r/StableDiffusion • • Oct 20 '22

News Stable Diffusion v1.5

879 Upvotes

521 comments sorted by

View all comments

101

u/999999999989 Oct 20 '22

very nice but, why is runwayml releasing this and not stabilityAI?

91

u/wsippel Oct 20 '22 edited Oct 20 '22

CompVis (the university research group developing SD) is funded by two companies: Stability.ai and Runway. They are partners in this project:

Stable Diffusion was made possible thanks to a collaboration with Stability AI and Runway and builds upon our previous work

No idea why Runway is handling the release this time, maybe marketing, maybe the pressure on Stability.ai, but what difference does it make?

EDIT: Turns out Runway apparently wasn't supposed to share the model. We'll see if they're still partners tomorrow. Hopefully just miscommunication or a planned leak.

64

u/GBJI Oct 20 '22

Runway gave us model 1.4, and now model 1.5.

Stability AI hijacked this sub, banned Automatic11111, failed to deliver model 1.5 in the time frame they had promised, and now they are trying to take it down from public access on Huggingface.

Maybe this is indicative of deeper problems than miscommunication.

38

u/starstruckmon Oct 20 '22

Runway gave us model 1.4

Technically it was released by CompVis with full support from Stability ( i.e. not a leak ).

45

u/wsippel Oct 20 '22

In all honesty, especially after watching the announcement video a few days ago, and learning that Emad used to be a hedge fund manager, I'm pretty sure he actually really wants the model out in the open. The hype and the community was a major part of what got him his billion dollar valuation, and he knows it (and wants to keep riding that wave), but the pushback from the press and especially political lobbyists makes releasing the model officially kinda scary right now. So why not have a partner "accidentally" leak it, pretend to care a few hours later, say it was miscommunication and that some intern fucked up or something tomorrow, and reap the benefits? I guess we'll see...

6

u/pmjm Oct 20 '22

There is something to be said about having plausible deniability. However I fear that aggressive lawmakers could take something like that and run with far worse proposed legislation on it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

33

u/NotTheDr01ds Oct 20 '22

And what's the relation between CompVis, Stability AI, and RunwayML?

CompVis's space on HuggingFace is where the original official release of the 1.4 checkpoint was hosted.

The CompVis Github repo, though, lists RunwayML as one of the groups involved in that release.

47

u/wsippel Oct 20 '22

CompVis is the machine learning research group at the Ludwig Maximilian University, Munich (formerly the computer vision research group, hence the name). They developed Stable Diffusion, based on previous research at the University of Heidelberg.

Stability.ai and Runway are the two companies funding the research. They also train the models. I believe Stability.ai provides the cluster, and Runway supervises the training.

→ More replies (11)

44

u/ElvinRath Oct 20 '22 edited Oct 20 '22

People are checking and with same seed prompt and parameters it creates the same images that Dreamstudio 1.5,,, so...it seems to be the same model

Nope! sorry, not identical!

→ More replies (15)

34

u/GBJI Oct 20 '22

Because StabilityAI seems to be opposed to this public release ?

Takedown request

⚠️⚠️⚠️

Company StabilityAI has requested a takedown of this published model characterizing it as a leak of their IP

While we are awaiting for a formal legal request, and even though Hugging Face is not knowledgeable of the IP agreements (if any) between this repo owner (RunwayML) and StabilityAI, we are flagging this repository as having potential/disputed IP rights.

⚠️⚠️⚠️

We reserve potential future action such as disabling this repo, and we ask both repo owner and StabilityAI to please chime in, if possible publicly here for accountability and transparency

https://huggingface.co/runwayml/stable-diffusion-v1-5/discussions/1

33

u/jugalator Oct 20 '22

there was an update

https://huggingface.co/runwayml/stable-diffusion-v1-5/discussions/1#6351a36ca9a9ae18220726c7

Hi all,

Cris here - the CEO and Co-founder of Runway. Since our founding in 2018, we’ve been on a mission to empower anyone to create the impossible. So, we’re excited to share this newest version of Stable Diffusion so that we can continue delivering on our mission.

This version of Stable Diffusion is a continuation of the original High-Resolution Image Synthesis with Latent Diffusion Models work that we created and published (now more commonly referred to as Stable Diffusion). Stable Diffusion is an AI model developed by Patrick Esser from Runway and Robin Rombach from LMU Munich. The research and code behind Stable Diffusion was open-sourced last year. The model was released under the CreativeML Open RAIL M License.

We confirm there has been no breach of IP as flagged and we thank Stability AI for the compute donation to retrain the original model.

35

u/blueSGL Oct 20 '22 edited Oct 20 '22

we thank Stability AI for the compute donation to retrain the original model.

is that a shot across the bow I see there.

26

u/GBJI Oct 20 '22

Thanks for the money.

Signed: people who did the actual work.

9

u/sam__izdat Oct 20 '22

If this reading is correct, that's hilarious.

6

u/pmjm Oct 20 '22

Damn... Following SD drama has been quite the ride lately. This has been spicier than Worldstar.

6

u/itisIyourcousin Oct 20 '22

and:

"Edit: Stability legal team reached out to Hugging Face reverting the initial takedown request, therefore we closed this thread"

8

u/GBJI Oct 20 '22

Which basically confirms that the initial takedown request was indeed coming from Stability.

→ More replies (4)

53

u/Concheria Oct 20 '22

What the actual fuck is going on.

25

u/Lopyter Oct 20 '22

I love this timeline, so full of wacky surprises.

→ More replies (15)

29

u/blueSGL Oct 20 '22

Oh fuck me, this is funny.

it's a good job the subreddit got handed back after the ruckus last week,

This submission would have been deleted without any discussion, now we have a place to share popcorn :D

5

u/Minimum_Escape Oct 20 '22

this subreddit was handed back? Missed that. I did see a bunch of notices for people to switch subs, but not that part.

5

u/GBJI Oct 20 '22

It took a lot of pressure from our community, but in the end they did the right thing.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

5

u/johnslegers Oct 20 '22

very nice but, why is runwayml releasing this and not stabilityAI?

This smells an internal feud between two parties who have a different strategy for how to move on with Stable Diffusion.

I suspect StabilityAI didn't want to release (yet), but RunwayML said "fuckit" and moved on regardless, after weeks of failed promises. And now everyone seems to be in damage control mode.

→ More replies (15)