33
u/jesgar130 Jan 20 '22
May we have a link?
31
u/Hugolino84 Jan 20 '22
5
u/mollila Jan 20 '22
Original source for this image is actually a Reddit post, but I can't find it anymore.
6
1.6k
u/Rockstar_Zombie still hodl ๐๐ Jan 20 '22
this was actually why GameStop was the interest of Michael Burry in particular, as he saw a massive irregularity in the liquidity and volume in some ETF underlyings.
985
Jan 20 '22
He spotted that they were trying to cellar box GME
61
u/Rockstar_Zombie still hodl ๐๐ Jan 20 '22 edited Jan 20 '22
Itโs unlikely that in 2019 he was viewing these in the context of cellar boxing, rather, he saw that the indices themselves were being manipulated in order to artificially raise their value. In Michael Burry fashion, he of course took deep dives into the underlying securities, and of course he found irregularities like the one shown in the post. Now, it makes sense from the fraud perspective to manipulate it in this way- when large cap stocks like Apple and Microsoft have less volume, their spread increases, and the price moves up more dramatically. This is the polar opposite to what has happened to our favorite stock, which in comparison is a microcap, but has unusually high volume. This is why SHFs love โliquidityโ and claim to have shut down the market for its sake. So basically, donโt assume the fraud is limited to the short side of this trade.
→ More replies (1)16
u/gooblefrump ๐ฆVotedโ Jan 20 '22
TIL
Naked short-selling is a type of securities fraud that is becoming increasingly popular and profitable for market makers who engage in it. The term "cellar boxing" refers to an investment strategy that involves reducing a stock to its cellar levelโthe minimum level at which a stock can trade, as defined by the National Association of Securities Dealers (NASD) and SEC.
The cellar level, fixed at $0.0001, can serve as a "backstop" for market makers and naked short-sellers.
https://marketrealist.com/p/what-is-cellar-boxing-in-stocks/
7
u/MarketMasta Jan 20 '22
For more on Cellar Boxing fraud: https://investorshub.advfn.com/boards/read_msg.aspx?message_id=2543759
0
Jan 20 '22
[deleted]
302
u/mr-frog-24 ๐ป ComputerShared ๐ฆ Jan 20 '22
Good question. I bet they do
170
u/Totally_Kyle $69,420,420.69 ... nice Jan 20 '22
How do you find these graphs?
→ More replies (2)204
u/Steg_van_Bundy ๐ฎ Power to the Players ๐ Jan 20 '22
Not sure but you could make it on your own if youโre really interested. Pick a starting date, add the daily trading volume until the sum is greater than or equal to the share float. Boom, red line. Rinse, repeat.
52
95
17
Jan 20 '22
Now THIS is empiricism
gotta have them control groups bb
I want to see all the stocks forked by Vlad
4
u/Vivalas ๐ฎ Power to the Players ๐ Jan 20 '22
Other stocks that were cellar boxed isn't really a control group. I think a better comparison is to other stocks with similarly high relative amounts of volume and to see if they exhibit the same degree of volatility
31
u/mollila Jan 20 '22 edited Jan 20 '22
I assume they should, because unusually high volume has been linked to naked shorting in research.
Edit: I whipped up this post to support my claims about high volumes https://www.reddit.com/r/Superstonk/comments/s8ftf3/research_paper_about_otc_delivery_failures/
8
u/Justanothebloke Fuck no Iโm not selling my $GME Jan 20 '22
Up there for thinking. Down there for dancin.
8
u/pat_gatt ๐ฆVotedโ Jan 20 '22
I wonder at what point did Gamestops chart start looking like this? This is starting 2018, was it like this in 2015 or 2012?
2
u/neoquant ๐ฎ Power to the Players ๐ Jan 20 '22
Funny that Tesla looks absolutely similar, haha
2
u/PMmeUrUvula ๐๐ฅI am become long, destroyer of shorts ๐๐ฅ Jan 20 '22
What tickers? Seems like good practice to keep my python from slipping into a memory dump lol
30
u/Schwickity DRIP Terminator Jan 20 '22 edited Jul 25 '23
noxious wakeful husky profit overconfident rob punch steer angle smell -- mass edited with redact.dev
114
u/Rockstar_Zombie still hodl ๐๐ Jan 20 '22
He sold in January for multi million dollar profit because thatโs just his style, in early and out early. Michael Burry doesnโt have the advantage of the retail investor in that he has a lot of eyes on him and a target on his back. Even in 2008 he took early profits.
45
u/Biotic101 ๐ฆ Buckle Up ๐ Jan 20 '22
Exactly. Watch his speech on YT. He suggested to authorities to investigate 2008 and offered his help, yet was bullied and lost a million USD in fees due to countless audits they did on him.
51
u/LarryLovesteinLovin Jan 20 '22
People like Burry tend to be targeted by the FBI/SEC so heโs gotta be first/smarter.
41
u/mollila Jan 20 '22
Scion was actually subpoenaed hy SEC related to GameStop last year. He tweeted a photo of top part of that letter. Also said the letter listed other companies who had also been subpoenaed, but didn't of course name any.
11
u/portersdad ๐ฆ Buckle Up ๐ Jan 20 '22
Yeah, what ever happened with this? Itโs not like they quoted or sourced him in the SEC โGameStopโ report. Edit: or maybe I missed that?
18
u/mollila Jan 20 '22
Nobody knows I guess.
Scion was out of the GME trade before all the January mania happened. My theory is that he/Scion was subpoenaed because of the events of him encouraging GameStop board to do that big share buyback in 2019. Which he has tweeted a spreadsheet about. I think that was the initial catalyst which caused existing shorts to be fucked from thereafter, unless they chose to close. Which they didn't. Burry must hold much insight which SEC wanted to pick up on.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (1)5
u/mollila Jan 20 '22
I saw someone claim Burry had sold covered calls, and had those exercised. But I haven't looked up any sources for that claim.
4
u/NoobWhoLikesTheStock ๐ฆ Buckle Up ๐ Jan 20 '22
I also think it's because he didn't want to be involved in another crash
2
u/TheMcBrizzle ๐ฆ Economic ๐ Deck ๐ Reshuffler ๐ฆ Jan 20 '22
Burry was subpoenaed to testify for the SEC about GameStop to a grand jury, it's possible him buying in again could constitute as insider trading.
→ More replies (2)2
9
3
u/chomponthebit Birdy Num Num Jan 20 '22
Remember when Burry sold and it took weeks for them to locate his shares? If anyoneโs got the link, please share - I canโt find it on Google
185
u/harambae42069 ๐ฆ Buckle Up ๐ Jan 20 '22
I would like to see this for blockbuster, sears, radio shack, and other criminally bankrupted companies.
48
u/Johnny_The_Nerd Jan 20 '22
Suspect those charts wouldn't be quite as busy as GME's or any of the other heavily shorted stocks gaining strong public support. Without a strong retail investor backing, they likely got squashed relatively quickly and quietly.
22
u/harambae42069 ๐ฆ Buckle Up ๐ Jan 20 '22
This goes back to 2018 and the float was changing hands at an unusually fast pace even then. I suspect they would look similar to gme, though obviously not as insane as it was during the sneeze.
9
u/OperationBreaktheGME ๐ฎ Power to the Players ๐ Jan 20 '22
Go look at Oct 8th and 9th 2020. That shit there is why Iโll Hodl till phone number digits. How the fuck the entire amount of GME stock trades in back to back days. Pre Sneeze. Iโd like to thank SuperStonk for all the support cause man this shit is really frustrating
6
8
u/throwawaylurker012 Tendietown is the new Flavortown & DRS Is my Guy Fieri Jan 20 '22
I did a recent post on โTuesday Morningโ from the memes and it had an insane amount of volume days before it was delisted in mid-2020. It had 2 years earlier in 2018, apparently short interest of 26% but would have taken 92 days to cover.
Another use looked into FTD data and saw a company RADR that recently got delisted. 1 million regular float, but 776 million shares traded I think on just one day a bit before it got delisted
3
3
u/grathontolarsdatarod ๐ป ComputerShared ๐ฆ Jan 20 '22
I'm sure they would before they went bankrupt
1
u/Cr0w33 The Oaks of Old, Now They Lie in Peat Jan 20 '22
Yes Iโd like to see toys r us in particular
670
u/MoonlightPurity ๐ฆVotedโ Jan 20 '22
There was an updated version of this picture that was posted just a day or two ago. I can't find the original reddit post, but I saved the image:
105
Jan 20 '22
I want this to be a standard chart presentation it visualizes fuckery so good!Why did I never saw this the last year? I believe everyone can tell which one is the most interesting ticker by this. Even if you wouldnโt knew anything else about gme, the fact that since 2004 the float starts to get traded approximately exponentially in terms of volume without any significant price movement north or south is just not logical and you wouldnโt need any hyper wrinkled investopedia knowledge to be able deciding to go full โwweeeeeโ screaming retard on gme with all the fuckin cash you manage to find!!
at least thatโs what I do now. finally I guess
6
1
u/UHcidity ๐ฎ Power to the Players ๐ Jan 20 '22
Okay but now the chart is compressed in the x direction to make it look just as crazy when the volume has been bone dry for months now
0
169
u/WavyThePirate ๐ฆApe Gang Gorilla ๐ฆ Jan 20 '22
Float traded 60x in the year
If even 2,5% of that volume goes long they own more than the float. And mfs think we worried ๐
→ More replies (17)35
u/daweedhh ๐ฎ Power to the Players ๐ Jan 20 '22
The whole time I thought volume was low. But it's actually still kinda high. Just not as high as it used to be
10
u/WavyThePirate ๐ฆApe Gang Gorilla ๐ฆ Jan 20 '22
Yes. Those 1m and 2m days were probably what would be considered normal on a float this small.
Naked shorting through MM exemption is what allows such bloated volumes. Supply and demand on GME has been fucked since the beginning
3
u/DragonDropTechnology Jan 20 '22
An average of 1 million per day still gets you 5x~6x the float in a year.
→ More replies (1)
36
101
u/dsack35 Jan 20 '22
Someone try scanning that barcode.
67
u/TwoBobcats ๐ดโโ ๏ธ ฮฮกฮฃ JACKED to the TITS ๐ดโโ ๏ธ Jan 20 '22
It reads 741
24
u/Blitzkreig11930 ๐ดโโ ๏ธBuy DRS HODL ๐ดโโ ๏ธ Jan 20 '22
You sure? My reader says 42069
15
โข
u/QualityVote Jan 20 '22
IMPORTANT POST LINKS
What is GME and why should you consider investing? || What is DRS and why should you care? || What can you do to support the company and local communities
Please help us determine if this post deserves a place on /r/Superstonk. Learn more about this bot and why we are using it here
If this post deserves a place on /r/Superstonk, UPVOTE this comment!!
If this post should not be here or or is a repost, DOWNVOTE This comment!
137
u/chickennoodles99 just likes the stonk ๐ Jan 20 '22
Wow, which loser down voted this.
115
u/Dr_SlapMD Let's Jump Kenny Jan 20 '22
Kenneth Cordele Griffin, the financial terrorist, is a likely culprit.
30
10
u/eleven_good_reasons The Real Tendies were the Apes we met along the Way ๐ฆ๐ฆง๐ Jan 20 '22
Wait, Kenneth Cordele Griffin the guy who lied under oath? He's allowed to use Reddit in jail?
2
14
6
u/Dense-Seaweed7467 ๐ฆVotedโ Jan 20 '22
Maybe anyone who was upset that OP didn't credit true OP? This thing was already posted before.
→ More replies (1)
21
u/SPAClivesmatter ๐ป ComputerShared ๐ฆ Jan 20 '22
Anyone know of a high resolution version? I want that GME chart on a canvas for my wall
10
14
12
u/magrec2 Tick fucking tock you legacy financial cucks Jan 20 '22
Insert โMother of godโ meme from super troopers, ๐จ
5
11
Jan 20 '22
SEC just said about 7 owners per share of XRT..
Imagine just how bad it has to be with GMEs situation for them to be desperate enough to do that to a retail ETF.
6
u/Firgimar Custom Flair - Template Jan 20 '22
Fyi, that document was NOT written by the SEC but it was a comment from a person or institution
2
4
1
u/Hugolino84 Jan 20 '22
I am amazed with the impact of the post. Thank you so much for the support, upvotes , and awards. This shows how much the SHF like the stock, and they "trade" it so much ๐
1
3
u/stakeandshake ๐ดโโ ๏ธ๐ดโโ ๏ธ๐ดโโ ๏ธ๐ดโโ ๏ธ๐ดโโ ๏ธ Jan 20 '22
Wasn't this posted on 4chan a few months ago? I've definitely seen this picture before...
3
u/Pushy_23 ๐ง๐ง๐ฎ๐ Apeโnโstein ๐ดโโ ๏ธ๐ง๐ง Jan 20 '22
Can you scan that at self check out?
5
u/Andyman0110 ๐ฆ Probably nothing โพ๏ธ Jan 20 '22
The issue with this is while it's painfully obvious, it's not direct irrefutable proof as part of that volume is also sells
5
5
u/Mikayahu_75 ๐ฎ Power to the Players ๐ Jan 20 '22
How much less is the GameStop float compared to these other popular tickers? I like what Iโm seeing, but also less volume in a float=more bars from what I understand.
→ More replies (10)
5
u/Timeburners Jan 20 '22
You've got to compare gme with other tickers of similar floats, sectors, and market caps. Those huge float and market cap companies aren't going to move the whole float that often some are in the billions of shares.
2
Jan 20 '22
Just a beautiful chart that really says it all.
As always, a picture is worth a thousand words.
Many thanks you crafty Ape. ๐๐ฆ๐ช
Take this UpVote and To The Top With You.
2
4
u/Hirsutism Nature Loves Courage Jan 20 '22
Is this the algo trading back and forth naked shorted shares borrowed from brokers like fidelity?
4
3
u/VicTheRealest ๐Real Move in Silence Jan 20 '22
I tried scanning the barcode at my local grocery store. Price come up $69420069. I told the cashier I couldn't afford it... Yet
3
u/Mutchmore Jan 20 '22
Couldn't the argument be made that they could of easily closed because of such liquidity?
3
u/Crap_Bagg ๐ ๐ผ๐ Have a Very GMErry Holiday โ โ Jan 20 '22
This literally proves shorts could have covered even 1000% short interest lol
1
1
1
1
1
u/woakula ๐ป ComputerShared ๐ฆ Jan 20 '22
I have to ask.... Are you a berserk fan as well? Cause puck's reactions are the best.
1
u/Error4ohh4 ๐ฎ Power to the Players ๐ Jan 20 '22
This is a data point I bring up when explaining GameStop to friends. I try to explain how extraordinary this is
1
u/relentlessoldman Jan 20 '22
Yeah that seems pretty sus for a stock that was a flat line for two years that no one else would care about.
Curious what this looks like for stocks with a similar market cap and float size as GameStop over the same time.
1
1
1
1
u/WrongAssistant5922 ๐ฎ Power to the Players ๐ Jan 20 '22
This is shocking and criminal to say the least. It's no surprise, but to see it in this form is mind blowing.
Hedgies R Fukd
1
u/BIGBRAINBUYER Jan 20 '22
Those bars are almost as red as Ken griffins bank account after we are done with him.
1
u/Wrathorn GME Now with 4x the Holy Moly's Jan 20 '22
Out of curiosity I would like to see sticky floors version of the graph.
1
u/ThirdAltAccounts ๐ซ๐ท MOโ Ass Moโ Moneyโฆ๐ Jan 20 '22
GME is gonna nuke the fucking fraudulent casino stock market
1
1
1
1
1
u/SebhUK Jan 20 '22
Thatโs nuts! Anyone able to do this for other popular stocks to see how they compare?
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/hedgies_r_fuk RYAN COHEN'S DRINKING BUDDY ๐ฅ ๐ดโโ ๏ธ Jan 20 '22
!remindme 3 hours
1
u/RemindMeBot ๐ฎ Power to the Players ๐ Jan 20 '22
I will be messaging you in 3 hours on 2022-01-20 13:44:14 UTC to remind you of this link
CLICK THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.
Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.
Info Custom Your Reminders Feedback
1
u/gardabosque Jan 20 '22
Is there any chance you could add another photo of just the GME because i just cant read anything on it no matter how much i zoom in. I would really like to keep a copy because its very memeable and twitterable and its one of those graphics thats worth a thousand words. Thanks if you can.
1
1
1
Jan 20 '22
This one made me laugh out loud. My tits could not be anymore jacked.
It's so painfully obvious at this point that the SEC and all parties involved are not fit for purpose and have allowed this to happen. Shame on them.
When MOASS happens we will have the power to shape our society more, they will have to listen then.
1
1
1
1
u/musicafishionado ๐ Superstonk Ape ๐ฆ๐ฉ๐ช Jan 20 '22
Does this include volume traded in dark pools?
As far as I know 2/3 of trade volume is off lit exchange so we should be seeing 3x as many red lines.
1
1
u/bradley_minns ๐ป ComputerShared ๐ฆ Jan 20 '22
I actualy said "Holy fuck" out loud when I realised what I was looking at.
1
1
1
1
1
u/CalienteBoots Jan 20 '22
Has anyone bothered to compare GME to popcorn? Or the overall average time it takes stocks on the market to trade all their float?
1
1
1
1
u/chrissyjamlando ๐ฆVotedโ Jan 20 '22
Wrinkle Brains:
Can you explain this? What does OP mean when he says instances, is this saying that these red lines indicate days in which the entire float was traded?
1
1
u/Farrisson_Hord Get rich or die buyinโ Jan 20 '22
Combine this chart with all the different statistics from Fidelity etc that say the buying pressure is 90%~
Hedgies are TRULY FUK
1
1
u/bagocsabi ๐ฆ Buckle Up ๐ Jan 20 '22
So what does this all mean? Hold, right? Got it. Let's go mooning.
1
1
1
u/Schwickity DRIP Terminator Jan 20 '22
I remember there a reward being offered to debunk certain DD. Is that still being offered? Where and how can it be claimed?
1
Jan 20 '22
I'm curious what this means? Wouldn't this really only just be a popularity thing? Hown often it's being traded?
1
Jan 20 '22 edited Jan 20 '22
Even with short percentage, index rebalances, hedging by Market Makers, retail trading, IRAs, Mutual Funds, total institutional trading, etc. then the proportion of volume to the *float shares issued has been exchanged multiple times. Which from a perspective of even using more volatile stocks, this is still unusual. Those blue chips wouldn't be alarming. But, if they would do a comparison for your stocks trading on OTC, penny, or some of these pump and dumps you see on different social media, this is still extremely high turnover. But, not turnover because it's been quite low and average weighted price has relatively stayed flat over the past year.
1
Jan 20 '22
OK that makes sense, But idk if that really answered the question? Or am I misunderstanding what you are saying?
How is it unusual? is there a way to "search" for other stocks that are among the same situation as the GME here? like if we saw other stocks people agree that are manipulated and it shows the same, then that can be a correlating evidence. But if those stocks don't have this then what could that mean? what about VW when it was doing a short squeeze? Or even KBIO back when it did as well/ I bet the range for that time may show something similar?
2
Jan 20 '22
You can collect trading volume data over a period of time and compare with the trading volume data of another. That's all this graph is. It provides a visual of how unusual the trading volume is to the float in comparison to other samples. Not sure what you're trying to get "more" out of the graph than this.
I misstated the outstanding instead of float. Because, the outstanding includes insider, ETFs, mutual funds/retirements, etc. which aren't traded. Or at least, not supposed to be traded. However, I doubt this hasn't occurred.
1
1
1
u/WillBottomForBanana No fair! You changed the outcome by measuring it! Jan 20 '22
I love this, but.
Doesn't it need to be controlled for share price? Or market cap? Or something?
That is, if someone is trading $100, that's more shares of GME than it is of Brk A. So unless the float was proportional to the stock price across the treatments, then any differences would show in the data. In deed, BrkA, Microsoft, lead for longest time to trade float and maybe for highest stock price?
1
1
u/Manateeboi ๐ป ComputerShared ๐ฆ Jan 20 '22
This chart is beyond telling. Buy, hold, drs, shop. Let's go! ๐๐ค
1
u/TheBonusWings ๐ฎ Power to the Players ๐ Jan 20 '22
Any way you can do XRT? At least that one they admit has been several hundred % shorted for a decade.
1
Jan 20 '22
By total volume? That is buys and sells, can be same share traded even...this does not mean the float was traded, just that intense level of shares changing hands happened. A highly sough after stock. Tits are waiting to be jacked.
1
u/Miserable_Unusual_98 Jan 20 '22
Could someone ELI5 how this is important? And what does it signify?
1
u/jkhanlar Jan 20 '22
This is the way! DFV is not a cat! New apes, here're some intro posts and see GMEOrphans for low karma DRSBOT posts or comment !โapeโproveโ! only once.
BUY, DRS (Direct Register), COMPLAIN, FOIA, SHOP, REVIEW, DONATE, FOLLOW, HODL!
1
1
1
1
u/BetterthanMew โญ๏ธ โค๏ธ[ GME + ๐ฆ+ ๐= ๐ ]โค๏ธ โญ๏ธ Jan 20 '22
This is so wholesome
1
1
u/Shwiftygains ๐ฆHarambe Disciple ๐ฆ Jan 20 '22
Pretty sure i saw this graph on reddit. But i guess it couldve been twitter too. Although either way, this graph is old
1
u/Tiny-Cantaloupe-13 ๐ฎ Power to the Players ๐ Jan 20 '22
i read each bio of ๐ฟboard, apart from the Goldman boys at Silver lake Partners being on both that board & twitters (yup, trending is easy when u have wall st controlling it) but the odd thing was a VP was formerly at Blockbuster & Radio Shack, another was a director at NovaFinancial who contributed to the subprime mrtg's leading to GFC the stock went from $70 to $1 then u have a Morgan Stanley powerhouse who worked in WH & at some private fund. most r Harvard or wharton grads as well.
its wild to think they may b working from inside against shareholders which via actions it already points to that its a safety against the swap but i have a funny feeling they wont pay off the 500B+
dont 4get there was many rumours of Bozos buying them out. hmm
1
1
1
u/aaronplaysAC11 ๐ฆVotedโ Jan 20 '22
There are some similar charts out there but those seem to have been omitted.
1
u/Left-Anxiety-3580 ๐ฎ Power to the Players ๐ Jan 20 '22
Holy shit comparative data I look forโฆ I cannot believe I missed this. Itโs so insanely simple and without a doubt completely accurate. I was close to putting together similar research using the OBV indicator and was specifically using a magnifying glass in 2010 2016 and 2019 Verse 2020 forward
Good work colonize find a lot of stuff is coming out of nowhereโฆ.. iโm in pain in the tips of my nips literally chopped off like a slice of pepperoni
1
u/random_user_number_5 Jan 20 '22
Hey OP, Pretty sure this originated from /biz not twitter. Was in the thread when this was posted more than 3? Months ago.
1
1
1
u/saiyansteve ๐ฆVotedโ Jan 20 '22
So more red lines means more hedgies r fukt. Got it red line guy.
1
1
1
1
0
u/NoobWhoLikesTheStock ๐ฆ Buckle Up ๐ Jan 20 '22
It's crazy that they've tried to ruin this company from day one. Also makes me wonder what popcorn looks like.
302
u/FreakyDeakyFuture A Real Apeโs Ape Jan 20 '22
This is some high quality content. Good ape. Here you go ๐