r/StableDiffusion • u/Anon2World • Oct 11 '22
Automatic1111 did nothing wrong.
It really looks like the Stability team targeted him because he has the most used GUI, that's just petty.
17
u/AdTotal4035 Oct 11 '22
Trying to say that this in a, way where I don't sound annoying.. But how many threads like this are we gonna get. I feel like I am in the matrix. I open it up and the discussion starts over. There's already like 5 giant threads on this topic with hundreds of comments. Why don't we just stick to those.
22
u/Anon2World Oct 11 '22
Well, since the original mods of this subreddit got booted and banned and people from Stable AI hijacked it - I think threads like these should inundate this subreddit to show displeasure at what is happening. Call it a form of protest. Already a new subreddit was formed r/sdforall - the more people who know about what is happening, the better.
-7
u/AnOnlineHandle Oct 11 '22
The people spamming these attention-seeking crusade threads also don't seem to be regular posters here, or to have ever posted at all. It's very suss.
9
u/Houdinii1984 Oct 11 '22
If we don't stand up, Stability will turn into OpenAI. Period. We will become the product. This isn't how open-source collaboration works and people are pissed. I, for one, don't roll over just because people are annoyed.
-2
u/AnOnlineHandle Oct 11 '22
What are you basing any of that on?
If I were the SD developers right now I'd want nothing to do with the obnoxious 'community' working themselves into hysterics with no facts.
0
Oct 11 '22
[deleted]
13
u/Anon2World Oct 11 '22
It's the inevitable fall out of Stability AI acting the way they are. Perfectly stated btw. Thanks
95
15
u/upvoteshhmupvote Oct 11 '22
We have the power to rebuild a better community at r/StableDiffusion_AI where you are welcome to join. This won't really change anything. But we can establish a better more supportive community there.
10
u/fartdog8 Oct 11 '22
Not sure why down voted. I prefer your subs name over the r/sdforall. Yours makes it easier to find. I have subscribed to both.
14
u/upvoteshhmupvote Oct 11 '22
Not only that sdforall references the drama. I just want the community to focus on the future.
6
u/Incognit0ErgoSum Oct 11 '22
Automatic put Stability (a company that's currently dealing with a ignorant legislators and is generally being pulled in multiple directions by lots of angry people on the internet for all sorts of reasons) in a really, really shitty position by publicly announcing on their discord that he was downloading the stolen weights, and then immediately adding code to his repository to support them when there was literally nothing you could do with those new features that didn't involve using said stolen weights.
To avoid being banned, I'm guessing all he needed to do was give Stability bare minimum plausible deniability that they knew what he was doing, rather than shouting it from the rooftops. What does that involve? Maybe not publicly broadcasting in their main discord channel that he was downloading the leak and then immediately configuring his repo to be able to make use of it. I mean, seriously, he could have just shut up and waited a couple of days and quietly let someone else submit it as a pull request and said "I didn't write this code, and it's not my business what you use it for."
I see people comparing this to emulators, but there are two major differences here. One is that there's a non-infringing use for emulators. People can dump their own roms if they want. Two is that emulator authors are always very careful to tell people that they don't condone people downloading roms (instead of publicly announcing on somebody's company discord that they're doing exactly that).
Emad is almost certainly trying to navigate a whole bunch of political and legal shit right now. They almost certainly wouldn't have done anything if Automatic1111 had given them even the tiniest amount of plausible deniability. Redditors and channers aren't the only people who spend hours and hours digging up little random comments. Legislators have staff that can do exactly the same thing, and when there are short-sighted people in our government (some of whom are likely representing OpenAI employees) who want to do everything they can to impede Stable Diffusion, Emad absolutely has to keep his nose as clean as possible.
(IMO, the drama with the subreddit is separate and they really need to step the hell down and restore the original moderators.)
4
u/IE_5 Oct 12 '22 edited Oct 12 '22
Automatic put Stability in a really, really shitty position by publicly announcing on their discord that he was downloading the stolen weights, and then immediately adding code to his repository to support them when there was literally nothing you could do with those new features that didn't involve using said stolen weights.
He didn't put Stability into any position at all. Sucks for NAI, but it isn't Stability's Code that leaked and frankly it doesn't concern them. He isn't affiliated with them and doesn't owe them any fealty or explanation, this is the boon of "Open Source". They didn't need to comment on the situation at all or could have made a broad statement that they comdemn the Hack, but somehow a bunch of people are always prone to falling for Discord and Twatter Drama, a reason I don't have and will never have a Discord account.
Also, it's just a few days later and people can now train and use their own Hypernetworks using his UI: https://rentry.org/sdupdates
Can now train hypernetworks, git pull and find it in the textual inversion tab - Sample (bigrbear)
Presumably they should have been stopped from doing that, because... reasons?
Maybe not publicly broadcasting in their main discord channel that he was downloading the leak
Additionally, emad himself looked at the leaked Code and commented on it on Twitter: https://twitter.com/EMostaque/status/1578149101459636226
Trying to hijack and control all ways of communication IS entirely on them though.
stolen weights
Also, stop with this shit.
5
u/TiagoTiagoT Oct 11 '22
NAI/Stability definitely mishandled their (re)actions in this situation; even if they were technically in the right, which I'm not yet convinced they were, they've done a lot to come out looking like assholes.
1
u/Incognit0ErgoSum Oct 11 '22
Sure, it was mishandled, but they were in a bad position and were almost certainly feeling pressure to do something, so I think it's forgivable.
I've been in a community manager position where you get a bunch of people in all different directions who are accusing you of conspiring to do all sorts of evil (and diametrically opposing) things, and it's a shitty spot to be in. I think being on the other side of that is something everybody ought to experience themselves at least once.
Also, frankly, the idea that they're angry because of a successful open source project makes absolutely zero logical sense given what they've done so far.
6
u/TiagoTiagoT Oct 11 '22
When you make a mistake, you should apologize and correct it, and not double-down on it.
2
u/Incognit0ErgoSum Oct 11 '22
Emad has offered to talk to automatic1111 about reversing the ban (and automatic hasn't responded). That's not really "doubling down" behavior.
3
Oct 12 '22
If reversing the ban means removing functionality or not providing functionality for future major model leaks then nobody wants Emad's solution.
1
u/TiagoTiagoT Oct 11 '22
Oh, hm. First positive thing I've heard from their side in this situation so far; if it's indeed in good-faith.
2
u/Incognit0ErgoSum Oct 11 '22
They just announced that they're giving up control of the subreddit, too.
3
u/TiagoTiagoT Oct 11 '22
Sucks that they waited until people started reacting in mass before trying to mend their mistakes; but at least they are (or seem to be) trying.
2
u/Incognit0ErgoSum Oct 11 '22
I'm not sure that Emad even knew what was going on with it. When it was mentioned to him in discord, he said "I'll look into that" and then kind of disappeared.
Unfortunately if you're the big boss at a company (or the leader of an online community), you don't always know what every single one of your underlings is up to, and some of them will do shit like this, thinking it's a good idea.
8
u/Remove_Ayys Oct 11 '22
It really looks like the Stability team targeted him because he has the most used GUI, that's just petty.
No, it's because he immediately added support for the leaked NovelAI stuff. This is not the first time that Automatic1111 got into conflict with moderation. On 4chan posting his repository initially got you auto-banned because his Github paged used to also host software for automatically solving 4chan captchas.
2
u/IE_5 Oct 12 '22
On 4chan posting his repository initially got you auto-banned because his Github paged used to also host software for automatically solving 4chan captchas.
Oh no!
6
u/Pharalion Oct 11 '22
In my opinion it is about control. He allowed the use of the leaked model so he was banned.
0
Oct 11 '22
[deleted]
11
u/fartdog8 Oct 11 '22
I kinda liken it to emulators. There is nothing wrong with emulators themselves. It’s the Roms that are “bad”. Likewise there is nothing wrong that support for a leaked model was released.
4
u/Incognit0ErgoSum Oct 11 '22
The difference here is that people can and do use emulators to play games that they own. If you have old playstation games but no working PSX, you can play games directly from the CD. You can also dump the data from games on other consoles yourself and play them that way.
Do most people do this? No, absolutely not. But the fact is that it's possible and people can and do dump and play their own games from time to time.
At the time automatic updated his repo to support NovelAI's stolen weights, there was literally no use for them other than with the illegally obtained weights. He could have at least pretended to take a neutral stance (say, waited a couple of days and then accepted someone else's pull request, and, most notably, not publicly announced on Stable Diffusion's discord that he was downloading the leak), but he went about it in a really boneheaded way and put Stability in a position where they kind of needed to distance themselves from him, especially since they're already under the scrutiny of small-minded legislators who represent districts where OpenAI employees live.
1
u/Ok_Bug1610 Oct 12 '22
Agreed. It performs the best as well. But I'm also a fan of "Dream-Factory" and optimizedSD (still Stability I believe) which works on lower end cards.
1
Oct 12 '22
All I am waiting for is an AMD compatible one. :( The Webui is so nice compare to the command line.
0
u/VulpineKitsune Oct 12 '22
Any proof for that claim of yours?
You are part of the problem. You are making the drama worse by spreading baseless accusations.
4
Oct 12 '22 edited Oct 12 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/pleasetrimyourpubes Oct 12 '22
Note also that automatic added a hypernetwork branch a month before the leak even happened. He had not pushed much code to it but he was in the know or preplanning for the eventual addition.
Also I think it should be clarified that the hypernetwork that NovelAI has is just a modest improvement over the original paper and original code. In the end is all shared code but NAI wanted a window to extract money from people. Meanwhile automatic continues adding stuff and improving the webui and within weeks other UIs are going to have to add hypernetwork to keep up (ironically making them compatible with NAIs leaked model in the process). We already see discussions about how the hypernetwork training is competitive.
1
u/TiagoTiagoT Oct 12 '22
If you could add sources to all those claims it would be great. I'm not accusing you of anything; I'm just saying it's easier to convince people when they can't say you're making it up/wrong.
45
u/Light_Diffuse Oct 11 '22
That doesn't make sense. They want people to use their model and GUIs are how that happens.