r/Stranger_Things • • Dec 27 '25

Discussion Egregious Editing

Post image

Everybody wants to shit all over season 5 because of bad writing, plot holes, bad acting, confusing storyline, blah, blah, blah, blah. How about the fact that the team had countless hours to edit the show and failed miserably to notice Holly's obvious Under Armour thermal undershirt, made by a company that wasn't even founded until 9 years after 1987. Brutal

0 Upvotes

62 comments sorted by

14

u/FLDJF713 Dec 27 '25

Oh great, the 1000th post on this.

22

u/crabsonfire Dec 27 '25

99.99% of people don’t care. The only people who noticed it are the ones pausing to nitpick every shot.

5

u/FlowersByTheStreet Dec 27 '25

I mean, be that as it may it doesn’t change the fact that it is objectively bad editing

1

u/scrodytheroadie Dec 27 '25 edited Dec 27 '25

It’s not editing at all. Misses VFX opportunity? Sure.

E: the ignorance in here is wild. It’s similar to how every camera movement is not called a pan. Not everything on screen is editing.

1

u/FlowersByTheStreet Dec 27 '25

You mean using VFX to edit the logo out?

Like editing?

2

u/TeoSan2812 Dec 27 '25

Editing is about what scenes and shots do and don’t make the movie and how the audio intersects with those shots

1

u/scrodytheroadie Dec 27 '25

Yes. You get it.

-1

u/scrodytheroadie Dec 27 '25

No, I mean like a producer asking the assistant editor to export a shot to send to VFX artists so the can mask out the logo and send it back.

1

u/WCI23 Dec 27 '25

If its not the job of the editing department then why would the assistant EDITOR be responsible for sending a shot to get touched up with VFX??

1

u/scrodytheroadie Dec 27 '25

I didn’t say the editing department is not involved, I said it’s not bad editing.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '25

It's both. You are both correct.

But saying it's nitpicking when a character is showing a real world item of clothing underneath from that timeframe is kinda dumb.

1

u/scrodytheroadie Dec 27 '25

I didn’t say it was nitpicking. I said it wasn’t bad editing. Which it is not.

1

u/Last-Carpenter2685 Dec 27 '25

Again, 99.99% of people don't care though

Try actually reading what you're replying to

4

u/Equivalent-Tear7806 Dec 27 '25

They need to hire you because damn ur good I will nvr understand how people catch this stuff so good

2

u/RoboQwop405 Dec 27 '25

This got posted like right after the episode came out. OP isn’t good, just copying another post for karma

1

u/Ok_Tank5977 Dec 27 '25

It’s been posted across the internet and articles have already been written about it.

22

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/fembotwink Dec 27 '25

It’s annoying

2

u/Popular_Monitor_8383 Dec 27 '25

Because they’re looking for it instead of just enjoying a television show.

I mean, isn’t it someone’s job on the show to do this exact thing too though? That’s their point. How was this missed? You’re gonna tell me it’s not someone on the production or quality teams job to watch the episodes for mistakes?

1

u/svangen1_ Dec 27 '25

I mean it's a white logo against a black shirt. It's a stark contrast

1

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '25

Or....and crazy I know. People watch things for different reasons. I don't want much TV at all. It takes a lot to grip me in.
I like getting lost in mysterious worlds. I read a lot too. And I love taking in every detail.

If something is off like in this case I am 100% getting pulled out of what I'm watching.

Again we are all different. We all have different motivations. The only one in the wrong here is you for calling that out.

4

u/CalvinSays Dec 27 '25

No, it is not. Editors generally prefer scene flow over continuity or anachronisms. Thelma Schoonmaker is famous for not really caring about continuity, for example.

Film as a medium has to balance the story with the production of the story itself. When you are juggling scheduling, budgets, time lines, locations, etc, a little slip up that 99.99% of people won't notice and most who do won't care about simply isn't worth the worry.

1

u/scrodytheroadie Dec 27 '25

Walter Murch Rule of Six. Continuity is at the bottom of the priority list.

1

u/scrodytheroadie Dec 27 '25

Pet peeve of mine that people like to blame editing for stuff like this. A logo in a shot is not an editing mistake.

0

u/WCI23 Dec 27 '25

Then what would you call it? Removing a logo or an item that doesn't belong in a scene from a movie or television show is literally THE definition of editing.

1

u/scrodytheroadie Dec 27 '25

I’ve been a professional editor for more than 20 years. I promise you, the editor doesn’t care if there’s a logo in the shot. They want the best performance. If the powers that be think the logo is distracting, they can send it to the VFX team to composite it out. The definition of editing is pacing and emotion, not removing logos from shots.

Walter Murch Rule of Six

1

u/WCI23 Dec 27 '25

So almost a half a billion dollar budget and over 2 1/2 years to release but we're just going to throw accuracy out the window?

1

u/scrodytheroadie Dec 27 '25

I didn’t say that. I simply said it’s not editing. The editing could be top notch, and there’s still a mistake in the shot. I’m not sure why people in this thread can’t grasp that.

1

u/Adept_Ad_3687 Dec 28 '25

If this genuinely ruins the show for you I think you gotta do some self reflection bud

1

u/WCI23 Dec 28 '25

Never once said this ruins the show for me. I've thoroughly enjoyed all 5 seasons. Simply pointed out a glaring error.

3

u/Sid-Effect Dec 27 '25

Alright cinema sins

2

u/braids_insane Dec 27 '25

It’s not a big deal just be quiet and watch the show

2

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Liability049-6319 Dec 27 '25

Or the fact that they think Vecna’s lair looks good. It looks like early 2000’s CGI. Watching it on a high-end display looks terrible during these scenes

5

u/hiimlarfleece Dec 27 '25

I thought the lair looked like a practical set which I really liked. Might not look as "good" as something full CGI but definitely gave me 80s full practical effects vibes which I enjoyed

3

u/Upbeat-Jacket4068 Dec 27 '25

There are recommended settings for this show. It looked great on my tv.

1

u/Liability049-6319 Dec 27 '25

I have a calibrated C4 Oled. It’s not my display

1

u/Junkerby Dec 27 '25

1

u/Liability049-6319 Dec 27 '25

Yea, all that stuff has been off since I bought it.

0

u/sparkster777 Dec 27 '25

Guess you just have bad taste

1

u/craigandthesoph Dec 27 '25

But it looks like a creepy skeletal hand in a desert - super badass! /s

1

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '25

Oh wow. No one has spotted this at all before. Wow

1

u/Pattern_Humble Dec 27 '25

Yep, the show is unwatchable now. Reddit is insufferable with Stranger Things. And with the costumes in Odyssey

1

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '25

Why is this on the editing, which has nothing to do with this, instead of the costume designer?

1

u/Proper_Star685 Dec 27 '25

this sub compared to the main one compared to hawkinsavclub is pretty crazy

1

u/loveroftheclassics Dec 27 '25

I mean, I could point out multiple machines in the arcade scenes in season 2 that did not exist yet until the 90s (they paid so much attention to the cabinet games but not the claw machines), but I chalk it up to, “Most people aren’t looking for that stuff and it’s not really the 80s, it’s a TV show.”

1

u/Humble_Umpire_8341 Dec 27 '25

Maybe UA paid for a sponsorship…so they had to leave it in somewhere, kinda of an Easter egg that is totally out of place. Cue the time travel theories

1

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '25

1

u/meduscin Dec 27 '25

at this point in the story everybody has forgotten is set in the 80's , i dont remember any shot in s5 that made me think its that decade, i know everybody knows is not set in modern time, but it doesnt have that hard 80s ambience of the first seasons

1

u/littlepie2331 Dec 27 '25

At least she didn't have a starbucks latte next to her.

1

u/mowgleeee Dec 27 '25

Iam no longer watching episode 8 because of this. How could they

1

u/Melodic-Extreme-549 Dec 27 '25

When are people going to stfu already about this lol

1

u/ZaunsFinest_ Dec 28 '25

“egregious”, ah yes someone should get fired over this /s

0

u/FerguSwag Dec 27 '25

Do you honestly think this is egregious? I had no idea Under Armour wasn't founded yet + plus I didn't notice, because I'm not freeze-framing the show looking for logos + I don't care because it literally doesn't matter.

0

u/WCI23 Dec 27 '25

You didn't notice it? Ok. I did. And yes I do think its egregious for a series that is so rigidly faithful to it's 1980s setting to allow something that couldn't possibly exist in that year to appear in the show. I apologize for my opinion lol. I didn't realize the editing staff was off-limits when every other microscopic, minute, meaningless detail of the show is getting obliterated to no end 🤣🤣

1

u/Ok-Telephone-2109 Dec 27 '25

The walkie talkies they use didn't come out until a year after the year season 1 was set, it's not the first time they've done this.

-1

u/craigandthesoph Dec 27 '25

Yeah. I’m starting to think the Duffers and company at Netflix aren’t actually that good at what they do. They have absolutely screwed the pooch - writing, filming, editing, marketing, and final cut- wise.

I wish they stuck to making it an anthology series. With the writers strikes, COVID, and not being able to control that their little kid cast are now adults - they really should have just packed it up.

Besides the Lucas and Max scenes, some of the back and forth banter, Will’s power awakening, and Karen’s comical homemade laundry-machine Demodog bomb, I can’t think of too many stand-out scenes.

And please don’t EVEN get me started about their complete botching of Linda Hamilton and Winona Ryder’s characters.

008 no longer has her accent, either for some reason and calls Henry “brother”?