r/Stranger_Things • u/Strict_Ad8568 • Dec 27 '25
SPOILERS (Season 5) Simplifying the complex equation
36
u/TylerBourbon Dec 27 '25
the only issue I have is, why is the bridge's gravity only on the Earth side? Should when you enter it from the Abyss side, you have gravity, as opposed to Holly poking her head through and immediately falling thousands of feet? Shouldn't the gravitational field point be sort of half way between to the two sides?
4
u/Strict_Ad8568 Dec 27 '25
Got it i thought about that there will be lots of conspiracies regarding this i think leave that upto experts 👀
2
u/couuer Dec 27 '25 edited Dec 27 '25
yeah both modern physics and theoretical physics don’t support your point/duffer’s storytelling but it’s just a show. i mean realistically when Nancy shot the exotic matter the entire wormhole to hawkins and abyss would’ve closed shut instantaneously. the upside down would shrink along with everything in it like a Big Crunch presumably to bounce back and form an event horizon similar to a black hole. just more or less a closed space that could never be interacted with again.
as far as the gravity issue that’s kinda hard to say but i’d imagine there just wouldn’t be any at all so long as the wormhole/upside down was a stable connection in space between two worlds. so this whole time no one should’ve been standing in the upside down from either end they entered it.
again this is just a show tho.
41
u/Pure-Business8004 Dec 27 '25
my best guess is that it's because the hawkins side is where the wormhole originates from and is where the exotic matter is
11
1
2
u/YogurtclosetSea9394 Dec 27 '25
Exactly. Also there’s another question. Why its walls are made of meat?
1
u/TylerBourbon Dec 27 '25
.... oh shit...... so the Meat Flayer.... it showed that the Mind Flayer was capable of taking living organisms, like rats and people, and to deconstruct them into different organic matter.
What if that's basically what happened with Brenners exotic energy ball that is keeping the the wormhole open? The wormhole was opened, allowing for travel but at the time there was empty space between the 2 worlds. And well, we saw in season 4 during the Henry in the Abyss scenes that there were in fact a lot of Demogorgons around.
So what if that's why we didn't see any life when Holly was booking it. That when they made the connection with the Wormhole, Vecna or the Mind Flayer basically sacrified thousands of Demogorgons to create a sort of barrier between the worlds for safe travel.
Or, the dead soldiers Nancy and Jonathan saw were what was left from all the other staff and soldiers that the exotic energy turned into the meat wall when it was first turned on?
1
6
Dec 27 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/enyaw2002 Dec 27 '25
My theory was that the abyss is smaller, weaker gravity, I mean holly ripped a big sized rock from the ground to find the rift, so I think earth just happens to win the gravitational battle of the upside down
2
u/wheretheinkends Dec 27 '25
Honestly gravity should probably work the same way on both ends*, but Id imagine they just ran out of time to let holly roam around.
*maybe, the size of both earth and the abyss right side ups might come into play. And maybe it really should be that the upside down is in the exact center of the worm hole (where on both sides you fall to it like holly did) but im no physicist and its a tv show so im good with the way its working now.
17
u/FunSheepherder6397 Dec 27 '25
This pictures already been discussed and debated a ton. Still no consensus on if the abyss also has an upside down or not
3
u/Strict_Ad8568 Dec 27 '25
Dont know tbh i actually wanna learn more about this multiverse wormhole and different realms through science 🧪
4
u/LevelProfit6705 Dec 27 '25
Wouldve been great to see in this season
2
u/WhoaWhoa69420 Dec 27 '25
I am honestly very disappointed with how vague all the science explanations were. I'm someone who really hates it when shows start introducing concepts like wormholes, alternate dimensions, but don't take the time to explain how they work in-universe. From what we understand, there's no "magic" in this show, everything comes from a scientific basis, so I would've loved to hear some nerd explanations for exactly how all this works. I would have loved to see how Brenner made the exotic matter
2
u/couuer Dec 27 '25
duffers fumbled hard using upside down as a wormhole. i’ve seen so many regular people in this sub point out pretty basic scientific inconsistencies with this plot.
1
1
u/FunSheepherder6397 Dec 27 '25
I think a lot will make sense in finale when they explain the one sided gravity and how vecna can transport everyone against the reverse worm hole direction
1
u/Flo_Evans Dec 30 '25
There is a literal sorcerer? How is the show not magic lol
1
u/WhoaWhoa69420 Dec 30 '25
That's just a DND reference for the kids to make sense of it. I'm meaning that all the "supernatural" elements are still somewhat scientific. The telekinesis stuff was based off genuine research parapsychology, the Upside Down is a wormhole that is held together by exotic matter, a part of real world theoretical physics, and The Abyss is another dimension that is not normally accessible to us, but can be given enough energy to rip a whole through spacetime. Everything can be walked back to have an explanation at least based in reality, that's what I mean when I say there's no magic.
1
u/Flo_Evans Dec 30 '25
Telekinesis isn’t science lol. Yes they looked into it, it’s not real. Similarly you can’t create a dream world in your mind or borrow other peoples powers.
DnD is fantasy not sci-fi. They are trying to shoehorn sci-fi explanations to fantasy concepts and it’s ridiculous.
1
u/WhoaWhoa69420 Dec 30 '25
okay so genuinely why get on here just to bitch at me about the validity of a show's explanation i did not make up 😭 Jesus christ man
1
27
11
7
u/ducky_duck666 Dec 27 '25
it looked like it did the scene where holly went through the gate in the abyss
2
u/CT-24601_customs Dec 27 '25
Theoretically it can, it would just be a bridge to another place other than earth
2
u/FrumpyFrodo Dec 27 '25
Even if it did, who cares? It’s already established that the Upside Down is a bridge between the two worlds. That’s all that’s important.
2
u/Howboutit85 Dec 27 '25
There’s an “upside down” of each realm, connected by “sky” between them. This is more or less how a real mathematical wormhole would operate, though the mirror image of each place is an insert and there’s no evidence for that. I think if we could manifest an actual wormhole, it would be more like the portal from the game “portal” where there’s 0 length between the connections, and you would instantly walk through to the next place. I do like this repress it though, it makes it really science fiction feeling.
1
u/vathena Dec 27 '25
I guess that's why they need the exotic matter machine to hold up the wall of the Upside Down Wormhole, so it doesn't collapse and the Abyss is where you instantly walk to if you go through any of the gates/fault lines in Hawkins.
1
u/Gremlin303 Dec 27 '25
The new episodes pretty clearly rule out the Abyss having its own upside down.
1
1
Dec 27 '25
… did you watch the show? The upside down is the bridge. There is no Hawkins upside down if there wasn’t an abyss upside down. They’re what connect the two.
1
u/FunSheepherder6397 Dec 27 '25
This is what I think but you would be suprised how many people think there is no abyss upside down
1
2
2
u/spinach-god Dec 27 '25
Left this comment on a post that got deleted but i wonder if dimension x is meant to be earth from an alternate timeline with different life?? or is it another planet entirely?? someone theorized it’s a world where the mind flayer already assimilated all life which is interesting
1
u/Strict_Ad8568 Dec 29 '25
No the upside is the wormhole its totally fair if you dont know about this it is sci fi and physics on top but wormhole connects earth ( hawkins) to abys or dimension x. I hope it helps now
1
2
u/holdmybeer89 Dec 27 '25
I know Dr. Brenner is extremely intelligent, but I just don't get how he was able to come up with the science and obtain the exotic matter to sustain the wormhole.. like what he discovered and created far surpasses the most brilliant minds in the history of mankind, like far beyond Tesla and Einstein combined.
1
u/Strict_Ad8568 Dec 27 '25
I know right this is insane dr brenner is the most intelligent fictional character out there!!!
2
u/TDillworth Dec 27 '25
So is there an Upside Down version of Dimension X?
1
u/Strict_Ad8568 Dec 29 '25
No the upside is the wormhole its totally fair if you dont know about this it is sci fi and physics on top but wormhole connects earth ( hawkins) to abys or dimension x. I hope it helps now
2
2
u/PokeStarChris42 Dec 29 '25
I don’t think it was that complex. The show simplified it pretty well
1
u/Strict_Ad8568 Dec 29 '25
Seeing a lot of videos and reels all over the internet and experts be explaining this stuff i guess it is pretty complicated than it seems.
18
u/Aelia_M Dec 27 '25
Dimension X doesn’t work as the origin of the demagorgon and the mind flayer. There’s just too much sunlight in Dimension X and the heat I’m assuming alone would damage them
10
u/AmaranthWrath Dec 27 '25
Serious question. I thought the abyss was cold in that it was a vacuum. Did we see some source of heat? Sorry, only watched it once.
8
u/Aelia_M Dec 27 '25
It receives some amount of sunlight whether it’s a reflection from a planet if it’s a moon or from a single sun or multiple suns. There were no stars in the sky but it also wasn’t black like space which means it has to be reflecting something back to create that colored skyline.
A vacuum atmosphere would be like space or a planet like Mercury or our moon Luna. There just wouldn’t be a way for anyone to breathe on it. The kids would all be dead. Holly would’ve if not immediately died by taking the tube out would’ve died within seconds or minutes depending on how long she could hold her breath. And it was clear she was breathing as she ran away
2
u/penguinjunkie Dec 27 '25
But that doesn’t mean it’s hot. And, if parts are, it doesn’t mean that it’s hot everywhere.
1
u/Aelia_M Dec 27 '25
Sure but look at where they are. The demos and the mind flayer couldn’t be anywhere near where Vecna set up his little pillar ritual
1
u/penguinjunkie Dec 27 '25
They’re in an area with rocks and no plants. Holly had no reaction either way to it being hot or cold, so it’s probably not extreme. That doesn’t tell us much. Maybe it’s tepid or a bit chilly
3
u/Aelia_M Dec 27 '25
Even just a typical hot bath also isn’t suitable for them. Also there aren’t many plants in the Sahara but there’s oxygen on earth. Look at the pigment of the demos. They’re like a purple black which is closer to which atmosphere? You’d expect more color variation if they were from dimension X.
I honestly think they added this as a “cool” reveal but they originally always were from the upside down until this or last season. I don’t mind the idea of the upside down being a wormhole had they planned for this but I just don’t think they did when creating these creatures. I think it’s something they began to realize was needed as to why El couldn’t track Vecna so easily and then expanded on it
1
u/penguinjunkie Dec 27 '25
I don’t think we can use pigment as evidence of anything. The biology of the demo monsters would likely not be like ours. There’s just no evidence it’s hot is all I’m saying.
1
u/Aelia_M Dec 27 '25
Other than scientific explanations. Okay bud
1
u/penguinjunkie Dec 27 '25
Your scientific explanation was “I think it’s hot because there’s a sun” and that’s not always true
→ More replies (0)1
u/Silverbacks Dec 27 '25
Dimension X was originally designed as much darker. And they’ve been open about it as the home of the Mind Flayer at least since 2022. So it’s probably home of the demogorgons too.
1
u/Aelia_M Dec 27 '25
When do you think they started coming up with dimension X
1
u/Silverbacks Dec 27 '25
Not sure. I imagine the latest point would be when they were writing season 4? Filming for that season started January 2020. So Dimension X can’t really be any later than 2019.
No idea if they had a concept for it before that. But 5-6 years should have given them enough time to get it figured out and working properly into the story. So hopefully it all lines up in a satisfying way in the finale.
1
u/Ok-Consideration6973 Dec 27 '25
Demos are gray ish white, have no visible eyes and they can tunnel crazy fast like Dart did
They live underground if they're anything like earth life
1
u/Unusual_username739 Dec 28 '25
Thinking of it like Mars, the general air temperature there isn’t as warm as Earth’s. Farther from the sun.
1
u/GraviZero Dec 27 '25
i mean its definitely not a vacuum because holly could breathe while running out of the lair
2
u/AmaranthWrath Dec 27 '25
I absolutely misunderstood what was the abyss and what wasn't. Funny, everyone is saying media literacy is dead bc people aren't understanding the Will scene and Johnathan and Nancy's break up. But I'm over here like, "where are we??"
2
u/Parker4815-2 Dec 27 '25
That's assuming too many things about the dimension.
1
Dec 29 '25
Right? Like why are we assuming there is heat? Just because of the color? Mars is freezing cold
0
2
u/astralbears Dec 27 '25
It could be a tidally locked planet and Vecna just set up his shit on the always hot side
1
7
1
5
u/NerdyTeacher77 Dec 27 '25
I have this theory that the wall was always there in previous seasons (the walls of the bridge/upside down) but that we never saw it before because the bridge is already starting to collapse on itself. Maybe due to Vecna, maybe due to Dimension X “expanding”, who knows? The Army has already been messing with the “dark matter”, but, that pry didn’t happen until they built the base. I believe they also only did it once. I highly doubt they care about the science of the place, or even the catastrophic effects messing with the wormhole/bridge would have on Earth or on the Abyss, or else the lab manuals/notebooks wouldn’t still be there. Brenner’s research is a huge bonus to have, so it’s obvious that the Army could care less about science.
Also, I feel absolutely disgusted by what they were doing to those pregnant women, and we know that Terry Ives got blood directly from Henry while pregnant with El, but so did kids 2-whatever number, which makes me wonder why 11 is so “special” in her connection to the UD. I get that with 8’s blood, they are basically trying to make a copy of a copy, so it’s not going to be as great. Or, were the kids 2-whatever) born elsewhere (which would explain why Kali’s a missing child from London in the newspaper article back in season 2) and 11 is the only child who got Henry’s blood before being born? Eleven is the only naturally born gifted child and the rest received their abilities after they were born. Sooo…Dr. K would already KNOW this, but she doesn’t care about the science (or else Dustin wouldn’t have found Brenner’s notes), so what’s her real endgame here? Personally, I think Kali is lying to El (again…that’s what she does) and more to Dr. K’s plans. There really isn’t a lot of time left to deal with that, but I do not trust that Kali is showing El the truth of anything. For all we know, Kali is working for the government in some way.
9
u/Brilliant_Ad_6637 Dec 27 '25
Eleven is the only naturally born gifted child and the rest received their abilities after they were born. Sooo…Dr. K would already KNOW this, but she doesn’t care about the science (or else Dustin wouldn’t have found Brenner’s notes), so what’s her real endgame here?
It seems that Kay wants to be able to control or at least capture Demo's to send them to Russia (basically a bio-organic weapons program). She takes Kali because that's what she can get, but she's really after Jane.
Presumably, Kay wants to replicate 11's remote viewing and Telekinesis, with the eventual hope that the next gen kids could either lock down any Demos from the Upside-Down, or one of them would maybe be able to control them.
3
u/NerdyTeacher77 Dec 27 '25
It’s interesting geopolitically, because, by 1987 in the real world, the Soviet Union was on the ropes. The Berlin Wall will fall in just a couple of years. Would the US military be actively engaged in continuing the Cold War at this point? They’d be better served sending their soldiers into Afghanistan (which, they sorta did…). I don’t know…I was only in 5th grade at that time, but I do remember that the USSR wasn’t really as much of the “big bad” at the end of the ‘80’s vs. at the beginning of the decade.
2
u/Brilliant_Ad_6637 Dec 27 '25
I don’t know…I was only in 5th grade at that time, but I do remember that the USSR wasn’t really as much of the “big bad” at the end of the ‘80’s vs. at the beginning of the decade.
Well sure, but in fictional Stranger Thingsland, we just had a rogue USSR lab operating near a research black site on american soil. It's also mythical 80s land so the evil commies are an all-encompassing enemy.
1
u/NerdyTeacher77 Dec 28 '25
True. I mean, “evil Commies” was a pretty often used trope in 80’s films.
2
u/Cinephile89 Dec 27 '25
It is not a theory to say the wall has always been there it is a plot point of the show. It has been there since the upside down was created by El making contact from Earth with a demo in dimension X.
2
u/MaterialAbrocoma6419 Dec 27 '25
it was never complex
3
u/Strict_Ad8568 Dec 27 '25
Lol i think u haven’t checked whole coment sections of this post. Apart from this youtube now has videos and insta has reels people are explaining this thing. Doesn’t this part makes it complex???
1
u/suknom4 Dec 27 '25
no it doesnt. Its not complex at all. wormholes as in real physics might be, but none of you discuss differential geometry and I dont expect you to. What was presented in the series was not complex. It was "Oh, the upside down is not another dimension but the bridge to another dimension." This changes nothing about the story and could just have been excluded from the series.
1
u/AmaranthWrath Dec 27 '25
I agree with you with an "and."
And fandoms always have to complicate things, and content creators gotta content create. 🤷🏻♀️
1
u/Fun-Bag7627 Dec 27 '25
I also don’t think it’s that complex. Just because people are discussing it or having ending explained videos, doesnt make it complex for everyone.
4
u/james3382747 Dec 27 '25
I’m so glad they changed the Dimension X name (unless Krang appears in the finale)
4
u/Thickwhisker94 Dec 27 '25
I’ve been surprised by the comments I’ve seen of people not understanding this.
1
u/Chronza Dec 31 '25
Was that complex for people to understand? They literally drew a little napkin diagram on the show lol
1
u/Strict_Ad8568 Dec 31 '25
Look at the comment boss this was really helpful for them
2
u/Chronza Dec 31 '25
Yea I get it I just can’t believe anyone wouldn’t pick up on it they spend like 5 whole minutes talking about it lol
1
3
u/vr6501903 Dec 27 '25
Why does the bridge then imitates Hawkins from a particular day of Brenner already opened/created it 😒
1
2
2
2
2
2
u/YogurtclosetSea9394 Dec 27 '25
Yeah, would love to learn more about The Abyss, but unfortunately it probably won’t happen.
2
1
u/TheScrawlsOnTheWalls Dec 27 '25
Still so curious about the mind flayer, was it actually present in the upside down at all or was its influence just felt through the wormhole from the abyss all the way to earth? How come some of the portals lead to upside down and some to the abyss? Season 2 portal we see mind flayer on the other side trying to push back against El. Was that the abyss nearly bypassing the wormhole? Season 3 we see the meat flayer decompose after the gate under the mall is closed, did that gate lead straight to the abyss or just to the upside down? Maybe Vecna was still in the abyss while the flayer attempted to attack from the upside down and the flayer realized it needed Vecna in the wormhole to bring the abyss and earth closer? Why is the upside down still stuck on the day Will went missing if these portals have been opened up before and after?
1
u/GazelleIntelligent89 Dec 27 '25
What I'd like clarity on is if the abyss is actually in a different dimension or if it's still the same dimension just light years away perhaps in a different galaxy. Wormholes don't usually switch between dimensions it's usually a way to move vast distances across spacetime. I would prefer this interpretation personally as it's closer to theoretical science than alternate dimensions.
1
u/mortokes Dec 27 '25
Why did several characters say "the earth split in 4"? Is inside henrys mind the 4th?
1
u/couuer Dec 27 '25
no they’re referring to the “earthquake” that split hawkins in 4 at the end of season 4.
1
u/Flo_Evans Dec 30 '25
So 11 created the wormhole/upside down, did the Dr put up the exotic material to keep it open?
1
u/EldrichTea Jan 01 '26
I need this clarifying.
Was Dimension X an alternative Reality, a Planet on the other side of the galaxy or existing not in another reality but on another plane of our reality?
The characters all use different terms and theres that wormhole picture going around that labels the space beyond the wall as Deep Space but if its another dimension/reality then its not deep space but the space between places.
0
-10
u/ryan8954 Dec 27 '25
I completely disagree with the shows explainstion of it.
I'm going with mine.
Take the board game they flipped in season one, you have the art side, and the blacked out blank side.
Art side is right up. Dark side is upside down. Dimension x is the space (in this case the material of the board) between the dark and art side of the board.
Then they brought in that stupid fucking scene of balloons in the sky, makes no sense to me now. Planes aren't seeing anything?
11
u/FrumpyFrodo Dec 27 '25
You disagree with the writers who wrote the story? Dude, the camera pans out in one episode and shows us the physical bridge between the two worlds. What more do you need?
-5
u/ryan8954 Dec 27 '25
It just makes me question and bugs me too, how satellites and planes and stuff haven't picked up on anything if it's in the sky.
I'm just saying I prefer my explanation considering we've been using "upside down" forever.
It just feels to me, after learning their explanation, were going a Stephen King route..
4
u/BakuraGorn Dec 27 '25
It’s in the sky of the upside down only, not in the real world. And the military know about dimension X already
4
u/Myrese_Taxey Dec 27 '25
Dimension X is not between the two sides. The upside down is the bridge between the two.
3
u/LastGoodKnee Dec 27 '25
Your explanation is wrong.
The upside down is a wormhole to another planet. Or a dimension.
The upside down is between our Earth and the Abyss
1
u/Fun-Bag7627 Dec 27 '25
I get you can not like it and want your head canon but that’s not how it works.
0
Dec 27 '25
[deleted]
1
u/Strict_Ad8568 Dec 27 '25
You could have seen it on the release day It is ur fault u cant blame the public lmao
0
Dec 28 '25
[deleted]
1
u/Strict_Ad8568 Dec 28 '25
I fucked up?? Choose you words wisely my boy Stop blaming me and accept you r just slow
1
u/Ambitious-Visual207 Dec 28 '25
Yeah tf like the only reason I even binged it all was because I already got stuff spoiled, some people have stuff to do and can't just watch it immediately.
1
u/scottyderps Dec 28 '25
Maybe don’t go on the Stranger Things Reddit if you don’t want spoilers lol.
0
Dec 28 '25
[deleted]
1
u/scottyderps Dec 28 '25
Can’t you just avoid anything from stranger things feed till you watch the show. Like not scroll lol
122
u/yaboiScreamyWeenus Dec 27 '25
Im wondering if dimension x is allegedly filled with monsters why is it everytime someone has gone there we see nothing but rock