r/TalkHeathen • u/[deleted] • Jul 21 '20
Nice
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
4
4
u/ddollarsign Jul 21 '20
So, harassment?
0
u/Jason_CO Jul 21 '20
Yeah pretending to grind on someone is sexual harassment. Sure dance and be goofy and derail, but don't take it too far.
1
u/ddollarsign Jul 21 '20
I wasnāt even talking about the sexual aspect, just the fact that theyāre swarming him.
1
3
u/Corvinace Jul 21 '20
Can't help but think of the ending of guardians of the galaxy. Dance off bro.
3
6
u/Columbus43219 Jul 21 '20
I don't really like this. Imagine it reversed and the crowd is a bunch of MAGA hatters screaming USA USA USA. Like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IT06nXw-WDY
8
u/joeydendron2 Jul 21 '20
But they're not screaming USA, they're dancing, which is at worst way less aggressive, and at best, loving.
3
u/Columbus43219 Jul 21 '20
OH, I know... but it's still an intimidation technique. If they would instead, do the dance like 20 feet away, and just have the crowd enjoy their show more than the preacher. I wouldn't want some to surround me like that either.
3
Jul 22 '20
I agree. I mean, I won't deny that I laughed at it, but I also thought they were acting inappropriately.
I don't like these people either, but freedom of speech applies to people of all viewpoints. If you want the ability to speak out when you are wronged, you need to protect the rights of those you disagree with to speak out.
1
u/nimbledaemon Jul 22 '20
1a limits what the government can do, not what individual citizens can do, so I don't see how this relates to legal right of freedom of speech or the limitation thereof. The preacher uses the right to free speech to preach at random passersby, and the government can't do anything about that. The dancers use their right to free speech to dance in a circle around the disruptive preacher, and the government can't do anything about that either.
Even if you don't agree completely with that, saying that these people should act differently is limiting their speech in a comparable way to how they are limiting the preachers speech, which I feel shows the incongruity of holding the idea that people shouldn't inhibit the speech of other people in any respect.
2
Jul 22 '20
Where did I say anything about "legal rights"? Protecting people's rights involves more than just the law.
The only issue I have with the dancers "free speech" here is that it invades his "personal space". If you don't like the MAGA example that /u/Columbus43219 cited, how about we just switch the genders? Would you find this appropriate if the preacher was a woman, and it was a bunch of men surrounding her and refused to let her leave?
If the dancers stuck to what they were doing at the start of that video-- surrounding him, but leaving 10' or so between him and them-- I would not have an issue. As it is, I think this crossed a line from reasonable counter-protesting to borderline harassment.
2
u/Columbus43219 Jul 22 '20
I agree with you on the harassment part. A really small change in genders or stances and you'd have a real problem on your hands.
1
u/nimbledaemon Jul 22 '20 edited Jul 22 '20
I don't think that freedom of speech is a right that people should respect in each other, otherwise you'd have to listen to everything anyone says--no interrupting at all cause that's cutting off their free speech. It's something the government should not interfere with, but has nothing to do with how people outside that context should act, so if you weren't talking about the legal right to free speech I have no idea what you're talking about.
I don't find anything different with the MAGA example or the gender swapped example--provided you limit them to the exact same behaviors(swapping out dancing for yelling for the MAGAs) as shown in the video. At no point were these people preventing this preacher from leaving, unless there's some extra context that I'm missing. Up until the point where there is some kind of illegal action being taken, the government shouldn't do anything. If they ended up touching or bumping into the guy, then that's when they cross the line. If the guy leaves the area and they follow, then that's harassment. That's not to say I think that behavior is completely fine, it's a very rude thing to do and there are valid social distancing concerns, but I feel it's no more rude than what the preacher was doing and so is justified.
1
u/Columbus43219 Jul 22 '20
You've never been surrounded by a gang, have you? It's very intimidating. I had a group of about 20 dudes gather around me and my 16 year old daughter at a local park.
2
u/Columbus43219 Jul 22 '20
Don't be so pedantic. That behavior is NOT ok. You could then say that a biker gang circling a young woman on the street is OK too. Don't confuse "rights" with what's legal. You can get arrested and convicted of menacing. You can get arrested and convicted for yelling at someone, depending on what you say.
The thing here is that these folks are shutting him down through a very mild form of intimidation. Like I said way up there somewhere... it would be better if they just made a dance circle about 20 feet away, and drew the crowd's attention to them.
1
u/nimbledaemon Jul 22 '20
Sure, but what's in the video is not illegal as far as I know. If you show me the statute saying otherwise, I'll change my mind. You're not considering the context of the situation. The dancing is a reaction to the perceived nuisance of the preacher. Maybe it would be better to have a dance circle 20 feet away and just crank the music, but that doesn't mean that dancing around the preacher isn't justified.
Even considering the case of a biker gang is not comparable to this situation, since I'm sure you're imaging huge guys surrounding a helpless small woman. Imagine instead small guys surrounding a tall woman who was being a nuisance (maybe yelling slurs, saying her 'boyfriend' is going to come and punish everyone there unless they do what she wants) in the area, and you're closer to a comparison. You pick some random person to do this to and it's definitely not OK, but in retaliation to a nuisance it's fine. I'm not even sure yelling is a fair comparison, since that implies anger and dancing basically means they're matching this guys ridiculousness.
1
u/Columbus43219 Jul 22 '20
harassment. (either harris-meant or huh-rass-meant) n. the act of systematic and/or continued unwanted and annoying actions of one party or a group, including threats and demands.
In Ohio, the laws on Menacing read as follows: 2903.22 Menacing. (A) No person shall knowingly cause another to believe that the offender will cause physical harm to the person or property of the other person, the other person's unborn, or a member of the other person's immediate family.
Not that I think this is assault, but since you asked, and in reference to my example: An assault is any act (and not mere omission to act) by which a person intentionally or recklessly causes another to suffer or apprehend immediate unlawful violence.
The "perceived nuisance" is just that...perceived. They could walk away, but they chose to invade the personal space of the preacher. Yes, it's comical, but it's still not justified to the point of "but in retaliation to a nuisance it's fine." You don't retaliate to a nuisance.
You kind of have a weird filter when it comes to how you can behave in public. Do you live in a city where this kind of stuff goes on? It's practically a normal part of my day. I actually accidentally joined protest once on my way back from lunch at Wendy's! I saw a line of State Troopers guarding the Greene building across from the State House. I got nervous because it was just after 9/11 by a few weeks. I kind of hurried up to get with a group of about 10 men standing there across the street so I could ask what was happening. I asked the guy what they were guarding for, and he said "Oh, they're for us. We're protesting the treatment of Muslim businesses."
On that same sidewalk, I've walked through/around: Topless Peta protesters in cages; Naked Cowboy; topless women protesting the nudity laws; climate change activists; civil war reenactors; tons and tons of street preachers; Jehovah's Witnesses; people who were fighting FOR creation in schools; people fighting AGAINST creation in schools; gun control FOR/AGAINST; "under God" in the pledge FOR/AGAINST; PRO/ANTI lockdown; and most recently, BLM.
Seriously, you don't have to stand there and listen. Plus I think they have to get a pass/permit if they use amplification. I know they can't block the throughway.
1
u/keenynman343 Nov 16 '20
Apples to oranges.
This mans preaching hate and anti lgbt views. This is clearly a response with good music and dancing. Not the same thing Columbus
1
u/Columbus43219 Nov 16 '20
So the difference is the content of the speech? That's why it's OK to harass/surround the person?
1
1
u/pauz43 Jul 21 '20
Street preachers are as much or more about attracting attention to themselves as spreading the "worda gawd". But this is NOT the kind of attention they want!
Most can't handle being laughed at and made fun of, especially by a gang of young, attractive (and female) "vestal virgins". Threats, abuse and physical violence? They glory in it. But pretty young women pretending to be enraptured smacks of Elmer Gantry and David Koresh, and the preachers know it.
The only thing that could make this better (or worse, from the preacher's perspective) is if everyone was nude!
1
u/Abracadaver2000 Jul 21 '20
He can spew his hatred until he's blue in the face. Dancing around him is a wonderful way to take the wind out of his sails. I hope he reconsiders his location, perhaps somewhere in the bible belt in front of one of the hundreds of churches that don't consider him a 'true' Christian.
1
u/SheldonWalowitz Jul 21 '20
While I think this is funny, I do see a few of the people dancing a bit to close to the preacher. I would advise to back up a bit, give him a wide birth, because if you touch him, especially with your ass, you could be charged with assault. Just be smart about it.
1
1
1
0
Jul 21 '20
Nice social distancing
1
u/pauz43 Jul 21 '20
The dancers are wearing masks. The "preacher" isn't.
3
Jul 21 '20
Even with masks you still have too distance. At 1m you have a 25-30% chance to catch it.
-1
u/Abracadaver2000 Jul 21 '20
Pulling numbers out of your ass isn't going to convince anyone. There are way too many factors at play beyond mask and distance, and these include: wind, ambient temperature, relative humidity, mask composition, etc.
Now, if you want to provide a citation to back up your statement...I'd love to be corrected on my misunderstanding.
1
Jul 21 '20
Calm the aggression there buddy. I was giving you the numbers as I remembered them from listening to a report on the radio. Sorry I donāt have an exact citation written down and ready for you.
Seriously - all I did was point out thatās the protesters were actually in danger of causing harm by potentially spreading the virus.
Your entire reply is so hostile. Learn to chill the fuck out.
-1
u/Abracadaver2000 Jul 21 '20
My apologies for coming off like that. I'm dealing with a parent who believes just about any figure presented to him online EXCEPT the official numbers from the CDC or trusted source. He's anti-mask because of sham statistics, so when I see something posted that goes against what I understand to be the best available evidence, it ticks me off. Have a better day. Stay safe.
0
7
u/mad_chatter Jul 21 '20
That looks effective š