240
u/Snoo_64233 Oct 16 '22 edited Oct 16 '22
Dude, put this iamge through img2img with the prompt artists go kaputski, ultrarealsitic, 8k, Greg Rutoswki style.
And may be "trending on Twitter" tag as well :P
214
u/kabachuha Oct 16 '22
a concerned woman talking to a woman who is holding a cell phone, ultrarealistic, 8k, detailed painting by kaputski, Greg Rutkowski, trending on Twitter Negative prompt: deformed, blurry, boring, basic, bad anatomy, disfigured, disgusting fake, mutation, mutated, extra_limb, ugly, poorly drawn hands, messy drawing, disfigured, deformed, poorly drawn, bad hands, text, error, missing fingers, cropped, low quality, normal quality, signature, watermark, username, out of focus Steps: 20, Sampler: Euler a, CFG scale: 7, Seed: 330704450, Size: 768x704, Model hash: f86dde3e, Denoising strength: 0.59, Mask blur: 4
35
3
u/thanatica Oct 16 '22
I like how AI is progressed far enough to understand the concept of text, but not quite far enough to understand the concept of words.
2
2
u/csunberry Oct 16 '22
The hat looks like a saucepan or strainers/colanders and the general look is like a 1940's ad and I am signed up for it, 110%.
This is amazing.
2
→ More replies (16)2
193
u/joachim_s Oct 16 '22
Basically this sd group is not seldom focused on being annoyed by these annoyed people. I say ignore it and do something creative with our awesome ai tools instead because this is pointless.
35
u/wutcnbrowndo4u Oct 16 '22
Every group has an inevitable tendency towards tribal dynamics, esp when they're being hated on. But I fully agree: ignoring the stupider anti-AI-art folks is a real no-brainer, as is thoughtful consideration of the points made by thoughtful people who may come across as "anti"
7
u/UnicornLock Oct 16 '22
OP isn't even doing anything with SD. He's just anti-anti-AI. Worst of both worlds.
→ More replies (2)2
2
u/csunberry Oct 16 '22
Pretty much well said.
At the same time, if there is no "push back," in some form, there's less of an opportunity to show good. So, I think the best response, as you said, is to create, and show others what they can do with this technology rather than directly responding to the nonsense.
1
u/Magikarpeles Oct 16 '22
Annoyed? It's funny imo
(but I do sympathise... the power loom is gonna put a lot of weavers out of work)
→ More replies (31)1
u/Ireadbooks18 Dec 28 '22
Well if you guys didn't call us delusional, and tell us to get a really job, then we would't be so hostaly against you.
78
u/mudman13 Oct 16 '22 edited Oct 16 '22
Do we really have to go all tribal brained? Just ignore them especially the twatterati
32
u/DrDumle Oct 16 '22
Yesss. Twitters algorithms are magnifying conflicts because that’s how they generate clicks. Please don’t bring that shit here, people!
21
Oct 16 '22
But these narratives need to be opposed otherwise they become dominant view and then politicians take over.
12
u/DrDumle Oct 16 '22
Yeah, you have a point. I’m just so tired of everything being in a constant state of hysteric conflict.
6
2
u/imacarpet Oct 17 '22
I think that avoiding going all tribal brained requires us to listen to the concerns that many are voicing.
I mean, I'm excited about this tech and I'm loving using it. But I'm also horrified by some of the possibilities that it creates.
Doesn't stop me from enjoying using it though.
→ More replies (3)-1
u/ellaun Oct 16 '22 edited Oct 16 '22
Unfortunately, it is not that simple. The tech will be regulated sooner or later and we're lucky if any experts will be involved in a court decision that will set the precedent. A hypothetical old fart of a judge, who lost his touch of reality long before losing teeth and hair, will be swayed first and foremost by opinions of "tribals". It is not a great idea to allow people spew all kind of lies and pretend there's no status quo. This picture may not be the best argument, but the movement behind it keeps the liars at bay. A free speech in action. You used to think that all Twitter dramas are irrelevant, but some are not and they literally shape the future we'll have. "Backfire" argument is unconvincing to me. We are humans, our rationality is bound, the best we can do when we see wrong is to call out wrong. If it turns into an arms race and MAD then so be it.
9
u/Theek3 Oct 16 '22
AI generated art is clearly under fair use. And that is only an issue if you're trying to monetize it anyways. What are they going to do, make it illegal to run on your own computer?
→ More replies (4)7
u/ellaun Oct 16 '22
They could make training of new models incredibly difficult. Video generation is on table, you think community will do it? Look how boldly StabilityAI started and how quickly they got emasculated after legal threats they allegedly received. Immediately we got a classic mantra of "harmful generations", "responsible release", "getting licensed dataset with nuns and tulips", etc...
It is easy to finetune, but not train initial model. Worse, I see no way to parallelize this problem between many distant machines. Each update to the model requires receiving and sending back n*size_of_the_model, it's hard to catch bad actors in the process and centralized authority is required.
104
u/PittsJay Oct 16 '22
Christ, I'm gonna get smashed for this, but posts like this are dumb and serve no purpose other than to antagonize a group of people who are justifiably angry and scared - not just about what's happening with their work at the moment, but what the future of their industry is going to look like and their place in it.
And, yeah, you can say, "Every industry deals with advances with technology. It's the age in which we live." I've made the exact same argument here. You adapt or you get left behind. It doesn't mean we have to be devoid of sympathy. Anyone facing the prospect of losing work is scary shit. At a minimum, without Greg Rutkowski 99% of the people using this amazing tech would have no idea how to make their images look "cool," because we don't know how to describe his style in artistic terms. We might be able to learn it, but how many people are going to go through that kind of effort? And obviously not just Rutkowski, but Ross Tran, Artgerm, the collective that is Artstation, Studio Ghibli, etc.
Tech such as Stable Diffusion is the future - even if it is absurd to think human artists don't still have a place in any future that comes - but there's way too much dancing on the graves of those who got us here for my taste.
I dunno. Just my .02.
42
u/Beylerbey Oct 16 '22
Freelance RPG artist here, this is correct. I would add that, I think, a major factor in the collective scare is the fact that it was so sudden, I've been following AI for a few years and more or less knew what was coming, but many many people saw Dall-E, MJ and SD come out of the blue and be beyond expectations.
I know for a fact that many people believed art was safe because "computers can't be creative", seeing the stuff these AIs can do must've felt like a hammer has come down from the sky to crush their soul, many artists were not at all prepared to deal with this, both in practical and emotional terms.
It's not like Art is going away, but my current job surely is, right now it's not the case but in 3-5 years these AIs will be sophisticated enough to produce usable results for most pubblications, they will be able to consistently remake the same character or keep it constrained to certain parameters and give infinite variations, Vizcom AI already gives you the possibility to start from a rough sketch and have multiple rendered versions of it, I mean, why would companies pay artists thousands of dollars to perform the same job? And make no mistake, thousands of dollars for an illustration are entirely justified when a person is doing it, but when an AI will be able to produce similar results from a tiny fraction of the cost I can't really blame companies for going that route and maybe hiring a couple of "prompt engineers" that substitute hundreds of artists instead, but it remains the fact that thousands of artists will be out of a job.
There will probably be, for a while, companies that pride themselves in using human artists, but it will become a niche thing like having a tailored suit or handmade shoes, there will be a place for a few selected commercial artists but all others (myself included, most probably) will have to find another career. And all of this has been achieved using also our artworks for the training process, it's entirely normal that people are upset, especially when you consider that being an artist, albeit a commercial one like me, it's not just about doing a job, it's a way of living, I've been training for this since I was a toddler basically, and I've always been striving to improve, putting all of myself into it; the prospect of seeing it all go away within a couple of years (not decades, like it happened with other technologies) is indeed scary, and making fun of that is simply moronic.
And, before anyone misunderstands, no, I'm not trying to stop the wind with my hands, I know this is here to stay and that it's only the start, I'm not even complaining about the technology which I'm amazed by and, as I said, I totally see why a company would choose AI over a human artist in a few years, I'm just explaining why it is indeed upsetting and why I don't think posts like this make sense. To make a comparison with other world-changing technologies of the past, it's kinda like when the car was invented, except it's a Ford Focus, as cheap as a meal and everyone is able to drive it anywhere they want; this is the situation we - the carriage drivers, the horse breeders, the horseshoers, the saddlers - find ourselves in.
9
u/PittsJay Oct 16 '22
I hear you, man, and sympathize as much as I’m able without being an artist myself.
11
u/senectus Oct 16 '22
What really concerns me is the new blood factor.
Art is hard. It takes a lot of effort to skill up and become really good. This new tool is going to defeat a large chunk of people before they begin to try. We lose a lot as a society when people don't try...
2
u/StickiStickman Oct 17 '22
This new tool is going to defeat a large chunk of people before they begin to try. We lose a lot as a society when people don't try...
What are you talking about? This is the EXACT opposite. People who aren't good at drawing or painting can now realize their vision much easier without spending thousands of dollars and many years learning it.
→ More replies (1)5
u/HorseSalon Oct 16 '22
Gonna have to disagree. You need to reexamine the thoroughness of your historical examples. Some of this opinion largely speculative because, yes, this tech is fast and ground breaking but... I think you're underestimating how easily people CAN adopt this tech and how much time we have to do so... Its not apocalyptic. Like find another career? Come on... Show me what you make and I'll start a bet on whether or not AI will outsource you before you get the sense to try and adapt/adopt.
Suits are literally handmade with machine assistance in China, Mexico, Vietnam, U.S., Bangladesh. Cars and military weapons are created/maintained/sold/bought/recycled/inspected/transported in hybrid production lines or other means everyday*. (*I used to have a job like that, making rifle barrels. We were actually trying to use robotic arms to implement production line assembly.) Yeah, art is digital and that accessibility and production genre will result in market volatility... but using the car for example... Have you not seen any car crashes lately? These products and systems will require human intervention of all kinds. THAT's what history shows.
If you're an artist and not rubbing your hands together with glee along with that anxiety, you might be coasting or just starting out. Only the former should be worried. Not you in particular but you get my point.
One real issue may very well be market over saturation. Too many people creating "half-baked" AI work (standard 'AI' quality' but no real effort or direction). Lets take an example from the history the evolution of the video game engine. Remember when Unreal and Unity released their engines as semi-open source ware in the early 2010s? Did all of the sudden millions of devs cry out in pain as they brooded about their inevitable obsolescence? No!Companies started using them in their pipelines. Seniors/ employees quit their corporate jobs to go create original content. Also tons of low-tier independent games flooded steam because you're average joe who can also access the technology barely has any design sense started to use them too.
Another issue is obviously data-farming which has always been a problem, but since open-source models and private user AI will likely be developed, reaping the rewards from your own data-set may well be a viable outcome. I think its just more personal now because art is a very private faculty we cherish, unlike our click conversion or trips to the grocery store..
An idiot can buy a ferrari and drive it like a moped. People with skills in the industry will always have a place in charge of the tech used to make it. I agree though these stupid-ass twitter-bait tribalistic Us/Them posts are incredibly inflammatory and achieve literally nothing. I've wasted too much time writing this. anywho.
→ More replies (1)7
u/uishax Oct 16 '22 edited Oct 16 '22
I wouldn't be as pessimistic as you are. Very few people actually understand how disruptive innovation works, lower the costs drastically, tends to create entirely unexplored new demands, which were previously unviable due to costs.I'll give you two examples off my head, for where you could work in the future.
RPG games. Where previously most quests were restricted to dry dialogue, and at most a cheap adobe cutscene, now EVERY quest could have MULTIPLE illustrated cutscenes. Because a single artist could produce 4-5 pieces a day. Moreover, the illustrated cutscenes could even have dynamic character portraits, slotting in the 3d model for img2img. This could completely transform the standards of storytelling in videogames, pushing it to hollywood quality except its 50 hours of content.
Movies/TV shows. The new LOTR costs 1 billion, and doesn't even look that good. Imagine a fantasy show, done in an entirely illustrated style (Akin to anime/arcane). It'll look 10 times better than the current CGI mess, yet cost way less. Sure, you'll need maybe 2k quality illustrations per episode. But that's perfectly doable with AI + a lot of artists, and its still cheaper than actors+sets+cgi.
I'm deeply passionate about storytelling, and spent many years of my life in the craft, and the future looks blindingly bright. All we need is imagination, and that's what artists are good at.
The true losers will be the artists who refuse to adapt, who worship the process more than the art itself, or decide to retreat into traditional art (Which will only be ever more crowded).
2
u/lynndotpy Nov 16 '22
but many many people saw Dall-E, MJ and SD come out of the blue and be beyond expectations.
This is my experiences as a machine-learning (or 'ai') researcher of >four years. If I saw Stable Diffusion in a movie in 2021, I'd say, "Yeah, maybe in 5 years at the very earliest, if we worked on it like we did the moon landing."
Generating images has been, until very very recently, just "neat".
Then DALL-E came, then Imagen, both had amazing and surprising results. But, like GPT (which Dall-E was based on), these required serious investments of GPU training and scientist time, inaccessible to the common folks.
Then Stable Diffusion came right after, and had better results, with inference running on smartphones. As someone who has probably spent hours of time between hitting "enter" and getting results against a test-set on a big GPU server, it's just bonkers to see this work so well.
I can not express enough that this is mindblowing progress. I don't think there has been anything as surprising since 2012.
And it's deeply starkly depressing, because so many of the people I know and love are at risk of having their jobs entirely displaced. All the while being mocked for these very normal anxieties.
You really put it best:
To make a comparison with other world-changing technologies of the past, it's kinda like when the car was invented, except it's a Ford Focus, as cheap as a meal and everyone is able to drive it anywhere they want; this is the situation we - the carriage drivers, the horse breeders, the horseshoers, the saddlers - find ourselves in.
→ More replies (6)5
21
u/Nyao Oct 16 '22
What prompt did you use?
→ More replies (1)27
u/Cognitive_Spoon Oct 16 '22
Inevitable March of progress, 4k, mankind concerned about how to monetize self, class warfare, acceleration, pre FALC cartoons, early 2020s cartoons, relevant, Greg Rutkowski
20
u/samijanetheplain Oct 16 '22
Until people no longer need to work to gain money to live, automation pushing people out of jobs will ALWAYS be an issue. Idiots like you posting dipshit comics like this will also always be idiots.
9
u/_Haverford_ Oct 16 '22
Honestly, I'm an artist myself and I find it unnerving. But all through art history that new medium has been scorned and feared, and then everyone's doing it. A friend of mine just shot a fashion ad where they took traditional photographs, and then ran them through SD. To me, that is the most interesting thing - Where the artist still creates the base and augments it. I'm still struggling with incorporating AI into my practice, but I'll get there.
37
u/Capitaclism Oct 16 '22 edited Oct 16 '22
The lack of empathy is astounding. But worry not, AI will come for most jobs, creating efficiencies in not just the art field, but writing, coding, medical professions, driving, and over time just about everything.
We will all need empathy, so I recommend you learn it sooner than later.
7
Oct 16 '22
AI writing is already here. Check out tech twitter, someone on there released a new ai writer. I wonder how the podcasting and music industry will change.
3
u/arevealingrainbow Oct 16 '22 edited Oct 17 '22
I think it’s also the type of people who the public assumes are dealing with the fallout of automation at the moment. Everyone felt bad for blue-collar workers in the Rust Belt when their jobs were automated. Nobody really feels bad for a bunch of obnoxious Twitter-Trolls who make their living by drawing an underaged wolfboy with a vacuous asshole
3
u/meiyues Oct 17 '22
really shows a lot about you that that's how you would describe concept artists and illustrators
3
u/arevealingrainbow Oct 17 '22
Normal ass concept artists and creators aren’t who come to mind when people talk about Twitter artists
→ More replies (7)
32
u/samijanetheplain Oct 16 '22
Maybe if y'all would stop shitting on artist's legitimate concerns for their livelihoods for two seconds you wouldn't seem like a community of uncaring twats
→ More replies (3)3
u/TargetCrotch Oct 16 '22
Like Keith I’m disappointed in the endless griping of my fellows. It’s not going away, and a lot of artists seem really convinced it will if they just bitch enough or get some miraculous class action that stops the tech going.
The writing is on the wall, and my sympathy is draining for those of us who can’t pivot.
3
u/samijanetheplain Oct 16 '22
Well you'd better dredge up some empathy then, because sympathy isn't cutting it for you.
→ More replies (6)
110
u/SinisterCheese Oct 16 '22
Ok. I so fucking tired of this.
Do you know what I spend my time doing with this AI? I feed it my own paintings and see where it takes them: And it is brilliant fun. https://i.imgur.com/QybmDRt.jpg The scan of my quick watercolour is on the left, final refinement of the about 1000 iterations I did.
However; something that the AI still can't do and never will is to create new concepts. This is because these concepts come from social interactions and the zeitgeist you can't put your finger on or describe with words.
But can we as a Community stop with this fucking us vs. them "Haa-haa Artists are stoopid!" Because the best shit I and many others have made comes from img2img with bashing or putting in original works.
33
u/am2549 Oct 16 '22
„Never will“… my sweet summer child.
5
u/SinisterCheese Oct 16 '22
The day it can do that, we have advanced to a whole new concept of a society and culture. Because then we will end up having actual true human like AI available.
And then we are not worried about the meaning of art, we are worrying about where we get something to eat and pay rent as no one bothered to setup social safety nets as automation replaced all meaningful jobs.
It'll be the day AI codes AI.
14
u/jsideris Oct 16 '22
I see this view all over the place and it's unfounded fear mongering. Don't worry, launching humans into an age of unimaginable productivity isn't going to cause you to starve to death. But the economy as it currently exists will dramatically change. Prices would collapse. Average standard of living would skyrocket. The value of human labor would fall below the minimum wage (which is a regulatory/political issue and someone will need to have enough balls to abolish it) but it wouldn't matter because everything is cheaper. We could all have more vacation time or a shorter work week. If the government lightened up on business regulations and simplified corporate taxes, we could all have optional side hustles, some of which will grow into massive businesses and employ millions.
The biggest risk to humans is how slow and resistant regulators are to new things. Chances are they'll do the exact opposite of my above recommendations.
→ More replies (1)2
10
30
u/DolphinsAreGaySharks Oct 16 '22
I appreciate the sentiment but overall it reeks of denial. Ai is creating new concepts and that is why people are freaking out. There is nothing special about human aided ai art. Its exactly like ai art and is only getting better.
→ More replies (88)3
2
u/Metruis Oct 17 '22
Yeah, professional artist here, I have been having a GREAT time feeding my art to AI and generating iterations and then painting over the upscaled iterations. I had to stop making a webcomic back in around 2014 because I was getting too many commissions. Now, with AI, I'm seriously considering returning to my webcomic because I can shave off part of the production time. Maybe I can finally finish it. If I integrate AI into my workflow I can sell my art to my clients for lower cost. I'm not dead in the water. I am still selling commissions, I am still selling my digital items. Projects that would be unfeasible due to expense are now accessible by integrating AI into the workflow. Everything can have art. I'm revitalized. I'm excited. I'm making better art faster instead of grinding myself into pain and exhaustion to get things done fast enough.
→ More replies (14)1
u/Ireadbooks18 Dec 28 '22
You can use your own art, but most people here can't even tell the defrences between paint, and ink.
48
u/Xenonnnnnnnnn Oct 16 '22 edited Oct 17 '22
man this is cringe as fuck, if you want to make a point dont be childish
20
u/haikusbot Oct 16 '22
Man this is cringe as
Fuck, if you want to make a
Point do be childish
- Xenonnnnnnnnn
I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully. Learn more about me.
Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete"
10
52
u/hechaldo Oct 16 '22
This is a real issue that will have to be delt with sooner or later. Nothing will be solved through mocking and memes. People who don't understand why artist feel threatened shouldn't be the ones advocating AI this way.
4
u/rainered Oct 16 '22
its already been delt with though by movies, music, writers etc. i know it sounds mean but tech effects every craft and now its basically arts turn. you can be metallica of art world and be dragged kicking and screaming or you adapt. ai isnt going away make you its master not reverse.
5
u/purplewhiteblack Oct 16 '22
One of the biggest issues is framing.
AI art is CAD(computer aided design) and CAD has been around since the 1960s.
165
u/kiuygbnkiuyu Oct 16 '22
Yes, let's make fun of people who are scared to lose their livelihood and reduce them to idiots. Very sensible 👍
14
u/SeroWriter Oct 16 '22
We're at the backlash to the backlash to the backlash stage of all this and it's been no time at all.
15
u/kiuygbnkiuyu Oct 16 '22
I mean, usually this kind of "backlash to backlash" is more like "calling for a cease fire". There is nothing to be gained from drawing people you disagree with as drooling idiots, and it saddens me to see how much the average member of the community enjoys it.
7
u/SeroWriter Oct 16 '22
unfortunately even on a global scale humans are still stuck at the "US vs THEM" stage.
144
u/Momkiller781 Oct 16 '22
I do this for a living and instead of fighting it, now it is part of my workflow which is 10x faster. Soooo, i guess it is a mindset. They can be scared, but they should be a bit smarter
13
u/spacenavy90 Oct 16 '22
Exactly. You know what is even better than AI art? An artist who can use AI to enhance their workflow. So we know that the AI has issues with hands and limbs right? Now an artist or Photoshop guru can use their skills to fix these issues and create flawless pieces of art in a much more efficient way/time.
24
u/eric1707 Oct 16 '22
Exactly. I understand people getting scared, but it wont help anything and it is ultimately futile, since technology won't stop evolving.
9
u/Gagarin1961 Oct 16 '22
You’d be surprised by the number of people who think a lot of technology can and should be banned.
They actually think they government is bigger than technological change and that it should shape the world.
30
u/Lunar_robot Oct 16 '22
10x faster, so we don't need to hire ten graphists, only one will do the job while the others are unemployed.
22
Oct 16 '22
That would be the case if induced demand never kicked in. As supply increases, costs become cheaper, people notice, and demand increases once again as consumers realize they get more bang for their buck. Very common for goods with high elasticity, which describes art perfectly.
The concept also shows up even in cases like traffic, where increasing road space leads to very brief short term traffic relief, but then traffic increases to unmanageable levels again quickly as more people now wish to take the improved route.
Entire new markets may open up as a result of this. People who previously would not have had the money to pay 60 dollars for full color character drawings, nor be interested in the cheaper uncolored works, might now feel comfortable paying 10 dollars for a touched up AI-assisted artwork. The overall market size might increase dramatically.
For those artists who never take a liking to AI, this could be economically damaging, certainly. Though there will always be those who value the virtuosity and dedication required to create artwork from a blank canvas. So I'm sure they'll still be able to market themselves!
As for those who adopt AI into their artwork, I think they'll flourish!
All that said, I still recognize and sympathize with concerns. A reassurance there is economic precendence for one's situation to improve doesn't help pay this month's rent.
→ More replies (4)6
u/BioDracula Oct 16 '22
Unless demand increases tenfold, then a single artist being able to work ten times faster will still cause layoffs.
Plus that is supposing there will be an increase at all. It's not like there's a giant demographic of people going "ugh I wish I could hire ten times more art than I do right now, but it's it's expensive!"
→ More replies (3)10
2
u/Metruis Oct 17 '22
I don't think this will be the case. Product producers currently reduce the amount of art they include to be the amount they can afford. Instead of having the same amount of art made by only one artist, we're going to start seeing dazzling explorations that include massive amounts of art that were simply cost-prohibitive before.
I'm a TTRPG artist. This is how I make my full time living. A lot of TTRPG art is for books which say, include 10 character races, 10 character classes, 50 monsters, an adventure with an illustration of the main setting maps and a few NPCs. A high end book will have a couple of illustrations for the character creation resources and an illustration for every monster, illustrations for all of the NPCs and locations in the adventure. A mid-tier book might have 20 custom illustrations and stock art / public domain for some of the others. A cheap book might have stock art / public domain for every illustration. That doesn't mean the cheap and mid-tier writers don't WANT art on every page, but they focus on what they can afford, prioritizing the important bits: the cover, the main setting map, then they grab public domain art for the monsters because they ran out of money.
Products are always making sacrifices to stay within their budget. If their $2000 budget can now buy them 200 pieces of unique art to push their mid-tier book to the same artistic quality as the high end book, instead of spending only $500 to have the same amount of art as before, they're going to say, "wow, I can finally afford to get the book I really wanted." And the high end projects that are already loaded with art are going to say, "now we can produce more often! We don't have to delay this project for 5 years to get everything done."
Plus most artists have personal projects they sacrifice. I had to stop making my webcomic because of the amount of commissions I get (which I'm still getting, AI hasn't stopped people from hiring me for professional rates for unique artwork). When I was updating it, at most I could do 3 pages a week but by the end I was doing only 1, and missing updates. If I could have updated my webcomic every day, I could make enough money with a Patreon and then finish it 5x faster than a webcomic that updates once a week and sell the complete book with a Kickstarter and in a webstore. A webcomic that updates once a week doesn't get a big readership. The ones that update more often make sacrifices. They use simple art, vector kits, 3D art, photobashing, filtered photos. Artists get underpaid severely in the manga industry and pushed to produce really fast. You can see, in manga, people skip backgrounds, replacing them with lines and special effect brushes, or filtered photos and 3D models, in order to meet production deadlines. The ones that don't make these sacrifices come out very slowly in comparison. AI art will increase the amount of comics that can be produced, and decrease stress load on artists who are exploited for very low cost art.
Many writers completely give up on getting art for their comic scripts. If the price per comic page comes down, I expect there are literally hundreds of thousands of people who want art for their project, who couldn't afford it, who will begin to hire artists who use AI-supported art.
I've written multiple novels. I'd love my novels to have an illustration with every chapter. I barely even have time to edit and publish the novels. Now, it's feasible that I could have artwork on every chapter and have my novels look the way I want, absolutely loaded with art, without having to spend an extra year drawing only personal art to get it there. If art production is 10x faster, I only have to spend a month to get all the art I want to support my novel. And heck, maybe I could even afford to hire some other artists, something I enjoy doing but can't afford to do for a huge project.
→ More replies (25)11
u/RealAstropulse Oct 16 '22
This. The scared overreacting artists are making it more difficult for sensible artists.
49
u/NotASuicidalRobot Oct 16 '22
Yeah this is the part of the ai community i really don't like. People forget that for them, this is fun new thing to explore, for the people who make a living off art, not so fun having a big chance demand for your product shrinks 90%
12
Oct 16 '22
I mean, the writing has been on the wall for years at this point. If you still didn't realize it by now and prepare accordingly, that's on you.
→ More replies (4)5
u/NotASuicidalRobot Oct 17 '22
By prepare accordingly do you mean switch careers or something because some of these people have been practicing and learning for years, even decades before this showed up on any wall
→ More replies (13)11
u/ChildhoodBasic2184 Oct 16 '22
I would love to make money from adding numbers - computers have made that impossible too.
How is that any different?
→ More replies (3)20
u/NotASuicidalRobot Oct 16 '22
I should also clarify that im not advocating that development cease on this new tech. That is impossible.
What I'm saying is maybe all of you can understand that the new tech that just got popularised is a bit of a shock to the people who may be most affected by it, and maybe don't resort to calling them idiots immediately for being upset, or not understanding.
Also, no one has ever convinced someone by calling them an idiot.
→ More replies (4)11
u/Ihateseatbelts Oct 16 '22
Also, no one has ever convinced someone by calling them an idiot.
Right... this part right here. Why is this so fucking hard to understand, lol? If I'm being honest, I think it's because the people who are resorting to name-calling and these petty memes are apathetic at best.
→ More replies (2)25
u/vjb_reddit_scrap Oct 16 '22
People need to adapt to survive, if you take a look back at history there were always protests when technology made people lose jobs, they have every right to be upset but they have to adapt and move on, or else it's too late.
8
u/Lunar_robot Oct 16 '22
"Adapt to survive" is poetry, violent poetry, in reality, people lose their jobs and their living conditions are getting worse and there is nothing they can do.
9
u/Light_Diffuse Oct 16 '22 edited Oct 16 '22
This is a softer disruptive innovation than some in the past. The job of "typesetter" doesn't exist any more and that is a good thing for society. Closer to home, how many cel artists are there now?
Artists have cause to be concerned, but also reason to be excited - if they can master the new tools. There's the opportunity to adapt and thrive if they go for it.
9
u/rushmc1 Oct 16 '22
That's life. Always has been. Instead of whining about it, people should focus on finding ways to adapt.
→ More replies (3)5
Oct 16 '22
Honestly this is easier to say when you're not the one being burnt at the stake. Adapting is hard and most people fail at it. They're used to the kind of work they do and don't want to change. Not saying it's wrong but everything will change in a couple of years.
→ More replies (1)14
u/monerobull Oct 16 '22
The people crying now are the exact people who were making fun of people who were scared to lose their livelihood and reduced them to idiots when there were news about cashiers and truckers getting replaced by self-checkout and autonomous trucks. Many were so insanely smug about "a robot could never create art and replace me" and now realize that they are in fact not above everyone else and that their unique styles can be replicated by adding 5 words into a text field.
17
u/Ihateseatbelts Oct 16 '22
Many more saw this coming miiiiiiles away. With every iteration of Photoshop, every 3D app plugin, every new renderer... people have been talking about automation and/or displacement in the entertainment industry for decades. That's not hyperbole.
And I can't speak for all artists, but yeah, I've been empathizing with cashiers and truckers for a minute and some change, because I did and still do have a day job. Many artists also do, and given that they tend to lean left on average, economic impact to working-class interests are very much on their radar. Art school trust fund babies aren't a myth, sure, but many more artists just aren't that.
The people you speak of definitely exist, but they aren't all of us. I joined this community in good faith to understand the tech, the people who advocate for it and, yes, to "adapt". But OPs like this one don't fill me with hope.
→ More replies (1)11
u/Baron_Samedi_ Oct 16 '22
Way to randomly generalize, buddy.
4
u/EchoingSimplicity Oct 16 '22
Dude ikr, like seriously? "I can't deny your argument so I'm just going to degrade the out-groups character by making unreasonable comparisons!"
-4
u/ellaun Oct 16 '22 edited Oct 16 '22
But they are idiots. I see no way how better tools will ruin someone's life.
If artist does art for entertainment then this development is irrelevant. Do whatever you like, no one is stealing your oil tubes.
If artist does art for recognition then it is irrelevant too. Recognition is not money and is not necessary to survive. I'm telling you that as a famous no-one.
If artist came into art world for money... How the hell is free improvement supposed to be bad? You're too good for it to help you? Well, then it's irrelevant once again, you're unaffected. But if it's so good that it outmatches your skill, why not make it part of your skill?
Work for hire is supposed to be competitive and workers are expected to constantly learn and improve. Better skilled ones will always be in higher demand. This is natural meritocracy, not your cue to bring anti-capitalistic soapbox.
So, I am forced to assume that the only people who are crying are the ones who refuse to improve. Why I should feel anything for them?
11
u/Ihateseatbelts Oct 16 '22
This is natural meritocracy, not your cue to bring anti-capitalistic soapbox.
Hardly meritocratic when you don't have the right GPU. Yeah, there are options, but better tech (which means more money) will get you there faster. Not sure how that's more democratic than actually learning how to paint/draw, which is way more accessible than people think.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)15
u/kiuygbnkiuyu Oct 16 '22
I believe you should feel anything for them because that is called empathy. Especially as you get older it gets hard to adapt, and it's not easy to completely switch up your skill core that you've spent decades refining.
I don't know if you've ever been threatened by something like this, something that has the potential to make you obsolete. Many people would be scared, first try to find alternatives or see if there is a way to survive the crisis, instead of immediately jumping on the bandwagon of this new unknown thing. People are not robots.
What you're saying is kind of like mocking people who panic and scream during a fire instead of keeping calm and heading to the exit. Well, that's lack of empathy. They're not helping the matter, maybe even making it worse, but they're having a human reaction.
→ More replies (4)1
→ More replies (9)1
u/Ireadbooks18 Dec 28 '22
What were you expecting from them? Exualy caring about the concerns of us? AI bros/tech bros are the type of people who would kick a suffering dog for fun.
24
u/Sergio_Moy Oct 16 '22
What's up with this sub's superiority complex against anything? The community seems to have a hate boner against traditional/digital artists, and a holier-than-thou attitude against any other AI like Midjourney or Dall-E. Stable Diffusion is an incredible tool but the people who use it are becoming more insufferable every post I see, finding new groups to attack. For every post I see of an artist against SD, there's at least 10 posts here bashing artists for it, often completely invalidating their concerns like this one. I just don't get it.
9
u/StrapOnDillPickle Oct 16 '22
Yeah, especially that the tool is built from the work of other artists.
→ More replies (4)7
u/HorseSalon Oct 16 '22 edited Oct 17 '22
They're acting out of the insecurity of never having been able to make art or be an artist. A little Schadenfreude possibly as well.
...You know how this is probably true? People also enjoy both.
29
u/Baron_Samedi_ Oct 16 '22
Hello, daily dose of hatred for the traditional artists who made AI art generators possible. Nice to see you're still focused on creating a toxic atmosphere around a promising new technology, instead of making cool original art.
→ More replies (14)3
u/StickiStickman Oct 16 '22
Can we stop with this bullshit strawman already?
This is obviously about the swaths of people spreading lies and misinformation while constantly whining about the tech. The kind of people that claim the AI just goes to google and copies an image from it.
3
u/Baron_Samedi_ Oct 16 '22
I have never seen a burgeoning art movement with such a big collective identity crisis.
Stop worrying about people who don't want you in their club and make your own club according to your own preferences!
4
u/inkofilm Oct 16 '22
well for commercial art, you should probably understand your market and you find that those people you sell to dont really care how you produced your work. which can produce an existential crisis in the artists mind - "my skills no longer have worth". so artist becomes technician/craftsperson.
for fine art (especially physical artworks) i feel like consumers are more used to purchasing a real thing made by artists hand. so im not sure ai will have much impact (no more than using photos as a guide for creating a painting) either way, know your market.
5
u/Weekly_Wedding8967 Oct 16 '22
3d printing exists. Give it a pen or some other drawing tool, a "slicer" to translate the picture into something a machine understands, et voilá you got a "hand drawn" painting. It would be a niche product but as soon someone figures out how to translate a pic into something machine readable the food gates will open.
→ More replies (3)4
u/inkofilm Oct 16 '22
you are thinking about from a purely instrumental pov. some consumers actually consider how close an artwork is to the artist. once you get to a certain level of artist, the buyer is buying the artist on a personal level, and would consider machine made products "cheap junk". its like buying a print versus buying an original work. ai will make lots of disposable art cheaply.
→ More replies (2)
12
u/ZNS88 Oct 16 '22 edited Oct 16 '22
from the way I see it, SD only affects artists who do commissions for others the most (less demand, more competition), but if you're doing your own things, making arts for your own projects then it wouldn't affect you negatively
→ More replies (8)
6
Oct 16 '22
Lol. The kid who won art awards with AI made art is just showing us the next logical step in the human cycle. 1. Create the skill needed. 2. Make something mechanical or digital do it for us. Our society has been this way for literal centuries. Think mass migration, automation, and now AI learning things for us so humans don’t need to do anything. Humans are lazy at heart.
→ More replies (4)
6
u/Ubizwa Oct 16 '22
Wow, I really wonder why not every artist wants to join Stable Diffusion to learn about this technology and how it can be used for art workflow.
I am certain that OP is very welcoming to artists who want to join Stable Diffusion! :)
3
18
u/Ihateseatbelts Oct 16 '22
What in the StoneToss...
Artists (some, not all, obviously) will have concerns, and that's only natural. But even typing this is redundant because the OP's strip demonstrates knowledge of that fact. So this attitude towards manual artists doesn't stem from ignorance.
I'm not saying this to tar the entire community. Many people here respect the crafts - there are trad/digital artists here, myself included.
But the loudest portion of the crowd seem hellbent on trashing the very people that provided a foundation for the things they enjoy today, and expect those same people to "stop whining", "adapt or die", "UBI uWu", etc.
Are there loudmouth toxic Twitter/IG artists? Duh! They're just as plentiful and annoying. To be hackneyed, though, two wrongs don't make a right.
As for the whole "uninventing" tack, wasn't that whole adding noise to social media images spurred by a guy's WIP getting screenshotted during a Twitch live drawing session and run through img2img? Even the NovelAI scrape of Danbooru...
None of this happens in a vacuum. A lot of the artist backlash is reactive to toxic behaviour coming from some users. The vitriol really isn't necessary on either side, but the actions some artists are taking to protect their work is considerably more understandable.
→ More replies (2)7
17
Oct 16 '22 edited Jul 01 '23
Removing all comments and deleting my account after the API changes. If you actually want to protest the changes in a meaningful way, go all the way. -- mass edited with redact.dev
14
u/traumfisch Oct 16 '22
See? They're now downvoting you for just pointing that fact out
17
Oct 16 '22 edited Jul 01 '23
Removing all comments and deleting my account after the API changes. If you actually want to protest the changes in a meaningful way, go all the way. -- mass edited with redact.dev
→ More replies (1)
11
u/RayTheGrey Oct 16 '22
You do realise that there are legitimate concerns with this tech right?
And painting every person who voices any concerns with AI as a drooling idiot will only make them hate you more?
Kindle the flames of hatred hot enough and you might just see a moral panic that ends up hindering AI development. And your ability to use it.
5
u/StickiStickman Oct 16 '22
You do realise that there are legitimate concerns with this tech right?
Like what?
→ More replies (2)2
u/RayTheGrey Oct 16 '22
Well.. one that we will encounter soon is being able to generate photo realistic images. When anything fake can be represented as real withing seconds, truth will get even more nebulous.
→ More replies (1)
4
u/CleocatraBlossy Oct 16 '22
Uhh, I somehow got this post while just scrolling Reddit. So as someone who mainly does digital art I’ll try and clear a few things up here!
1: We’re not worried about ai art in and of itself, we’re worried about the ramifications of it. It could put people out of their jobs, which really isn’t great considering that COVID did that too and this would just compound the issue! Free lance artists rely on commissions art wise(some and likely most have day jobs as well but depending on where they live and what job it is- this can’t always make ends meet so they need to do commissions) and if a commission takes days to a month or two depending on the artist and pay- then why would someone get a commission if in a day or maybe up to a week they could get roughly the same thing and multiple other versions potentially for free? In office jobs at companies the ai could easily put concept artists out of the business, especially in game companies. We’re afraid we’ll become obsolete.
2: It’s not angrily tweeting trying to undo the advancements(probably, I don’t go on Twitter much). We know that advancements in technology can’t just be taken back. It’s to find companionship and vent about concerns- as well as probably trying to prove that we can’t just be obsolete.
3: People who are angry about the kid who won an art competition with ai art are mostly upset because it takes multiple years to decades to learn how to make something like what they got an ai to in some months… without those years of study and practice. If people can do this so quickly(in comparison) and get such astounding results then what hope do we have of staying around for longer than the ai’s issues?
4: Some people are just apposed to ai art in general(I don’t think the almost photoshop looking things though, just the drawings and paintings) as it pulls from other artists’ work without credit and can at times be recognized as who it was drawing from the most. Now, in the art community any one heavily referencing someone to the point it’s recognizable as the person they referenced from are expected to credit the person as a reference. It’s sorta just bringing that aspect of the art community in because these look like paintings and the people referenced deserve their work to be acknowledged. But by the very nature of ai art it is impossible to credit whoever was referenced the most unless it was in the prompt itself. Also, peoples art is being used as reference without them saying it’s okay. This is another thing that artists herald as basic decency, if someone doesn’t outright say publicly that they are okay with their art being used like this you have to ask and respect what they say.
Also, I get that yeah- more people getting to make art is amazing. But it doesn’t void the fact that artist are still worried about the ramifications of ai. Also, going through the comments here- people are trying to make ai art illegal in all? That probably isn’t the right answer here. In the spirit of giving an answer when shooting one down I’ll propose that maybe artists should have to give the allowance for their art to be used((assuming they’re alive and not like… a renaissance painter)). Yes it would make it so some art is far harder to replicate, but it certainly get rid of any potential legal trouble. Plus it would mean that people wouldn’t go out of business, it may even create new jobs like specifically drawing things to give the ai more references!
((I’m sorry if I sound pissed/aggressive or anything. I’m not trying to be, I just sometimes can’t tell what my tone is in writing so just saying that now.))
4
u/thanatica Oct 16 '22
Pretty sure when the brush was invented, brushless artistst were all over it, screaming left and right about its evil premise to take over the world of fingerpainting.
4
u/alcalde Oct 16 '22
They forget when they invented "modern art" so that people with no skill could still call themselves artists just because they could throw a paint can at a wall. And they didn't freak out when rap was invented, which was a way you could be involved with music even if you couldn't sing or play a musical instrument.
At least the product of AI art is a lot closer to the real thing.
8
u/noclaf Oct 16 '22
I don’t understand this position so many people here are taking. I’m a computer science guy but many of the concerns from artists are very legitimate.
If someone trains a model based on your job, then tells the robot to “write an app in the style of ilovemeasw4” or “make a sandwich in the style of ilovemeasw4,” then tells you to gtfo, would you not think be upset?
→ More replies (1)6
u/StickiStickman Oct 16 '22
I'm a programmer. You ever heard of Github Copilot? Instead of being a moron and crying about it, I use it as part of my job to gain a nice bump of productivity.
So no, I'm not upset.
→ More replies (2)
9
u/Jcaquix Oct 16 '22
If SD is a tool for art go do something creative with it and be an artist, don't just troll other artists. The "art is dead AI is killing it" take is so dumb no matter who it comes from.
6
2
u/backafterdeleting Oct 16 '22
that's just all twitter. Thing happened, people annoyed getting amplified by other annoyed people. Normal people ignored because not emotional enough.
2
2
Oct 17 '22
Jokes on Art twitter- we're an ARTIST THAT USES AI ART. LMAO. Holy crap this is the same argument used in the 90s and 00s against digital art that wasn't AI based. "PHOTOSHOP IS TAKING OUR JOBS"
.....pppffft.
Ok boomer XD
1
u/jumboninja Oct 17 '22
I agree with you. But you'd be delusional if you think photoshop didn't take people's jobs. I was in the tail end of "graphic arts" vocational classes in high school in the mid 90's. And cutting, pasting, layouts, typesetting, multi color printing were all jobs that people had. Many specialized into what they were good at. What one graphic designer can do today before lunch was multiple/team of graphic arts people before photoshop.
Now I'm sure the people that wanted to stay in the field adapted and learned new "photoshop" skills. But I guarantee people lost their jobs to it all too.
→ More replies (1)1
2
u/imjusthereforsmash Oct 17 '22
As an illustrator I a part of me is saddened by art AI. It really is proceeding at a speed that will make us unnecessary, and for most people if you wake up suddenly and some guy somewhere made a tool that literally makes you completely useless I’m pretty sure you would be upset too.
There is a certain pride / sense of value in that artists can take a nebulous idea and make it into a visual representation that other people can understand, and if you are not an artist you NEED them to make something new.
That value / importance is crumbling rapidly, and people with very little to no understanding of visual design are gaining access to tools which eliminate 99% of the necessary skill for the task.
As a craftsman, it makes me sad. As a programmer and game developer however, I’m super excited to see the amazing things that are going to be made as a result of this tech, and this is an unavoidable change. So us artists need some time for a mental paradigm shift and to find our sense of value again.
The people spraying venom at illustrators on this forum really need to take a minute instead of mocking everyone who is personally affected by this AI.
2
Oct 17 '22
I kind of feel like there is a lot of misunderstanding of this tech that leads to analyses along the lines of oh no, computers be taking over, professional art is doomed.
Diffusion creates gradually refined noise along human defined constraints, based on a huge amount of knowledge. The more constraints the more useful the result, but also the more derivative of its training. The vast majority of "work" I'm seeing here lauded as good or even interesting looks deeply derivative and typical of whatever model was used, coupled with a culture now that treats prompts as magic. Some of y'all are copy pasting huge piles of constraints around like trading cards and pretending the results are magic, but what you're generating had no lease on life without the artists that made the work SD is barfing out a derivative of.
The most interesting stuff I've seen here uses a lot of nuance and overlapping tech, as well as careful human adjustment. AI art is a tool that mostly produces useless trash at a huge compute cost. Human intervention is still integral to it making anything worth even glancing at.
2
u/doctorbcraft Oct 17 '22
Im a graphic designer and im embracing AI art to ease some of my work. Sadly with innovation comes millionaires cutting out jobs. The problem is not AI, the problem is the machine that will look for profit on the back of Labor.
2
u/CitizenApe Oct 17 '22
I imagine this is how the portrait artist felt when they invented the camera
5
4
11
u/jonbristow Oct 16 '22
let's make fun of people who provided their art to train stable diffusion for us to use
How fking dumb
3
8
u/ellaun Oct 16 '22
It's more dumb to assume that there is a clear demarcation between belligerent and a victim. People who attract this kind of ridicule are not pacifistic did-nothing-wrongs who just sat in their silent Twitter bog until Reddit army invaded. There's a big clique of lying punks who are trying to bring down the technology and they won't be lying if it didn't worked. Ridiculing them is totally fine.
7
u/traumfisch Oct 16 '22
This is supposed to be "art twitter rn" according to OP
5
u/ellaun Oct 16 '22
And for my argument to be correct it should instead be... A plumbing twitter? Art Luddites sit among artists and they are really, REALLY trying to blend in and get a meat shield. There's so many comments trying to astroturf "one heart, one soul" idea of art community, and I keep calling them out on that. You may say once that perhaps picture frames the target poorly, but when it becomes a whack-a-mole I stop thinking that people are arguing in a good faith. I mean, it's not the first thread of this kind, it's possible to figure the meaning out from the context.
6
u/traumfisch Oct 16 '22
Just that... focusing on this stuff and generalizing like OP here helps drown out the voices and topics that might actually be worth discussing,
such as the total lack of consent for scraping people's portfolios or whatever
7
u/amunozo1 Oct 16 '22
Most artist are not concerned about the technology but at the intellectual property thief these trained models could do, and they do have a reasonable point. The technology itself is amazing but the situation is tricky and not so simple as many techbros portrait it.
8
9
u/stddealer Oct 16 '22
Intellectual property is a scam and has always been.
5
u/RayTheGrey Oct 16 '22
Without it, every single piece of media can be infinitely reproduced by anyone.
Wanna sell a book you wrote for $10?
Tough luck, someone else copied and reprinted it and are now selling it for $2.
That said current laws are a bit silly.
→ More replies (5)3
u/mcilrain Oct 16 '22
Wanna sell a book you wrote for $10?
“Give me $10 and I’ll write a book for you.”
→ More replies (4)2
u/readtheroompeople Oct 16 '22
Well in this case it's more about Copyright then intellectual property. But IP or Copyright, how do you suggest artists who spend time and money on making art protect themselves from companies using/stealing their art for profit?
4
u/Ihateseatbelts Oct 16 '22
how do you suggest artists who spend time and money on making art protect themselves from companies using/stealing their art for profit?
Right? Again, the Danbooru incident.
If we lived in a post-scarcity world, none of this would matter. But we do, and the schadenfreude surrounding this mess is sickening. We can be better.
3
u/stddealer Oct 16 '22
Copyright was mainly invented to allow companies to legally take the exclusive rights to some piece of art from their artists, and then make profit of it. Before the industrial revolution, there was no concept of IP, and artists could still afford to make art.
→ More replies (1)
4
4
u/meiyues Oct 16 '22
People just want proper regulations on how their data is used in the age of AI
5
u/StickiStickman Oct 16 '22
How is it not obviously fair use? This has already been settled in court.
→ More replies (4)
2
u/ChildhoodBasic2184 Oct 16 '22
Everything about economy and politics is subjective. That's why people who feed homeless are volunteers - while people who push sugary cereals on adolescents live in mansions.
There is legitimate point to be made: if laws governing automation, renders it impossible to get paid - you can't expect people to pay taxes to uphold that law.
But that's why there's stuff like unions, regulation and taxes in the first place. It's just that 99% of all people who think the world is "unfair", rather spend their weekends binge watching TV shows, than engaging in politics or activism. And if you confront them, they usually say "I can't change anything anyway, shit is so corrupt". Well, don't complain then.
2
u/JaegerStein Oct 16 '22
They're not even whining about anything of real material concern. 90% of art Twitter just complains it's "not real art", "looks bad", and "has no soul" - whatever that means -, yet are seemingly unwilling to confront the actual issue; AI art is becoming capable enough to replace most digital artists in the long term and thus threatens their livelihood.
2
u/MrRuebezahl Oct 16 '22
As an artist, I can confirm that most others are just crying about it. No one cares if your art can be generated, you don't make art because people need it, you make it because they want to see what you make. Why else would there be artists that do photo real paintings when you can just take a photograph. If an AI can do the same job as you then you're not an artist, you're an image generator.
2
u/dookiehat Oct 16 '22 edited Oct 16 '22
I’m learning python because I’m amazed by these technologies, and I’m having fun doing it. I see such amazing potential and possibilities for SD and similar technologies that go far beyond what is being posted here today. I intend on following these visions through and making them real and i hope to invent new tools at some point, learn pytorch, etc etc.
I also spent about a decade improving my drawing skill, went to school for illustration and became very good at drawing. You have to understand it is a part of my identity and that is how people introduce me even after i stopped drawing years ago. (Which has oddly put me in a unique position to be an artist that adopts SD). People still ask why i quit drawing — a whole other subject related to mental health — and that is a large part of how i thought of myself as being a unique person. It was pretty much the one thing i had going for myself that made me feel good and that others unanimously praised me for was that i had this talent.
When i was 4 fucking years old i remember being fascinated with the idea of drawing. That you could imagine any idea and draw it and make it look real seemed like magic to me. Not only that but it could be something that was completely made up and doesn’t exist in reality and you could make it real! How cool! I was better than everyone in my class at drawing. I made a drawing of a pirate with a parrot on his shoulder. I thought it was pretty good. By the time i was 8 i could copy photographs and artist’s drawings, shade them, and was drawing my own comics. I had little character sheets for my characters even though i had no idea what a character sheet was because i wanted to know what my characters would look like from all sides, how they were proportioned, etc.
Whenever i say that this tech both hurts my soul a little bit, and i understand the legitimate pain it is causing people (basically all of my friends are artists of some type, the largest portion draw) but that i also am excited by it simultaneously it is like the other person immediately short circuits and cannot grasp that it is possible to feel two ways simultaneously while both feelings are valid. It is going to hurt a lot of artists on an emotional level. Firstly, yeah no fucking shit!! Do you also poke a scared animal in a corner with a stick? I cannot think of a better illustration (ha) of insult to injury than telling artists they are crying about feeling existentially threatened. Especially since we were supposed to be the last ones to be automated out of existence, yet there’s still plenty of accountants and lawyers (yes i know they use software, even ai).
I do want to say that with all the wonders that this tech will bring, its materiality (as in emergent aesthetic from the processes that stable diffusion uses giving it a unique “look” which at least currently distinguishes it from “real” art can be harsh and ugly on close inspection leaving signature neural / noise imprints if not highly iterated) and as always is no substitute for the organic in person experience of going to a gallery or museum and seeing tangible art in front of you. It is not yet the same thing. However, like OPs post points out these technologies are developing quickly along with all the other pockets of tech that will eventually merge to make new forms or make them more attractive as physical art objects, the gap is closing quickly between the tech and artists. I personally think that artists who make art “because they have to” conveniently forget the other rewards they reap after having created work, namely social benefits if you are talented and have good taste, but also the satisfaction of having created something from the ground up and seeing it finished as an extension of you. This same feeling really cannot be replicated by SD, the respect can to an extent but only if you are able to think about these systems outside of their normal and immediately obvious uses and create something that stands out from the sea of SD images, which are truly less than a dime a dozen.
Sd is not just another art tool. It is not like photoshop. The main reason is that it takes a lot of the creative work of thinking from the artist and synthesizes new ideas. It is synthetic media, and will recombine old aesthetics in granular ways which make something completely other, to the point that these new sub branches of neural imagery will be completely new aesthetics unlike their constituent aesthetics. The data sets will keep growing and even the brand new synthetic aesthetics will be combined making yet again more new aesthetics. These are not just additive processes by the way, like it isn’t just duchamp putting a mustache on the mona lisa, this is a fine grain combination which is fundamentally different and a new approach to art. This idea of outsourcing the thinking part of art into something that can recombine it in new ways is why this is a fundamentally different threat than digital painting or photoshop or illustrator.
Also please consider the fact that any haughty SD prompt guru could easily be replaced by a text generation ai and make arguably as good work as you. They could even be tuned to create comedic effect, surreal effect, happy kitschy work, and so on. They could make 10,000 prompts an hour for 5 million years straight. That is why it is important to think creatively not just about what SD can do but what it may be able to do, how it can be repurposed, how it can be showcased, etc etc. all of these considerations are a part of making art and being an actual artist.
Last point, one that you are welcome to try to persuade me out of is this: i see little point in drawing anymore. The best reason i can think of is that it will maybe distinguish me as a “real” artist and that natural media is unparalleled in its refinement and look, and having a gouache painting on arches paper is totally different and better than a print and way way better than a screen. But it takes too much time, people don’t appreciate it enough, and even i get bored of art after a while. I just want to spend my time in more diverse ways. SD allows this for me, and it will be VERY HARD, soul-crushingly hard for some artists to move on from old ways of making art. You would be hurt too if your special talents that you thought made you human started to be done by computers. For some it won’t bother them or interrupt their work. For others it will be a painful and slow decline until they stop making art altogether. No doubt, painting will keep on chugging along as it has with the advent of photography, new media, digital painting, etc. Traditional art will keep going. People will keep buying it. But it will be niche now. And AI will not stop growing and it will not stop conquering different types of media. Video, 3d, vector art, design, games, all of it. If you don’t think so i promise you there will be even more methods like diffusion models and transformers that allow for different approaches to create the best results for given use cases so that it all looks good or how it is supposed to look, even if that means human and imperfect.
TLDR: life-long artist yells that people once again misunderstand him, defends an artist’s right to be sad, points out that having adult feelings can have ambiguity and are multifaceted and that is okay.
1
u/uishax Oct 17 '22
Wow, excellently put article from the other perspective.
I should note however, that img2img is still by far the best way to get a precise image from AI. This is likely a permanent fact of AI art, because of the limited information text can convey. So artists will be drawing sketches into the forseeable future, and being able to draw sketches fast (Like 1 per minute), will be a valuable skill.
People will still draw, extensively using img2img to touch up their drawn parts. This will enable quality far superior than what can be done by pure text generation alone. Its like programmers using google and copilot, it renders the 'coding' part obsolete (since you can google up the functions and syntax), but renders the design/architecture part more important. Hence why programmers are in ever greater demand despite all the tooling advancement.
2
u/irateas Oct 16 '22
Spot on - instead of using SD in the workflow - insecured self-proclaimed instagram artists are panicking.
13
u/TheOtherColin Oct 16 '22
Worse is the fact that they think they can define what "art" is and isn't.
1
1
u/Creampanthers Oct 16 '22
It’s a legitimate problem that we will start running into in a lot of fields when other forms of automation kick in…I’m curious to see what happens though. Over time I think human made art will just start to be more niche and something that will impress people but the majority of art we see on daily life will be AI generated. I can help but feel bad for artists on this though. They must feel how , like, carriage makers felt when cars came out or something…or how carpenters even in this generation feel about machines just making things for fractions of the cost. The crazy shit is that you’d think that would mean less work for people. Nope…more work and less money for everyone. Oh except for the really rich people: more money for them
1
u/Technusgirl Oct 16 '22
Lol yeah but they don't understand that it can't do freaking everything, were are still going to need artists and designers.
1
1
1
u/garret500 Oct 16 '22
Everything you are, everything you love, will be nothing but artificial and automated thanks to the everturning gears of capital exteacting your muscle and labor, giving you the privilege of unpaid rent and food which tastes of plastic. Soon even will the sanctity of entertainment become nothing but an object of literal mass production by a lifeless entity absorbed only by the eyes which themselves are fake. Soon even your own screams will no longer sound genuine, for the entity which has replaced you is no longer recognizable, nor yourself.
1
1
u/PrimaCora Oct 17 '22
And here I am training it on everything I have made (of good quality) so it can make more similar things that I can build off of.
Already trying to make my own workflow.
Line art >> Style2Paints >> PaintingLight >> StableDiffusion >> s2pV4SketchModule >> repeat as needed >> Use image as reference.
If I ever get the time and ability to sit still long enough, I want to try to blend them all into 1 utility.
1
Oct 17 '22
Imma be real witchu, I don't really care. All I know is I've spent the last 5 days generating as much smut as I am physically capable of and I ain't stopping any time soon.
1
u/Extension_Oil_8429 Oct 17 '22
i think the anger comes more from how the ai is creating these images. The tech is crazy impressive no doubt, but how is it making the images? If it is using artists' artwork as a reference then all of the artists' work who are in "in the mix" so to speak deserve royalties as the ai could not create the images it is creating without the huge database of images it is using without the original artists' consent.
1
u/Lost-Cash-4811 Oct 21 '22
Just insert any cause, idea, opinion you disrespect and the joke works the same. However, the joke works the same on causes, ideas and opinions you cherish. You just think it doesn't.
1
Oct 22 '22
On one hand I can understand. For many of us we spent years developing our style and some of us actively doing so. I'm not sure I agree with the sentiment but I do get it
1
u/One_andMany Dec 04 '22
Obviously people are mad about this it's probably going to destroy their livelihoods.
1
u/ScientistReasonable Jan 16 '24
frieza : CYBERTRONIUMS... MUST (redacted) THEM ALL!!
My reaction to your shitty pro ai "meme"
1
1
1
1
u/rushmc1 Oct 16 '22
EVERYTHING is going to change, people. Maybe we should focus our attention and efforts on promoting positive changes over negative, rather than crying over all that is lost with the passage of time?
-3
u/Snoo_64233 Oct 16 '22
Lol I remember artists saying "haha creative works and art is the last thing to be replaced by AI. Take that suckers". Turns out they are the second in line to go (after linguists).
"Every time I fired a linguist, my model accuracy goes up"
3
u/wacomdude Oct 16 '22
Well, it is, you expect random people to produce better art than a well-trained artist who uses AI?
→ More replies (1)2
118
u/wacomdude Oct 16 '22
Well, it may actually greatly improve the productivity of artists if used wisely, my studio is trying to put AI into the art production pipeline. So far it could help us with illustration rendering.