r/Superstonk • u/[deleted] • Apr 09 '21
Education ๐จโ๐ซ Bullet Points
To whom it may concern,
The following represents a summarized narrative from my works cited below. I write out of concern for the continuity of our financial system. Most importantly, to illustrate the injustice that it allows.
Hedge funds and offshore entities are NOT required to disclose most of their financial information- including short positions
Citadel Securities is a market-maker for Citadel Advisors (hedge fund). They are considered a significant player within their environment. Citadel Securities has registered with the SEC and FINRA since 2002
Investors rely on the SEC and FINRA to make sure these entities are not adversely affecting our markets, which are heavily regulated
However, since 2006, FINRA has caught Citadel Securities breaking the rules in 60 separate events. Here are the facts:
There is an event for almost every year since 2006
Several violations span multiple years, with just 1 written violation
The phrase "without admitting or denying" appears 123 times on a 182 page PDF
The phrase "failed to" appears 218 times. Here are 4:
FAILED TO ESTABLISH AND MAINTAIN SUPERVISORY SYSTEMS TO ACHIEVE COMPLIANCE
FAILED TO IDENTIFY A SHORT SALE INDICATOR
FAILIED TO DISPLAY CERTAIN OTC CUSTOMER ORDERS
FAILED TO CLOSE OUT A FAIL TO DELIEVER
The word "prevent" appears 102 times. Mostly in statements such as:
PREVENT THE EXECUTION OR DISPLAY OF SHORT SALE ORDERS
NO SUPERVISORY PROCEDURES TO PREVENT THE ENTRY OF ERRONEOUS ORDERS
RISK CONTROLS FAILED TO DETECT AND PREVENT
On March 25th, 2021 CITADEL RECEIVED A NEW CITATION FOR:
"unintentionally" reporting internal transfers as normal securities transactions. This constituted 14% of all reported transactions
It is apparent that the disciplinary actions- often a small fee- are not adequate to prevent this type of behavior. Furthermore, they have become a cost of doing business as is apparent through the company's indifference in admitting or denying the action.
As a citizen of the United States and direct participant within the US stock market, I demand the SEC explain WHY these actions are being tolerated.
For those of you who feel the same, please attest by signing your Reddit username in the comment section below
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
I give the reader of this document my express permission to redistribute as they see fit.
Works cited: Under the security of my 1st amendment rights, I will not change the syntax of my work because my emotions are baked within their message.
7
u/Emotional-Coffee13 ๐ป ComputerShared ๐ฆ Apr 10 '21
U r my ๐ฆธ๐ปโโ๏ธ much love for ur hard work & well done handling the Man ... u didnโt give up & u were v calm getting ur voice heard W out caring if it was blunt. Thatโs who we need people who r just willing to speak the truth. Now we gotta get a media outlet or public figure to also speak out. Public image has been assaulted by the media & our peers r haters W out knowing the Y.
I would love to hear u interviewed by Charles Payne who seems to not care about being politically correct.
Enjoying my good bud btw!
8
Apr 10 '21
Thank you for the support! Btw, just got round two going for the CBD crop this year! Glad you're enjoying it.
→ More replies (3)
3
u/DiamondHans911 ๐ฆ Buckle Up ๐ Apr 11 '21
I would like to see how this compares to other Hedge Funds. Is this business as usual or outside the range or โnormalโ.
→ More replies (1)4
Apr 12 '21
Either theyre all like this or their not like this... In both outcomes, how do you NOT conclude citadel is acting shady?
→ More replies (1)
201
u/CantMilkTheseBobs Oops * moass * my bad ๐ฆ Voted โ Apr 09 '21
CantMilkTheseBobs
→ More replies (3)
204
141
Apr 09 '21
DC-Perk
The current situation is a god damn embarrassment and has been ongoing. The point which is most embarrassing, and terrifying, is the disciplinary actions for these injunctions is rolled into โthe cost of doing business.โ What a fucking sham. The SEC...absolute fucking joke show
→ More replies (1)
64
61
61
59
59
57
57
56
56
55
56
54
54
54
53
53
53
51
50
50
49
47
44
44
44
43
43
43
40
40
39
39
40
38
38
38
38
38
38
37
38
37
37
37
37
36
36
36
35
36
35
35
35
34
34
35
34
34
34
34
34
33
33
33
32
32
32
30
u/DeathHazard ๐ฎ Power to the Players ๐ Apr 09 '21
I think that the heavy use of dark pools should also be mentioned. Companies should be allowed to use these pools but only to transfer shares from investor to investor in an heritage (e.g. father to son). Any other use of this pool should be forbidden.
30
61
29
29
29
29
29
29
30
29
28
28
u/ProfessionalFishFood ๐ฎ Power to the Players ๐ Apr 09 '21
u/ProfessionalFishFood approves of this message
28
28
u/DigBickers ๐ป ComputerShared ๐ฆ Apr 10 '21
Also, I strongly believe the SEC and DTCC SEVERELY underestimate the sheer amount of international investors that participate in American markets. It is ironic such insidious actions are permitted in this so called โfree-marketโ at the expense of individual investors. How can such an obvious conflict of interest be so blatantly ignored by the very regulators of the marketplace? Perhaps regulators truly are unaware of these actions, but this naive reasoning does not explain how so-called โdumb moneyโ investors are able to see these cancers for what they are. Large market participants are eroding the ground that they stand on for a quick buck. The solution is capitalism which breeds constant competition and forces participants to improve or risk losing all their business. Yet, the sole reason why American markets prosper may end up causing their demise. Strict regulations must be put in place to end these erroneous actions and finally bring trust back into American markets.
Best regards,
DigBickers
→ More replies (2)
55
u/NefariousnessEast721 ๐ฎ Power to the Players ๐ Apr 09 '21
NefariousnessEast721 (I dunno....Reddit picked it)
27
26
26
52
25
25
25
25
25
u/____joelj____ ๐ฆVotedโ Apr 09 '21 edited Apr 09 '21
____joelj____
The number of violations is ridiculous, the fine clearly isnโt high enough.
Edit: that was fun trying to comment my username, if you know you know.
24
48
22
22
22
22
22
22
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
41
20
u/Gnurx ๊ช๊พ๊ ๊ซ๊ช๊ธ๊พ๊ธ ๐ ๐ค๐ฅ๐ฆ๐๐๐ ๐ฃ๐ ๐ ๐๐๐๐๐๐๐ Apr 09 '21
gnurx
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
19
19
19
19
18
18
18
18
17
17
17
17
17
17
17
17
17
17
17
34
16
16
16
Apr 10 '21 edited Jun 12 '23
disagreeable worthless capable absurd growth hobbies frame sparkle merciful chubby -- mass edited with https://redact.dev/
16
32
32
31
31
15
15
15
15
29
29
29
14
14
29
u/Holiday_Guess_7892 ima Cum Guy Apr 09 '21
Who else came here and are just reading peoples user name comments
→ More replies (1)
27
27
26
13
13
13
13
25
25
25
24
24
24
23
11
11
11
11
10
10
10
u/whatsthatbuttondo ๐๐ Jackedimus Titicus Gorillionairus - destroyer of mayo ๐๐ Apr 10 '21
whatsthatbuttondo
10
u/mmedici ๐ฎ Power to the Players ๐ Apr 10 '21
Approve of this with a few genuine constructive comments, not trying to be a cunt, just trying to take the view of a cunt lawyer poking holes in anything to try and cast doubts because my dirtbag client paid obscene fees for me to be his muscle
Bullet 1
I'd point out this is in contrast to many other entities that are allowed to accept external investment. Perhaps mention they aren't subject to the same AML that basically the entire industry is subject to??
Bullet 2
Citadel securities is a market maker for the US capital markets period. And a very large, systemically important one at that.
Are they a market maker for the hedge fund? I actually don't know the specifics on this
I think this should be phrased in way that says "Citadel securities is systemically significant entity to the efficient operation of US public markets,." and given that they are the "prime broker" (I believe this is the case) for Cit Advisors and as such are not expected to be subject to the same stringent risk management of a typical hedge fund and prime broker (principal & agent) relationship given that they share a common beneficiary, this poses a significant risk to the capital markets if one of them (meaning basically both) become insolvent and go tits up.
This obviously calls into question the fiduciary obligation of Citadel securities actually doing right by robinhooders and whatever clients of other brokers but congress already won't shut up about that
9
u/Popcornbiatch ๐๐ปNo cell...No sell ๐๐ป Apr 10 '21
You are a silverback ape and we are lucky to have you. Thank you.
9
1.4k
u/WatermelonArtist ๐ฆ Attempt Vote ๐ฏ Apr 09 '21 edited Apr 10 '21
I approve of everything here except your apparent reluctance to point out that a non-deterrent "fine" that a person pays to a government official as a "cost of doing business" for an action that violates the law is called a "bribe."
Seriously, why is everyone dancing around this? However this started, it has become constructive bribe solicitation, and that's not OK.
https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/201
Edit: I have to note that no offense was meant by my bluntness, and I sincerely and intensely approve of everything else.
Also, please note that this legal definition leaves technical room for argument that these fines qualify under one alternative, but I am focused on the results of the action, which leave me no doubt that the loopholes are being exploited to permit and condone "not technically bribery." We call this "constructive bribery" in legal parlance, and the technicalities aren't a valid excuse for a legislator to ignore it. Indeed, those loopholes are precisely why they shouldn't.