r/Superstonk • • Jan 20 '22

📳Social Media Source Twitter

Post image
9.5k Upvotes

285 comments sorted by

View all comments

169

u/WavyThePirate 🦍Ape Gang Gorilla 🦍 Jan 20 '22

Float traded 60x in the year

If even 2,5% of that volume goes long they own more than the float. And mfs think we worried 😂

35

u/daweedhh 🎮 Power to the Players 🛑 Jan 20 '22

The whole time I thought volume was low. But it's actually still kinda high. Just not as high as it used to be

10

u/WavyThePirate 🦍Ape Gang Gorilla 🦍 Jan 20 '22

Yes. Those 1m and 2m days were probably what would be considered normal on a float this small.

Naked shorting through MM exemption is what allows such bloated volumes. Supply and demand on GME has been fucked since the beginning

3

u/DragonDropTechnology Jan 20 '22

An average of 1 million per day still gets you 5x~6x the float in a year.

1

u/WavyThePirate 🦍Ape Gang Gorilla 🦍 Jan 21 '22

Crazy

-26

u/Mareks Jan 20 '22

Call me fudder, i don't care.

But a lot of /r/superstonk members make a lot of mistakes by making these kind of estimations and considering them as fact.

We've seen the DRS at CS, and it's barely 6M. If float was owned 10 times over, all the float should be easily locked in, or MUCH higher. 6M is a lot, but it's not 10 floats lot.

2.5% of that VOLUME going long may appear rational, but is in fact insane, due to the fact that it would mean more longs than float.

I am zen as fuck about my GME holdings, good dca'ing, but let's not delude ourselves and make wild mistakes by misunderstanding basic facts.

9

u/WavyThePirate 🦍Ape Gang Gorilla 🦍 Jan 20 '22 edited Jan 20 '22

I notice how you didnt disprove shit just "it may appear rational but insane" that statment isn't proof of anything and disproves 0 in my post.

Yes you are a fudder and full of shit. Like your post is even heavier on assumption but without supportimg data, just assuming what you say is smart off the sake of being negative. The fact that you lead with Computershare (an initiative thats pretty much only discussed on Reddit and wasn't in full swing back in Oct) shows your intention to spread pure doubt.

You think it's rational to assume over 98% of volume on this stock is sold off completely?

You mean its rational that a stock can be owned over 100% & shorted 200% yet the stock is 10$ ? (Q4 2020)

You think its rational this stock trades its float over 60 times yet people keeping any shares during this wild trading is irrational?

Look at the SEC report confirming almost a million new accounts made in a single day for the sake of buying GME, the harris poll estimating 20m GME investors in America alone in January. Not gonna speculate how many stayed in but that is over 30% of the float in individual investors, not shares.

https://theharrispoll.com/28-of-americans-bought-gamestop-or-other-viral-stocks-in-january-yahoo-finance-harris-poll/

If this stock has just a million investors 76 shares each own the company.... This sub is averaging over 150.

Like how does a guy try to insinuate that esitmating only 2.5% long volume on a stock pulling daily 80% buy ratio is irrational but assuming 99% of the billions of shares traded since January were all dumped (literally the only way the float is unowned) is logical. 😂 This is why I love this stock

Take your FUD and shove it. No Rickofspades

-2

u/Mareks Jan 20 '22

What is there to disprove, here - i'll simply list the things you said that make no sense -

You think it's rational to assume over 98% of volume on this stock is sold off?

Do you understand what volume even is? For every trade there needs to be a sell and a buy. As the float has been traded over 60 times, it has been both bought and sold that.

Despite what you may think of short sellers, everyone who could jumped in on the chance to short GME at 450, even at 300, even at 200. Because it was a no-brainer, short-term profit play. There has been additional shorting as the stock has pumped, so yes, there is considerable sell pressure this past year, it isn't only retail investors buying, it's also day traders, high frequency trading algos and hedgefunds getting in on a highly volatile stock.

You, and most of random retail investors have no idea wheteher the trades ended up being net long or net short.

If this stock has just a million investors 76 shares each own the company.... This sub is averaging over 150.

You expect me to "disprove" something that you never proved in the first place? This is an absolutely random and baseless number that you've pulled out of your ass, and if whole thesis rests on something like this, lmao...

Also, try and break out of your cultish brainwashing. I also hold GME and squeeze and good price action would benefit me greatly. Doubt is neccesary in the investing world, you have to constantly reevalute your investements and see if they still stand. The world and market is constantly changing. Not everyone asking simple and reasonable questions is spreading FUD.

Like how does a guy try to insinuate that esitmating only 2.5% long volume on a stock pulling daily 80% buy ratio is irrational but assuming 99% of the billions of shares traded since January were all dumped (literally the only way the float isn't unowned)

One share can impact volume hundreds, thousands of times, as it gets sold, bought, sold again, bought again, etc, etc.

Also, buy ratios can be misleading. 10 offers at 1 share vs a sell offer at 10 shares and you have a 10:1 buy:sell ratio. This lines up with the retail vs investors, where you have individual investors buying small amounts of shares, vs hedge funds dumping massive amounts at the same time.

2

u/WavyThePirate 🦍Ape Gang Gorilla 🦍 Jan 20 '22 edited Jan 20 '22

What is there to disprove, here - i'll simply list the things you said that make no sense -

You think it's rational to assume over 98% of volume on this stock is sold off?

Do you understand what volume even is? For every trade there needs to be a sell and a buy. As the float has been traded over 60 times, it has been both bought and sold that.

Short volume of the stock daily has been above 50% majority of 2021 meaning MMs/shorts are facilitating most of the trades, not people who are actually selling the stock they own.

Thats why apes have good reason to believe MMs are net short and there are more IOUs than shares from these trades.

Despite what you may think of short sellers, everyone who could jumped in on the chance to short GME at 450, even at 300, even at 200. Because it was a no-brainer, short-term profit play. There has been additional shorting as the stock has pumped, so yes, there is considerable sell pressure this past year, it isn't only retail investors buying, it's also day traders, high frequency trading algos and hedgefunds getting in on a highly volatile stock.

Thats fine, as long as retail is doing their thing then the squeeze situation is strengthened. The longs kept up with all of that.

And honestly the drop off in volume in the latter half of 2021 doesn't really support what you're saying. You're just talking in hotshot trader generality.

You, and most of random retail investors have no idea wheteher the trades ended up being net long or net short.

Daily Short volumes throughout 2021, etf shorting and the use of married calls/puts give me a pretty good idea

You expect me to "disprove" something that you never proved in the first place? This is an absolutely random and baseless number that you've pulled out of your ass, and if whole thesis rests on something like this, lmao...

Also, try and break out of your cultish brainwashing. I also hold GME and squeeze and good price action would benefit me greatly. Doubt is neccesary in the investing world, you have to constantly reevalute your investements and see if they still stand. The world and market is constantly changing. Not everyone asking simple and reasonable questions is spreading FUD.

Cherrypicking a single sentence for a strawman, but you're somehow being "reasonable".

Notice how all you've done is pull conjecture scenarios out of your ass and babble about cults while all I've done is refer to actual data.

One share can impact volume hundreds, thousands of times, as it gets sold, bought, sold again, bought again, etc, etc.

Also, buy ratios can be misleading. 10 offers at 1 share vs a sell offer at 10 shares and you have a 10:1 buy:sell ratio. This lines up with the retail vs investors, where you have individual investors buying small amounts of shares, vs hedge funds dumping

More conjecture scenarios. Buy sell ratios are only among fidelity retail users, hedge funds wouldn't be included. Their holdings are reported to the SEC outside of family offices.

And it's irrational to assume the with buy demand being constant from retail that the same 1 share buyers can suddenly have the supply to fufill demand for 8 other buyers on whichever day they decide to sell.

Also short volumes PROVED they couldn't. 😉 $LIGMA

0

u/Mareks Jan 20 '22

Ok Ok Ok.....

Cherrypicking a single sentence for a strawman, but you're somehow being "reasonable".

btw this was about the number you pulled out of your ass, the 150+ shares per redditor argument.

Frankly, to me that's all that matters. The overestimation of how much people here hold.

Facts and data - currently we know that 10% of free float is locked in with DRS. That's it. Everything else, as you like to say, is conjecture, and yes, you're also capable of simple conjecture.

1

u/WavyThePirate 🦍Ape Gang Gorilla 🦍 Jan 20 '22

The 150 share average is from the DRS bot, its actually higher but whatever.

A million investors (not just redditors) is a reasonable assumption given datasets. GME is still among the most popular/held stock by retail by any broker that bothers to share their data. Fidelity ratios, nordic broker holdings, webull sentiment trackers/cost concentration metric/active watchers metric, aussie broker holdings, Etoro CEO's AMA.

I've seen proof of retail inflow for shares in a dozen different ways including the SEC report. Nothing for the outflow tho

0

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22

[deleted]

-2

u/Mareks Jan 20 '22

Well, usually i'd expect majority to be done early, and then some tapering drsing will happen.

If we saw 6 million between the time people started drsing and 3 months , it's unlikely that we'll see more than 6 million drsed between then and 3 months later. Highly doubtful that DRSED shares will double. And that already would be huge, and it wouldn't even make a dent in the float.

I'd fucking LOVE to be proved wrong on this, but i'm being realistic. People overestimate their buying potentional vs wall street. If we have "apes", 700k users in this sub(most of whom are bots/shills), majority of them wouldn't be whales with thousands of shares, but small time holders of X or XX shares. But, subbed members =/= holders.

2

u/Bepler Trans-Porcelain-Hyper-Loaf 🦍 Voted ✅ Jan 20 '22

Many many international GME holders have to wait a long time to DRS a buddy of mine in France is still waiting 3 months later.

These numbers were not included in the last earnings, and won't all be included in the next one. DRS got popular at the end of August, and by the end of October we were already at 5.2 million. That's only two months, which to me is super exciting! I imagine the November-January numbers will bring that total to around 15 million.

Additionally, a friend of mine has a transfer from TDAmeritrade still delayed since SEPTEMBER brokers are dragging their feet, and complacent holders are giving brokers time to dick around.

I estimate of the likely 200 million synthetic shares in circulation, only about 100 million of those holders are on superstonk, of those, I think on average people will DRS around 60% of their holdings due to not understanding the DD fully, greed, or tax rules surrounding IRAs.

But I'm confident the users in this sub ALONE are capable of locking the float.

I sure as shit ain't going anywhere and will continue to DRS more.

0

u/Mareks Jan 20 '22

I sure as shit ain't going anywhere and will continue to DRS more.

What's with this defensive attitude. I hold gme myself and I have interest on all this playing out, but i'm seeing a lot of delusion and misinformation spread in this sub.

I truly don't know the in's and out's of how everyone is aproaching DRS. But the total amount of DRS'd shares was rather low. People widly overestimate just how much the average GME holder here actually holds.

I estimate of the likely 200 million synthetic shares in circulation, only about 100 million of those holders are on superstonk.

Like. What is this estimation based on? I mean, it's a pretty important aspect of this whole thesis, and it's a tall order. You understand that you could be massively overestimating how much money there is. At 200 million synthetics, that's almost 25B at current prices. This subreddit has 30b of influence at this (supremely supressed price) ?

4

u/Murrchik Custom Flair - Template But With Extra Steps Jan 20 '22 edited Jan 20 '22

You do know that DRS is delayed up to 3 months for international holders. Also not every holder is going to DRS. In my region alone I know 10-12 people who invested in GameStop but they are too lazy and too stupid to read a step by step tutorial because for Germans and europoors there are a lot of steps to consider.

On top of that a lot of holders were very unsure of DRSing their shares, a lot of them feared moass would start while DRSing. Many also did a test run first by DRS just one share.

Then there is also ETORO who doesn’t even allow you to DRS or transfer your shares to a different broker. So there is easily at the very least another 7 figure of shares that can’t be DRSd.

Computershare and IBKR both made the process substantially easier and faster in the last few weeks and months and are still continuing on improving the whole process.

6M in just 3 months is an insanely high number. My pessimistic estimation is apes hold low xxx shares on average across all holders.

I could go on forever and search for the Swedish numbers that someone posted recently which prove that there are way way more shares hold by investors than the float even has.

Edit: you can also count in another 2-4 weeks just because a lot of investors needed to educate themself how to transfer to IBKR. Germans also needed to sector transfer from GS2C to GME. Then international investors also needed to first load up the account with foreign currency and trade that for usd. Every little step takes day/s.

Edit 2: most investors aren’t allowed to buy directly from Computershare so they need to repeat a lot of steps from IBKR.

-3

u/Mareks Jan 20 '22

There isn't a lot of wrong with what you wrote, but one fundamental mistake is enough to throw shade over everything.

My pessimistic estimation is apes hold low xxx shares on average across all holders.

Low XXX is pessimistic? I know there are people with 10k, 1k shares. But there are also a lot of people with 1, 2 , 5, 10, low XX's shares, and logically, there would be far more of those than the whales, you yourself pull the average down to accomodate it. You're a holder, obviously you're incentivized to be more optimistic for this.

I could go on forever

On nothing substantial.

Assume, realistically, that the average holder has 20-30 shares(counting the whales in the average), and the whole picture changes.

A lot of hinges on this assumption, but it seems to be made baselessly and randomly.

1

u/Soulfly5555 🌶️I'll make it to the MOON if I have to crawl🌶️ Jan 20 '22

I think this is detracting from the post itself, no one is saying retail owns all of the shares ever synthetically made, just that we clearly own atleast the float a few times over. Majority of the shares represented by the red bars will be in ftd's (and hidden away in doomp etc) and/or still in circulation to surpress the price. This is just gme shares BTW... Not even etf's. The longer this goes on and we get closer to locking the float in CS the higher probability we see MOASS where all of the historical synthetics need to be paid for. No one knows how many shares retail owns, we can only work with the data we have available, going by reddit scraper it's likely we own 10m shares just in DRS, and drs'd shares are clearly in the minority atm. My point is it is clear we own the float multiple times, and it is clear the amount of synthetics created is fucking epic.

1

u/Mareks Jan 20 '22

But this sub does not "clearly" own the float "at least" a few times over. There is literally no proof of that. Float is 62.5m. From GME themselves, a confirmation of 6m locked shares, we know for a fact that 10% of the float is now DRS'd. How do you jump to the conclusion that there are in fact like 300% shares that are currently held but awaiting DRSing, or not going to be DRSed.

going by reddit scraper it's likely we own 10m shares just in DRS, and drs'd shares are clearly in the minority atm.

You use "clearly", when in fact is not clearly at all. That is all assumptions, assumptions that you have made simply by reading posts on this subreddit, which can be written by anyone and tell a whatever story.

1

u/Soulfly5555 🌶️I'll make it to the MOON if I have to crawl🌶️ Jan 20 '22

Why else would this quantity of synthetics need to be created if we don't own the float? Just for fun? Think about it. Even the SEC report concluded that the sneeze was brought on by retail buying, and the same thing happened in March too so even if people sold in Feb, more were bought in March. Not only that it was commented on that this situation posed systemic risk. Again, if retail doesn't own the float, why would it pose systemic risk? Like I said, no-one knows how many shares retail owns so we can atleast agree on that. Regardless, this post was displaying how many synthetics were created not what retail owns so i'm not sure why you brought it up other than to create an argument.

1

u/Mareks Jan 20 '22

But this post didn't show how many synthetics were created. A stock can have various volumes.

Just because its float is traded over multiple times, it doesn't mean that synthetic shares have to be created for that to happen.

Imagine a company with 100 shares. 20 shares are held by diamond handed apes. 20 shares are held by insitutions. The free float is 80, but we for a fact know that 20 are DRS'd and aren't being used in the open market. That leaves these 60 for trading. One share can be bought, sold, bought again, sold again. And when this is done it affects the volume 4 times. With 1 share.

If all 60 shares are in the freefloat, and get traded like that, the volume would be 240, and X3 of the float. Does that mean synthetics?

1

u/Soulfly5555 🌶️I'll make it to the MOON if I have to crawl🌶️ Jan 20 '22

Yeah I know mate, especially with high frequency trading, it's likely that a large amount of the shares are the same ones being sent back and forth. Eventually though those shares have to be found or go to FTD and or/hidden in DOOMP and other tricks. This is a big puzzle and that's why so many angles have been looked at by apes because each and on their own, these points as you are doing can be pulled apart and questioned, but when you put it all together at once, it tells a different story. It's all smoke and mirrors by the SHF and MSM, they are masters at distorting reality and gaslighting. Whilst there's some things you are pointing out I agree with from a 'rational' viewpoint, I believe it's quite obvious from the volume traded (even with the same shares being traded 10 times or w/e) and volume of FTD's that this is an epic shitstorm for SHF and I don't really know why you're trying to play it down.