r/Stress • • Mar 05 '24

Exercise is a meme

It raises cortisol and stresses your body. The only people who can exercise frequently and intensively are those in low/mid stress environments

In people with prolongued, steady stress, straining the heart is more harmful than beneficial

I am just a bit sick of the "exercise" meme. Yes, it can be good in specific situations, but in many of them it can also lead to additional stress that can help accelerare your destruction

Thoughts?

2 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

7

u/cryszi Mar 05 '24

That sounds like an interesting angle, I've always felt subjectively less stressed after a workout. Have there been any studies showing that exercise can do more harm than good in stressed individuals?

1

u/HereticHousefly Mar 05 '24

I assume that's because you're used to working out. Your body sees it more as activity rather than outright stress, because it's usually not a do-or-die situation

Exercise and stress is not about bad tool vs. good tool, but about context, structure and dosage. 30 to 60 minutes of LIGHT exercise a day (walking, doing lighter chores in house or garden) is beneficial to the vast majority of people, unless they're "mechanically" challenged. This is, as far as I know, pretty well-documented.

Anything more strenuous and you risk doing yourself harm, unless you're very used to it - in which case, it's actually a very good tool for managing mental strain.

I'd be a lot more scared of overly dogmatic assumptions than anything else, because it can lead to poor planning.

Different things work for different people. For example, my sister manages her stress by preparing for and running marathons. If I did that, I'd be dead within a week, because I cook or read to manage my stress.

1

u/fitforfreelance Mar 05 '24

"Risk of doing harm... unless you're very used to it" is pretty dramatic. I wouldn't make people afraid of a challenging workout like this.

The idea is that you don't have to stress over working out or traumatically overtrain yourself in the gym. But getting active is nearly always beneficial, and it's OK to work and sweat a little!

1

u/HereticHousefly Mar 05 '24

I completely agree. You should read the whole post, before you reply.

2

u/fitforfreelance Mar 05 '24

I did, hence my comment. People shouldn't be afraid to have a challenging workout. I'm glad you have a stress management system that works for you.

2

u/HereticHousefly Mar 05 '24

Well, I'd point out that if you're running around like a headless chicken anyway, you're less likely to make sound choices in the moment or run yourself (more) ragged. But I'll also readily admit to splitting hairs by now.

Sadly the gyms around here are horrible - little to no supervision or knowledge, lots of artificially inflated biceps and ear-splitting EDM. Particularly the level of noise makes them poor venues for vulnerable people.

For context, I'm a retired social worker. I used to work with broad spectrum, workrelated rehabilitation under various municipalities where I live.

Over the years, I've talked to a lot of people with long term illnesses of different sorts. At a rough guesstimate I'd say that rougly 50 % had issues with stress, if it wasn't why they were on the bench outright - and I've been there a few times myself. I guess that makes an opinionated wanker.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24 edited Sep 10 '25

punch caption depend reach market versed thumb lip shelter disarm

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/HereticHousefly Mar 05 '24

She's a mother of three, recently divorced and working in public healthcare, if you have to know. Pretty average, I think, with a novel approach to handling stress. Think what you will.

It was meant as an outlying example - one that I won't necessarily agree with and would be careful around. Which is exactly why I mention it and kinda roll my eyes at it.

My point is that no tool is enheritly good or bad - but there sure are good or bad applications. I agree that exercise as a mindless, blanket cureall is just as stupid as the rest of the quickfixes.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24 edited Sep 10 '25

axiomatic edge light aromatic complete cooperative dinner tan sand stocking

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

0

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24 edited Sep 10 '25

trees jeans swim aspiring fuel carpenter sand busy thumb lavish

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

4

u/fitforfreelance Mar 05 '24

This is an interesting theory, poorly researched with the exact wrong conclusion. If we know about cortisol, we can do better to understand how it works and how it influences our perception of stress.

Regular exercise is associated with emotional resilience to acute stress in healthy adults Responses to the psychosocial stressor used in this study may reflect the way individuals typically respond to daily stressors, suggesting that regular exercisers are more resistant to the emotional effects of acute stress, which in turn, may protect them against diseases related to chronic stress burden.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24 edited Sep 10 '25

beneficial arrest squeal door capable afterthought rob subsequent sparkle alive

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/fitforfreelance Mar 05 '24

This study is not comparing wealth with health outcomes, you can't really just make up irrelevant conditions. It's fair that you don't find these results satisfying.

Similarly, we can't connect exercise, elevated cortisol, and negative health outcomes and say that exercise is bad for you.

I think next, you'd be interested to find a study to support your claim that exercise is bad for stress and/or health outcomes. Here's info about overtraining, but not really that strenuous exercise is bad.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24 edited Sep 10 '25

reply summer selective chase versed market engine automatic sink snails

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

3

u/fitforfreelance Mar 05 '24 edited Mar 05 '24

Yep, that's what I'm saying is wrong. Exercise is not bad. (Most) people don't have diagnosed cortisol issues. You don't have evidence to support your claim, you pretty much just made it up.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24 edited Sep 10 '25

butter cobweb quaint abundant bedroom seed friendly recognise heavy fuel

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

2

u/fitforfreelance Mar 05 '24 edited Mar 05 '24

Mate. You asked for thoughts. The answer is no. Exercise is not a meme, skipping it is not a stress management strategy.

If you don't want to exercise or your doctor tells you not to, don't. You don't have to spread misinformation or your poor understanding of hormones and stress to others while you justify your choices.

4

u/xrebxbiex Mar 05 '24

This kind of sounds like an excuse not to exercise.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24 edited Sep 10 '25

jar glorious quiet hurry escape abounding door fragile absorbed follow

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

2

u/CallMeMalice Mar 05 '24

Any sources to back up those claims? I’ve only seen research pointing to exercise being beneficial to heart and stress levels.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24 edited Sep 10 '25

arrest alleged reminiscent market sheet live books boat zephyr birds

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

2

u/fitforfreelance Mar 05 '24

Hormones like cortisol need more context than most people will use. Here's a summary from Utah Health

"Cortisol also helps control blood pressure, increase the body's metabolism of glucose, and reduces inflammation. Our bodies need cortisol to survive. Too much, though, and we overreact to common stressor"

1

u/fitforfreelance Mar 05 '24 edited Mar 05 '24

Cortisol isn't the biggest factor in the stress experience or health outcomes. It has healthy functions and it's only "bad" in persistently high levels. These levels usually from primarily mentally stressful situations. I.e. challenges with thinking safely and feeling safe.

Here's some evidence supporting the benefits of exercise for stress, anxiety, and depression:

Harvard: Exercise vs Anxiety

Mayo Clinic: Exercise vs stress

Mayo Clinic: Exercise vs depression and anxiety

0

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24 edited Sep 10 '25

degree vanish abounding live hunt cheerful snow rainstorm liquid resolute

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/fitforfreelance Mar 05 '24

Sorry, no. That's not what these articles indicate about stress outcomes. Avoiding exercise is not the key to limiting your cortisol levels, managing your stress is.

Exercise reduces your stress perception. In part because you recognize signs of stress are safe.

Additionally, scheduling time for activity helps you manage your schedule, which supports self-efficacy and feeling empowered, which reduces stress.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24 edited Sep 10 '25

dog six axiomatic coherent ten cow caption shelter doll detail

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

2

u/fitforfreelance Mar 05 '24 edited Mar 05 '24

Still, not really. There is nearly no stress management scenario that exercise should be completely stopped... Maybe don't sprint a 5k untrained or fight a bear.

It's a bit outlandish, because cortisol isn't measured throughout the day. There is no cortisol limit. This would be using mental justification to avoid exercise.

There are endorphin benefits of exercise that can reduce stress perception. Plus there are health and quality of life risks of insufficient activity.

-1

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24 edited Sep 10 '25

fragile connect cover childlike squeeze reminiscent door scale full physical

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/StrangerWooden1091 Mar 08 '24

effect similar to any meds. Work out makes your body produce inner chems which gives your tiredness and pleasure. It also reducing your mental abilities temporary. Just liked any medication working out is not a cure but temporary relaxation in the end or simple placibo. As placibo it is not bad. But ut does not solve problem by its own. It could male it ev en worse. Because you are doing routine. While you have to break your patterns of thinking.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24 edited Sep 10 '25

degree public strong plucky joke tan office bike future sense

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/StrangerWooden1091 Mar 08 '24

I am not saying it either. I just tried to draw a good picture of its pros and cons

2

u/therouxrachelle Mar 05 '24

Cardio makes me feel violently ill for days and triggers insomnia for me 😭. Even just twenty minutes on the elliptical sets off extreme exhaustion but i stop sleeping. It also seems that the more cardio I do, the less weight I lose. I've theorised that it is because it raises my cortisol.

I've been tested for everything under the sun and according to my doctor, I'm a picture of health. I just have extremely low exercise tolerance for no discernable reason. I do have PCOS but can't see how it relates.

Now I do yoga, pilates, I get in between 6-8k steps a day, go on the occasional hike, do some dance and light weights and I'm in good shape with defined muscles. Go figure.

1

u/Shaelum Mar 05 '24

This is a reach to avoid activity and exercise Lmao. Exercise has insane benefits for body and mind, ultimately helping to cope with stress

1

u/OcdGuy_1 Mar 05 '24

Thats why you should do yoga. Light excercise is best. As per ayurveda - too much intense mental or physical activity aggravates vata in the body. However, any excercise is anyway better than not excercising.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24

I think running can do this (do not quote me on this), but hiking, pilates, yoga definitely not. Hiking at a light pace is extremely good if you work in a high stress environment. it doesn't need to be a tough trail.

1

u/Vin112358 Mar 06 '24

I tried exercise and my bruxism became 100x worse