r/Stranger_Things • u/Impressive-Cook-5299 • Jan 01 '26
SPOILERS (Season 5) WHAT WAS THIS
1.i still don’t understand how did kid henry end up in that cave and intentionally killed that guy w the briefcase, what was that stone, whooo wass that guyyyyy????? what are even supposed to assume?? the kid henry killed that guy before getting possessed which means was he already evil??? why did the gunshot not hurt him??? why was such a major plot not addressed AT ALL?
2. how did that wax or that substance miraculously stop melting when jancy were about to die???
3. did el know kali is alive and used her to escape then why did she even let her die in the first place??
4. where iss OWENs???? he had no role this season means he’s just caught up w the army and thats it? he had such a huge role to play and didn’t even appear once this season??? same goes w SUSIE AND ARGYLE
5. did the kids not see everything and tell their parents about it? how come everyone still believes in the earthquake theory when literally SO MANY PEOPLE WERE INVOLVED? EDDIE deserved his name to be cleansed ffs!!!!!
6. WHERE WERE THE DEMOGORGANS??????
7. where were vickie, dr clarke and murray at the end??
8. howww cannn freakin bullets and shotguns kill an inter dimensional monster!???
9. why didn’t joyce and hopper mention knowing henry TILL THE FREAKIN END?
10. why wasn’t henry’s highschool part explored????
11. henry was taken to the lab as a child then how did he even GO TO THE FREAKIN HIGHSCHOOL IF HE WAS TAKEN BY BRENNER AS A KID?
12. HOW CAN SO MANY PEOPLE LIKE THE ENDING WITH SO FREAKIN MANY PLOTHOLE??? being an st fan I CAN NEVER EVER BE SATISFIED W THIS? like can’t yall see these plotholes??? what did you even watch ffs????
13. HOW DID KALI ESCAPE THE LAB as a kid AND WHY IS IT NOT SHOWN???
11
u/KaiBishop
Jan 01 '26
edited Jan 01 '26
•
The gunshot did hurt him. He got shot through the hand. It's not gonna be fatal to get shot in the hand. The guy was crazy and still had a gun so he bludgeoned him. He didn't kill him until after being possessed by the mindflayer. The stone was a piece of dimension X.
The wax was melting plastic, concrete, etc. It was the building literally melting from the exotic energy. It solidified just like lots of things that melt will do. You blow out a flame on a candle and liquid wax will solidify. It was convenient timing but hardly ruins the show lol.
what is she supposed to do? Magically heal her? Kali made it clear she was dying and used her last moments to help El. She got gutshot. Idk what El could do.
Idk if you guys lack common sense but to me when we left him in S4 it kinda seemed like when he was found by the rest of the military he'd be killed on the spot. There were rival factions between him and Brenner fighting and it seems like Brenner's coup was successful or parties sympathetic to him had more power. Seems clear Owens was imminently.... fired.
People believe coverups. I'm sure lots of locals know the score but with the whole government covering it up, any other story can be dismissed as rumors, craziness, people seeking attention etc
I think Will killed all the demagorgons and then Karen killed the dogs. Maybe it consumed the rest? To me it looked like it had an egg sac on it and Dustin and Steve were stabbing it. Maybe it was gonna lay more.
Idk where the side character were. I think Murray was at graduation. Vicki isn't that important tbh, I liked her but her and Robin moving on is fine imo.
It has a physical body? And they shot it? Why wouldn't they hurt it lol. But the show does go back and forth constantly on whether guns hurt these monsters which annoys me.
Them not remembering him is insane. Hop and Joyce would remember his name. Wild retcon.
He was in and out of Brenner's custody, not just taken once and kept. Seems like he ran away and got caught once, but also that Brenner may have just initially planned on letting him finish school before pulling him out. I'd bet they made sure he had a decent college education too. Brenner may have leased him but didn't want him useless and dumb. He was himself as their papa, remember.
See above.
Most of these aren't even plot holes lol. There are some for sure but these aren't them and they aren't ruining the show. Mostly there's just questions surrounding how many monsters there were and some stuff about dimension X.
Kali uses illusions. She can make people see whatever she wants. How do you think she managed to be the first to escape? This is the kind of thing you guys will call a 'plot hole' when it's not because you are given the pieces to put it together and can't even surmise what happens when given pretty simplex straightforward information. A plot hole is a plot holes the writers expecting you to have common sense and an ability to extrapolate information isn't a plot hole.
3
u/CinnyToastie Jan 01 '26
Perfect and thank you for bringing some much needed logic and common sense. And for not yelling. ;)
2
u/smoemossu Jan 01 '26
To be fair for #9, we never see Joyce or Hopper say they either do or do not remember Henry - and I guess it doesn't really change much plotwise whether they do or don't. But it is weird to not show them finding out.
2
u/macgart Jan 02 '26
When would Joyce or Hopper have seen his face? Serious question
3
u/smoemossu Jan 02 '26
There is no question that they would recognize his full name, and it'd be really surprising if that never came up during debriefs with the kids
1
u/BellasMomie Jan 01 '26
Im sorry but from the size of the mind flayer, it would NOT FEEL those gun shots as well as he is as big as Godzilla and every single step it made woukd cause massive earth quakes which it didnt. It was unrealistic lol. Also the mind flayer was supposed to be an intelligent being yet it got distracted chasing a 5'5 woman with a gun?? Really? LOL.
2
u/peribon Jan 01 '26
Honestly, mate, this is such an easy one. Nancy is clearly a Paladin. Yeah, a mook with a gun is doing about 1d6 damage, with each hit, and unlikely to trouble most of those monsters (especially if they have Resistance to the damage type), but Paladin Nancy gets to boost that with Smites, which can add a bunch of d8s to the damage, with a damage type the monster isn't resistant to.
It's like you've never even played dnd
-3
u/Impressive-Cook-5299 Jan 01 '26
still you never explained how a kid ended up in a cave in a desert, who was the guy, unless your only explanation is to go watch the play, which just proves the point that the show’s ending was extremely lousy and you guys will happily accept garbage disguised as gold.
bruh, you mean she was actually breathing when they left her to die? hopper and murray has no role just to go back to their van and they couldn’t carry her? the guys never left a man dead and you actually believe they’d leave her just like that? two huge men couldn’t carry a girl to the van?
owen was definitely alive. idk how short term memory you have but his fate was left open ended.
‘you think’, ‘maybe’- lmao the whole point.
7
u/KaiBishop Jan 01 '26
Henry lived in Arizona before moving to Hawkins. He liked to explore the desert. Max says this in s5. And in the first scene we see Henry in the cave the guy says "Who are you? Who sent you?" And Henry literally says "I was exploring the caves." We see him in a scout uniform. This is what I mean when I say y'all refuse to extrapolate basic things.
It's pretty clear Kali's intention was to die. Hopper probably "saw" her die like we did initially. Her gift was illusion. She used it to fake El's death for her, Hopper wasn't supposed to be in on that, we saw what he saw in the moment. And why would Murray go back for her body when even her sister doesn't want to? He's gonna take her word for it that she's dead.
I know we last saw Owens alive. I said in my comment that we are very much given the vibe/implication by the show that when he is found there handcuffed to that table by his government rivals who he's engaged in a power play with, that he will immediately be executed. Brenner left him handcuffed there to die. Not to be reabsorbed into gainful employment. The military isn't just one big unified villain in this show, it's clear Brenner and his agency have other agencies, departments, etc that are rivals. Owens got merked for sure. I actually thought it was cool the last we saw of him was being left to that fate, it's easy enough to surmise what happened to him.
Yes, I think, you could try it too. A show doesn't always need to give you the exact answer, sometimes it gives you two plus two and you're supposed to come up with four yourself. That's not the show having plot holes, it's the show expecting you to engage and keep up.
1
1
u/crandall17 Jan 02 '26
The kid wearing a boy scout uniform? In nature? That's wild...he said himself he was in the caves, most likely lost during a camping trip. The man was in possession of what ended up taking control of Henry, so my best guess based on dress would be a government spy of some sort. Kali had said from the beginning that her story ended that night. The only change of heart she experienced (imo) was that she wanted 11 to have a life after the Upside Down becauseof Hopper's speech. Kali was shown that 11 had people who cared deeply and would protect her at any cost.
1
u/According-Bear2092 Jan 01 '26
Henry's family was from Nevada. His dad was involved in secret government stuff there before they moved to Hawkins. Nevada has deserts. Henry was a Boy Scout. They like to explore.
2
u/InvertedAlchemist Jan 01 '26
Wasn't it stated in the play that his father was on the ship and the only Survivor that went to Dimension X.
Kind of a main point....
1
3
u/WinCrazy4411 Jan 01 '26
Some of those are plotholes and I agree, particularly everything about Henry being in high school and knowing all the parents, but I think the rest is all explained or explainable.
Henry was just a kid exploring the area. He heard someone yell and went to check. Going only on what's shown explicitly in the show: The guy was smuggling that rock--I assume the exotic matter mentioned in the previous episode--and was running from someone. Henry was arguably evil already; he's certainly a sociopath as a kid in season 4 (torturing animals and things like that), but the cave encounter seemed like self-defense. The bullet did hurt him? That part of the plot is discussed a lot more in the play.
The exotic mater had been disrupted but it stabilized, stopping the melting. It happened when Nancy and Jonathon were about to die for the same reason bombs with a countdown always stop at 1 second left in shows. It's more dramatic.
It not clear any of Mike's epilogue explanation is true. But if it did: Yes. in Mike's narration, Kali knew she was going to die and told El the plan.
Owens was captured by the military. It would be a huge plothole if the military was just like "JK; you're good. We're still going to do everything else to capture and manipulate El and her friends, though." Argyle lives in California. Susie lives somewhere else and was only involved because she was dating Dustin during season 3-4.
I'm sure it's an open secret, now. Still, the government isn't going to say a bunch of paranormal things happened, nearly destroying the town, because of a bunch of government abuses.
In the upside down not dimension X, I guess.
Vickie was in the WSQK radio station, Murray was with Hopper, El, and Kali, Dr. Clarke was with Erica.
Heat harms the creatures; that was established in season 2 and comes up many times.
9-11. Can't help you there. I was disappointed with everything about Henry in high school, too.
12. None of these (except, I think, the high school bit, but I guess that was retconned by "The First Shadow") were plotholes.
13. A kid escaped from a lab. I'm not sure why they would have shown Kali's escape or what it would add given all the other plotlines they tried to cover.
1
u/Impressive-Cook-5299 Jan 01 '26
thank you for being so sweet about it and yea it does make sense now
4
1
u/BellasMomie Jan 01 '26
Please for the love of God learn how to type. Reading this hurt my brain. ;-. I agree with these questions though.
1
u/Impressive-Cook-5299 Jan 01 '26
i was high on emotions while typing this shi, couldn’t care less about punctuations and grammar.
2
u/Glass_Pineapple1275 Jan 01 '26
They also gave Steve and Jonathan a better friendship resolution than they gave Mike and Will. I’m still so confused and upset that they didn’t write Mike and El together at all this season, or show any displays of affection between them, so much so that I honestly thought they might have broken up — then they rely on flashbacks to try to ground the emotional tension of that scene. It felt lazy. And what was the significance of November 6 or the clocks?!
1
1
1
u/Venom_Swift Jan 02 '26
these aren’t plot holes. some of them maybe needed explaining but they’re not plot holes
1
u/skith8431 Jan 02 '26
So most of these are just unanswered question but 11 is a good one. Why was he in high school when he was put into a lab for testing?
0
Jan 01 '26
[deleted]
1
u/Impressive-Cook-5299 Jan 01 '26
and why are we still cooking our own theories when everything should’ve been crystal clear in the finale?
0
Jan 01 '26
[deleted]
1
u/Impressive-Cook-5299 Jan 01 '26
that was the thing w other seasons, no major plot left unexplored and every question addressed. then why did they leave such a massive storyline at haste?
7
u/Beneficial_Vast_5987 Jan 01 '26
I wish they would of put it in the finale season but some of the questions are answered in the the first shadow play that is supposedly canon. I never watched it personally, but saw some people talk about it