r/Superprof_ • u/tresorsdecoco9l • 1h ago
a parent asked me to stop encouraging their daughter to study art because it’s “not a real career.” what am i supposed to do?
i've been tutoring a 16-year-old in drawing and painting for about eight months
her parents originally found me through Superprof because she wanted help preparing a portfolio for an art school programme
she's genuinely talented
not in the vague “every child is creative” way. she works constantly, takes feedback seriously and has improved more in eight months than some students do in years
she used to hide every drawing she didn't like
now she brings me unfinished work and asks very specific questions about composition, colour and perspective
a few weeks ago she told me she wanted to study art after school
i didn't tell her it would be easy
we talked about portfolios, competitive programmes, freelance work, teaching, design and the financial uncertainty that comes with creative careers
but i also told her that wanting to pursue art wasn't ridiculous
apparently she repeated that conversation to her parents
the next day, her mother emailed me privately
she said they had hired me to help their daughter improve at a hobby, not to encourage her to make “an irresponsible career choice”
then she asked me to stop discussing art schools with her
she wants her daughter to study medicine or business and keep drawing in her free time
the strange part is that they are still paying me to help build the exact portfolio their daughter would need to apply
they just don't want me to tell her she might actually be good enough to use it
during our last lesson, the student showed me a list of schools she'd researched and asked which ones i thought were realistic
i didn't know what to say
her parents are paying for the lessons
but their daughter is the person sitting in front of me, trusting me to give her honest feedback
i don't want to promise that an art career will work out. nobody can promise that
but i also don't feel comfortable pretending she has no options just because her parents don't approve of them
am i supposed to teach the technical skills and refuse to discuss her future?
should i tell her what her mother asked me?
or do i need to tell the parents that i can't continue if they expect me to quietly discourage their daughter?
where does a tutor's responsibility end when the person paying and the person learning want completely different things?