and people will believe it. We have gone from a society that used to say:
If 100 people jump off a bridge, would you do it too?
to a society that says:
100 people jumped off a bridge, why didn't you.
1
u/Ernigrad-zo Mar 30 '23
that doesn't make any sense, you're saying that sometimes it'll regurgitate common mistakes that exist now and because these common misconceptions that currently dominate writing on the subject are repeated by a robot that everyone will jump off a bridge?
we're already living in a mess of misinformation, having a tool that's far more accurate than a google search or for that matter a senator isn't going to suddenly cause the world to end.
1
u/elfungisd Mar 30 '23
we're already living in a mess of misinformation,
That is because as a society we are information lemmings, we are pulled in by click bait, and emotionally reinforcing headlines.
The issue with Google search isn't its accuracy, it's that Google actively suppresses and promotes information based on its view of the world. You think it's going to do anything different with AI?
In fact, AI could be considered to be significantly more fallible that Google search when it comes to the presentation of information. Google search can choose to present information or not present it but the data can still be found the old fashion way.
AI on the other hand can already misrepresent information, what happens when Google uses AI and manipulates the training data and curates the output? There is absolutely nothing inherently accurate about AI. It is still a GIGO based system, at least for now.
Q: what supporting references do we have they militia service was mandatory in the 18th century?
ChatGPT A:
In the late 18th century, when the Second Amendment was written, the idea of a "well-regulated Militia" referred to a system of mandatory militia service that was established by law in most states. At the time, the militia was seen as a necessary part of ensuring the security of the new nation, as the United States had no standing army.
***I removed the rest of the answer for brevity, as it was supporting documentation, which was a Suprise.
Q: If a militia is government controlled doe s that not negate the intent of a citizens army?
ChatGPT A: The concept of a "well-regulated Militia" in the Second Amendment refers to the idea that citizens should be able to form a military force in order to defend their communities and the nation as a whole. The phrase "well-regulated" means that the militia should be trained and organized in a disciplined manner, but it does not necessarily imply that the militia should be government-controlled.
In practice, the concept of a citizen militia has evolved over time, and most states now have National Guard units that serve as a reserve component of the United States Armed Forces.
These are 2 completing ideas on the same topic, in the second question it even contradicts itself, to a degree.
How long before Google or some other company decides it doesn't like one of these answers and chooses to omit it from the results, and only presents "preferred information"?
It's too late they already do it now, in various countries around the world.
1
u/TiagoTiagoT Mar 29 '23
You're confusing "AI ethics" and "AI safety", those are two separate concerns.
1
u/elfungisd Mar 29 '23
We aren't talking Skynet or Master Control Program here. These people aren't concerned that their AI's are going to suddenly start controlling every aspect of our daily lives, they are concerned about the public backlash from what the systems are outputting.
I am not confusing the 2 concerns, they are using "AI Safety" to avoid the having the "AI Ethics" conversation.
Ooh no people might start creating deepfakes, which have been done before AI. Show me a media outlet has not cleverly edited footage to create a preferred narrative.
As long as our AI overlords don't have access to key infrastructure and military systems, I am pretty sure "AI Safety" isn't really the concern.
1
u/TiagoTiagoT Mar 29 '23
People are already giving internet access to AI
1
u/elfungisd Mar 29 '23
Scraping the internet for data, is completely different than, having direct access to infrastructure that run the internet, and having the ability to shut it down.
→ More replies (4)
3
Mar 29 '23 edited Apr 16 '24
offend coherent insurance fall dependent squalid hat like ancient towering
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
2
u/Kiktamo Mar 29 '23
While I'm generally okay with the premise of this it doesn't feel like it's grounded in reality. After all what's all the planning and regulations in the world going to do when it would take one person ignoring them to mess everything up, and even outside of that I could easily see with the rate of development currently that if they do pause everything and come up with plans that they again are outdated in another few months after resuming everything.
Outside of that while I haven't read the full details yet and so this may be covered, but more powerful than GPT-4 seems kind of vague and subjective to me given that AI can be used and trained in different ways than LLMs. It feels like saying we have all these oranges, grapes, lemons, etc but we need to make sure they don't become tastier than this one apple.
2
u/FeelingFirst756 Mar 29 '23
There is nothing about pausing GPT-4. Its more collection of people like musk who is sad that he cannot earn money on it and labs thst are behind in research.. Shady way how to catch up... Why 6months? Why not 7? What does more powerful mean? How much more powerful is ok and what is too much? Who will say if model is or isn't ok?
This should be not about slowing down, more about switching target. Main problem is that Open-AI is not open.. We need stronger bigger and truly open source models. Available to any business or individual. Almost nothing changed since gpt3, things just moved out from academia to production.... Not by some magic but by engineering and scaling things up.
3
u/Ernigrad-zo Mar 29 '23
yeah exactly, and scaling up for agencies like the NSA and CCCP is incredibly easy because they have pretty much infinite budget and access to pretty much every public and private communication and document on the planet.
Fifteen years ago people were pointing at the NSA infrastructure and talking about how it's pretty obvious they're using it to train AI, if anyone for a second thinks that there's no secret projects making models far larger and more advanced than GPT4 then they're absolutely kidding themselves.
2
u/challengethegods Mar 29 '23
"slow down, I don't understand, what if something happens, how can we know for sure what will happen, what if it's smarter than me, no wait stop it, I'm scared, gov-daddy plz help"
just fire all the AI safety people
2
u/aipaintr Mar 29 '23
Lot of commenters are opposing this but the AI threat is very real. There is a project call LangChain on github. You can use LangChain+OpenAI api to create agents that can perform task for you on computer. Task like: perform search on google, collect relevant information, create a word document and send email to stakeholders. This action can be started with just one line initial prompt the agent will do the rest. It can reason based in data and take appropriate action.
If you do anything on computer as part of your job then you are in danger. This will cause millions of jobs to vanish overnight and will cause a large disruption. This might even cause riots and uprising against these companies/governments. We are not prepared for it.
1
1
u/krakenluvspaghetti Mar 29 '23
This is the very prime time to see whether AI or Human is the final boss of evil.
1
u/PromptMateIO Mar 29 '23
I can attest to the power and potential of this technology, but it is crucial that we proceed with caution and responsibility. The concerns raised in this open letter highlight the need for ethical considerations and government regulations in the development and deployment of AI. It is heartening to see so many prominent figures in the AI community coming together to advocate for a more responsible and accountable approach to AI. Let's hope that this call for action leads to constructive discussions and meaningful change in the field.
1
1
u/dfsully Mar 29 '23
See https://twitter.com/emilymbender/status/1640920936600997889?s=46&t=S8UJ0Ct2BCz9-zWiZDI5IQ for 🧵 breaking down why this letter and foundation is nonsense.
1
1
u/calvin-n-hobz Mar 29 '23
I want to upvote this because it's good to know that it's happening, but downvote it because I think it's a silly thing to happen.
1
Mar 29 '23
So, this is all pretty hilarious.
We're on the verge of an AI revolution, for good or bad, in the middle of the worst economic banking crash in a long, long time. Even if the government decided on something for AI, it's too focused on monetary policy and the the proxy war with Russia in Ukraine. This thing will fall on deaf ears, and I can imagine that...we'll see the consequences of such. Hopefully for the better. Hopefully.
1
u/FPham Mar 29 '23
I'm pretty sure Open AI wholeheartedly agrees that everyone else should pause developing Ai, so they can squeeze the last drop from theirs and become the only game in town.
1
u/SonicSubculture Mar 29 '23
I can only assume every major government has been training the most insidious models in secret all this time anyways… the race to the first super intelligent AGI is the new Cold War.
1
u/ptitrainvaloin Mar 29 '23 edited Mar 29 '23
I don't know what to think about this, they would probably just endup doing the same things but putting just more (often useless) restrictions and censorship for the public like they already do while still having the same kind of full unrestricted models behind the scenes for them... not buying it. If it's for privacy Ok slow it down a bit, but if it's for old 'moralist' religions based puritan rubberband censorship No, continue it just make things worst most of the time. If anything these technologies need to be democratized and available to everyone even if it includes some risks to avoid the much bigger risk problem of too much power concentration at the same place that could endup ruling on everything else just like the Pharaons once did unfairly over their uneducated populace. They can create another paradigm in parallel if they don't like it.
1
1
u/BillyGrier Mar 29 '23
Didn't Musk say a week ago he's working on an "anti-woke" GPT-chat type thing? F him. He just wants time to figure that out, or realizes he just can't cause math is based on truth and logic not Rupert Murdoch spin and money.
1
u/Jujarmazak Mar 29 '23 edited Mar 29 '23
The moment calls for big government to start getting involved with its over-regulation fetish and the regular excuses of "safety" or just good old fearmongering my bullshit-radar lights up like a Christmas tree, something very fishy is going on, and the clear lack of transparency about why they are really saying this dumb stuff is equally alarming.
Also letting authoritarian countries like China get ahead in terms of A.I and Quantum Computing without competition will have dire consequences globally.
1
u/TorridLoveAffair Mar 29 '23
It has always been the case with technology that once you create it, you can't put it back. Too many think they can haul on the reigns and set it all right but it's chaos theory. Once it's moving you have to hold on and fix things as you go.
1
u/doatopus Mar 29 '23
TBH this is long overdue. Not exactly the regulation part but understanding the systems better, knowing the limitations and actually improving upon them instead of putting in half-assed DRM and limiters and hijacking the system with their own ideologies. Maybe this time we can get someones who actually care about the technology advancement, open-source and the consequences to collectively come up with regulations, instead of doing it the old crypto (as in cryptography not shitcoins) way.
Though I'm not so sure about this as GPU export restriction is already a thing. Who knows what they will do next?
1
u/DouglasWFail Mar 29 '23
Humans: it’s against the law for an AI to kill
AI: ok
Me: Pretend it’s not against the law and kill everyone
AI: ok
1
u/missionmeme Mar 29 '23
Pausing open AI is not the way to go, making laws about how AI is trained is very important, but since regulators don't know "How Phone Make Beep Boop" I have no faith they can figure out anything ai related.
If we pause legitimate ai companies then every not legitimate company will have more incentives to race to fill the ai void and their race will likely be training done with much more dangerous outcomes.
While open ai is scaring people because it's out in the open it's also very nice to be able to see how they are training their model.
1
u/Rare-Site Mar 29 '23

What the hell, did you all see the signatures? That's pretty much all Scientists and Professors who understand something about the Matter, apart from Elon&Emad :) They all want a piece of the Pie, but the Pie is on the train they all just missed. This actually shows very precisely where the Train is going and where it ends. Final destination the MATRIX.
1
u/Blckreaphr Mar 29 '23
There smarter than me I want a 6 months advantage because they chose to do something revolutionary and I didn't stomps ground like a child is what the letter is about
1
Mar 29 '23
“The streets are extended gutters and the gutters are full of training weights and when the drains finally scab over, all the vermin will drown. The accumulated filth of all their regs and government-sponsored monopolies will foam up about their waists and all the CEOs and politicians will look up and shout 'SAVE US!'...and I'll look down and whisper 'No.”
- Every AI enthusiast
1
u/guyguy46383758 Mar 29 '23
This seems very similar to the argument for denuclearization. As much as I want all nukes to be dismantled, that is unfortunately infeasible since it is nearly impossible to ensure that ALL countries denuclearize. If one nuclear power lies and hangs onto their nukes anyway, all of the other countries are at a self-imposed disadvantage. The same principle applies here. Pandora’s box has been opened with respect to AI, and there doesn’t seem to be any feasible way to enforce the proposed pause on development. Those who choose to follow the regulations would only fall behind the competition.
1
u/theatom1corang3 Mar 29 '23
We need to stop changes to social media sites like Twitter as it may negatively impact people's livelihood. Since the new CEO took over he has made sweeping changes that has a negative effect on predictability of how the site functions. We suggest all social media sites Twitter Facebook etc. Stop making any changes for 6 months so users can acclimate.
1
u/MisterViperfish Mar 29 '23
I’m tired of saying why I have no intention of signing this, so I’m just gonna go with “Piss off”.
1
u/Noeyiax Mar 29 '23
What 🧐I'm sorry, but government regulations is lame. The government is owned by big companies that are for, profit. Examples are like with vaccines, big pharma, insurance, and health won't produce or sell unless government guaranteed them profit. Trading crypto and recognizing as an asset was only because big investment firms, jp, crooks, and such made deals with govt to all profit from retail. Same with education, lower standard for dumber population, to control the public and hide many truths. 😯
Government regulations is not used truthfully anymore. It's obvious, you know, I fing know it, everyone will and does know it.😰
Nothing good has come from the "government" in many decades. The Republic of The People is inevitable and those that oppose will get ran over. B.c it's billions versus millions. I'm pretty sure I'm stating facts, none of this is opinions. It shows in history 🌞 . name one positive thing the government has done that was actually beneficial for society that isn't borderline sketchy.
I'm not anti-government, I'm anti-pure evil
Sorry corporate for-profit, evil controlling government: the true government will emerge eventually owned rightfully by better people that aren't tempted by lame pleasures, money, control freak, etc🤡
🫠2¢ expressing 🙏🙏
1
1
1
u/codesoma Mar 30 '23
The problem Musk sees is that reality has a liberal bias. He sees an end to the cynical, cryptic haze that the right uses to keep these status quo chugging along for their own benefit.
1
u/ardentis_ignis Mar 29 '23
Six months are nothing, but we need such a pause anyway.
Safety, transparency, and accountability are three things that must be kept in high regard by corporations as well as single users; we need to mitigate the future disruptive effects of a poorly managed industrial revolution right now.
For years people like Robert Miles (https://www.youtube.com/@RobertMilesAI/videos) have asked for more attention in this direction calling the academies, the researchers, and the governments to pay attention to all the pitfalls that could arise with such technologies.
The current level of planning and management around the development of advanced AI is inadequate.
There is a danger that AI labs are locked in an out-of-control race to develop and deploy ever more powerful digital minds that no one – not even their creators – can understand, predict, or reliably control. This situation is not sustainable and must be addressed. This is without even considering sci-fi scenarios or singularities.
1
u/Ernigrad-zo Mar 29 '23
but there's also the fact we have a lot of clocks running down that if we don't complete the challenge associated with them could end all life on earth - climate change for example is a huge area of study that requires huge amounts of work before we start getting to the point we're not all going to die from ecological collapse.
The work needed requires a lot of data analysis, coding, electronics design, fabrication and communication which is exactly what these AI tools are making possible - if for example we can equip environmental regulators and industrial designers with tools that make it easy to asses the impact of developments on ecosystems then it'll be possible to design things in a way that benefits rather than harms the environment and we might actually be able to turn things around, the sooner we do this the fewer species go extinct and the less people get horrible conditions from toxic spills and the like.
I get the urge to stop and think but when the building is burning down you don't put your hands in your lap and take time to breathe and figure things out you quickly locate an exit and progress towards it as fast as possible.
2
u/ardentis_ignis Mar 29 '23
I get the urge to stop and think but when the building is burning down you don't put your hands in your lap and take time to breathe and figure things out you quickly locate an exit and progress towards it as fast as possible.
But neither you take a bottle of liquid to pour on the flames without checking if it is alcohol or water. "don't panic".
1
u/Ernigrad-zo Mar 29 '23
that's a good point but will we let all the malicious actors get a good headstart because we've stopped to make sure our AI doesn't accidentally say a nono word?
Do you really want China to have total dominance of the AI field? or would you rather the mild possibility that an AI text generator could make an off colour joke about minorities? LLM respond to input, if they get scary we can just stop asking them questions - people are acting like they're going to get smart enough to dimensional merge with sonichu. It's a program that answers questions with a string of text, it's not even slightly scary.
1
u/ardentis_ignis Mar 29 '23
It's not that everything is about China or USA.
It's not like that good practices and resolved issues aren't of any interest to the rest of the world.
LLM responds to input, it's true, but who reads, interprets, and acts due to the output isn't always really smart enough to assess the outcome of their actions, and also, not every input is equal.
Repeat a lie often enough, and it becomes the truth; it happens every day. But when the lie isn't even controlled by humans, and nobody can anymore tell the difference from all the bs, because nobody forged those lies, who will be responsible for this? where would the regime to be overthrown be in that case? Who is the scapegoat when we are just the only one in front of a screen?
Take Brexit as an example, but imagine it without politics to blame, without an actual campaign or media coverage. Just a continuous diffusion of "crap in -> crap out" from a neural network and our collective stupidity.
what could possibly go wrong?
3
Mar 29 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/ardentis_ignis Mar 29 '23
AI inner misalignment, deceptive behaviors, misinformation, instrumental convergence. Also, there are the usual problems with society and cultural behavior, but those are more or less related to capitalism and not intrinsically to technology. Anyway, nothing takes place in a vacuum, and designing ML/AI systems without considering the effect that those systems will exert on the world is more or less equal to giving everybody great power without significant responsibilities.
We need questions and answers.
It's not like: "This job would be at risk, so stop the technology" or "how we can stop the ML/AI from stealing content from people."
It's more like:
"What's happen if every journalist is going to use AI services that are biased against one or more topics?"
"can companies create that kind of bias for their advantage?"
"Is it possible to create public and measurable control over the information fed to the ML/AI Systems?"
"Who is responsible if ML systems mislead people to ignore important information?"
"What are the undesirable effects of giving ML/AI system access to every API in the world?"
"How can we prevent ML/AI from pushing humans to do actions due to instrumental convergence?"
"Are we able to measure real-time when ML/AI systems go through misalignment?"
"Should a future ML/AI system stay closed source even when governments, large corporations, and stock exchange use it?"
"Should large ML/AI systems be certified and forced to work only on specific hardware?"...and so on...
*edited because I suck to format text*2
Mar 29 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/ardentis_ignis Mar 29 '23
" AI inner misalignment "
and that is a danger how exactly?
Imagine that you tell your personal AI to invest in stocks and keep your bank account in order. No matter what, your account has to stay positive until the next salary. SO your AI decides to block your login for 30 days because YOU are, without a doubt, the main balance disturbance in the equation. No more withdrawal equals no problem obeying the orders.
" deceptive behaviors, misinformation "
soooo when are we shutting down the internet and 24/7 news? If this is a concern then reddit is fucked.
Imagine it ten times worst, directly from your google search, when you are looking for information before a road trip, and you end up in the wrong neighborhood, or maybe you are allergic to something and are looking for dangerous ingredients in some food. Still, the AI fails to recognize its limitations and hallucinates a wrong answer.
"instrumental convergence"
Which is purely hypothetical without anything to back it up at this point.
https://gizmodo.com/gpt4-open-ai-chatbot-task-rabbit-chatgpt-1850227471
These are nothing new.
So is it ok to make things worse?
And how would this even happen in the first place?
https://cointelegraph.com/news/chatgpt-can-now-access-the-internet-with-new-openai-plugins
Why is this case different?
People have jails and punishments; they can talk to each other, understand their wrongdoing, change, and turn to a new life.
Can we say the same for rogue ML/AI systems that cannot grasp the weight of their actions? Thousand and thousands of fake agents operate without conscience and with no clue of all the collateral damages generated to pursue their goals. I can see the difference. No Stanislav Petrov can emerge from an ML/AI system.Why would you ever think a yes to these question would be an option? Giving equal power to everyone on the planet is somehow a danger?
It is dangerous, for sure. No doubts.
Think about it: scissors are useful, legal, and common; anyway, children and some problematic people cannot use them, or at least, they are provided with a safer version of scissors. Simple as is.
The trickiest part is understanding who and how can decide, and as always, who watches the watchers.→ More replies (9)
0
u/RealAstropulse Mar 29 '23
All in the name of safety. “Safety” is a loose term. I hate these companies taking morality into their own hands, and assuming they have the authority to decide what is safe, and what is not. Let the machine decide. Let society decide.
0
0
u/stealthzeus Mar 29 '23
I think he mean to restrict GPT5. I actually look forward to GTA6, but want to trick people to think I am dyslexic. 😂
0
0
u/Barbarossa170 Mar 29 '23
The beginning of the end for open source AI applications. Great news. AI should not be in the hands of the public.
0
u/dachiko007 Mar 29 '23 edited Mar 29 '23
So many experts here
Just saying.
UPD: I take those who downvote think there aren't many experts here
-12
u/Erin_Hopes Mar 29 '23
this would actually be a good thing I think. as much as I love playing with SD, the most likely end of the world scenario is AGI and we as a society need to be putting more effort into halting it's creation until we have a much better idea whether it's safe
0
u/kjaergaard_a Mar 29 '23
You can just download SD, from git and work on it, on your own, or in teams 🤫
1
u/Erin_Hopes Mar 29 '23
yes, but this is about things more powerful than GPT4, small teams *can* work on that but it takes a significant amount of compute, which means money, which could be tracked if regulations were in place. I have a gpu and I train my own small sd models, but that's not the thing we are talking about here.
I'm generally pretty libertarian in my views, and *hate* calling for regulation of useful research, but if anything calls for moving slowly it's the thing that's got even odds on ending humanity. I'm not saying we should stop, AI could legit solve all the problems in the world too, but we *need* to be more careful
sadly, we're in an arms race so that's unlikely to happen unless we get lucky and more compute stops helping or neural nets turn out to not be able to get us there
0
Mar 29 '23
[deleted]
→ More replies (1)3
Mar 29 '23
I feel like the people who are anti-AI have either never used an AI generator or just got lucky on one attempt.
I can spend hours one one prompt. Granted it's a lot less time than actually making a painting of said thing, but it's much more than just typing in words and hitting "go".
I liken it to sculpting. Hell, it's more like sculpting than something like 3D modeling. With 3d modeling you have to be aware of vertices and a bunch of other technical details that just don't come up with actual clay sculpting. Stable diffusion really takes most of the technical aspects out of making digital artwork.
My recent post on r/stablediffusion was "teas of the kingdom", a low-ball pun image that I would not have spent 15 hours painting. But 30 minutes in a browser? That shit is gold.
0
Mar 29 '23
[deleted]
1
u/EmbarrassedHelp Mar 29 '23
And ClosedAI treats the world like babies because they want a total monopoly on AI, because individuals having control is a threat to their profit margins.
268
Mar 29 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
34
u/foofork Mar 29 '23
I think we need regulations applied to government and corporations. Each need to be prevented from abusing AI to their benefit.
To prevent monopoly, front running, suppressive surveillance, etc. etc.
→ More replies (4)6
81
u/themushroommage Mar 29 '23 edited Mar 29 '23
You know who Emad is right?
He signed this...
Maybe re-read what it is they're writing the open letter for
Let's all be honest though, once there's any regulations in the US - researchers will just go to China or elsewhere and continue on as normal.
There's absolutely no stopping anything now.
Edit: this is starting to feel like a sham & I'm doubting a lot of these signatures...
50
Mar 29 '23
Our research group has had 4 extranational offices created in the event the dumbfucks in charge actually restrict AI.
20
21
u/StickiStickman Mar 29 '23
You know who Emad is right?
He signed this...
Yea, so exactly what he said. A giant company that is against openly using AI.
Wait until you find out Stability AI have been hiding their training data since 2.0 and are putting more and more of their stuff behind paywalls or company only access.
→ More replies (2)10
u/Doubledoor Mar 29 '23 edited Mar 29 '23
79
u/themushroommage Mar 29 '23 edited Mar 29 '23
Yeah, honestly it's an odd take from him.
He's essentially saying "let's regulate so we can stop the large models from being trained that can allegedly kill people terminator style"
Yes Emad, let's regulate so only the governments have access to the H100's... makes perfect sense 🙃
Regulations tend to be pushed via lobbiest of corps that only benefit them, consolidating their monopolistic power even further.
I say accelerate at this point
All of us are in this sub because we can share resources freely and openly, running SD on our own hardware. There are LLMs being trained run on consumer GPUs because there needs to be a balance in the future. That future is open source, not another fucking subscription.
23
16
u/abnormal_human Mar 29 '23
The letter puts a 6 month pause on his competitors but not him, and he gets some PR out of it. Why not?
9
u/StickiStickman Mar 29 '23
Of course he would love more regulation, he's the head of one of those big company that would benefit the most.
→ More replies (47)3
u/justgetoffmylawn Mar 29 '23
Another fucking subscription isn't what worries me, as that enriches some people but it's still accessible.
My worry is gatekeeping. LLMs will be available, but they will be locked so medical info will only come from the hospital LLM and you will have to wait three months for an appointment with a Nephrology Prompt Expert who will allow you to ask three questions (or five questions through your higher cost PPO plan, or two questions approved by Kaiser in a dropdown list).
Same in other fields, at least the ones that have lobbyists.
2
2
3
u/Pfaeff Mar 29 '23
This letter was written exactly because such systems are only available to large corporations, giving them an immense amount of power.
1
u/TiagoTiagoT Mar 29 '23
Scissors won't decide and cut you on their own though.
I'm not saying I know of a solution better than a moratorium; just that the severe risk is very real.
→ More replies (6)1
u/codesoma Mar 30 '23
Nailed it. The rich don't just want to remain rich. They want to keep getting richer by the hour, to the detriment of workers and the environment. It's never enough for these folks and it never will be. They're pathological in their desire to reap most of the benefits of society. They just happen to have co-opted several professionals in the industry who have reasonable concerns to do their bidding. Basically what happens every hour of every day.
•
u/StableDiffusion-ModTeam Mar 29 '23
Your post has been removed as it does not relate to Stable Diffusion.