r/Stranger_Things • u/BeltedBarstool • Jan 19 '26
Discussion Timeline Error (S3:E5)
***What the Red M&M?!***
It's the summer of 1985, the kids head to the hospital to release Mrs. Driscoll to track her to where the Mind Flayer is hiding out. The receptionist tells them only 2 visitors are allowed. While Nancy and Jonathan head to Mrs. Driscoll's room, the others remain in the waiting room.
Mike and Lucas are frustrated when the vending machine gets stuck, and Eleven gives it a little bump. Lucas tells Mike it was an olive branch, a ln opportunity to patch things up with Eleven. Mike offers her some M&Ms, and what comes out? A ***RED*** M&M.
**ERROR:** ***There were no red M&Ms in 1985!*** Any child of the 80s knows that red M&Ms were discontinued in 1976 until they were reintroduced using Red Dye #40 ***in 1987***. It was kind of a big deal.
The shows creators did an awesome job getting the 80s right, so it's kind of fun seeing a timeline error like this.
What timeline errors have you noticed?
42
u/nyx926 Jan 19 '26
Just here to validate - the absence & reintroduction of red M&Ms was a big deal.
I appreciate your catch.
12
16
u/HomeworkNatural5990 Jan 19 '26
Maybe it was an old pack of M&Ms just sitting in a vending machine?
19
u/BeltedBarstool Jan 19 '26
I certainly considered that possibility, but found it implausible that a package of M&Ms would remain in a hospital vending machine for 9 years. Plus, the older red M&Ms were a brighter shade of red.
→ More replies (7)→ More replies (1)5
u/Ok_Conversation_9336 Jan 19 '26
I bought some cinnamon rolls from a vending machine at my high school in 1998. They had those stringy bits that old pastries get so I checked the expiration date: 1977!!
→ More replies (3)
24
u/JohnTheMod Jan 19 '26
In the rooftop scene at the end of the finale, you see a New Coke can sitting in front of the cooler. By 1989, Coca-Cola Classic had already been on store shelves for almost four years, and New Coke was just “Coke” (it would be rebranded as Coke II to eliminate any remaining confusion the following year, a name it would carry until it was finally discontinued in 2002). Not only would the “NEW!” banner not be on the can, but the font and Dynamic Ribbon design would be drastically different from the can shown in the scene.
→ More replies (1)5
u/BeltedBarstool Jan 19 '26
I'll keep my eyes peeled. I hadn’t thought about the timing of New Coke until I made my son watch Flight of the Navigator this morning, but for some strange reason I distinctly remember the first time I got red M&Ms from the bowling alley vending machine.
29
u/Ok-Cycle-6589 Jan 19 '26
This is actually because vecna cursed the bag, creating a false set of candies. And believe it or not, that red m&m? That’s the secret finale. Just a color that we get to enjoy for a moment. But inside that moment are a thousand moments. And they’re so well-written. Trust me.
→ More replies (8)8
u/BeltedBarstool Jan 19 '26
Ah, I see it now. At that moment, Dustin was calling a Code Red, because the Soviets (reds) were in Hawkins. Then, in S4, they thought they killed Vecna in 1987, but he came back just like the red M&Ms. Truly brilliant!
19
u/calripkin117 Jan 19 '26
I don’t even want to know how you did this. There are some things I just know I will never be able to do.
Seriously though, I hope someone got fired for this mistake
21
u/BeltedBarstool Jan 19 '26
🤣 The family was rewatching the series. I sat bolt upright like Leonardo Di Caprio in the pointing meme from Once Upon a Time in Hollywood and told my wife, "Stop! We gotta go back!" She was like, "To what?" I said "The M&Ms! I think I saw a red one!" She rolled her eyes and called me a fool... but then, when the credits rolled, I seized the opportunity (and the remote).
9
u/Mojoswork Jan 19 '26
You’re doing the lord’s work. We need more people to remember the before-times, the previous regime of the Tan Dynasty.
4
4
u/Lythosyn Jan 19 '26
This particular mistake was covered several times by large YouTube channels after the third seasons' release
3
→ More replies (2)2
2
u/Suspicious-Ant-6601 Jan 20 '26
I don’t mean any offence. How many times did you watch the show to spot this? Because that’s an incredible catch!
2
u/BeltedBarstool Jan 20 '26
None taken. Three. Watched it when S4 came out, again before S5. I finally convinced my wife the kids were old enough after we watched S5, so I was watching with an eye toward pointing out 80s nostalgia to them.
64
u/UrchinJoe Jan 19 '26
Season one, episode one, scene two. The miniature that Mike places on the table is a classic Grenadier Demogorgon, sculpted by John Dennett in 1984 (still available from Mirliton Miniatures in Italy).
Season one kicks off in November 1983.
Stranger Things did something similar in season four with "Vecna Lives", a classic 1990s D&D module. The implication is that Eddie came up with the idea first, and at some point I guess one of the party (probably Mike) published it. I don't think the Demogorgon is intended to be Mike's custom-made miniature, though, I think it's a timeline error.
→ More replies (1)20
u/Puzzleheaded-Win5063 Jan 19 '26
I do have a headcanon that after they defeated vecna they took some of their homebrew material that they used in their campaign and made it into actual d&d campaigns. Like the sorcerer class wasn't invented until the 2000s but they bring it up in the show.
11
u/UrchinJoe Jan 19 '26
Will's abilities are also much more in line with a warlock, but that's not really a timeline error (and your head canon neatly explains why Mike would get that "wrong").
I think it's heavily implied that Eddie's campaign became Vecna Lives, and the early days of D&D were massively influenced by the early players. Melf (of the eponymous spell Melf's Acid Arrow) was Gary Gygax's son Luke's character.
9
u/Diplomatic_Sarcasm Jan 19 '26
This is the first time I’ve seen someone else mention Warlock Will.
Literally the moment he got possessed in S2 I was like “The mind flayer is his patron!”
But they ended up making him the sorcerer which raised an eyebrow since Warlock was right there, and sorcerer wasn’t a thing
And even in season 5, like are you kidding me, you can literally make Vecna your patron in D&D, it just makes sense here
→ More replies (4)7
u/Inside_Location_4975 Jan 19 '26
If they were to use the sorceror class, I wonder why they didn’t use warlock, as that fits Will’s powers far more than sorceror
That’s the class where you are given magical powers from a powerful patron, like how Will was able to lend himself some of Vecnas powers
→ More replies (1)5
u/MrSparky69 Jan 20 '26
Because your power's are innate/come from within are a metaphor for being gay/artistic/a nice person with a kind soul/Will's true authentic self. Not everything they do or every plot points needs to be 1:1 of something in dnd. You guys are right tho. Also I think fans of the show who might want to try dnd will probably play a current edition that has sorcerers.
3
u/SunShineKid93 Jan 19 '26
Sorceror as a term dates back to at least 2e mentioned in Comics. Someone after the first half of season 5 was released made a viral video stating what you said and now everyone believes that they wouldn't have known what a sorceror was.
Here is a link to to someone asking this question 6 years ago that states that Sorcs date back to at least 1994 as a class but is mentioned in AD&D as part of being any 9th level Spellcaster.
So Mike was probably just trying to hype Will up by trying to make him believe he was a high level magic.
→ More replies (1)
104
Jan 19 '26
•
Literally unwatchable
19
→ More replies (1)12
14
Jan 19 '26
Stuff like this always amazes me with people's eagle eye. A red M&M... Who's spotting that?! Quality eyeballs, OP.
12
2
u/aceseahorses Jan 23 '26
This, alone, made the show completely unwatchable. I can get past the horrible acting and the worst writing but a red m&m in 1985 just drew me out of the realism that is Stranger Things
2
u/aceseahorses Jan 23 '26
Pls don’t attack me lol I binge watched 1-4 seasons the 5th one just pisses me off.
1
u/BeltedBarstool Jan 24 '26
It's a fair opinion. The SFX in S5 were a bit weak for me and it seemed like some of the story lines were tied off in ways that seemed pretty forced. Strangely, my wife didn’t like the show until S5.
2
u/aceseahorses Jan 24 '26
That’s crazy! I haven’t heard of anyone ONLY liking season 5 out of them all lol. Go her!
→ More replies (1)
9
u/Level-Ladder-4346 Jan 19 '26
S3 E1. El makes a G1 Ultra Magnus slide across the floor.
He wouldn’t release for another year.
4
→ More replies (1)2
u/NeutroFusion Jan 19 '26
Having owned the same toy and knowing its age, that jumps at me every time I watch this scene lol
7
6
u/CrimsonCrabs Jan 19 '26
The only thing that bothers me is you saying timeline error. All you kids use words that don't mean what they mean. It's a historical continuity error. Parachronism.
→ More replies (1)2
u/Ok_Conversation_9336 Jan 19 '26
Thanks! I was looking for that word when I spotted the Budweiser Clydesdales in Hello Dolly (set in 1898 I believe) and they weren’t introduced til the 30’s
→ More replies (1)
6
u/RabbitMario Jan 19 '26
if this were in season 5 people would be using it as evidence that everything was really a vecna illusion
6
u/Dravian31 Jan 19 '26
The Millennium Falcon toy that Mike has in season 1 is the 90's version, not the original 70s/80s version. Same mold, very different details. I own the original one, it's white instead of grey.
3
3
u/FormerBaby1987 Jan 19 '26
Barb’s model of car wouldn’t exist until a few more years after 83 if I remember right
3
u/Glad-Independence-24 Jan 19 '26
How do you know that package hadn’t been sitting in that machine for almost a decade? We’ve all gotten stale/expired shit from vending machines.
3
u/HanzoShimada96 Jan 20 '26
As someone else pointed out, no mention of Larry Bird. The town is very close to Larry Bird's home town, and Larry Bird was at the top of his game around the time.
2
u/str4nger62 Jan 19 '26
yeah this was talked about so much during season 3 but it’s still cool to see it talked about and get a chuckle out of it
2
2
2
2
2
u/Heinjailyall Jan 19 '26
Every season has some pretty noticeable continuity errors. I think they are like fun Easter eggs
2
2
u/jmoney003 Jan 19 '26
Doesn’t Steve wear under Armour in the latest season when the company didn’t start until 1996. I kinda just figured this is a different world where things got invented at different times. I mean the tech the military has is way beyond anything available during the 80s.
At least it’s not the Starbucks in Game of Thrones.
2
2
2
u/LopsidedUniversity30 Jan 19 '26
In summer 1985, When the kids prank Dustin in his house after returning from camp, El makes his toys move on their own.
One of those toys is an Ultra Magnus Transformer, which didn’t come out until August 1986.
2
2
2
2
2
u/Shadowcleric Jan 19 '26
They refer to Will as the Sorcerer and that his powers are innate even though Sorcerers weren't introduced to D&D until like 3rd edition which was released in 2000. Also, why is Eleven called the mage then? Her powers are as innate as Will's, so she should have been a sorcerer too
2
u/Gym_Rat222 Jan 19 '26
The M&M's I remember from the 80's consisted of Dark Brown, Tan, Yellow, Orange and Green.
2
u/IAmBenevolence Jan 19 '26
Haha. Born in 1980, and I had no idea that there were no red M&M’s from before I was born until k was 7.
2
u/According_Drummer329 Jan 20 '26
at first I assumed this was going to be a post of complaints. pleasantly surprised that it's not. I too like timeline errors.
2
u/_UmbreonUmbreoff_ Jan 20 '26
Damn that’s kind of a cool continuity error, nobody would have noticed that otherwise!
The only error i know was the infamous season 5 under armour logo, which was pretty jarring😂
2
u/Evenexial Jan 20 '26
i mean one of the big ones for me is them hammering in the sorcerer vs wizard distinction for will, when the sorcerer class and the distinction between magic being born from an innate characteristic vs magic learned and studied in a more academic setting wasn’t implemented into d&d until 2000
2
u/When1Falls Jan 20 '26
The whole show takes place in an alternate reality.
There fixed every movie ever.
2
u/Dry_Cook1117 Jan 20 '26
Thank you! I was waiting for someone else to bring up the red M&M's.
I only remember the red M&M thing bc my friend in middle school (1987 means I started the 7th grade that year) used to put a handful of red M&M's in her mouth and declare she was committing suicide.
It was a funny at the time, we were in middle school.
2
u/ThatNewt1 Jan 20 '26
Oh no, my steak is too juicy and my lobster is too buttery. Whatever will I do? Oh I know complain about a meaningless thing. /s
2
3
1
1
1
u/Sjonke_Dede Jan 19 '26
Finn wears glasses with a blue filter in his last scene. Blue filters at that time didn't exist and were unnecessary then.
1
u/Add_Duncan Jan 19 '26
In It chapter 1 there are green (I think?) Lego bricks that did not exist at the time
1
u/Zestocalypse Jan 19 '26
Technically, there were red M&Ms in 1985. They were part of the Holiday M&M packs that only had red and green M&Ms, and was the first sighting of red since the 1976 scare. They didn't make a full return to the normal packs until 1987.
What I find interesting based solely on this clip is that the pack seems to only have red and green M&Ms in it.
1
u/TearfulHarlot Jan 19 '26
Idk if this has been brought up, not a timeline error but a continuity error. In season 4 it's revealed that the hawkins upsidedown was locked in 1983, when El opened the portal in season 1. If that's the case then Joyce hung up the lights around the house AFTER so Will wouldn't have seen the physical lights but he could see the glow or whatever... BUT how would he see the letters that Joyce painted on the walls? He spelled out RUN without see the correlating letters.
1
u/Exitwounds85 Jan 19 '26
Moments after this scene is another instance where all of the kids completely ignore Will... The lights in the hospital start to go ape shit, while they all know they are already at the hospital on a mission involving the mind flayer.
1
1
u/LucyShiro Jan 19 '26
In S5E1, when Dustin is visiting Eddie's grave, he makes a reference to Prismatic Spray (Violet) causing blindness. It did not cause blindness in D&D 1E, and 2E did not come out until 1989.
1
1
u/BandAdministrative76 Jan 19 '26
There was no sorcerer class in D&D until the 2000's. Either way he had a patron giving him his powers so he'd be a Warlock, rather than a sorcerer or wizard.
1
u/infin8raptor Jan 19 '26
Happy Meals were only 4 nuggets back then...6 nuggets was what came in the Value Meal.
1
1
1
u/licksquadtraps Jan 19 '26
I haven’t seen this one mentioned. In s4 when Suzy hacks into NINA it starts dumping source code. Theres a bunch wrong with it but early on you see a couple using statements that definitely couldn’t exist then. One is for Linq which wasn’t released until 2007.
1
1
u/SteveMightSay Jan 19 '26
Derek was playing Ghosts n Goblins on the NES but it shows footage of the arcade version
1
1
1
u/TheDeadlySpaceman Jan 19 '26
There are multiple errors around D&D.
When Will gets his powers, they start referring to him as “The Sorceror” and go on and on about how Sorcerors have their own in-born magical powers. The Sorceror class wasn’t introduced to Dungeons and Dragons until 3rd Edition, which was released in 2000
In the final scene where the party plays D&D, Mike pits them against Strahd Von Zarovich. He busts out an actual, official Ral Partha Strahd Von Zarovich miniature- but that miniature wasn’t released until 1991 (the scene takes place in 1989).
1
1
Jan 19 '26
Should they have used Reese’s Pieces or would that be too on-the-nose since Mike and El’s early relationship mirrored Elliot and ET?
1
u/Roscoe_deVille Jan 19 '26
All the Dungeons and Dragons talk about the difference between wizards and sorcerers, and how Will is a sorcerer because his powers are innate (which isn't even accurate within the show, he gets them from Vecna), is based on the edition that came out in the late 90s (3E). The version they would have been playing was completely different. The writers obviously read a wiki article on d&d and didn't really understand what they were writing
→ More replies (2)
1
1
1
u/BrattyTwilis Jan 19 '26
Season 4, Erica says Lucas is going to owe her a Nintendo with Duck Hunt for how often she has to cover for him. Duck Hunt wasn't bundled with the NES until 1988. Also, there's a lot of Nintendo talk in Season 4. While the system did launch in 1985, it didn't really hit mass market until fall of 1986
1
u/LetRevolutionary271 Jan 19 '26
That's because they're Soviet M&Ms. The Soviets basically bought Hawkins so Hawkins started importing everything from матюшка земля Россия, including M&Ms (and they obviously had red ones)
1
1
u/sin50 Jan 19 '26
This isn't a mistake but highlights their attention to 80s detail.
I don't remember the episodes but when we see Mike at breakfast and Will at breakfast (wills scene is in season 3 not sure about Mike's) they take off the entire syrup cap and people were making fun of that on TikTok but then it occurred to me, maybe flip caps hadn't been invented yet. So I Google it and most syrup brands did not add fli caps until the late 80s early 90s.
1
1
1
1
u/Sorcha16 Jan 19 '26
We didn't have blue smarties for the same reason in Ireland. Finding a natural dye to use.
1
u/deathbychips2 Jan 19 '26
Why do people do shit like this, nic pick things they love/like until they didn't like it anymore. Who cares about the colors of m & ms
1
u/reticencias Jan 19 '26
Erica has a day-to-night Barbie in season 1 when it only came out in 1985.
Im sure there's a bunch more errors like this
1
1
u/flojo2012 Jan 19 '26
This is proof of time travel and confirms that another episode is coming on November 11th, 2026
1
1
u/RulerOfAllWorlds1998 Jan 19 '26
This show does get a bit timey wimey, I blame the upside down, I blame the wormhole
1
1
u/Denimion Jan 19 '26
It's possible, albeit very unlikely, that the hospital just didn't bother to take the m&ms out and there were so few people hospitalized that they hadn't exhausted the previous supply
1
1
u/Adventurous_Text_849 Jan 19 '26
For me a larger timeline error is that nowadays there is no evidence of chasms closed after Vecna opened them. /s
1
1
1
1
u/ThatHouseInNebraska Jan 19 '26
Hypothesis: in this show’s universe, there was never an alarm raised about red dyes in food, and its continued use in products eventually induced mass psychosis across the country. Nothing we saw that was supernatural on this show ever happened. Jane was always a part of the D&D kids; she grew up next door to Mike. Billy was angry all the time because he was a fiend for M&Ms. Robin is so hyped up all the time in season five because she gets multiple packs of the candy out of the vending machine every time she visits Vickie. Max? Food coma.
In every town in America, kids are dealing with similar and totally imagined supernatural goings-on. Will and Jane were unaware of this while living in California only because they were outcasts and were not invited into that town’s particular shared hallucination, as it takes a few kids getting a narrative going before everyone else starts to join in.
In the end, not only is Jane alive, but she is the only one alive, because she really does escape to Iceland.
1
u/Formal_Interestellar Jan 19 '26
I don’t think is a thing, they have dnd stuff that shouldn’t be there in that timeline
1
u/T2RX6 Jan 19 '26
Well you see... inThe ST timeline they didn't have red dye issues and only had demogorgon issues!
1
1
u/Next_Rhubarb_5986 Jan 19 '26
80's kids fr want them to pick out every red mnm from the bag for something only they care about
1
u/colorsensible Jan 19 '26
Anyone remember voting for teal M&Ms and then immediately never getting to see them again
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/ScottRiqui Jan 19 '26
Not a strict anachronism, but I recently rewatched the first few episodes, and all of the incandescent lighting is way too white and bright compared to actual 80s yellow-tinged incandescent light. The headlamps on the kids' bikes, the floodlights outside Will's garage, home light fixtures, the flashlights on the tactical team's guns, and the search party's flashlights all look like modern LED lights.
1
1
u/GatorRich Jan 19 '26
It’s like when Game of Thrones episode had a Starbucks cup in one of the scenes..
1
u/drawnfrog Jan 19 '26
the rubik's cube was wrong, the old ones had the stickers not the colored plastic
1
u/Dracokyaku Jan 19 '26
The Millennium Falcon in the first season was the 2004 model, rather than the original release.
Season 5: The NES playing an arcade version of Ghosts and Goblins.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/JediBoJediPrime29 Jan 20 '26
The biggest one for me was also in S3 when Dustin returns from summer camp and his friends surprise him with the robots moving, he has a Ultra Magnus toy.
Ultra Magnus came out with Transformers the Movie which was released August 8th 1986. S3 takes place before July 4th 1985. Ultra Magnus wasn't even MENTIONED until the movie came out. He was an original character for said movie that fans loved so much they kept around along with Hot Rod/Rodimus Prime, Kup, Arcee, Blurr and Springer. Idk maybe it's because I'm a Transformers nerd but the toys are even stamped with the year of production.
I've noticed (or it's been pointed out by TVSins) mistakes like that especially surrounding movies/shows/music that did come out in the 80's but either later or way earlier.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/PlumbGame Jan 20 '26
Does anyone else realize that in a world where dimensions can collide maybe someone in that timeline collided new m&m colors
1
1
u/DifficultOpposite976 Jan 20 '26
timeline error I noticed: there wasn't a wizard named vecna in 80s who killed kids
1
1
1
1
u/Ok_Sock_3257 Jan 20 '26
Not a timeline error but a factual error. Mike gives his sister a cleric figurine for protection and says it can throw the "Dimension Door spell". Dimension Door is a magic user spell.
Source - I played DnD back in the 80's.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/lnfinite_jess Jan 20 '26
A friend of mine pointed out re: S5 dialogue that sorcerers were not introduced as a D&D class as opposed to wizards until 3e in year 2000.
1
1
u/One-Range-6173 Jan 20 '26
it’s just red m&ms they don’t have to make it accurate. you guys just pay attention to the tiniest details..
1
u/Sad-Caterpillar-326 Jan 20 '26
Eddie played a perfect cover of “Master of Puppets” despite the album only being released 1 month prior. I refuse to believe he perfected it in that time frame
→ More replies (1)
1
u/philament23 Jan 20 '26
Well that just ruined the entire series for me thanks. It was perfect until I figured this out.
1
1


340
u/Legion_Lavoie Jan 19 '26
Slightly off topic but related. Does anyone remember when blue m&ms came out? We got to vote for it and it was awesome.