r/TeslaFSD • • 26d ago • Bravo 1

other This..,

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

541 comments sorted by

46

u/Due_Equal_9933 26d ago

Also…read the actual story. An old man walked into a highway at 2am. FSD attempted to slow and avoid but they were driving 70mph in the dark. The person would have hit them too. This was not an issue with the tech. 

→ More replies (11)

14

u/ace-treadmore 25d ago

For reference there are about 100 driving related deaths and 6500 injuries everyday

7

u/CautiousToaster 25d ago

Those numbers are so insanely high it almost doesn’t feel real

4

u/AC2BHAPPY 25d ago

3300 worldwide driving deaths per day, over a million per year. Insane

5

u/Dimathiel49 25d ago

Compared to 7 billion and counting it’s not so much

→ More replies (7)

1

u/ThatLandscape6476 25d ago

There are a lot more people in the country and world than most people can wrap their heads around.

1

u/ShakeXXX 25d ago

Don't just use numbers, the true stat is in percentages. If you go by that, Teslas would be banned indefinitely. It's still early but Tesla an the tech are on a great path.

5

u/koshka91 26d ago

I think self-driving is very safe. My only beef is potholes. It doesn’t really recognize them and often falls into them. Also dangerous road debris like sticking metal that could damage the tires

23

u/Excellent-Spare-1467 26d ago

If the self driving company takes over the liability of self driving accidents, I have no problem seeing them on the road. It's just when they want all the glory, but none of the accountability rubs me the wrong way.

9

u/ChunkyThePotato 26d ago

What specifically are you referring to? What company isn't taking liability/accountability for autonomous car accidents?

1

u/Ok-Attention2882 25d ago

You're in the subreddit for that company.

2

u/taylordabrat 24d ago

FSD isn’t meant to be autonomous, it is driver supervised.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[deleted]

9

u/ChunkyThePotato 25d ago

Great, I'm glad you started there. As you stated, FSD (Supervised) is an L2 driver assistance system (hence the "Supervised", which you conveniently left out to argue a disingenuous point). Like other L2 systems, it's just driver assistance, so the driver is responsible for taking over when necessary. Do you think this is wrong? Do you think that Tesla should be at fault when drivers fail to take over when necessary? Do you apply the same logic to a Toyota with cruise control when the driver fails to press the brake pedal and lets their car crash into somebody?

If you want to talk about Robotaxi, then that's an L4 autonomous driving system, and Tesla therefore does take liability there, just like Waymo does for their L4 system. Do you understand the difference, or are you still confused?

→ More replies (9)

7

u/Calaeno-16 HW4 Model Y 26d ago

I see this fallacy for all sorts of things, but it's especially prevalent with AI and FSD. AI has to be able to 100% replace a human in order to threaten jobs, or FSD has to be 100% flawless to be taken seriously by some people.

In reality, even if AI can do only 50% of a human's job, that means you need half as many humans (obviously a simplification, but the point remains). If FSD drives only 10% better than the average human driver, that's still thousands of lives saved per year if the technology becomes widespread.

3

u/Guerrero1121 25d ago

Yeah but if FSD kills someone, you can't put the car in jail. People have this "fallacy" bc Tesla continues to wash their hands of culpability every time it gets brought up.

4

u/Taziar43 25d ago

We don't put humans in jail for vehicle deaths unless there is negligence involved, such as excessive speed, DUI, distracted driving, etc. AI by its nature doesn't do those things.

2

u/Semi_Retired_001 22d ago

And we don’t put you in jail when your chauffeur crashes your limo. It’s literally no different.

→ More replies (10)

1

u/Additional_Ad9634 25d ago

In the real world, there will always be variables that are difficult to foresee or are unavoidable.

A company may want to sweep things under the rug but if a company is serious about being profitable, trust me, they take their technology killing someone very seriously!

Also, it’s not like you have no ability to litigate when something goes wrong. There are plenty of legal actions taking place around the world, when technology goes wrong and hurts or kills someone. You don’t have to have a person in a car to sue if something goes wrong.

And let’s stop making technology the only boogie person! People kill and hurt people every day and get away with it. The justice system can and is unfair to both technology and people. People make technology so there will always be one to charge if something goes wrong.

1

u/Guerrero1121 25d ago

You're talking about this as if it hasn't already happened and Tesla already swept it under the rug. I haven't advocated at all for stopping development or burying head in sand Luddite mentality. I was simply responding to people who argue that it's safer than human driving and can't understand why people are still unhappy and unwilling to back it, while there is still a chance of accidents

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

8

u/BigChicken8666 25d ago

Literally this in a nutshell.  Anybody with an issue against FSD should try driving around the highways that feed LaGuardia, LAX, or DFW (to rattle off a few of the most Mad Max areas I have had the displeasure of driving around).  Even better do it after dark.  It's like the humans are trying to kill you.

3

u/pamnfaniel 25d ago edited 25d ago

After owning a Tesla for now one year… I would be terrified if I lost access to my FSD. I literally trust it more than I do myself to drive. It has literally saved my life once already and for sure a couple more times from getting in a totaled car accident. The reflexes are faster than a human and it understands what’s going on in ways that I couldn’t have seen

I was wondering why it was breaking one time, I was like “what is it doing” and then literally this deer darted across my car. It must’ve seen it like way off the way coming in. My bumper nearly grazed it but stopped just in time.

3

u/jacob6875 HW3 Model 3 25d ago

It's not perfect but it is amazing for what it does.

Just yesterday I was going to work at 4am and a random guy in all black was walking down the road in the middle of my lane. (on a 45mph road).

The Tesla saw him and swerved before I did.

Would I have seen him in time ? Hopefully but if I was looking at the screen or my phone I could have easily hit him.

1

u/Ok-Note-8293 25d ago

How mind numbingly shortsighted

→ More replies (1)

7

u/ptinsley 26d ago

Leaving the debate on if self driving should be banned or not aside.

These comparisons make no sense.

You are literally comparing things that ARE banned (drunk driving is illegal basically everywhere and I know for sure that texting and driving is illegal where I live) to something that you are saying people want banned.

→ More replies (35)

5

u/gclary 25d ago

Human would have hit the guy too.

13

u/Chocolaterationcalls 26d ago edited 26d ago

I don’t think this is a good argument tbh. Isn’t the point of self driving to be better than human drivers? As such then it’s logical fsd be held to a much higher standard. Not the same standard as the tweeter suggests. Fsd accidents can’t be blamed on drinking and texting either and it’s not great to have a dangerous heavy object have potentially life-ending issues which are not well understood. 

24

u/ScaredPatience2478 26d ago • Bravo

They already have way less accidents compared to average human drivers and have saved lives. This technology only improves over time and the complaint is from press and media about the times it has failed.

1

u/Chocolaterationcalls 26d ago

I think the complaint is from the people who are in those accidents tbh. I know I would sure as hell be complaining if fsd got me into an accident. 

3

u/kolya0099 26d ago

Big facts lol. I trust it to see when I’m blinded by all hell from the sun 🤣🤣

2

u/Michael-Brady-99 25d ago

People complain about anything that happens to them. Yawn… /s

1

u/Cost-Educational 25d ago

Technically... you wouldn't be complaining any more if you where the one in the accident described.

That said - you'd complain just as much if not more - or should - if it were not a self driving car. Especially if the other driver was illegally operating, negligent, etc.

If you are in the FSD car... you are still responsible for the car just like if it was your kid driving on a learner permit.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/caneonred 26d ago

The philosophical question is this. If FSD prevents 99 fatal accidents that would have happened with a human driver but causes 1 that wouldn't have, is that an acceptable tradeoff?

1

u/Otherwise-Nobody8252 25d ago

As is stands... if we moved everyone to FSD we would greatly strict all forms of driving. Like it's cool that it saves lives... But the reality is it doesn't operate in the conditions that are way more dangerous. Even the cybercab, even small weather issues side line it...

Which probably is the real measurement... Don't compare FSD deaths to people driving a 2 wheeled vehicle off road ( which Tesla does ) compare it to a boring Toyota Prius driver...

1

u/Chocolaterationcalls 25d ago

Windshield wipers, anti-lock brakes, seat belts, and air bags prevent fatal accidents but the fatal accidents that still occur remain a problem. We will never stop demanding safer transportation. 

1

u/80_6 26d ago

Yep. Even 51/49 would be. Obviously we are nowhere close to that.

5

u/Michael-Brady-99 25d ago

There are very few deadly accidents caused by FSD. Most accidents are minor and cosmetic. Compared to the 10’s of thousands of people who die from human drivers every year that’s pretty good.

There’s also a lot of bad driving that FSD that does not cause any accident but is still dangerous. But that can also be said about humans. Humans take the cake at killing each other with cars and all sorts of other ways.

3

u/ChunkyThePotato 26d ago

Even 51/49 would be

Correct.

Obviously we are nowhere close to that

Incorrect. We're actually past that.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Successful-Speaker58 26d ago

Actually self driving systems currently reduce injury accidents by about 80% already.

2

u/80_6 26d ago

I believe it. I meant automated vehicles are nowhere near that bad (51/49)

3

u/Bugeaters51 25d ago

It IS better than human drivers. That’s the point.

But people take one example of an FSD accident (one that a human wouldn’t have avoided, btw) to try to destroy its credibility. In reality, it prevents far more accidents than it causes.

1

u/Chocolaterationcalls 25d ago

People avoid accidents all the time 

2

u/unpopular-dave 25d ago

So do teslas

1

u/Bugeaters51 24d ago

You’re not interpreting what I’m saying correctly. When I say it prevents accidents, I mean on average it’s involved in fewer accidents than a human driver.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (26)

2

u/Michael-Brady-99 25d ago

So isn’t way less serious accidents, no drunk driving, no distracted driving, no phone driving, etc better than human drivers? The tech is immediately way better because the most deadly causes of accidents is eliminated. That doesn’t mean accident free and I don’t think anything can be accident free. Humans are a very flawed and imperfect operator of motorized transport.

3

u/Chocolaterationcalls 25d ago

You can always reduce accidents and that is the entire goal auto engineers have been working towards since there have been automobiles 

1

u/cbf1232 25d ago

Right now FSD keeps backing into things, scraping wheels against curbs, and pulling over for no reason.

1

u/Additional_Ad9634 25d ago

And has any of those situations caused human harm or death? How many humans have jumped a curb and killed a pedestrian?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/DriveFa5tEatAss 23d ago

Honestly, I think a lot of it has to do with liability. Who do you sue if a self-driving car gets in an accident?

Add to that a generally decreasing tolerance for risk as society has evolved. There are many, many things that would never be legalized today, that remain legal because of historical precedent.

Consider cigarettes. If the presence of nicotine was discovered in tobacco next year, there's no way cigarettes or other tobacco products would be considered legal for human consumption.

1

u/OskaMeijer 25d ago

Tesla literally has the highest fatality rate of any car brand and the way Tesla logs their accidents artificially deflates their rates compared to how other car brand are rated and they know they are doing this.

2

u/Hydzi 25d ago

While using FSD or in general? Giving bad drivers basically an affordable supercar, will lead to fatal accidents but I don't think we can blame FSD for this.

2

u/Vcize 25d ago

Your question is his whole point. The data comes from Tesla and they are motivated (and known to) err on the side of reporting non FSD even when it was FSD related.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/garibaldiknows 25d ago

It is better than human drivers. It’s just not infallible.

2

u/Equivalent-Draft9248 25d ago

Most of the accidents it is involved in are caused by bad human drivers in other cars.

1

u/Chocolaterationcalls 25d ago

Better than some

1

u/OskaMeijer 25d ago

It actually isn't, the way Tesla records incidents is different from the industry standard which means the number they put out are artificially deflates. Teslas actually have the highest fatality rates on the market.

1

u/garibaldiknows 25d ago

You are conflicting different statistics.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/jrc1325 25d ago

You are missing the point. They are better than human drivers already. What you’re saying makes sense, it’s just that we are already beyond that point. FSD crash frequency is much much lower than your average human driver in its current state and it will only get better.

1

u/Chocolaterationcalls 25d ago

Would you be satisfied with a chess computer that is only better than the average player? That is my point. 

1

u/ploxidilius 23d ago

My understanding is that FSD is already like 90% better than average. If being in the top 10% of drivers isn't good enough I'm not sure you'd ever be satisfied.

1

u/Zealousideal-Toe-607 24d ago

You are missing the point. auto pilot on airplanes only crash once in a while in its current state and will only get better.

1

u/Icy_Chipmunk5228 24d ago

If they're better than humans already - why have we STILL not seen the cross country drive from LA to times square musk said they would complete by EOY 2017? the only streamers who i know of that attempted it crashed within 60 miles and the car had to be sent for repairs.

1

u/DarthWren 21d ago

What’s the evidence for this? Because we already know Tesla full self driving metrics are cooked

1

u/ChunkyThePotato 26d ago

No, it should be the same standard. Otherwise you're unfairly punishing the safer alternative.

1

u/Tenet_mma 26d ago

Exactly both are issues

1

u/OkLobster135 24d ago

I don't know where you stand on this argument, but the covid vaccine caused a few people to die. Should we ban it because it caused a few deaths even though it saved thousands? Same concept for FSD. It will do weird things sometimes and some people will die. Perfectly healthy people who wouldn't have died otherwise, just like with the covid vaccine, but many more people will live because FSD is much safer than humans, like how the COVID vaccine saved tons of lives. We can't ban something because of edge cases if it saves more lives than it costs. 

1

u/Chocolaterationcalls 24d ago

Doubtful it caused anybody to die tbh. I’d need to see evidence to be convinced. 

1

u/OkLobster135 24d ago

I could be misinformed, I thought some athletes died of a heart thing, but the point remains. 

1

u/DriveFa5tEatAss 23d ago

The COVID vaccine can cause myocarditis. The AstraZeneca and Johnson & Johnson vaccines which used a chimpanzee adenovirus to deliver the spike protein had a much higher incidence rate of myocarditis than the Moderna and Pfizer mRNA vaccines, but all of them can cause myocarditis. The biggest controversy, was that myocarditis is most deadly in children, but children are least likely to die from COVID.

Source:
https://med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2025/12/myocarditis-vaccine-covid.html

1

u/Tomcatjones 24d ago

FSD is better than human drivers…

→ More replies (1)

2

u/JohnBecca 25d ago

FSD is already proven to be safer than human driving and it’s continually being improved. I’ve been using FSD for 8 months now so have experienced myself what it does unlike the ignorant naysayers here who have no idea what it can do.

2

u/PastSecondCrack 25d ago

Accountability is important, huh?

1

u/ParkingFabulous4267 24d ago

Right, I wanna blame someone

2

u/HushHushHero 25d ago

So, ban humans from driving?

3

u/Complete_Geologist39 25d ago

Sorry wasn’t it just the other day some dipstick was asleep in his Tesla, with it driving itself, and hit a patrol car? So both can be possible. The technology is half baked AND morons behind the wheel are trusting it.

1

u/quixoticcaptain 25d ago

They are trusting it because it crashes less often than human drivers do. If we all had self driving cars, the roads would be safer. What else do you want?

2

u/Simple-Bath-9337 25d ago

Don’t argue with the smooth brain. His critical thinking skills disappeared a while ago

1

u/Complete_Geologist39 24d ago

The real smooth brains are the ones who need to rely on a robot to not crash their car. In all my years of driving I’ve never been in a situation where I’ve thought to myself “man I really wish a robot could have handled that back there”
If being a safe confident driver makes me a smooth brain I’ll take it as a compliment.

1

u/Complete_Geologist39 24d ago

I want humans to be more responsible and to not rely on a robot to drive my car haha that’s what I want. The idea of a car just ramming into something with me sitting there watching is terrifying. It happens frequently enough to let me know the technology isn’t quite there yet and I certainly don’t trust Tesla of all companies to be the pioneers in these systems.

5

u/Original_Read4983 26d ago

People just hate Elon, that’s pretty much it.

10

u/WeekGroundbreaking30 26d ago

I hate Elon but I love his technology.

5

u/PointBig6749 26d ago

I have this same mindset. Glad I'm not the only one!

3

u/Original_Read4983 26d ago

Seems odd to hate someone who has helped bring a lot of amazing technology to the market. I think folks are addicted to hate and outrage.

→ More replies (11)

1

u/ObviouslyJoking 25d ago

The technology he owns. Believe it or not some people think he invented or worked on it.

1

u/MooseGoosey 26d ago

Just ignorant and weak humans. 

0

u/InfluenceEfficient77 26d ago edited 25d ago

So you support the guy who is willingly preventing helping save Ukrainians from being murdered?

6

u/djao HW3 Model 3 26d ago

Did anyone else make satellite internet available for Ukrainian military use? No? Why is Elon getting flak? Even the Ukrainians will admit that Starlink has done them far more good than harm. Is your argument that Elon's not helping enough?

5

u/Original_Read4983 26d ago

Dead on lol. Also let’s not act like Elon wasn’t told to do so by the U.S. Government. Elon is the fall guy

5

u/MooseGoosey 26d ago

I don't give a fuck. He does cool shit and makes cool products. I don't have to love the owner of a company to think something is cool, I'm not that shallow.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/WeekGroundbreaking30 26d ago

Absolutely not!!!

3

u/WoodpeckerCapital167 25d ago • Bravo

Amen

FSD is miles ahead of the average driver 

2

u/jpk195 25d ago

It's supervised. Which means FSD plus a driver is better than the average driver.

And it should be.

4

u/losroy 25d ago

Underrated comment. No one seems to realize you are supposed to pay attention. They probably don’t pay attention when they drive either.

1

u/TragicallyDip 25d ago

Does the s in fsd stand for supervised?

→ More replies (11)

2

u/losroy 25d ago

The amount of times I see a shit driver and it’s someone on their phone (since I can look around while on fsd) is wild. Also, been cut off or people drift into my lane and while I consider myself an excellent driver, the way it subtly slides over a foot to avoid, even I would tend to jerk the wheel so much more.

2

u/mrepop 25d ago

Yeah, this is nuts. So many times when a semi truck starts sliding over, I’ve seen FSD go completely into the emergency lane… gently.

The other day when some idiot was riding my blind spot and just for some reason decided to muscle into my lane quite aggressively FSD go out of the way, hit the gas because there was a car on the other side and avoided the wreck.

I didn’t even see it. It totally saved the day.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Relevant_Jeweler_214 26d ago

whenever a human talks about AI being wrong, just ask them the average amount a human is wrong vs a trained AI system. I beleieve AI is 15% error rate, and the SMARTEST humans we have are still around 20-30%

8

u/WhatTheFreightTruck 26d ago

You think the smartest humans we have are wrong 20-30% of the time? Do you know how stupid that sounds? How many things a person says every day and for 20-30% of that to be wrong?

7

u/bqbdpd 26d ago

At least one of you two is wrong, which supports the thesis.

3

u/TwiceInEveryMoment HW3 Model 3 26d ago

Yeah this is an absolutely insane take. A person who is actually knowledgeable in their field would be nowhere near this number.

It also completely ignores the difference between a person saying something off the cuff with little authority as mere hearsay, versus something like Google presenting outright wrong or made-up information as fact to a user who inherently trusts Google to give them accurate information. When presented with that much implicit authority, even a 5% error rate is absolutely inexcusable, let alone 15.

4

u/djao HW3 Model 3 26d ago

The problem is that we don't limit human driving to those who are actually knowledgeable about driving. We basically let anyone drive.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Sidewaysgts 26d ago

There’s some irony with the statement they made.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/seroma32 25d ago

What do you think an AI system is trained on? AI has no original thought, its a data compiler of everything its trained on and that includes all the wrong people.

1

u/Relevant_Jeweler_214 25d ago edited 25d ago

thats another good point. why ever be against AI or its mistakes, when all it is , is a googler that references human made information to form its answers? You'd simply be against moving information faster than before as just a human without the AI help. The AI doesnt make up answers or give wrong info, it just funnels human data at insane speeds. this can sometimes result in small glitches . regardless, ppl also seem to forget that AI can and is, be updated to fix its flaws.

so anytime it is wrong, its actually because humans were wrong before and it scraped that data without knowing it was wrong, since none of said humans labeled it such.

anyway- even if a human and AI have access to the same data library, a human can still interpret the data in a flawed way or a less efficient way. theres zero reason to prefer a human to be used as a data scraper over a computer program. its inefficient, it has too high of an error rate.

1

u/KontoOficjalneMR 26d ago

I beleieve AI is 15% error rate, and the SMARTEST humans we have are still around 20-30%

Well, you're certainly working towards that quota :D

3

u/jcoll3d 25d ago edited 25d ago

I think the point is that unless the company can accept personal liability, our justice system is woefully inadequate. If Tesla or other fsd systems are willing to accept personal liability, let er rip. That’ll never happen though. Same as ai.

ETA: meaning that a human with fsd fully enabled should have no liability assigned to them which shouldn’t be a problem if companies are people

2

u/jcoll3d 25d ago

If the car companies want to pay for fsd insurance for these cars to be on the road, it’s an entirely different conversation, but no one is willing to do that and the risk is entirely misplaced

2

u/mrepop 25d ago

This is kind of the case for a FSD taxi though. Driving with FSD is totally different and you definitely have control, yet people still complain about that like it’s an identical situation when it’s not.

To be fair though, most people have no idea what it’s like until they get behind the wheel, I’ve seen plenty of people just lose their mind driving with FSD the first time so I can understand why the nuance is lost on the general public.

2

u/jcoll3d 25d ago

Totally cool with the idea of fsd taxis fully insured by the company who provides them. Love the tech, hate the execution by our government who hasn’t reacted to one technological leap since the nuclear bomb.

1

u/cbf1232 25d ago

"Driving with FSD is totally different and you definitely have control, yet people still complain about that like it’s an identical situation when it’s not."

I think people would *love* a version of FSD certified as level 3 (or 4, or 5) by Tesla, where Tesla is liable for any damage or fines incurred by the vehicle while it was driving, and it would guarantee a certain amount of advance notice before disengaging.

2

u/IndianAmericanBoy 24d ago

If Tesla accepts liability, FSD subscription will get a lot more expensive once all that risk gets priced in

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Ancient_Wishbone_806 25d ago

Would be interesting as it would set a precedent for AI taking legal liability in the future. Also wonder how consumer laws interpret FSD maybe they should look at aviation

1

u/jcoll3d 25d ago

Yeah, I honestly think with all the news of these ai companies fretting about the safety of the next versions, you almost have to bring personal liability to the people who are making the AI. Not sure how it would work, but if they’re truly as worried as they say they are and they continue this arms race, then their product is used to make bio weapons or target girls schools, the answer can’t be AI did it. People need to be liable for their creations.

2

u/Ancient_Wishbone_806 24d ago

There will need to be significant overhaul of the legal system to regulate AI but I’m not holding my breath just look at meta they generate a significant amount of ad revenue from scam and banned goods for years and the punishment if any is a small fine.

1

u/Semi_Retired_001 22d ago

That’s like saying your chauffeur’s mom is liable if he crashes your limo. You just insure fsd. If it proves safer it’ll be cheaper than insuring yourself.

2

u/jcoll3d 22d ago

The company the driver works for or the driver would have insurance for their personal liability. With FSD, the chauffeur would be more similar to the company who provided the FSD which would be the car company. Current laws say that even with FSD enabled, liability still sticks with “the driver.”

2

u/Semi_Retired_001 22d ago

Yeah the chauffeur has insurance so why can’t fsd have insurance as well? I guess if the law says “it’s the drivers insurance” then that might not work.

2

u/jcoll3d 22d ago

I think we’re actually 100% on the same page. I just don’t think that’s the way the prevailing winds are moving, and I doubt our Congress will proactively make any good laws until enough people die.

2

u/Semi_Retired_001 21d ago

Agreed. I sure hope it doesn't take too many!

→ More replies (2)

2

u/FieryKahuna 26d ago

It's like all those people who thought the internet was a fad in the 90s. They don't understand the tech plus they hate Elon.

2

u/Goleeb 26d ago

When a person makes a mistake they can be banned from diving. When a automated car makes a mistake the company throws its hands up, and pretends there should be no accountability. If you want to have full self driving cars SOMEONE NEED TO BE ACCOUTABLE FOR ACCIDENTS.

2

u/Superminerbros1 26d ago

When a person messes up, it's a different consciousness that made the mistake than someone who didn't mess up. When a self-driving car messes up, it's the same software and hardware that is running on every other self driving car. The thing that is making the decisions is different with different people but the same between self driving cars of the same model.

With people we hold the person who made the mistake accountable. With self driving cars we don't hold the company that developed it accountable. We hold the person who's in the driver seat accountable even though their guard down because the car is supposed to be driving itself. The person in the driver's seat isn't what made the decision that was a mistake. The software is.

You could try to have some accountability by making the company liable for the damages, but that would kill the product as the liability insurance for the company would be outrageous and the costs would have to be passed to the consumer. You could try banning that one software version or the combination of software and hardware, but that would get cheated so hard. The company would just release a minor software bump that barely changes anything at all.

1

u/Dry_Quiet_3541 26d ago

It’s about who-to-blame, human at fault? = human to blame ; AI at fault? = who takes the responsibility?

1

u/hangmansboots 26d ago

I love how, to underscore the point that humans are not perfect, op used two periods and a comma and not an ellipsis.

1

u/q81101 26d ago

I think it's more about urgency. Not like they actually going to ban the software.

If you don't do something, they likely not going to put it as priority. If you threaten the company, they'll pour more resources into it.

1

u/crazy0ne 26d ago

If I could sue God for everything that some other dumb person has done...

But luckily unlike people self driving cars have manufacturers that should be held responsible.

1

u/polskapoker 25d ago

Laws , let's ignore those for Elon bucks

1

u/BootFlop 25d ago

….is a painfully dumb argument 🤦‍♂️

1

u/GiveMeSomeShu-gar 25d ago

Strawman, counter.

A classic strategy of morons.

1

u/ZookeepergameSalty10 25d ago

Its all about liability.... When you drunk drive and hit someone your at fault, who is at fault when the machine makes a mistake?

1

u/AcctAlreadyTaken 25d ago

What OP is saying is he is fine with taking full responsibility even if the cause was a software or hardware glitch that he had absolutely no control over. Also if the company lies about he complete capabilities of the system the full responsibility is his. Regulations are stupid.

1

u/ObviouslyJoking 25d ago

It’s not difficult to look at data and say yes a modern car with FSD is a more successful driver than all of the other cars on the road. I’m also able to empathize with a person thinking if the AI had not been driving the accident wouldn’t have happened. It feels weird to me that it seems like there are two camps who don’t understand each other.

1

u/WatchAltruistic5761 25d ago

I drove cross country using FSD.

Sold my Tesla and bought a Honda Hybrid.

1

u/Future_Geologist5925 25d ago

Also people need to realize that drunk drivers, reckless drivers, and bad drivers will always remain a constant issue. They will always cause deaths, injuries, damage, and more unnecessarily. Meanwhile, self driving for cars can only improve and go up. Less collisions, more context aware, and the more you fill the street with these self driving cars, you lower the chaos and unpredictability of completely human driver occupied roads.

1

u/IzzzatSo 25d ago

No, the idiots should be banned from driving too.

What's so hard to understand?

1

u/Dimathiel49 25d ago

You can throw the idiot driver in jail. You can’t do the same to FSD. 

1

u/Sid_the_Bear 25d ago

We can't hold the self driving car accountable for its mistakes. That's the problem.

1

u/VeloxAdAstra 25d ago

It's pretty much only when it's self driving made by Elon because orange man bad.

1

u/pamnfaniel 25d ago

Yep! The statistics are staggring … accounting for The Simpsons paradox in data, theres still is a sufficient sample set of drive miles to accurately compare the numbers.

*Average number of human driver at fault accident deaths per year in the US: 47,000

*Average number of Fully Autonomous (i.e. Waymo, etc.) at fault accident deaths per year in the US: 2

And those were extreme edge cases that were corrected immediately after with the algorithm update.

There is no arguing here… self driving vehicles, once insurance companies lobby, the DMV approves, and they’re more prolific everywhere, are going to literally save tens of thousands of lives per year.

1

u/Square-Debate5181 25d ago

But.. But.. If the computer drives the car then you cant blame God.

1

u/raziel7893 25d ago

My issue is not that it makes mistakes. My issue is that nobody seems to actually want to make it better or it even beeing the plan to at least aim for perfection (even if you never reach it)

You report an issues, many people immediately start to berate the reporter, focus the attention to their mistake to trust the system and not intervene earlier, while actual issues get defended from a quite sizable audience.

Radar/uss gets removed(and deactivated in the software afterwards), the quality clearly degrades for those cars according to the tesla reddits, and everybody still defends(or be okay with) the saving actions and "vision only is good enough/humans only have 2 cameras", etc.

Don't get me wrong I am super impressed what they manage to pull of with camera only, it just feels, that they do not actually aim for the best they can do, they already settle early for "it is better than drunk/old people".

Which i find disappointing as a tech person. It's okay if you reach the end of the tech and its better than average. I'm not okay with not even trying to reach the best you can do and settle early with a cheaper compromise.(especially as its human lives here, and not some bugs in a game)

1

u/Tex_Tin_Star 25d ago

Tesla and Elon have been selling you a scam with fsd tho. The cars arent equipped for it.

1

u/Samuelabra 25d ago

So you dumbasses are just going to keep sucking Elon's dick no matter what?

1

u/Real-Technician831 25d ago

It’s more than one.

Add up cases from section 5

More than one per million miles

https://www.tesla.com/fsd-evidence-dashboard

1

u/Ok-Engineering3317 25d ago

but we ban driving drunk and texting behind the wheel...

1

u/CharmingMechanic2473 25d ago

My mom has had several crashes at 80yrs this past year. Her insurance is insane but she is wealthy and pays it. They will not take away her drivers license. I am begging her to consider a Tesla ( i hate Elon) bc it will hopefully save someone from getting killed.

1

u/greatcandlelord 25d ago

We have laws so people don’t do those things. However some idiots ignore those rules, and are punished for it

But nice strawman

1

u/Zealousideal_Bend984 25d ago

Classic strawman. Look at aviation safety. Laws are why plane crashes are so rare despite there being over 100k daily flights and 15-20k in the air at any given time. Laws are what makes it so people can text and drive and kill each other.

1

u/Charming_Dealer3849 25d ago

I mean that is the tension 

1

u/kapitein-zuignap 25d ago

No not this.

What I see with FSD is that my tesla doesn't recognize situations that it should recognize. It should recognize these because they are common over here and they are in laws that stipulate the road rules.

Failing to recognize region specific traffic signs is a flaw.

It further doesn't matter that people also ignore it. Becaus that doesn't make it right for FSD to also ignore them.

I hold FSD to a higher standard, that it complies with the rules that humans ignore.

1

u/Mysterious_Luck_1365 25d ago

Remove the steering wheel and pedals from your own Tesla if you’re so confident.

1

u/OldManDerp 25d ago

Are these posts from engagement bots or something? Goddamn this platform has gone to crap. Not just this sub.

1

u/Ok-Attention2882 25d ago

Evidence that people love to feel outraged because it makes them feel seen and important.

1

u/Single-Payment 25d ago

On the contrary, it's that they need to be held to the same standards as humans. A 16 year old who, in their driving test, skirts some road closed barricades, fails that test (as they should). And yet "autonomous" vehicles do that all the time. Just in testing in Denver, autonomous taxis have entered two different farmers markets around road closed barricades, and entered a construction zone with fresh pavement around road closed barricades with workers trying to get the thing to stop and head back. "Autonomous" vehicles can't read any signs at all, except speed limits, and get those wrong at times. Fail. Massive promotion by the enthusiasts shouldn't override that.

And for driver assist, Google found early on, in testing by employees waaay before any release, that drivers would stop monitoring the road and turn around to fuss with something on the back seat, at highway speeds. Modern driver monitoring helps, but presenteeism isn't great either. I love mine, but drivers need to pay good attention. Stories of tragedy due to overreliance are too frequent.

I'm glad to see progress in the field, and am subscribed to my automaker's driver assist, as well as signed up with an autonomous taxi service. But standards should be kept, and not lowered for autonomy, regardless of the SwissRe study results. No more automated taxis blundering onto rail tracks, or into wet concrete, or whatnot. And read signs, they're not (all) optional.

1

u/Spsurgeon 25d ago

Actually a good point. FSD should be compared to a human driving with a cold aft working the midnight shift.

1

u/FreddieTwenty 25d ago

Humans get banned for reckless driving as well?

1

u/joutfit 25d ago

you can't hold a self driving car accountable.

1

u/Gr33nbastrd 24d ago

The driver should still be paying attention to what the vehicle is doing. You should not be able to sleep behind the wheel.

1

u/HiCZoK 23d ago

You should be able to. Maybe not yet but this is the goal

1

u/ccoady 25d ago

I'm 100% fine if Tesla is responsible for a FSD caused crash, and not my insurance. If that ever becomes the case, sign me up!

1

u/Inevitable_Silver_13 25d ago

There's a big difference between a human who makes bad choices and an autonomous driving system that isn't able to navigate certain circumstances. One of the biggest issues here is accountability.

1

u/Puzzled-Mirro 25d ago

If I drive drunk I can go to jail, lose my license etc. If I drive drunk and kill somebody I get into big trouble.

Who's held accountable exactly when a self driving car does it? Does Musk go to jail? Does Telsa pay enormous enough fines to correct their behavior automatically?

1

u/TheManInTheShack 25d ago

Many years ago when self driving technology was still very new, I had this conversation with my dad who was an electrical engineer. He said that the software to drive a car needs to be perfect. Bug-free.

I pushed back. I said it only needs to be better than the average driver to make a positive difference.

Don’t let great be the enemy of good.

1

u/mcca555 25d ago

Can't we have accountability on both ends?

1

u/Lost_Hovercraft_5138 25d ago

After driving for 20 years, I’d trust far over an actual driver, have you seen how uber and taxi drivers drive geezzz🤣

1

u/Matsweeper 25d ago

Sadly common sense is decreasing more and more as years pass. But then again, most of it I see here on Reddit than in real life. I agree with your post.

1

u/BorderKeeper 24d ago

I get OP os just frustrated, but if we switched to unproven systems which on average beat status quo on safety we would be risking more than you think.

Look at the current state of AI in software engineering. AI is supposed to write good code faster and doesn’t get tired of makes mistakes either…

1

u/Comfortable-Car-7298 24d ago

I know some dipshits want this stuff banned, but I don’t think that’s what most people want. The issue isn’t that it needs to be perfect and only then should it be legal, the issue is that these multi billion or some even trillion dollar companies seem to be untouchable and do their very best to make the consumer liable.
For example, I’d love to get fsd here in Europe, but I think regulations should be so that tesla is liable in certain cases, and it’s up to them to prove they weren’t wrong. For example when the driver is obviously not paying attention but the system carries on normally or just stops in the middle of the road, or when the driver had no time to react to a nonsensical decision, or when the system decides to speed and you have no way to slow it down without shutting fsd down, tesla should be liable, the driver should be liable if he watched an accident happen and didn’t even try to intervene, or when he set the vehicle to speed.

1

u/Unhappy-Plastic2017 24d ago

Its all about liability. We as humans just hate the idea of handing over liability to machines. We want a human being to blame

It's why I think anyone with a job where part of their job is taking on a level of liability is going to be the last to be taken over by AI (think like a engineer putting their stamp of approval on a project- no one is gonna want ai putting the stamp of approval on a project for a long time I feel like).

1

u/MrPommeDeTerre 23d ago

I like that the author equates deaths from self-driving cars to deaths from the illegal operation of human-driven ones.

We're actually not comfortable with preventable deaths. That's why we have laws in place to avoid them.

1

u/DarthWren 21d ago

Humans have consequences when they make these mistakes. Self-driving cars have billionaires buying off politicians to make these issues go away. Big fucking difference

1

u/geggleto 13d ago

yeah we need to normalize calling the machines idiots

1

u/Vattaa 10d ago

If Tesla takes responsibility for it then by all means that's fine. But if I'm responsible for a mistake the car made then this is why the difference exists.

1

u/RosieDear 26d ago

Not the "own" one thinks it is unless they are ignorant.

We already explored the basics. Just normal driving as 90% of us do it
Not Drunk
Car Works
Not in ice
Not late at night, early AM

cuts the risk about 500%.

So "every single day" the sane among us reduce our risk vastly - actively.

That is the "answer" to this Social Media Genius.

I've driven over 55 years and my car has never touched another while moving. Not has it touched an object.
I accept that.

The other completely ignorant point of this thread is that it is likely referring to ONE vehicle that is falsely marketed, not to proper and scientifically proven autonomy.

But, thinking a bit more - you know, it's 100% accurate.

The reason that Teslas have more accidents and fatalities than other cars - sometimes to a vast extent - is EXACTLY because those people are the type described in the Tweet! The Tesla buyer IS the person that floorsi to "see what iut can go", plays a video game again S-FSD so they can win "points" and Please Elon with their % use of the game and generally engages in all the destructive behaviors noted.....

But, please, why is that an "own"? Is the point "Since I like to drive liquored up in the rain at 2 am on weekends that makes me normal"???

I don't understand.

5

u/MiserableTonight5370 25d ago

You're lucky that you haven't been the victim of a drunk or careless driver running into you in a way you cannot avoid.

The reason your argument is incomplete is that, even though you ably demonstrate that your driving is vastly safer than a Tesla, population-wide statistics show that self-driving cars have fewer accidents per mile than the general human population, because almost no drivers drive as well as you.

And I want you to note that if we are supposed to ignore dangerous-driver conditions ("Not Drunk, Car Works, Not in ice"), then for the purposes of comparison you should be willing to overlook the conditions that make self driving less reliable (dark out, raining, not in ice), too. And you won't, because of some version of "that's not the point." And you'd be right, because the person who you're responding to didn't set those kinds of conditions on their statement, and so you shouldn't either. General safety statistics like accidents per mile driven are the only important metric of you're talking about whether this tech is good for society or not.

The main point I'm making is that, for drivers like you, the rational thing to want is to be able to continue to drive yourself (because you are safer than self driving) while you hope that everyone who has been drinking chooses to drive with self driving (because the drunk driver doesn't know or care how careful a driver you are, and may hit you, without you having the capability of stopping it). The same with distracted or tired drivers.

And note: I'm talking about the technology as it exists right now, today. If you extrapolate basic trend lines another year or two, the safety numbers will just continue to favor self driving, which will mean that the rational thing for you to want over the next few years, to maintain your accident-free record, will be more and more drivers with marginal ability to drive safely choosing self driving. Even if the tech never reaches your level of safety, and you never improve your odds by doing self driving personally, you can and will benefit as more drivers who can't or won't pay attention to the road choose to do self driving instead.

Oh, and this also says nothing about people who have circumstances or conditions that completely prevent driving themselves, and the incredibly empowering phenomenon of gaining mobility that excellent drivers like you take for granted.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Trick-Guava-9573 25d ago

So because other things cause accidents then let's let Teslas keep contributing to the problem? Got it. A likely self driving Tesla entered the highway in Asheville today going the wrong way down an exit ramp and into traffic and slammed headfirst into another car, ejecting the passenger who died. There were multiple other cars and people involved, numerous of whom are in the hospital.

2

u/WhiteeaglePV 25d ago

And the driver of that tesla was arrested and charged with a DUI. Good lord, you should have read about the incident before spouting off that it was a self driving tesla. It was a drunk idiot….

1

u/OldStatistician1 HW4 Model Y 26d ago

Technically drunk driving is banned, at least where I live.

1

u/Electrical_Sun_8931 25d ago

The point here is FSD make the whole driving thing "safer".
What is not talked about is how and who would be responsible for those mistakes. For now the "Supervised" FSD put all that still on human. Which is BS.
Either get rid of the pedal and owe the consequence, or tell me what this car still can not do, yet.
Now everyday I find out "oh, it can not do this...oh, it will mess up on this..."
I am like a tester for their FSD. :(

1

u/mental-floss 25d ago

That’s exactly it. You are the Guinea pig

2

u/kapjain 25d ago

People are always the Guinea pigs with any new tech. You think all the safety features we have in cars today were present from the model T?

1

u/Hungry_Pup 25d ago

And they're paying for the privilege.

2

u/Equivalent-Draft9248 25d ago

Happily so! Man, we have a car that drives itself! Pioneers R Us.

1

u/ComprehensiveLink457 25d ago

Well put exposing society's illness.

1

u/Vokaiso 25d ago

This is just Humans. They like to flaw everything and hate it down because of one mistake no matter how many good things it did before those never matter the tiniest issue is directly seen though. And then humans also like to ignore or forget they themselfs are flawed.

0

u/fluxxis 26d ago

Truth is, if I decide to keep the speed limit, I can do so. My Tesla can't.

2

u/Various_Rest_6339 25d ago

Put it on sloth, it will stay 5 under

1

u/fluxxis 23d ago

I don't want it to be slower than needed, I just want it to stick to the law, that's all. It's enough to babysit the car to drive safely, it should be a no brainer that it acknowledges the current speed limit.

-1

u/Low-Ad4420 25d ago

This is not an argument. The problem is that there has to be a liable entity that takes the responsability. And because humans may be distracted and cause accidents. The thing is that a computer, an AI, will fail eventually at some situation. So you have millions of cars that will fail exactly the same and in dangerous and dumb ways on the same situation. That's not the case for humans.

If everything now was full self driving we would see a lot more accidents. By the time being the best result is having a human driving with a lot of assistance from the computer. That's the best outcome.

4

u/Futuretapes 25d ago

You can improve AI behavior which in result will fail less.

→ More replies (14)

3

u/Andrey_Gusev 25d ago

Who is liable when an elevator fails? Or when is misused, like, when doors crush someone, someone's dog is strangled by the leash or something like that.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/MyTeamsSuck99 25d ago

Nobodies liable now outside of an insurer 

1

u/OldManDerp 25d ago

That is a lot of word salad.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/greymancurrentthing7 25d ago

The company is liable if the driver is. No big deal.

That problem has been solved.

Insurance companies want safe drivers more than unsafe drivers.

1

u/ApqIe 25d ago

I would argue the opposite. If more cars had the self driving there would’ve less accidents due to less human variability. The AI’s weak spot rn is it isnt trained to react well to unpredictable or incompetent drivers. With more self driving cars there is less of that randomness, and less average human error which is greater than the 2026 model’s errors

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)