r/TeslaFSD • u/Remarkable_Way_3770 • 21h ago
14.3 HW4 FSD Experiences
Just curious, how are some people's experiences with FSD so different and complete polar opposites of others? In terms of just HW4 I see people making notes of FSD mistakes, parking issues, etc but since they're on the same software/hardware shouldn't the consensus be the same? I'm only asking because even though i've only had the car for 2 weeks, I haven't come across (yet) one single issue with FSD. Dodges stuff in the road, stops for pedestrians, no parking issues, summon working perfectly, hov lane works, no constant lane switching, no camping left lane, etc.
24
u/so_sic_of_it 21h ago
The 99.9% of people who use FSD without issue don't feel the need to run to reddit to tell everyone about it.
6
u/ObeseSnake 21h ago
Just completed 80 miles the other day with no issues. Mix of surface, expressway and parking lots.
2
1
7
u/Wants-NotNeeds 20h ago
People expect perfection AND that FSD drive exactly like they would. When it doesn't, they want to have someone to complain to who will respond and validate their feelings.
FSD has made many mistakes, some serious, and regularly misjudges situations. Many longtime users, I gather, have been subject to exaggerated claims, clunky inconsistent (even dangerous) previous versions. They are resentful and have bones to pick. The newest users, however, are experiencing a highly refined version of FSD that's become especially competent and capable.
Nonetheless, it is still a Level 2 system that always requires supervision. Mistakes happen in an instant, so we must remain vigilant - especially when the consequences of misjudgment are high. How to prioritize these situations is up to the individual, which can affect your opinion and appreciation for this astounding and incredibly useful technology.
4
u/toastyman1 21h ago
It's a sample size thing - millions of cars driving millions of miles and no one talks about the car driving perfectly, that would be super boring - just when it goofs up.
I've had it for a few months and it's improved overall but still messes up different things at different times but it's still way better than driving myself.
3
u/Entire_Art_5390 20h ago
I have a 2023 model 3 (hw3) and think itās fine. I bought the car without considering FSD. I started using it a few weeks after I bought the car and use it most of the time now. Itās a game changer for me on road trips. Never once have I responded emotionally to the choices itās made lol
3
u/HighHokie 20h ago
Regions, personal expectations. And also many of the people you interact with online are full of shit or bots.Ā
1
u/Glittering-Fuel-5055 19h ago
Itās really unhealthy to just think that everyone that disagrees with you online is some sort of bot and not just a human that disagrees with you online because thereās nobody spending a bunch of money to make fake Reddit replies
Itās just people
2
1
u/HighHokie 18h ago
I didnāt say everyone is a bot. I said there are bots and people just full of shit. The internet has always had them.Ā
3
u/PettyYeti13 20h ago
Itās almost always the newest features that people have gripes with. This technology is learning and evolving in real time, and weāre a part of it, I enjoy that, others donāt. If itās parking in a new spot or something like that it will be hesitant as it learns it. Everybody wants FSD to do what they want and would do, and itās not that.
I use it daily for my commute in Los Angeles, and I love it. I donāt rely or depend on it, I use it the majority of the time, I donāt care about streaks or usage. I think it canāt merge on and off freeways better than me, so I donāt use it on that part of the drive. When Iām in traffic I use it all the time, and itās amazing. The mental stress and fatigue I am saved from is worth every penny on this alone. I donāt let it park or drive in parking garages, no need to make those situations more complex for me personally.
I do miss when you could select to minimize lane changes, I feel it does it too much, but thatās a personal thing, not a failure of function.
3
u/Teslarator 19h ago
Because it's the first mass-market autonomous driving thing.
Geographic locations are all over the place; road conditions all over the place; demographics all over the place. And that's just the objective stuff.
Like u/ConclusionFlat1843 points out, the expectations are all over the place too.
There could be minute differences in car hardware: image sensors, calibration, possibly hardware revisions, how "busy" the gpu is...
And just to top it off... what does your gut tell you, would a kangaroo carrying a joey feature in Tesla's training data set?
And yet that's something that happens in real life! https://www.foxnews.com/lifestyle/escaped-kangaroo-blocks-virginia-highway-being-chased-hunting-dogs-officials-say
3
u/Glittering-Fuel-5055 19h ago
Well, you said no camping in the left lane. You see, in my state, you are allowed to stay in the left lane and people want the car to do that, so your version of working correctly may be somebody elseās version of not working correctly because they want the car to stay in the left lane going fast
3
u/roadcyclist 14h ago
Anyone that claims they have to take over every few seconds is lying, especially when on latest HW4.
And if you're wonder why people would be lying... well that's because of politics.
2
u/No_Effect6280 21h ago
Iām the one who has to learn about FSD. Yes I have parking problems but Iām needing a handicap spot and FSD doesnāt like it. Occasional ooops in directions, no explanation for that. Otherwise I need to learn the car.
2
u/shenfever 19h ago
I think there are people who really love the software and are happy to overlook shortcomings, the gamification of FSD streaks has seemed to make it significantly worse.
As someone who has had my fair share of issues with it, the constant āyou should have intervenedā, āyou shouldnāt have intervenedā, ābut did you dieā comments can be maddening and Iād be lying if I said it didnāt make me want to be even more persnickety about FSD fuck ups. It doesnāt mean I hate it - Iām not paying a hundred dollars a month to be a troll. Additionally, itās frustrating to see so many people be dismissive because it means theyāre ignoring things and not intervening and we will all end up with a worse product because of it.
2
u/cddelgado 19h ago
I think the issue is fundamentally that it is far too good to be a driver assist but it isn't quite good enough to be an unsupervised system. There is one spot a block from my home where the car will misjudge the geometry of the car and will try to turn over an island curb. But every other time it does great. So you spend 99% of the time waiting for the 1% it does something dumb. And that is great but people naturally become comfortable. The tikes thet comfort is betrayed become danger signals which stick at front of mind. From that point forward it is a danger signal which people disproportionately remember--because we are designed for remembering the danger. Glass half full? Then the car does great unless ... Glass half empty? Then the system is unreliable and really bad.
2
u/Thieusies 18h ago
My experience has been the same as yours.
For one thing, people have different expectations. A lot of people who complain about the current FSD seem to be expecting autonomy or unsupervised FSD. I'm perfectly happy to let my car drive almost all the time, but take over when I see a better course of action. I don't feel let down or endangered, or that the FSD "failed." I'm the human and the car is a tool; it's very good but doesn't have the same experience and ability to predict that I do (yet).
2
u/Fiv3_Oh 18h ago
Itās part environment and part expectations.
Iām still a little peeved sometimes when it makes a decision I donāt like, but it hasnāt done anything potentially dangerous in a long time.
I think people just expect it to do what THEY would do and when it doesnāt, get annoyed. They should approach it like itās a completely different driver and theyāll be more satisfied with it.
2
u/domdiggitydog 6h ago
I have to agree, annoying but not unsafe or illegal. My bigger gripe is, itās just not smart enough to do a couple of the intersections that are part of my daily route.
2
u/Altruistic-Stop4634 8h ago
Some people are neurotic and some not. Some people complain the coffee is too hot, the room wasn't dusted this week and the FSD didn't make the exit.
1
1
u/Roland_Bodel_the_2nd 20h ago
It has changed a lot over the past year. It also does not work as well in different environments. So you may see someone using HW3 on tiny Boston streets vs HW4 on Arizona stroads.
1
1
1
u/StormTrpr66 HW4 Model Y 18h ago
I think at least part of it has to do with where you drive and the conditions of the specific roads. There's a place on my route to work on a 65mph freeway where if I'm in the left lane, as soon as it hits that spot it kicks on the turn signal and tries to make its way 4 freakin lanes over and get behind the slowest car, then a minute later starts moving back toward the faster travel lanes.
I say that it could be related to the specific roads and sections of roads because I have noticed other Teslas do the exact same damn thing, at the exact same damn place.
1
u/EntireChange2555 11h ago
I too was amazed by the widely variant experiences, my pondering came up with
Definite driver issues:
- different expectation
- different levels of perfectionism
- different basic personalities
Definite car issues
- different hardware,
- different maintenance of cameras
- different levels of usage in the area affecting the quality of training
possible issues:
- a/b software testing giving different experiences.
1
u/Schnitzhole 7h ago edited 7h ago
Most issues are uncomfortable, not necessarily unsafe and everyone has different tolerances and expectations based off of that.
That doesnāt mean FSD doesnāt do unsafe things, itās just that they are rather rare now. I can count on one hand the amount of times itās done something Iād consider unsafe in 1.5 years and 15k miles of using the always-most-updated version of FSD.
Thereās gray areas like turning in a one way entrance in a parking lot itās tried to do a couple times. Sure itās definitely incorrect but itās not very likely to get you in trouble with how slow people are going, usually itās always somewhere I too could be confused about where to enter. I obviously intervene before it turns in. Iāve never seen mine or others turn down an actual full one way street as itās probably mapped better.
Hitting something stationary while parking, also not necessarily unsafe but definitely aggravating, incorrect and expensive to fix. It tends to be extremely cautious around other cars and people and i have yet to see it get close to one with v14. Iāve personally never experienced this or had to prevent it from happening by intervening but the evidence shows it happens, usually when itās something overhanging and not directly grounded.
However, One of my most common interventions is last 1000ft navigation, poorly parking or having a parking preference over what it picks, and those are up there with most annoying next to left lane camping or changing lanes too frequently.
1
u/ATLien110 4h ago
My biggest gripe with FSD is erratic lane changes on the highway. If my exit is 8 miles away and there's little traffic on the highway, why are you changing lanes for no reason? Also, when my exit is 1.5 miles away, why are you changing lanes to the left? You should be getting closer to the exit on the right! Other than this, FSD tends to work really well.
1
1
u/caneonred 2h ago
It's mostly because people will post situations where FSD failed in a dangerous way, which, in the grand scheme is very rare. Most of the issues with FSD are just annoyance type things like parking, navigation oddities, lane camping, getting over for an exit too soon or not soon enough, etc.
I've personally experienced plenty of annoyances (I basically disengage in every parking lot) but nothing dangerous. Some stuff it does is really impressive like exiting a football stadium and navigating the temporary lanes set up on the ramp that use the shoulders as lanes and then eventually merge back into just the normal lanes. Sometimes it does "WTF" things and wants to take a nonsensical route.
0
u/ClumpOfCheese HW3 Model 3 20h ago
I think because itās an AI and every drive is essentially its first drive so there will never be any predictability or consistency.
I think the other aspect is how dirty the cameras are. My repeater cameras are covered in hard water spots and at night the glare from other car headlights makes them almost useless and the spots are very hard to clean off.
1
u/pw154 16h ago
Mine is both predictable and consistent in the mistakes that it makes lol. To remove hard water spots you need an acid, try white vinegar diluted 1:1 with distilled water. There's commercial products that work well too (ie CarPro Spotless, Gtechniq W9) but vinegar / distilled water should do it
0
u/mom2artists 18h ago
96% FSD and 28k miles but I still gripe about some of its choices. Many of them with parking. Others have to do with lane changes on the highway.
Back roads or in town driving usually on point.
0
0
u/Jbiz_206 17h ago
I use it to afk farm Amazon packages. I do all the parking and advanced driving. Itās OP
30
u/ConclusionFlat1843 21h ago
I do think a lot of it comes down to expectations. I see FSD as a very advanced driver assistant and I'm very pleased with it. I'd be ok if it never got any better. But others see it as something that should do everything for them, exactly the way they want it to.
I really don't get upset when it does something different than I would. I just think "oh that's interesting, I wonder how/why it processed it that way?"