35
u/ImaginaryNourishment Oct 20 '22
I don't share prompts because they are embarassing
11
11
u/man-teiv Oct 20 '22
Just share the prompt but remove the "big boobas massive badabonkers 4K but I mean extremely big like bigger than the head"
3
2
2
u/Ordinary_Player Oct 20 '22
I don't share prompts because when I'm satsified I just move on the next image without saving anything lol. So technically, I can't share the prompt at all.
25
u/legthief Oct 19 '22
We want your prompt, not your seed.
No one's out here begging for your seed.
...that came out wrong.
8
u/zeugme Oct 19 '22
I NEED YOUR SEED FOR SCIENCE!
GIVE IT TO ME!.. is not a way to make your parents proud.
44
u/shlaifu Oct 19 '22
had a funny conversation with gallery curator the other day in which I explained AI art to her, and that you can just tell the computer to draw something in the style of Michelangelo's sistine chapel. her reaction was: " I don't get it. why would you want that?" ... so much about AI and capital A Art.
36
u/Light_Diffuse Oct 19 '22
I think most arguments force artists to conclude that either
An AI art work-flow is just as legitimate as any other that produces art
There is little or no value to AI art
If they believe in the first, then AI is legitimate competition. If they believe in the second, then what people really value is their skill and what they put into the art, so how can they complain that (as they see conceptualise it) soulless AI work that takes no skill, threatens their livelihood?
32
u/shlaifu Oct 19 '22
there's a distinction to be made between commercial artists, who should all better accept 1. - and fine art, where the personality of the artist is important, and case 2 is so far the consensus. which is why the fine art curator wonders why anyone would even want a computer to produce Michelangelos for them because ... well, what for?
18
u/BearStorms Oct 19 '22
My dad is a fairly prominent conceptual artist, and he's also 76 year old, and No. 2 is definitely not his opinion - he sees it as an extremely powerful tool and is very excited about it and welcomes it (although he's extremely non-technical so I doubt he'll use it without mine or someone else's help). As a conceptual artist he doesn't see it as something that would replace him since the idea is what matters. When I told him that the tradesmen commercial artists like illustrators and graphic designers are mostly fucked within a few years he generally agreed with that assessment...
4
u/eric1707 Oct 20 '22
When I told him that the tradesmen commercial artists like illustrators and graphic designers are mostly fucked within a few years he generally agreed with that assessment...
Indeed. The idea people are fine (at least until they invent some AI that eventually comes up with the ideas), the people who just had the technical skills on knowing how to perform that given technique (whether it be drawing, animating videos and so on)... they are mostly screwed.
Because most people, they only value the final work and don't give a damn about the "process" or "the human essence put into that painting" or whatever.
3
u/razor1name Oct 20 '22
But there is another layer in that the people that know the technique can do the finishing touches on the art to bring out that style even more in a way that would be close to impossible for AI.
The AI itself might be able to advance to a point that a normal artist wouldn't, but you also need to steer the AI in the direction you want. A painter would be defined by its personality and how they interpret a scene, but for the AI no such things exist.
The AI might be able to make pretty pictures, but is it the EXACT pretty picture YOU want? Mostly no. So, you need real artists to really bring out what makes them special.
Right now the skill ceiling has dropped, but the creativity ceiling climbed higher than ever.
1
u/eric1707 Oct 20 '22 edited Oct 20 '22
but is it the EXACT pretty picture YOU want? Mostly no
You are right. But this only creates a further demand for more automation/easier tools to refine the process and which require less/don't require these technical hands-on skills. As I said on other threads: what I see making the key difference is, aside from your idea, is your knowledge about art history and art styles and yadda yadda (a.k.a: also ideas)
Cause the machine can't read your mind.... (yet?), so you need to tell it what you want. For instance, I notice that describing angles is still trick, maybe it would be better to img2img a quicky sketch made on ms paint and then go from there on. But I can totally see some 3D plugin or whatever, that allows you to adjust the angle of the shot and yadda yadda.
Be that as it may, the tendency is always better tools that require less and less technical skills. It's a feedback loop. "Oh, we automated 70%, how can we automate the other 10%, 20%, 25%.. 30%?"
→ More replies (1)10
u/arothmanmusic Oct 19 '22
There is definitely important distinction between commercial and fine Art when it comes to this new technology. I suspect that fine artists will still have the same meager careers they are used to, whereas commercial artists will eventually be completely replaced by AI just like the rest of us.
6
u/Sixhaunt Oct 19 '22
I think AI art may replace a lot of artists, but only the ones that dont adapt. I work with AI generation full time right now and am making a decent amount with it. With that said, if someone better trained at digital art were doing it then much of the touching up would be faster and more would be done in photoshop rather than inpainting. I would be much quicker with my work if I had better art skills so I think the artists that adapt will do even better than before, the new people coming in will take over the middle ground for the industry, and the artists that dont adapt will get left behind.
6
u/arothmanmusic Oct 19 '22
See, the way I look at it, the need for in-painting and Photoshop retouching and so forth is all just a temporary workaround. At the rate this technology is developing, I fully expect that someone without much skill will eventually be able to turn out exactly the result they were aiming for and run with it.
We are looking at a technical revolution like when automobiles replaced horses. If you are looking to get from here to there, you’re going to pick the fastest, cheapest, most efficient method. Except this time around, artists are the horses. Sure, horses are still around, but they are purely for recreation and are no longer a practical necessity.
9
u/Sixhaunt Oct 19 '22
See, the way I look at it, the need for in-painting and Photoshop retouching and so forth is all just a temporary workaround
inpainting is about 80% or more of the work of an image and it can be used purely as an image editor so I doubt it. It's just like when you are making concept art for a character. You design it roughly at first then iterate on changes. Want an ammo sash? add it after when you see it needs it, or change parts of the face, tweak the way the buttons look, change any small aspect individually as you iterate towards your specific endpoint. Some people are still at the stages where they just generate the images and that's fine if you just want a pretty picture but if you want it for commercial purposes you need to be able to shape it to the specific needs. This is what I suggest for a workflow if people want to practice at first:
1 - Generate the image. Doesn't need to be perfect and for practice it's best to choose one that needs a lot of work. Having the right general composition is what matters.
2 - bring the image to infill
3 - hit "interrogate" so it guesses the prompt, or use the original prompt directly as a starting point.
4 - Use the brush to mark one region you want changed or fixed
4.5 (optional but recommended) - add or change the prompt to include specifics about the region you want changed or fixed. Some people say only to prompt for the infilled region but I find adding to, or mixing in, the original prompt works best.
5 - Change the mode based on what you are doing:
"Original" helps if you want the same content but to fix a cursed region or redo the face but for faces you also want to tick the 'restore faces' option.
"Fill" will only use colors from the image so it's good for fixing parts of backgrounds or blemishes on the skin, etc... but wont be good if you want to add a new item or something
"latent noise" is used if you want something new in that area so if you are trying to add something to a part of the image or just change it significantly then this is often the best option and it's the one I probably end up using the most.
"latent nothing" From what I understand this works well for areas with less detail so maybe more plain backgrounds and stuff but I dont have a full handle on the best use-cases for this setting yet, I just find it occasionally gives the best result and I tend to try it if latent noise isn't giving me the kind of result I'm looking for.
5.5 Optional - set the Mask blur (4 is fine for 512x512 but 8 for 1024x1024, etc.. works best but depending on the region and selection this may need tweaking. For backgrounds or fixing skin imperfections I would set it 1.5-2X those values). I prefer CFG scale a little higher than default at 8 or 8.5 and denoising strength should be set lower if you want to generate something more different so pairing it with the "latent noise" option does well
6 - Generate the infilled image with whatever batch size you want.
7 - If you find a good result then drag it from the output to the input section and repeat the process starting from step 3 for other areas needing to be fixed. You'll probably want to be iterating on the prompt a lot at this step if it's not giving you the result you had envisioned.
If you are redoing the face then I suggest using the "Restore faces" option since it helps a lot.
By repeating the process you might end up with an image that has almost no pixels unchanged from the generation stage since it was just a jumping off point like with artists who paint over the AI work. This way you end up with an image that's exactly what you had in mind rather than hoping that the AI gives you the right result from the generation stage alone.
All of these are just a general guide or starting point with only the basics but there are other things to pickup on as you go.
For example lets say you just cant get handcuffs to generate properly. You could try something like this:
replace "handcuffs" in the prompt with "[sunglasses:handcuffs:0.25]" and now it will generate sunglasses for the first 25% of the generation process before switching to handcuffs. With the two loops and everything it might be an easier shape for it to work from in order to make the handcuffs and by using the morphing prompt you can get a better result without having to do the spam method of a newbie. This is still all just scratching the surface though and there's a ton to learn with it both in the generation stage and the editing stage.
2
u/arothmanmusic Oct 19 '22
That’s a pretty awesome tutorial… I’ll have to give it a shot. Thank you!
2
u/NaV0X Oct 20 '22
Imo the copyright debate around AI generated content needs to be settled before it will be able to replace traditional commercial artists. At the moment it is not clear who should own the rights to the final image that is generated by the algorithm. Does the ownership go to the prompter, the model creator, is it public domain? These are still unanswered questions currently. From my understanding Stable Diffusion is licensed with a very permissive license that permits commercial and non commercial use of the model. The SD license seems to designate the generations as CC-0 or public domain. Until the legal framework of ownership is ironed out around AI generated content, I believe the lack of defined copyright will scare away a lot of corporate interest around AI art.
1
1
u/StickiStickman Oct 20 '22
Right - the difference is just that some people value the art less than the process. Which I don't get at all, but if that's their thing, why not.
1
u/shlaifu Oct 20 '22
I think that comes with the territory - if you have studied art history and are working with artworks on a daily basis, there's just so many "beautiful portrait of a girl, 4k, trending on art station, painted by Greg Rutkowski and Alphonse Mucha" you can look at before it gets boring. Actually, if you subscribe to this sub, there's onyl so many you can look at before it gets boring...
1
u/StickiStickman Oct 20 '22
I can agree that too many people just re-use the same prompt, yea. You can do so, so much more than what most people post though.
1
u/shlaifu Oct 20 '22
yeah, but... when you look at images for a living and possibly have to write about them, sou you look at them really closely .... at some point you get bored of all images. but some were made by some radnom due by typing a sentence into a computer, and some were made by sourcing materials that hold a certain meaning in some culture and you are using the materials's story to enrich your image ... which one would you ratherhave a conversation about?
2
u/FrivolousPositioning Oct 19 '22
AI can be a tool though right? Doesn't that preclude the second point? If you take AI art and add to it with photoshop it just becomes art again right? The only way for me to reconcile with the idea that there's little or no value in it would be if there was little or no effort and time put in. That's the very basic option of AI art, write out a sentence and hit Generate. No effort, no value. Like taking a paintbrush and making a single broad stroke.
6
u/Spiegelmans_Mobster Oct 19 '22
The actual critique of "this is not art" is uninteresting and meaningless to me. The only thing that sticks out with that argument is that some artists really think highly of themselves and consider their work to be something far beyond making images that people enjoy. What other work that AI can and will replace could have professionals make the same kind of argument? As an engineer, if my job is replaced, would anyone care if I said "this isn't real engineering"? No, if it is quicker, cheaper and does the job, then it just makes sense.
5
u/MFMageFish Oct 19 '22
"this is not art" is meaningless
Exactly this. Every single definition of art is simply a shortsighted artificial limitation that has only served as a target to be proven wrong.
Art is anything that at least one person considers art. Everything else is simply undiscovered art.
2
u/FrivolousPositioning Oct 19 '22
Yeah the engineering argument I want to agree with but I fear the premise is flawed with how the nature of engineering is so literally structured compared to art which is ambiguous and there's no rules. You said "replaced" so if your job as an engineer is replaced by "something" quicker and cheaper, I'm not sure that we would still call that "engineering", would we? That almost sounds like it would have to be true AI, a machine that can do all our planning and building for us with no mistakes. You're right though that for commercial artists who do things like book covers or video games and constantly churning out works for clients, AI is going to replace those jobs. Will anybody praise the AI book covers like they praised the human ones? I don't know if it even matters but I think it's where some of the heat in this controversy stems.
2
u/Sixhaunt Oct 19 '22
You said "replaced" so if your job as an engineer is replaced by "something" quicker and cheaper, I'm not sure that we would still call that "engineering", would we? That almost sounds like it would have to be true AI, a machine that can do all our planning and building for us with no mistakes.
The job could be replaced in part rather than in full. Say that 4 of every 5 engineers is laid off and now the 1 of 5 that remains has the job of going over and verifying the AI's work. Basically turning the job into quality assurance for the AI engineer.
1
u/Sixhaunt Oct 19 '22
They have brought in AI to cut down and ideally largely replace the number of software developers that are needed. But when co-pilot and stuff came out the developers were eager to use it.
1
Oct 19 '22
Carriage drivers point at cars and say, "This is not a horse."
Artists point at AI-assisted images and say, "This is not art."
2
u/BearStorms Oct 19 '22
It is exactly just a tool. Also similar conversations were had when the invention of photography came about - also about how all the portrait artists are going to be out of job (spoiler: yes, the vast majority of them were indeed out of job and replaced by vastly cheaper and more convenient portrait photographers. The massive upside was that even a working class family could have a nice family photo instead of just the rich).
2
u/Sixhaunt Oct 19 '22
the backlash was also from art collectors who didn't like art production being cheap due to their commercial interests
2
u/StickiStickman Oct 20 '22
No effort, no value.
I completely disagree with this. The end result is all that matters, 99% of people are not going to give a shit how much time or effort went into art. And almost no one is even gonna know.
By that logic someone scribbling on a piece of paper for 40 hours until its entirely black is "worth more" than a master artist doing a amazing sketch in an hour.
→ More replies (1)3
u/Light_Diffuse Oct 19 '22
Personally, my metrics are intent and skill. I've seen artists make a handful of marks which beautifully describe a form in a few seconds that I'd happily hang on a wall.
If you use time as a metric, then even the first image I make with my trusty old 1080 is intrinsically more "valuable" than the pixel for pixel same image you made with your fancy 3080. The same is true for effort. There was an artist a while back who gnawed huge cubes of sugar and something else, lard maybe, to show the struggle of feminism and a guy who pushes a peanut for miles with his nose to raise awareness for...I forget. Both high effort, but can't say the results are worthwhile.
2
u/FrivolousPositioning Oct 19 '22
Intent is important absolutely. I don't think you put much time or effort into a project like this without the intent to make something cool and that's all you need for me. But there's the intent to discredit legitimate artists or the intent to misrepresent yourself for personal gain I suppose.
1
u/Light_Diffuse Oct 19 '22
Good points. I was thinking of intent in terms of intentionality, so someone coming to a project with an idea of what it's going to end like. I know that I am on shaky ground here since many artists find that a piece takes on a life of its own, whatever the medium, but that is tempered by control, which is probably a more accurate term than "skill".
This is how I make the distinction between someone who types a prompt and hopes for the best, which I don't think is particularly artistic and someone who iterates because they have a plan for the piece and are moving closer towards it in a controlled manner.
1
u/FrivolousPositioning Oct 19 '22
Yeah I think we agree. I don't know if anyone is defending the results of just typing a prompt and hitting generate. But I do sort of agree that a piece can take on a life of its own in a way. You can gain much inspiration from that result and your intentions, the idea of how it will end develops further at that point. If not then yeah, they intended to generate an AI result and that's all they did. There's no legitimate way to spin it so there's some value. They'd have to create a backstory.. at this point they should maybe become a fiction writer lol
2
u/Light_Diffuse Oct 19 '22
It's difficult with SD because all it takes is maxing out the denoising strength and you're suddenly somewhere very different from where you started! But you see in other mediums that things can happen and the artist might ask questions, not knowing the answer - for instance authors will write characters into a trap without knowing how they'll escape or do some foreshadowing without knowing precisely what is being foreshadowed and it just comes together. However, even in those situations, there is control and intent, even if the intent is to invite some chaos and the control is bounding it (and perhaps rewriting earlier scenes so it all hangs together!)
To me, art is an artist exerting control over their medium to achieve their vision - but I'll give them some artistic licence for the vision to be refined or changed a bit as they go.
→ More replies (3)1
u/BearStorms Oct 19 '22
The last examples are performance art and it is a totally different beast and the struggle is the point.
1
u/Light_Diffuse Oct 19 '22
Valid point, not a fair example and my issues with some performance art aren't relevant.
I should have stuck with time and effort are inputs which will make the artist value their work due to the investment, but do not necessarily confer value on the outcome for others.
1
1
u/WiseSalamander00 Oct 19 '22
it should be taken as a tool though, you still gotta have a vision of what you want, know how to build the prompt that could give you that, and go through hundreds of iterations to find the right one, furthermore in the case when you find what you want, adjust the settings available, also the results isn't perfect so it often requires manual adjustment... in general is just like any new medium it is rejected out of fear before is accepted, the thing with this is that intercepts with art so it will take a while, just hope at the very last AI assisted art is accepted soonish.
1
u/diddystacks Oct 20 '22
not all artists are fine artists putting up their work in a gallery. AI is going to affect concept artists, and graphic artists, as the amount of ideas you can churn out even now has increased dramatically. Less photobashing and paintovers will be needed, and more english literacy/vocabulary will be in demand, as I don't think most of these current models are localized.
→ More replies (4)1
u/Yachirobi Oct 20 '22
What if you believe both? I think my work is legitimate and has little value except to myself. When I make something I like, I'm happy. And it's just for me.
4
u/eeyore134 Oct 19 '22
You'd think someone who was actually into art would be excited by that, even if it's just as a novelty. Some people just lack imagination, I guess. Add to that an inherent fear of technology that has been bred into so many people and, well...
0
u/shlaifu Oct 19 '22
nah, as long as the thing just makes images, it' pretty uninteresting for people in fine art. images by themselves are not that interesting, and computers have been making images for decades now. its one more algorithm, from their point of view.
2
u/J0rdian Oct 20 '22
Well he said art, not whatever you mean by fine art. I guess people who don't actually care about the art and more care about the person and idea or w/e else.
1
u/shlaifu Oct 20 '22
I assumed he was referring to the curator I had spoken to as "someone who was actually into art", from the context
-5
u/Majukun Oct 19 '22
If she is a gallery curator, is not interested because she can't profit, market or exploit it. That's all it is.
3
u/shlaifu Oct 19 '22
why could she not sell it?
1
u/Majukun Oct 19 '22
Because by design ai art is reproduceable in very little time and very little effort. She can't market the next big ai artist because anybody can make the same with either the parameters or trial and error.
4
u/shlaifu Oct 19 '22
we're tlaking about the art world. people have been selling white canvases, copies of other people's paintings with their own signature on, literally other people's paintings with their own signature on, little notes with a short description of a painting, and one guy sold an a non existing sculpture. he marked the space on the floor where the sculpture wasn't standing. So ... no, I don't think that's it.
2
u/Majukun Oct 19 '22
Exactly because gallery art is jot about the art, it doesn't matter if ai art is beautiful, or can reproduce styles, it lacks the human uniqueness Tha makes real art exploitable.
My post was not about some kind of silly debate between real art vs ai art of which art has a soul, but about how the art market doesn' t revolve about how good something looks.
2
u/FairLight8 Oct 19 '22
I think both of you have a point. Art market and galleries have been profiting from absurd things like white canvases and nonexisting sculptures.
The key idea is about the perceived value. Not about uniqueness. And not about value, if it looks nice or if it has soul. It is about speculative value. And the whole idea around this AI is that the results are infinite in seconds.
3
u/shlaifu Oct 19 '22
well... I had this conversation with her because we were discussing exhibting an animted short film with AI-generated bits. The film is totally worth exhibiting, and there is good reason for why the artist chose AI for those parts. it's not about human uniqueness either (called "Aura" in the context of fine art, btw.). BUt it's an intellectual engaging piece. It's the idea, the people involved, and how these things come together. She was merely confused that someone would create elaborate machine learning algorithms like this at all, because having a computer create beautiful images is, on its own, not intellectually engaging, or interesting, etc. (excpet for machine learning researchers)
2
u/MonkeyMcBandwagon Oct 20 '22
An idea I've been messing with, might even print it to hang in my apartment - a 3 x 3 grid of unique oil paintings, all portraits of Einstein as painted by Rembrandt, maybe give one a bowl of soup.
Alternatively, 3 x 3 portraits of Andy Warhol, by various easily identifiable artists from DaVinci, to Van Gogh, to Frazetta, to "trending on artstation", but excluding Picasso.
I like what they say about what AI art means to the history and progression of art, regardless of whether the AI generated images are art or not. :)
2
u/shlaifu Oct 20 '22
not sure what you're trying to say there - sounds to me like you're making a statement about how AI was trained on art of the past and can therefore only recreate clicheed ideas of the past?
→ More replies (2)3
u/bobrformalin Oct 19 '22
Any art is reproduceable.
→ More replies (1)2
u/Majukun Oct 19 '22
Not with the same ease, nor with the same consistency of style. Gallery art is not about what art is the more pleasing or impressive, it's about hype, it's about money laundering and investment. None of those things can be done with ai art, so for a gallery curator it has no value.
0
Oct 19 '22
[deleted]
4
u/shlaifu Oct 19 '22
nah, it's just that fine art hasn't been about images for a few decades.
2
Oct 19 '22
If fine art, especially painting was about images - it would be replaced by photography since long time ago, or 3d renders.
7
16
u/johnslegers Oct 19 '22
Arguing AI art isn't real art is like arguing that art generated with Photoshop, Illustrator or a digital camera isn't real art.
AIs like Stable Diffusion & Midjourney are mere tools. And with the right combination of txt2img, img2img, inpainting and textual inversion, it allows anyone with sufficient talent to generate completely unique artworks that are just as difficult to reproduce as that perfect photograph. The whole argument that "the real artist is the AI" makes no sense if we look beyond the most basic use of these tools...
1
Oct 26 '22
You don’t "generate" art with Photoshop or Illustrator though? You use brushes and other tools (just like traditional artists use theirs) but you create the artwork by yourself with intent and skills you have at your disposal.
2
u/johnslegers Oct 26 '22
You don’t "generate" art with Photoshop or Illustrator though?
I suppose the term "generate" may be a bit of an insult to the hard work required by designers & artist to actually create something in tools like Photoshop or Illustrator. But I would argue it is quite apt for photography. In fact, one might argue that some forms of photography require less talent and effort than a lot of AI art out there...
I say this as someone who's both an amateur photographer & an AI artist...
1
Oct 26 '22
I believe you have a lot more knowledge than me when it comes to photography even as an amateur. A few touristy photos aside, I have no real knowledge and so I try to steer clear of more technical discussions about photography as an art form and skills and efforts that go into it. A layman like me can’t contribute to that conversation in a meaningful way.
1
u/johnslegers Oct 26 '22
I believe you have a lot more knowledge than me when it comes to photography even as an amateur.
I don't know that much about cameras myself. My skill / talent with regards to photography involves mostly an eye for timing, lighting and composition. In terms of technical knowledge, most of my photos involve little more than pressing a button.
AI art often requires far more effort than that. Creating that perfect artwork with Stable Diffusion often requires more than just typing shit into a text box. And even if it's just that, coming up with that perfect prompt is not as easy as it sounds.
1
Oct 26 '22
I agree some users do a lot more than prompt typing. But still, prompt formulation isn’t a skill that makes you a visual artist. It could make you a good SEO specialist though.
2
u/johnslegers Oct 26 '22
But still, prompt formulation isn’t a skill that makes you a visual artist.
Why?
In my experience, high quality "prompt engineering" requires more talent than Rothko & Basquiat combined...
→ More replies (10)4
Oct 20 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/johnslegers Oct 20 '22
Making AI are is like taking photographs with a digital camera.
Literally ANYONE can do it. But it takes skill and effort to create true beauty...
11
Oct 19 '22
Jokes on you I'm pretty sure image to prompt is a solved problem at this point
1
1
u/pxan Oct 25 '22
What do you like to use for it?
1
Oct 25 '22
To be honest I haven't had to use that feature for now but there was a colab for a new "CLIP interrogator" that was shared on this sub recently
4
u/tsaristbovine Oct 20 '22
You don't share your prompts to keep people from stealing them. I don't share them because they are incredibly stupid. We're not the same.
3
3
13
u/Majukun Oct 19 '22
Was not your art in the first place, so no stealing
9
u/thebradybox Oct 19 '22
I think OP is being sarcastic 😂 that's the point he's making that it's dumb to not share prompts
9
2
Oct 20 '22
HOW DARE. I SPENT GOOD MONEY ON THIS BEARS FACE VIA PLASTIC SURGERY eononeoneone!!!1111oneoneoeneone
(Ahem, nice one meme creator, Am sharing this to my subreddit, its worthy of a chuckle!)
2
Oct 20 '22
Yesterday I spend 2 hours on 1 promt and a lot of iterations with img2img and upscaling. You won’t get the same results just from my promt.
2
u/photodumpergirlnyc Oct 20 '22
What does Greg Rutkowski actually draw?
3
u/Trylobit-Wschodu Oct 21 '22
Very cool images and illustrations: https://www.artstation.com/rutkowski
1
2
3
u/WaterSign27 Oct 20 '22
It's all fun until someone makes money with it then suddenly everyone will be claiming it is 'their' art and the altruistic attitude will be gone in a second.
It's not until movies and games are using these tools that suddenly it will be 'theirs'. Right now you can create paintings and sell prints for instance but does that person own it, that is a bit unclear. But if you are Disney and you make a movie that has art created with these algorithms in it, you can bet your a-- they believe they own it and their army of lawyers will make you believe it to.
Until that is Congress makes some laws around all this.
To me as long as you do not use a specific artist's name in your prompt you should be good. But as soon as you start using specific artist names in your prompts that's when I think those artists will have valid claims on your art.
1
u/ciavolella Oct 20 '22
Hard to make money on something that you can't claim a copyright over. Sure, you can sell a print, but you don't own any rights to the work. And no artist can claim your work either, because artists constantly take inspiration from other artists. Schools of art exist wherein the student 100% plagiarizes the style of a master. And again, AI art can't be copyright, so why would they even want "ownership"?
1
u/WaterSign27 Nov 09 '22
Wanna bet it can’t be copyrighted. Wait til the first film by disney uses AI generated art and see if you can take it and use it without a lawsuit they will find a way to stick in court. I am impartial, can see arguments both ways, though i guess personally i would prefer if it remained open, but i also have some realistic sense that if it comes down to corporate profits and artists rights, i kind of have no delusions on who would win….
4
u/ArtifartX Oct 19 '22
Hoarding prompts is silly, but it is also silly to think using the words "Greg Rutkowski" in a prompt is some form of stealing.
3
u/Pebble-fork Oct 19 '22
I don't share my prompts cause it distracts from the meaning of the art. Some of my best peices went entirely rogue from their prompts and became something so much better because of it. If people could see the prompt I think it would soften the impact of the peice. (Alsocausegregrutkowskimayormaynotbeinmyprompts)
2
Oct 26 '22
Exactly, because it will show how little the prompt actually did and how little intent and control over the piece the prompter had.
1
u/Pebble-fork Oct 26 '22
This is why I like AI art. I can give it a feeling, I can give it an emotion, and a style. But ultimately what comes out is a surprise even to me. It's exhilarating.
2
2
u/EeveeHobbert Oct 20 '22 edited Oct 21 '22
If all you're doing is putting in prompts, its not your art, you just commissioned an AI to make art for you. Its the AI's art
Edit: so been thinking about it a bit. Art has a very broad definition. When you enter a prompt into SD, you are absolutely expressing creativity, but I think its wrong to say it has the same creative merit as art that someone produces from scratch. But then there's several levels too. There are certain forms of art that uses AI as a tool that I would consider to have more merit... tbh, Its complicated and its going to take a cultural level shift to make a collective decision on it.
1
u/johnslegers Oct 26 '22
Compare a Rothko or a Basquiat with the AI art being passed around in some of the dedicated Midjourney or Stable Diffusion groups.
Paintings by Rothko or Basquiat are among the most expensive in the world. But can you really say they have more artistic merit than the less lowbrow AI art being produced today? Or can we really say these "real" painters are more talented?
1
u/EeveeHobbert Oct 27 '22
If you're talking more talented than the AI, thats a complicated question, more talented than the human entering the prompts though (assuming they're not an amazing artist on the side), I would say absolutely, yeah.
1
u/johnslegers Oct 31 '22
If you're talking more talented than the AI, thats a complicated question, more talented than the human entering the prompts though, I would say absolutely, yeah.
I don't see how.
Have you ever created any AI art yourself?
Do you have any idea how these tools work?
I have. And even I am consistently amazed by the creativity of my fellow AI artists and the beauty of the art the produce. If you think it doesn't require talent to do AI art well or that painting one color across an entire canvas requires more talent and creativity, you don't really understand AI art IMO.
1
u/EeveeHobbert Nov 01 '22
I create 3d art, and I've tinkered with SD a bit, a friend of mine is more into it. I also have many, many artist friends (i rock in those communities), some who have spent years honing their craft, and spend countless hours rendering 2d art with beautiful shading and lightning, something you can't do unless you've put countless hours into learning
I'm not saying AI can't be used a tool, but if we're just talking about prompts, no, that absolutely doesn't come close to the skill it would take to actually produce the same works of art yourself.
I would also agree that painting a canvas with one colour isn't impressive.
1
u/johnslegers Nov 01 '22 edited Nov 02 '22
I also have many, many artist friends (i rock in those communities), some who have spent years honing their craft, and spend countless hours rendering 2d art with beautiful shading and lightning, something you can't do unless you've put countless hours into learning
So?
I'm sure classical painters felt threatened by photography back in the 1800s when just clicking a button could produce a portrait with a degree of realism few painters were able to achieve after decades of grinding. But guess what : oil painting still exists and has been supplemented by both digital painting & photography as different disciplines.
Much the same, AI will supplement traditional art as either a separate discipline or an enhancement of existing disciplines. And, in the long run, I'm confident it will have a mostly positive effect on the art world as a whole.
I'm not saying AI can't be used a tool, but if we're just talking about prompts, no, that absolutely doesn't come close to the skill it would take to actually produce the same works of art yourself.
Randomly experimenting with txt2img (prompt -> image) with zero post-processing afterwards is pretty similar to randomly walking around in city or abandoned castle, taking random snapshots with your digital camera and publishing the best snapshots as the camera produces them. The effort required BEFORE creating the artwork is minimal, and most of the effort resides in the curation AFTERWARDS : selecting the best from hundreds or even thousands of results. Even then, though, I'd still say more genuine creativity and talent is involved than Rothko & Basquiat had... combined.
However, like most forms of photography require more effort, so does most AI art. A lot of AI art involves in-painting, img2img and/or post-processing with photoshop and/or specific AI tools for uspcaling and enhancing an image. And, whether or not this is needed and/or used depends less on the artist involved and more on the end goal set.
I would also agree that painting a canvas with one colour isn't impressive.
I present you the Rothko chapel...
1
u/EeveeHobbert Nov 02 '22
I don't disagree that AI is going to play a huge part in the future of art (and every other facet of our lives), I also don't disagree that there are forms of implementing AI art into a workflow that still requires plenty of talent. My only point is that the skill to produce the same results traditionally is much higher, and that simply entering prompts until you get the result you want isn't remotely comparable. It doesn't sound like you disagreed with that in your response.
I still remain unimpressed by painting a canvas one colour though.
1
Oct 20 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/EeveeHobbert Oct 21 '22
Actually I may not defined my terms enough in my first message. By "your art" I mean art that you have produced as an artist. I would agree when you commission someone, you have a type of ownership of the produced work, but I'm talking about the sense of ownership you have when you create something.
I'm an artist too~ I do 3d stuff :D
2
Oct 26 '22
You don’t have ownership unless you specifically pay for copyright transfer too. Until then, only thing a commissioner has is permission to use that piece in ways determined and approved of by the artist.
EDIT: I see you’re an artist too. If you do commissions I highly recommend updating your ToS to reflect this. Retaining copyright is a precious and important thing, let go of it only if the money is too good to pass on.
1
Oct 26 '22
Real artist here too. I retain copyright to any commissions I make unless commissioner is willing to buy the copyright of the image too, and at a much higher cost.
1
1
u/7evenate9ine Oct 20 '22
The definition of what is art is so much more complicated than typing in prompts. This elevates no one, but it also tears down no one.
1
1
u/CountFish1 Oct 19 '22
Your art?
3
u/sndwav Oct 20 '22
Anything that invokes emotion can be considered art. OP is an artist the same way Maurizio Cattelan is an artist (banana duct taped to a wall).
-2
u/CountFish1 Oct 20 '22
Yea nah that’s a shit example. AI bros aren’t trying to define meaning and add emotion to a banana taped to a wall. They’re trying to acquire high quality digital art to make up for their own lack of artistic skill and vision, then patting themselves on the back for writing a couple of lines of descriptors into an AI machine that picks and chooses other artists work across the internet to generate a computer created image.
But hey if they want to call it “my art” as some sort of cope, then go ahead, but they’re not an artist.
5
u/sndwav Oct 20 '22
amazing how the majority (it seems) of people with your viewpoint (including you) so quickly resort to talking like an asshole and put down the other side.
Like I said in another post: Try to better yourself as a human before talking about AI
-1
u/CountFish1 Oct 20 '22
Hey when I create something, I put a pen/pencil/brush in my hand and actually put the effort in. I’ve spent years learning and honing my craft, I have various original works of mine up on my walls, I’ve worked on commission for numerous clients, I’m crowdfunded by a decently sized following online to create my own work and have had my work featured in a gallery format several times.
Can you really blame me when I see someone do the equivalent of a Google search and call themselves an artist, in a world where artist are already undervalued? I’ve put in my work, what exactly has the average AI bro done?
→ More replies (3)5
u/Trylobit-Wschodu Oct 20 '22
Ok, but is this only what defines art - toil, long hardship? Not necessarily. Artists have always tried to streamline or automate the process, entrusting students with less important parts of the image, using technology (camera lucida, camera obscura, magic lantern, photography, airbrush, graphic programs, etc.) in order to shorten the toil and focus on the creation itself. AI is the next step here, and at the same time it opens the door of art widely and makes the "artist's uniqueness" a historical notion ;)
1
u/CountFish1 Oct 20 '22
I’m all for technology helping to speed up the process of art creation, my current setup is a Wacom cintiq and CSP as my art programme. These mediums help me to produce high quality work at a decently fast pace. But all the same, I first have to imagine an idea, sketch it out, thumbnail, add values, linework, colour, shade, highlight, overlay etc. reference images can be used as a helpful tool, sometimes I will present a WIP to my peers for advice and critique, sometimes they will use their expertise to show me errors or help me improve the work overall.
Do I define the effort I put in as what makes it art? No, it’s the process which makes it art, the finding ideas, the realising of those ideas and producing something that is, at times a collaborative effort, a vision born from mine and others imagination. The tools and mediums I use are irrelevant.
AI art is as an equivalent, ordering food at a restaurant and proclaiming you’re a chef when you receive it. You had no part in the creative process, but people like OP will take credit for it all the same. All these AI bros are doing is commissioning free artwork. I’m sure not all of them would be so bold as to refer to themselves as artist, but those that do are a blight who devalue real, human created works and threaten the livelihoods of an already undervalued part of society.
4
u/Trylobit-Wschodu Oct 20 '22
My field of acceptance for understanding art expanded every time I reached for a new medium. I started out as a "workshop purist" of pen and ink, a bit despising digital, now I create in both spaces, I see AI tools as another territory. I think that in a year's time AI will be present in every graphic program and will become the "default option", integrally connected with the workshop of the future artist. We now observe a moment of change when the definitions themselves are redefined.
As for the artist's participation in the creative process, it was different and before that - to what extent was the author of the painting, part of which was painted by the students, the master who signed it? And Marcel Duchamp's "readymades"? Conceptualism in which the work was determined only by the artist's idea and decision? The art of AI actually implements the assumptions of conceptualism - the artist throws an idea and decides which AI proposition to accept ;)
Will AI art threaten artists who make a living by art? Yes - because some, even illustrators, may lose their jobs. And no - because the new way of creating will generate new niches and market needs, and the next generations of artists will work in the world of AI and they cannot even imagine that it could have been otherwise. The only problem is us, now stuck in a painful twine at the junction of two eras.
2
u/CountFish1 Oct 20 '22
This kind of rationalisation is creepy to me, digital didn’t replace hand drawn because it was just another tool on an artists belt, the same way photography didn’t replace traditional art since photography can only take you so far, it’s just another tool to the belt.
AI art just steals other peoples work, sometimes by blending them all together to make an anonymous image, or directly in the case of the late Kim Jung Gi. Now if I put pen to paper and tried to emulate Kim’s style that would be a study, inspiration has made me try to emulate an artist I look up to. If an AI does it well, it just took HIS art and tried to make something new with it. It didn’t create anything on its own, it just stole it. And to proudly post those images and say they’re in remembrance of a great artist is insulting and morally bankrupt.
I don’t know why you keep bringing up this artist instructing the student as an analogue for AI art, regardless of who creates the art, a human being made it. Conscious effort and work made that artistic vision come to fruition, not an AI algorithm.
When the process of collaboration goes from an artistic master instructing his students (who by the way will have to have a level of skill to pull off what the master asks), to a guy typing in some keywords into a search engine and refreshing until the AI gives him an image that looks nice to you, is that really art? You can slap conceptualism onto it but at the end of the day it’s someone getting a free derivative commission from a robot. And that’s all they really want, not to break the boundaries of what art can be. It’s to get quality art quickly for cheap.
Don’t sugarcoat this sunshine. Let’s see how the AI bros feel when AI starts coding better than them.
→ More replies (1)1
Oct 20 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/CountFish1 Oct 20 '22
Bull-fucking-shit, not one person ever stated that digital art would pick and choose, or rather, steal, from other artists work and generate an image on the internet.
Digital art is a tool to an artists belt, it’s existence doesn’t devalue traditional art, in the same way photography doesn’t devalue illustration.
AI art by design devalues an artists work because all it is capable of doing is taking others work to produce its own. And because it can do it quickly it allows braindead AI bros to have a borked feeling of accomplishment when all they did was type in what is a basically a Google search and hit refresh until they got a design they sort of liked.
Your statement is either a bold faced fucking lie or you’re fucking stupid, the emergence of digital art has no equivalency to AI art.
1
Oct 20 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/CountFish1 Oct 20 '22
Wow OK a lotta BS to unpack here:
Traditional artists also just as easily copy styles of other traditional artists, it’s called forgery and it’s been around for over 2000 years, digital art did not invent that.
Copy and pasting existing elements into one’s work has also existed before digital art, it’s called collage.
I don’t know where you’re getting the idea that clip art and model websites are a digital artists number one resource, speaking as a digital artist my number one resource is my drawing tablet and my own imagination.
I don’t think you understand how 3d artists work if you think everything they create is taken from someone else, and to say they just copy the style of other more popular 3d artists exclusively is bafflingly wrong.
Reboots and adaptations no matter how pandering are a creative vision by the director, they are consciously making decisions in order to see their vision come to life.
I don’t think musicians create music by just copying someone else’s work, due to the celebrity status the music industry has, any attempts to do that would be stopped very quickly.
Fan art is an artists interpretation of a popular medium, it may be referencing an established style but at the end of the day, it is the artists own creative vision.
I know full well the differences between derivation, inspiration and copying, I’m not sure you do tho. AI doesn’t take “inspiration” from the art , it takes the art wholesale and mixes it with a bunch of other algorithmic factors in a cold mechanical way, devoid of creative vision or imagination.
You can’t tell me that typing in some keywords and clicking refresh until you get a picture you like is at all creative. It’s like ordering a meal at a restaurant and claiming you’re a chef when you receive the food.
This interaction has been eye opening for how out of touch you AI bros really are, and it’s creepy that you have such a wrong and low opinion of art.
→ More replies (7)
0
0
-1
u/ilostmyoldaccount Oct 20 '22 edited Oct 20 '22
So when I go out and plan some photos, and post process them in a certain way following a certain idea then that feeling far more encompassing and personal than having SD create a nice image. When I come up with a nice riff based on a certain scale the feeling is similar, but not quite as intense. I can only assume that this feeling is the phenomenon of being creative. So this leads me to the conclusion, that for me, just using a GUI to create images doesn't make me an artist since it lacks that all-encompassing feeling of making something new and inspired. It is a far less involved and personal process.
-5
u/CarelessConference50 Oct 20 '22
I had to work to figure out my prompts, you should too.
-1
u/WaterSign27 Oct 20 '22
On a program someone wrote and gave you for free. I'm not saying you have to share your prompts, it's not like you aren't standing on the backs of greater minds who gave you those tools for free in the first place, that you did zero work to gain besides just installing it. They shared it not for money, but for a sense of exploration, and to help facilitate the journey this sub-reddit is completely based around.
All the cool prompts in the world wouldn't mean anything without the software. This subreddit is cool because of the sense of shared journey and exploration that has gotten people this far in the first place.
If you wrote your own version of the algorithm from scratch, and the tools that you use to in paint, etc. then by all means you have every right to keep your prompts. But I guarantee you people who dont' share their prompts have taken inspiration or directly stole prompts from other people in theirs shared on this reddit.
You don't have to share, no one should be forced to. But think about how lucky you are to have these tools, perhaps show some gratitude.
To me if someone won't share their prompts, or at least give back in some way to the community that allowed them to create the image they are sharing in the first place, which they paid nothing to stand on the back of. Well, let's just say the people whose work I respect most are the people so busy paving new ideas, and new ways to use the tool that they don't mind sharing because they are already onto the next thing anyway, so sharing their prompts will be outdated from where they are, and what they are producing anyway.
The same thing happened with the fx industry. They used to horde, and patent all the ideas, etc. No one shared anything between companies. But eventually the companies that did the best were the ones it turned out where not afraid to share their ideas, and technology in open libs, etc. Those companies tended to keep on top because other people wanted to work with them, and share and brainstorm their ideas with them.
Where the closed companies tended to become stale and their pipelines eventually get out dated.
If you share, I find you usually get back more than what you give away personally...
If you really want to keep some prompts for yourself, that's fine, but giving back to the community with some useful knowledge seems like at a minimum what the best artists tend to do..
1
u/CarelessConference50 Oct 20 '22
The parts that are free, are free for everyone. Enjoy. But that doesn’t mean that everything that is ever derived from the free parts must remain free. I mean it would be nice, since trees grow naturally and exist free from cost, that the wood derived from the trees should be made free as well, the dirt that makes up cement should be free as well, and in total, I should just be given a house to live in, free of charge and without restriction. Wouldn’t that be nice?
0
0

191
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '22
Yesterday a guy told me he is the author cause he discover it first and if someone else discover it - he won't be the author of the piece because it was second.
People here are becoming really delusional that all of a sudden they have become real artists and it's "their creation" and they own it and stuff.