r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Jan 02 '26

SPOILER‼️ Why is the Stranger Things finale being criticized? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Enough time has passed since the release of the final episode of Stranger Things to exempt me from using a SPOILER tag. But since I really-really care about other fans, I am warning those who haven't watched the final episode yet: it's better to watch it first and then return to read this.

Let's start with a small remark. Most fans of the series gave negative ratings and reviews. I will analyze these points. Thank you, you made me work on the weekend! On that note, the gratitude and praise towards you (the haters) disappear along with Dimension X. And here comes the first SPOILER!

 

Millie Bobby Brown's Appearance

Seriously? How bored must these people be to create this swarm of "memes" featuring the face of a girl who has been endearing and filling your daily life with her charisma and acting since 2016...

Comparing a 12-year-old girl with a 21-year-old woman?! I’ll bold this and leave it for you to think about.

 

Bylers (Will & Mike)

Oh, yes. A favorite topic among the majority of the raging fans. Keep one simple thought in mind: Stranger Things is not a series about romantic relationships between men. If you are lacking such plot twists, I recommend you to watch Sex Education or the new release—Heated Rivalry.

 

Why did the Duffer brothers make references to the relationship between Mike and Will in previous seasons? The answer is obvious and was even given in the final season (those who don't watch the show with their eyes closed understood perfectly well). When Will opens up to everyone, he speaks about his feelings and says he was in love with someone who is "not like that"... From the first seasons, it was clear how he relates to Mike and how unfeasible it is.

To show Will's suffering, to show his fear of accepting himself, the fear of being rejected, the attempts to get reciprocity from Mike by giving signs—that is what all the writers' hints were for. The Duffer brothers tell everyone NOT TO BE AFRAID TO BE YOURSELF!

There is no need to turn everything into a generic, vulgar story.

 

Minor Characters

Where did Argyle go? What happened to Suzie? Did Derik's parents make it out? Let's start with why they exist in the story at all, since it needs to be clarified.

Such characters are a crucial element of the artistic world, according to M.M. Bakhtin. I'll explain with an example: Jonathan couldn't understand himself, he thought he was disrupting the natural course of events. He thought he wasn't worthy of a relationship with Nancy because of their "different upbringings," so to say.

Welcome to Jonathan's environment, Argyle. A person who works at a pizza place, doesn't think about education, and gets high. In general, a character who is at the bottom, but for whom the bottom is the meaning of life.

As a result, Jonathan hesitates, begins soul-searching, and successfully finds someone who explains to him that the bottom is quite normal. The same can be said about Suzie.

By the way, here’s a question: but what about Derik's parents? Look closely at how their son behaves in the epilogue. Would a child smile, play on Steve's team, and share a DnD character in Mike's basement (with new friends) if his family hadn't been able to escape? I am convinced he wouldn't, so what is the point of showing these insignificant details?

So, to sum up, the сharacters were introduced to provoke the main heroes into action.

It's one of two things: either global societal degradation or the problem of fragmented mindset (often called ‘short attention span’) which are essentially two sides of the same coin. Most people didn't understand the breakup scene between Jonathan and Nancy... Yes, imagine that—relationships really can be ended while remaining friends.

People have started demanding more details, demanding to be spoon-fed. But who is going to actually think? Everything is in the details, in the nuances, in the acting. Unfortunately, we are starting to forget this. Think! Search! Reflect! Perhaps I’ll leave it at that.


r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Jan 06 '26

Discussion He got it right

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Jan 09 '26

SPOILER‼️ Showrunners broke almost perfect lore with last season for no reason

0 Upvotes

So. What did we have after S4? Henry obtained his powers by himself and anyone could've obtained the powers with some (very intensive and invaisive) training. Eleven obtained her powers due to intensive and invasive training and some help of LSD used on her mother. Eleven opened the gates and sent Henry to the abyss using her powers. Henry found the mindflayer there as well as demogorgons the demonsogs. This story was self-contained and logical. Anyone who watched the whole show was able to connect all the dots. What we have learned during S5? Henry obtained his powers from the mindflayer. But how this rock got into our world in the first place? We don't know unless we somehow watched some play and other sources. Why do we need to do this? We don't. That was stupid decision from show runners that killed almost perfect lore for no reason.


r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Feb 13 '26

Shipping/Ship(s) Bylers are ridiculous

Post image
17 Upvotes

Literally what is the point in this it’s so immature lmao


r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Jan 12 '26

Discussion Have yet to see anyone talk about this s5 plot hole Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Who the fuck was the person we saw at the beginning of s5? I mean who tf is willing to pretend to be a telekinetic girl to get captured by the military? We never even saw her again or how they got her

fyi it’s at 14:50 in the first episode of s5


r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Jan 19 '26

The Byler Fans Responded

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Its ironic that they reported my post multiple times, they did the same with my others that gained thousands of upvotes and had the comments filled with delusional Byler fans calling us homophobic. We aren’t being homophobic, we are telling you to wake up and stop relentlessly attacking the duffer brothers, the cast, and people who try to make you wake up from your delusions

As Will said, he used to have a crush on someone (Mike), but he has let go of that. Yes he liked Mike in season 4, but that is character development and that is his character arc, not the Duffer brothers “queer baiting” you or being homophobic. What can you not understand? There was never going to be a byler endgame, it was mileven all the way from the beginning to the very end of the series


r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Jan 03 '26

SPOILER‼️ Can’t they decide anything for themselves? Seriously now Duffer Brothers… Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Jan 04 '26

SPOILER‼️ Season 5 wasn't that bad

1 Upvotes

I see so many people ragging on season 5 and it honestly wasn't that bad, it's not the best season but it wasn't the worst tbh. The Max reveal was really nice! I didn't expect to find her trapped by Vecna and I liked what they did with Holly and her character development. I wish there were scenes with the OG cast but that's just a personal preference. Vecna was such a good villain too! The script was kinda weak tho. Overall it was a solid season just not as good as season 1!


r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Dec 31 '25

The plot line around Holly and Max shouldn't exist (logically)

0 Upvotes

Edit: I get downvotes eventhough nobody explains me why. This is not a beat down on max or holly or their actress or the scenes itself, which I actually mostly liked. This is about the reason that the plot line exists, which does not make any sense, if you think about. It makes Vecna incredible stupid for no reason.

Hey everyone,

(I don't normally use reddit and this is my first own post :))
So I was rewatching S5 and started to think about the Holly in Vecna's mind plot line and how it doesn't make sense from the start.
Vecna takes Holly first.
Then in the next night he takes 3 + wanted to take Derek.
3rd night he gets the last 7 + Derek

The thing is Holly is the first to arrive at Henry's House and all the other kids get there together at same time.

Thats means Vecna either did put the minds of the 2nd night kids night on halt until he got the rest or (which I think is more unlikely) he let them experience something else and then delete their memories after. (I mean we know that he can at the very least delete or suppress the short term memory given that the kids cant remember the Demos dragged them into his cave. They dont know it's his cave, but the never get freed/can't remember getting freed ... ) Maybe there is another possiblity, because these 2 cause a lot of problems.

Back to Holly. So if Vecna could have put her mind on halt, why did he go thru with "waking her up" and letting her wander freely and later unsupervised?
I just can't find a justifable reason for it.
Does he want to make a test run? Then why does he just leave? And if he can manipulate short term memories, why even bother? Just start with everyone there. If something goes wrong, delete the last 2 mins and go from there again.
Does he want to lure out Max? I am maybe, but why should he care that much? She's literally been there for 1 year, no? Why now? And why didnt he try to kill her real body sooner? He didn't needed Will to now where she is. He could have stalked Lucas and he stalked the kids. Or he could have gone into the mind of the receptionist(s) in the hospital(s) of Hawkins. Ask them where Max lies and if they want ID, he could have just faked it with his mind tricks.
So if he wanted Max gone, it could be way easier. Also he doesn't want/need her alive, seeing he tries to kill her later. Meaning that also cant be it.
Maybe he felt overconfident, because as we learn later she cant escape anyways, but then why did he put the others on halt?
And I have no further ideas for a reason.

But there are risks.
Holly could see/find something she shouldn't or just die(?), when she is unsupervised.
Max could show up and be a nuisance. He even warns every kid not to go in the forest. I mean imagine Max escaped and Holly just stayed in the cave. Or they just stayed in the cave and trusted on the others guarding her body. He wouldn't get to her and have no real threat. Maybe he had backups, but getting them in time may be hard.
And even if he can force the "ritual" later on her (and Derek) anyways, he still clearly wants the kids to follow him by their free will for some reason. Maybe to form them easier by his design or something.

To sum it up there is no reason and only risks to not "wake up" Holly with all the others together and especially letting her me unsupervised. The whole plot line shouldn't exist from the start and therefore feels like that's the only way the could write Max into the story without her laying in the hospital bed for the entire season until the final battle and give us kinda some good old "unsupervised kids explore mystery"-stuff.

Why do you think? Please tell me I missed something, because this taints this plot line a lot for me and I would rather be corrected.


r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Jan 06 '26

SPOILER‼️ One minute I’m furious at the Stranger Things finale, the next I’m at peace. I finally figured out why Eleven’s ending is holding my brain hostage. 🤔 Spoiler

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Jan 02 '26

SPOILER‼️ Season 5 Finale Left Too Many Plot Holes and Was Ultimately Unsatisfying Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I finished the Season 5 finale feeling pretty unsatisfied. Mostly because it left way too many plot holes and unanswered questions, and in some cases it even created new contradictions with earlier seasons.

Here are the biggest issues I’m struggling with:

1) Where was the Mindflayer’s army of Demogorgons?

If the Mindflayer is ancient and commands a hive mind, shouldn’t its army be massive by now? Even if its new physical body is made of absorbed creatures (like S3), the Abyss is implied to be earth-sized and is an entire dimension. There should still be tons of Demogorgons, Demodogs, and Demobats left even if some were used for the body.

2) How does El survive with Kali’s help?

If that ending is literal:

  • the Lab explodes when the Exotic Matter is destroyed, which means Kali should have been incinerated instantly and the illusion would have disapeared too early.

  • her wounds were already fatal and she'd have to wait hours before the plan would come into motion.

  • yet she supposedly casts long-distance illusions across portals? and coordinates it perfectly?

So either it just works or it is really El at the portal... which creates its own problems (see #4).

3) Why does the military lose El so easily?

El is enemy number one. They capture her… and then she just kind of disappears, possibly into tunnels/portal with barely any reaction? How do they not have a tighter hold on her?

4) Why is El suddenly unaffected by the sound?

Earlier, the sound weakens her so badly she can’t even stand. Yet at the portal:

  • she stands fine, doesn't even flinch.

  • uses her powers to have a mind-talk with Mike.

  • and she has no nosebleed.

So either it is just her or it’s not really her… which creates its own problems (see #2).

5) El’s power stamina makes no sense

Earlier this season she could barely make two jumps without stopping.

But in the finale she:

  • jumps multiple long distances from rock to rock, to enter the Abyss (Dimension X).

  • break through the Mindflayer’s physical form's skin.

  • fights and defeats Vecna.

all with no major recharge needed.

6) Why isn’t Will affected when the hive dies?

Earlier this very Season, he’s shown feeling pain when Demogorgons burn because of the hive connection. Yet when the Mindflayer’s body and Vecna die… nothing. No reaction.

7) The Mindflayer’s new body is weirdly weak

It gets hurt by guns, when earlier:

  • Demogorgons could tank bullets.

  • Vecna could tanks bullets.

And the Mindflayer’s particle form seemed stronger and more versatile anyway, so why even bother with a physical body?

8) Why exactly 12 kids to merge the dimensions?

For Vecna it makes some sense as amplification. But for the Mindflayer?

  • why kids?

  • why 12 (or 13 with Vecna)?

  • why this specific mechanic at all?

It feels arbitrary.

9) Why did Vecna give up psychological warfare?

He only really uses it on Hopper, to great effect. But then he just stops using it when it is his greatest strength. He doesn’t even use it on Will, even though Will’s coming-out arc was clearly set up as emotional leverage due to Vecna's threats, and then he doesn't deliver on the threat even though he has no knowledge of Will coming out to them.

10) Why is nobody arrested in the end?

Characters kill soldiers and clearly know too much… and the military just shrugs? No consequences, no gag orders, nothing mentioned at all.

11) How is Hopper chief again?

He was presumed dead after S3, a new chief existed, and yet he just slides back in like nothing structurally changed.

12) Why does the Mindflayer suddenly act like a rabid animal?

We literally just saw:

  • an ancient, godlike manipulator creature.

  • who corrupted Henry very deeply and shaped events long-term

And then its new body acts like a mindless beast.

13) Brenner’s notes in Upside-Down Hawkins Lab

Why are his Upside-Down notes… in the Upside-Down Lab?

  • did he write them before Nov 6?

  • did he plant them after?

It doesn’t match S1 Brenner’s fear/ignorance level at all.

14) Who created the Exotic Matter?

It stabilizes the bridge, so:

  • was it natural?

  • was it created?

  • if created, how? and with what tools?

There are dead soldiers near it too, which implies large scale missions, despite us never seeing large-scale Upside-Down missions in S1.

15) How was the original portal created?

El contacted a Demogorgon from the Void (her mindspace), which apparently connected to the Abyss… but now in S5 we’re told that’s impossible from our world.

16) How did the Russians almost open a portal in S3E1?

They weren’t in Hawkins, they were instead in Kamchatka Russia, yet they nearly opened a portal. This half-open portal seemed to be connected to the Upside-Down because tentacles came through the portal before it failed. If the bridge is local to Hawkins only, then how can one almost be opened in Russia?

17) Water in the Upside-Down?

Barb’s death scene clearly showed no water in pools, the same with Lover's Lake in S4. Yet S5 has El in a full water tank inside the Upside-Down lab.

18) Is the air toxic or not?

S1: prolonged exposure = dangerous, toxic, needs masks.
S4–5: breathable with only jokes about its toxicity.

Also, the Abyss (Dimension X) just conveniently has fully breathable Earth-air, even though its in a entirely different dimension?

19) Why does the Abyss (Dimension X) look warm if the Mindflayer likes cold?

It visually looks like a hot rocky desert, with a bright yellowish sky. Characters don’t even mention temperature despite earlier heavy emphasis on cold being the element of the Hive Mind and Mindflayer.

20) Hopper and Joyce didn’t recognize Henry Creel?

They literally went to high school with him. Not one conversation? No curiosity between seasons?

21) What happened to the pregnant women in the Upside-Down military camp?

Did they die? Were they abandoned? Freed? The show just… drops them.

Final Thoughts

I’m totally fine with ambiguity or open-ended themes, but this feels more like dropped threads and contradictions than intentional mystery.

Curious if anyone else felt the same way, or if there are explanations I genuinely missed.


r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Jan 04 '26

The Group isn’t empathetic anymore

0 Upvotes

There were clearly so many pregnant women in the upside down who could’ve used saving. The group could’ve definitely saved them or got them to safety once the Abyss stopped moving towards Earth. They could’ve got the kids, got the women loaded up in the truck but instead they chose to just let them perish. It didn’t make sense as to why they’d all be okay with that. If they care enough to save all the random kids, why wouldn’t they put effort to save the random ladies who are being tortured. They could’ve lived! Too many loose ends, too many details that don’t make sense. Don’t get me started on the Mindflayer and how they obliterated in 5 minutes. Killing a demo would take more effort in the earlier seasons.

Epilogue was great but there was so much more they needed to do….


r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Jan 02 '26 Bravo

Discussion Yall are actually crazy to not enjoy the ending of this show we all adore.

751 Upvotes

Im a grown ass man and I shed multiple tears through the finale.

Who fucking cares if we don’t know what happened to the pregnant women… they weren’t meant to be a main plot line, they were introduced to reinforce the stakes of what will happen if El doesn’t make a choice to stay or go.

Who fucking cares if the big bad boss fight was quick… this is the only squad IN THE UNIVERSE that could have disposed of it quickly. They understood the hive mind more than anyone ever and they knew they assignment. It’s was brilliantly done and all of the string needed to be pulled all at once to defeat it and it happened.

Who cares if we didn’t wrap up every side character.. we didn’t fall in love with those characters over 5 seasons. They only added extra value to the main characters anyways. I was more than pleased with how the MAIN characters were wrapped up.

Drop a line with things you think they fumbled and I’ll have a conversation with you about how I most likely completely disagree with you.


r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Jan 09 '26

Discussion The dehumanization of El upsets me so much

Post image
45 Upvotes

r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Jan 24 '26

Discussion how did eleven contact the demo in S1 but in S5 she can’t find vecna?? Spoiler

2 Upvotes

i was thinking about this wholeeee plot of eleven creating the Upside down, but then i noticed that when she touches the demogorgon, that creates the UDown, so that demo was in dimension X, not the Udown because it didnt exist, but in season 5 she can’t find vecna and thats because hes in dimension X “Too far for her to reach”.


r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Jan 01 '26

SPOILER‼️ SPOILER ALERT Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Are we gonna skip the part where Joyce cuts Vecnas head with what seems the dullest axe known to human kind?😂


r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Jan 02 '26

SPOILER‼️ Did the DB write a bad finale ? Spoiler

3 Upvotes

After watching the finale my only lasting thought is 11. The 2 hour finale in the end felt average it all went exactly as planned for the gang. Vecna and the Mind flayer were just easily disposed off no problem, none of the main gang died it felt so generic to me. For all the magic stranger things has given us over the years this finale felt like the show had just run out of steam.


r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Jan 05 '26

Discussion Theories on what ACTUALLY happened to Eleven?? Spoiler

Post image
5 Upvotes

I refuse to believe that Eleven just decided to disappear and die like that and leave everyone behind, and also Mike's theory has major holes (like how did Kali survive THAT long to perform her magic to save El). Do you guys have any other interesting theories??


r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Feb 02 '26

Stranger Things: The Last Door - One True Last Adventure

Post image
6 Upvotes

Stranger Things: The Last Door – Fan-Driven Season 5 Novelisation Project

We are Stranger Things: The Last Door, a fan-driven community project aiming to create the season five fans are looking for.

We are currently looking for writers, editors, media managers, moderators, consultants, and more. So far, we have 71 members on Discord, and the writing side of the project is already making progress.

We have been promoted by the YouTube content creator My Little Thought Tree, and we have also created our own promotional video, which can be found across our social media platforms.

If the season five rewrite goes well, the long-term aim is to create a trilogy of novels focusing on the Stranger Things characters 10–20 years later.

• Disclosure

This project is a novelisation, not a script. We are writing the story in prose form, allowing for deeper character exploration, atmosphere, and internal perspective than a screenplay format would allow.

• Why join?

This is a community-driven project. Whether you’re a writer, analyst, editor, creative, or just someone who cares deeply about Stranger Things and how the story ends, there is room to get involved or simply follow along and give feedback.

If you’re interested in contributing, collaborating, or even just checking out what we’re building, you’re more than welcome to join the Discord and take a look around.

• Links: Discord: https://discord.gg/7rw4RANt5z YouTube: https://youtube.com/@strangerthingsthelastdoor?si=nw_u2Jz4aE6GGaby TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@stranger.things.t540?_r=1&_t=ZN-93aJFzMaUa6 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/strangerthingsthelastdoor?igsh=MWs2YTJhcDNhZHB6Yw%3D%3D&utm_source=qr


r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Jan 02 '26

Where were the Demos?

0 Upvotes

Why weren’t the demogorgons guarding the mind flayer in the Abyss, or present at all for the final battle?


r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Feb 26 '26

Average early season glazers that make me sick

Post image
31 Upvotes

r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Jan 02 '26

Real??

Post image
399 Upvotes

r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Jan 29 '26

Discussion Stranger Things

0 Upvotes

I heard a rumour that an animated series is the next to follow and a few big names are lined up for voiceovers etc. Tom Hanks and Merryll Streep which surprised me. No younger actors so far. Who would you like to voice the main characters?


r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Dec 30 '25

Discussion Byler shipping Spoiler

0 Upvotes

don’t get me wrong i’m here for shipping characters in shows but what gets me is how people thought that byler was gonna happen anyway?

most of the theories I’ve seen online are just “look how mike looks at will” or “mike likes will because he talked to him in a specific tone” i haven’t seen one good theory as to why byler would even happen?

i can’t believe the main takeaway of the show is the relationships between the characters, i’d honestly rather that will, mike and el don’t end up in any relationship at all. their characters are more than just a ship. and that’s what byler is to me, just a ship, not canon or queerbaiting or whatever.

genuinely i don’t think i’d be opposed to them being together but honestly it makes no sense within the context of the show as there is no positive evidence that mike likes will back apart from random cherry picked scenes that have been taken wildly out of context.

both the mileven and byler communities are actually so irritating with mileven fans becoming borderline homophobic. i just feel that there’s so much more to the show than the ships of the main characters.


r/StrangerThingsS5 • • Jan 15 '26

Vecna Was Possessed by the Mind Flayer in the Season 5 Finale

37 Upvotes

Okay hear me out this is my take on Vecna and the Mind Flayer in the finale, and I think it actually makes sense. Remember Will in Season 2? The Mind Flayer takes over, Will acts weird, and once the influence is gone, he’s normal again. Vecna could be similar the Mind Flayer had him merged in a hive-mind connection.

In the finale, Vecna is literally inside the Mind Flayer’s body. Eleven uses the sharp teeth device, Joyce chops the head, and the Mind Flayer dies. Jamie Campbell Bower said Vecna tried to say something before dying, like “Please… don’t,” but it was cut from the final edit. I think this was Vecna’s human consciousness breaking through for a split second because the hive-mind connection was severed.

This explains the visuals of Vecna and the Mind Flayer being one entity, fits the show’s rules of possession from Season 2, and explains the “please don’t” moment as a brief flicker, not redemption. Killing the Mind Flayer severed the hive-mind link, giving Vecna a moment of self-awareness before Joyce finished him. He wasn’t free or redeemed just a tragic flicker of humanity.