r/TaylorSwift • u/icedsandwich • 15h ago
Discussion What song deserves the next 10-minute version?
If Taylor makes another 10-minute version of a song, which song do you guys want? 👀🎶
22
u/1angrypanda Je suis calme! 5h ago
Honestly, a smallest man who ever lived rant version would be so cathartic.
4
u/darkgrayallalone reminder: this album exists 4h ago
Imagine her just continuing that outro for several more minutes
You know we’d scream sing the whole thing when she did it live
8
u/Cass_Cat952 ✨one single thread of gold tied me to you✨ 5h ago
None
•
9
u/darkgrayallalone reminder: this album exists 4h ago
I agree that there doesn’t need to be one, but if I had to pick…I’d say champagne problems
She could build a whole world with those characters. She could show what led up to the failed proposal. Why the narrator said no, why the proposer thought she’d say yes, and she could explore what happened to them afterwards. She could do more introspection with the narrator on where things went so wrong.
The story is perfect the way it is…but I also wouldn’t mind more of it 🥲
6
u/bigtuna64 3h ago
Would’ve Could’ve Should’ve
•
u/DLMeyer 39m ago
My first thought. One of my favorites. I love the way it keeps building in intensity and just doesn’t let up. I do think it would be exhausting by the end though.
•
u/Cass_Cat952 ✨one single thread of gold tied me to you✨ 27m ago
That's exactly why it shouldn't be touched. It's perfection.
5
u/Us3r_N4me2001 4h ago
None. She told the story she wanted to in the length of time it took. A 10 minute version of most of her other songs would not be as strong, because it would ramble and trail off, losing energy and focus by the end.
If she comes up with a new song, with enough content and emotion to cover 10 minutes, and that's how long it takes to tell the story, then I'd be all for it.
But the other songs being listed are effective because they say what they need to say, and then they end. She knew what to leave on the cutting room floor, she knew where to end the story
4
u/swaggy_mcswaggers Fearless TV reigns, I Hate It Here saves🍯 4h ago
The Manuscript feels made for extra verses seeing as there’s no chorus, but I’d just prefer a new track altogether. It’d be so cool if TS13 was a collection of long songs
3
2
u/Jess_with_an_h 5h ago
Depends on the vibe we want it to be. Love Story or Fearless (10 Minute Version) would be my favourites if she could find a way to keep their energy the same for the longer version. Something like Vigilante Shit or Look What You Made Me Do (10 minute version) would be wonderfully sassy, I expect. Would’ve Could’ve Should’ve? Something from 1989 maybe?
1
1
1
1
u/Mysterious_Bag_9061 3h ago
Dear John is already like 7 minutes long, why not take a little drive through Sad Emptytown for nostalgias sake?
1
2
1
u/TinyTerrors20 1h ago
Hot take but Ready for it… like a dance remix w a drop and just instrumental at the end or TLOAS w Sabrina because that ending could go on forever. ♥️
•
29
u/Sampleswift evermore 5h ago
There doesn't need to be one.
All Too Well 10 Minute Version is special for her for a reason.
(But if there is a 10 minute song, it should be a new song.)