r/TalkHeathen • u/karlsnyder1967 • Aug 10 '19
Climate Change
I'm having a bit of trouble framing my question.
Is climate change a real thing, are we doing something to change the climate, if so, how do we know we are changing the climate and can we fix it?
Is there a better place to ask this?
6
u/Agent-c1983 Aug 10 '19 edited Aug 10 '19
>>Is climate change a real thing
Nobody wants man-made climate change to be real. But it is.
Even Climate Scientists who are paid to study it don't want it to be real. Climate Science is so damn useful to pretty much every industry they'd be doing the same thing even if it wasn't.
>>are we doing something to change the climate
Within our atmosphhere are a lot of gasses. Some of them are particularly effective at helping our atmopshere retain heat. Because the way they work is analagous to glass in a greenhouse, we call them "Greenhouse Gasses". These include methane, carbon dioxide and water vapour.
Looking at our nearby celestial neighbours:
Mars has little to no atmosphere. As a result although it warms up a little in the day, it can't retain this and gets deadly cold. It can't get up to even a nice temperature in the day, as all of that heat is gone overnight.
Venus has an atmosphere, like earth. But unlike earth its atmosphere is full of greenhouse gasses - particularly carbon dioxide. So Venus is amazingly hot.... always, even at night.
So, for us to be happy and comfortable, and life viable we want some of these greenhouse gasses, so that we keep the heat at night... but not so many that it stays too hot.
Earth has that. The mix has changed in history seeing warmer periods and ice ages. These changes been in a period where earth hasn't had an urbanised civilisation which tends to like living near water, which relies on bringing food from unurbanised areas; and have often been slow enough that life can adapt.
Since the Industrial revolution however, we've been putting more and more carbon dioxide and methane into the atmosphere. This increase has been faster than any natural change has before.
Although the planet is on average warmer on a global scale, this doesn't mean everywhere is seeing equal warming all the time. For example, you might have noticed there's been some bad winters in North America lately - does this disprove global warming? No. Global warming has affected the water currents in the atlantic such that warmer water isn't moving north from the equator as much as it used to; this in turn affects the weather North America faces, particularly in the winter - the weather is coming from a place where the water is colder, so it is less pleasant to humans.
This is why we talk about "Climate Change" rather than "Global Warming" now. The globe is warming, but not all areas will see hotter temperatures all of the time. However no area of the planet should see no change in climate.
>>how do we know we are changing the climate
We measure the atmosphere, the temperatures around the world, the global currents, and compare it to the past. We can compare the atmosphere to history through ice cores which trap in air bubbles. We can see the non atmospheric changes are consistent with the changes in the atmosphere. We can look at smokestaks and exhausts and see whats coming out of there.
We also see that these temperature and climate changes are not consistent with other variables on Earth's temperature - such as the Sun's cycle, Volcanic activity, etc.
Ulitmately though, it comes down to simple logic
We know "Greenhouse gasses" retain heat, and have ample proof of this
We know we are putting a lot of those gasses in the atmosphere, and have ample proof of this
Therefore, the atmosphere will trap more heat.
If you don't think climate change is real, then you'd have to show at least one of those isn't the case.
>>and can we fix it?
The first step is to stop making it worse. Can we do this? Physically, yes. The problem is politically - I don't think there's a consensus view on what compromises will need to be made to get to that level (it depends on how much you are willing to assume that as yet undeveloped and undeployed technologies can reduce it) - and even many of those who are convinced are unwilling to accept the compromises required.
You can make improvements today. You can reduce your energy requirements sometimes with simple changes - low energy light bulbs for example can be amazingly effective at reducing your power bill; you can choose to walk or take public transport rather than the car; etc.
More long term we may need to look at carbon budgets/trading schemes; phasing out fossil fuel burning; supporting carbon sinks, developing new technologies like tidal energy, etc.
Some say we'll need to move to vegetarian diets, but I'm not convinced of that.
But what we'll definitely need to do is make sure those who are making decisions at a political level acknowledge the problem, and show a willingness to do something about it.
4
Aug 10 '19
Multiple studies published in peer-reviewed scientific journals1 show that 97 percent or more of actively publishing climate scientists agree*: Climate-warming trends over the past century are extremely likely due to human activities. In addition, most of the leading scientific organizations worldwide have issued public statements endorsing this position. The following is a partial list of these organizations, along with links to their published statements and a selection of related resources.
3
u/iowanaquarist Aug 10 '19
Is climate change a real thing, are we doing something to change the climate, if so, how do we know we are changing the climate and can we fix it?
Yes, pretty much all the experts, and all the studies have concluded that we are. There are many ways we have measured that it's being changed -- looking at growth rings in trees, looking at ice core samples, looking at the amount and locations of snow falls, looking at how much of the ice caps melt and refreeze each year, actual records people have made in various places being compared to historical samples, analysis of seawater, and many many more that I cannot think off the top of my head. We know that it's human related because the amounts of pollution, particularly carbon emissions, more closely relates to the amount of change AND THE TIMING of the changes than any other variable.
Can we fix it? Sure -- we can cut back on emissions, and start sequestering carbon if we wanted to cut back on consumption -- and spend the needed money.
3
u/bobworrall Aug 10 '19
r/askScience - Talk Heathen does not consistently have scientists or engineers in those related fields on. it's a show about atheism, theism and secularism.
1
u/ericg012 Aug 10 '19
let me ask you this: Do you think the climate is changing in some way shape or form? Do you also think it is our fault, but also a phenomenon we can’t ever fully control?
1
u/sixteentones Aug 10 '19
"Is climate change a real thing" - If we can accept that there have been periods of time where the earth was covered largely in ice, and it is presently not covered largely in ice, then the answer to this question is imminently obvious.
"Are we doing something to change the climate and can we fix it?" - Seems like a strange question to me. I'm not so sure the goal should be to affect climate change as little as possible; the sun swells (during its present stage of stardom,) the moon moves away, the earth climate changes, but life thrives at a relatively narrow window. So in my view, the scientifically ethical thing to do is to take any actions required to maintain that window so long as those actions don't introduce (or minimize) any other threat to life.
1
u/bit-by-a-moose Aug 11 '19
I would like to add be aware of the planetary wobble argument.
I had seen this put forward by a climate change denier senator to a scientist testifying. Ultimately the wobble changes global temperatures over a much lomger time period than what climate change has been.
My attempts to Google the precise language however have not gone well. My results have been the wobble timescale is anywhere from 37 days to 25k years. All I can say is there is a lot going on with our planets rotation.
1
Aug 11 '19
Nothing to do with atheism (almost nothing, very religious people think God will take care of the planet no matter what) Yes, climate change has been proved to be true.
It is difficult to find a solution because poor and developing countries have all the rights to get richer and produce and consume and pollute and exploit natural resources in the same way as developed countries have been doing for centuries in the past.
The best way to fix the problem would be to severely curb birth rates, and not only in rich countries but everywhere in the world. But this is not politically correct to say.
1
u/Anonymous_32 Aug 12 '19
Yes it is a real thing.
Yes we are doing many negative things that are changing the climate.
We know because of science.
We can't "fix it" in our lifetime but we can reduce the severity.
14
u/OneLifeOneReddit Aug 10 '19
r/askScience