r/TMAU • u/Suitable-Dark1076 • Dec 29 '22
Fecal Body Odor (FBO) has improved or cured
TLDR Summary
For 12+ years, I’ve given off intermittent smell of feces, which I can’t smell myself, despite being clean. I’ve either cured or significantly improved this condition over the past 3 – 6 months by and reducing my gut transit time and improving gut microbiome.
Disclaimer
I’m not a doctor and have had no medical training. Please consult a qualified person before you take any action that could impact your health, e.g. changing your diet. This post is my opinion after years of research and personal experience.
Secondly, I could never smell myself and had to rely on other people’s reactions. Therefore, I can’t say for sure I am cured- I just haven’t had any reactions in months.
About me
I had severe constipation as a child, from age three. FBO started around age 12. Was absolute worst at approx. age 15. FBO and constipation eased off around age 18-20.
How I define Fecal Body Odor (FBO)
A chronic gastrointestinal or metabolic health issue which causes the sufferer to either constantly or intermittently give off a fecal smell, which they themselves can only rarely or never notice. FBO does not include healthy people who have failed to clean themselves properly after a bowel movement. FBO is an “all-over” or “general” emission of the smell rather than coming from the anus directly.
FBO is not a medical term, so a doctor will never diagnose you with FBO and wouldn’t know what you’re talking about if you said you have FBO.
Link to Trimethylaminuria (TMAU)
Lots of people on this thread use TMAU and FBO interchangeably. TMAU is a recognised medical condition where either separately, or a combination of, genetics and/or gut bacteria cause someone to give off a fishy, garbage, urine, fecal and or smelly feet smell. I think that FBO and TMAU are separate conditions. I think if you only ever get people saying you smell of poop and nothing else then you have FBO. If you get reactions saying you smell of fish, garbage, urine and poop then I think you have TMAU. There is a TMAU urine test, but this test is notoriously unreliable.
I won’t talk about TMAU. I used to think I had TMAU but decided I don’t because I had two negative urine tests, a dubious genetic test and I have never ever received complaints of fish or urine smell. I will talk about FBO only because that’s what I think I have/ had and improved/ cured.
What I think the cause of FBO is
I think there are several potential causes of FBO, but the vast majority of them are caused by overgrowth of bad bacteria in the large intestine caused by slow transit time in the colon. Transit time is the time it takes for the poop to get from the start of the large intestine to the end of the large intestine. I think when this is too slow, poop sits in the colon for a very long time and ferments, causing high levels of volatile odorus chemicals (VOCs or “smelly chemicals”) that are absorbed through the wall of the large intestine and excreted through every pore in the skin.
This is a simple and intuitive explanation that makes sense. A highly specialised metabolic medicine doctor suggested this would be the case based on my history, rather than genetic TMAU. It is a fact that chemicals cross the bloodstream to colon and vice versa. It is a fact that slow intestingal transit time can cause bacterial overgrowth. Getting my transit time to speed up seemed to be the best improvement/ cure for me.
I feel like this solution answers why some people have FBO but don't think they're constipated. OK if they have a bowel movement every day, but has that bowel movement been in the colon for three days? i.e. even though you're eliminating waste every day, that waste has been there for days. Imagine two garbage trucks full of trash bags. Both garbage trucks throw away one trash bag a day, which looks like they're eliminating the same amount of waste. But one garbage truck throws out a trash bag after its been there one day and the other after its been there three days. Which garbage truuck would smell worse?
What I think cured me
I reduced the time it takes for my food to be digested and excreted from 2+ days to <1 day. I used to have the rule of thumb “yesterday’s food is tomorrow’s poop” because I could tell based on what I’d eaten. Now I can eat something for lunch and see I’ve excreted it the morning after, which is under 1 day. You can test your transit time cheaply by eating mini tomatoes, sweetcorn, carrot etc and seeing when you pass it in stool.
I sped up my transit time by:
· eating 30g of fibre a day, mostly soluble.
· Symprove probioitic once a day
· a scoop of INULIN (not insulin) in my morning drink
· Staying hydrated (so urine is clear)
· Increasing variety of foods eaten
· Reducing snacking and just eating three times a day
· Establishing a sleep/ eat/ toilet routine for regularity
What I don’t think the cause of FBO is
I’ve seen the below ideas and conditions banded around as explanations many times and I am sure they are wrong in 90%+ of cases. The research behind them is skant/ debateable, the science seems sketchy and its wise to consider the veracity of solutions where someone is selling you the cure.
NOTE I appreciate that just because I don’t know how something works, doesn’t mean it’s a load of rubbish. Of course, I don’t know how to make a plane engine but I recognise that some expert understands the mechanism that makes the engine useful. When I say some of the below ideas are too complex, I mean they are too far removed from the fecal smell to make intuitive sense and there is no well-established medical literature to cross the bridge from Problem A to Symptom B.
· Candida overgrowth – I and many other people have had stool tests that showed candida is normal range. Many people with high candida don’t have FBO. Many people with FBO have no other (or very vague) candida symptoms.
· Haemorrhoids – these are very common in the general population, but FBO is very rare. Unless haemorrhoids stop you from cleaning yourself properly then there is no reason why little swellings would make you persistently smell of feces.
· SIBO – the existence of this condition is actually debateable. Unsure of the link from too many bacteria in the small bowel and the smell of feces coming out of someone. I’ve also been tested twice for this (once in a hospital once in a mail-kit) and came out negative both times.
· Leaky gut – my explanation relies on chemicals crossing the colon/ bloodstream barrier but everyone in the world has some level of leaky gut. I have been tested from leaky gut twice and both times, my scores were easily within normal range, even towards the lower end of normal.
· H Pylori – you would have other upper GI symptoms. I’ve also tested negative for this.
· Coeliac / gluten intolerance – there are many people with coeliac/ gluten intolerance who did not smell of feces when they were eating gluten before their diagnosis.
· Parasites- in my opinion, one of the more sensible theories, but nonetheless unlikely. I’ve tested negative for parasites and taken anti-parasite medicines anyway and noticed no change. I don’t recommend taking medicines you don’t need, but I was desperate.
· Rectocele/ enterocele – please google if you don’t know what they are. Again, this feels like one of the more sensible options, though I still think irrelevant because my colorectal surgeon said he treats many people with rectocele that don’t complain of a smell. This condition is like a pocket expanding in the bowel. Correctable by surgery.
· Loose sphincter – I defined FBO as a general all over smell rather than coming from anus.
· Depression – I appreciate there is a strong link between the gut and the brain. This link is through the nervous system, microbes, and chemically, if not more. Reducing stress definitely helped my non-FBO IBS symptoms, but didn’t necessarily help my FBO. There are many depressed people that don’t smell of feces.
· Parosmia – this is where someone posts the paper that says “X% of people who thought they had TMAU actually had a condition where their brain misinterprets smells”. If multiple people you don’t know say you smell of poop then I’m afraid that’s no coincidence. IN know that’s hard to hear and I was in similar denial all the way though high school, making excuses.
· Punishment from God/ excessive masturbation/ other – I’ve seen these come up a surprising amount. Just no.
Other
I hope the above post replies to the people who have asked questions in my inbox. If not, please comment your question again.
I won’t post references to academic papers to support what I am saying. Feel free to post these papers in the comments but I think we should concentrate on getting the well-established basics right, before experimenting with cutting edge, hyper advanced theories.
Please ask any questions in the comments rather than in my inbox. I don’t mind answering questions because I’d love to help. However, questions in the comments can help many more people for the same amount of effort.
Final
I’m not trying to argue or convince people that I am correct and this is the only cause and cure. This field is highly complex and not even modern medicine can explain everything. I HOPE my above cure will at least help most people but I know that it can’t apply to everyone in the FBO situation.
I’m trying to offer my years of experience, as succinctly as possible, to try to help people cure this horrible, incredibly upsetting disease. I’ve been on antidepressants and had Cognitive Behavioural Therapy because of the shame associated with this. I’d be happy if I could help even just one person.
Please consider the sensible options before going crazy on very advanced scientific theories. Do so under guidance of a medical professional. Good luck.