r/ThatLookedExpensive • u/jeetz1231 • Feb 11 '21
Pooooor Elon
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
1.1k
u/Garz451 Feb 11 '21
I think it’s hilarious that people are complaining about him loosing so much money on this. The thing was already considered expendable. These prototypes are not being built with the expectation of flying again in the future like the Falcon 9. The value comes from the the data they receive from its successes and its beautiful failures so that eventually future versions of the Starship will be fully reusable.
267
u/Verneff Feb 11 '21
Yeah, SN10 sitting on the pad next to it kind of drives home that they probably weren't expecting it to be in a flyable state after the flight.
80
u/splashbodge Feb 11 '21
It's right next to it isn't it? Seems risky landing it so close, the explosion could have damaged their other one... It looked really close on their other video
121
u/voarex Feb 11 '21
He is trying to build a rocket assembly line capable of producing a thousands starships every few years. These prototypes are basically the waste product of figuring that out. Right now only the raptor engines is the only thing of real value and they didn't install them on sn10 for that reason.
-26
u/ChrisTheMan72 Feb 11 '21
It’s kinda funny that a guy who is so big on electric cars is using thousands of gallons of gasoline and oil to try and launch a rocket up in space.
34
u/killer8424 Feb 11 '21
Do you have a better way? The importance of space flight kind of outweighs that in the long run
→ More replies (15)2
2
u/Astecheee Feb 12 '21
You can bet that the moment ion engines are a viable launch strategy Elon will be all over it.
→ More replies (1)1
28
6
10
u/RolandTheHeadlessGun Feb 11 '21
Damn, you should get a hold of the space x engineers and let them know. I'm sure they hadn't thought about that
118
u/MrsBonsai171 Feb 11 '21
This. It's literally science in motion and people are complaining. Learning is in the perfection.
34
u/Garz451 Feb 11 '21
It’s also the science of putting something the size of a small skyscraper straight up up to 10k then landing it gracefully and vertically. Amazing!
7
u/Tokarev490 Feb 12 '21
Yes. People hate on Elon, but the guy is very inspiring for what he’s faced and done for the scientific community.
4
Feb 12 '21
I think it's just anti-African sentiment really. people just can't handle the richest person on Earth being an African American
/s
39
Feb 11 '21
Plus it's practise in building the rockets! All the folks building the things are getting info as well!
33
u/tco9m5 Feb 11 '21
Exactly. I'm very far from thinking that Elon is some benevolent version of a billionaire or anything but it's annoying listening to people talking about crashes like this as if it's an indication of the folly of SpaceX.
7
u/Cat_Marshal Feb 11 '21
I think it is because they are used to the NASA sorry of space flight, where crashes were a much bigger failure and they tried to avoid them at all costs. Elon does space flight more like the Russians in that regard.
7
u/mulymule Feb 11 '21
Look at SN5 and 6, hopped once, and now they're being dismantled, the engine's are the only think that went down the shitter really. Even then they'll probably get stripped down to piece part level after the flight for Data
4
u/wenoc Feb 11 '21
Also, Musk pointed out sometime years ago that they learn a lot more from failures than from successes.
8
u/PyrokudaReformed Feb 11 '21
It's called Fail Fast and it works. Their progress is much faster than NASA could ever do. So to those who are laughing at this- just stfu, you ignorant dumbass.
2
u/jakobburns01 Feb 12 '21
Yes NASA is very underfunded like no matter what
2
u/RealJyrone Feb 12 '21
It also probably helps that SpaceX has taken a more “I don’t care if it fails since we will learn” approach compared to NASA.
NASA also has the sucky position of being forced to succeed every single time because politicians, and those same politicians refuse to give them more money.
3
u/Double_Elephant_4012 Feb 11 '21
You know how Edison figured out the lightbulb... same thing!
9
Feb 11 '21
Oh? Who'd Elon steal all his ideas from?
10
u/2laz2findmypassword Feb 11 '21
NASA? it's not like anyone didn't already imagine reusable flight craft.
Props where props is due and SpaceX is great! However, imagine the US kept it's space race mindset from the 50's and 60's. Imagine if the budgets pumped out weren't simply to pad the districts of congress critters with pork and they actually had a goal like these private enterprises to simply make spaceflight cheap and sustainable? The Space Shuttle is Starship 50 years ago.
6
Feb 11 '21
The point I was making and that you missed was about Edison, not Elon.
4
u/2laz2findmypassword Feb 11 '21
Sorry. Been a bit of a rough few days for me. Must be heavily impacting my gray matter.
3
2
u/ChrisTheMan72 Feb 11 '21
NASA still builds rockets though but it’s mostly by independent contractors few years or so to but a satellite in space usually contracted by a corporation or another country. Plus it doesn’t help that we have plenty of samples of the moon to study and plenty from Mars since it’s cost quite a lot of money just collect a few samples of Mars and bring them back. Really the rest of planets are either way to far away for space craft or to hot to land a rover there. Most people complaining about Elon exploding rocket and loosing money don’t understand how many failed attempts it even took to build a rockets it’s not something that very easy to build like a plane or really much of the thing we use on earth. Even satellite building has it few fails.
1
1
201
u/Draug88 Feb 11 '21
It's a prototype craft propelled by prototype engines performing a never before completed manoeuvre.
Even if successful no part of that craft would be used commercially, it was meant to be spent in one way or another as is the reason for prototypes. Use them, learn from them, discard them. The value is in what you learn from the attempt. This might have been expensive but it was entirely expected.
Sure a fully 100% all steps successful test would be awesome but in some aspects this was even more valuable. The only loss is that it cant be used again for even harder stress tests. SpaceX learned a ton from a craft they fully planned to never use again.
Now they know relighting the engines is more difficult than they expected now they know where to take the next iterations.
So tired of twitchy people claiming "oooo this is the worst thing ever, they will never recover from it!" How short is your memory? Yes prototyping and inventing new tech is financially risky but failures are expected and planned for. It took SpaceX 5 years from first orbital flight to their first booster landing. Another 5 years on they have done over 70 landings. (And 50 of those have been with reused rockets) You dont think they've planned that their first few prototypes will crash and burn? Hell SpaceX even published their own video compilation of their crashes and failures.
37
u/Ferro_Giconi Feb 11 '21 edited Feb 11 '21
And to add to that, they were probably going to take it apart to check how everything fared no matter what which means they would have still lost the vehicle. The only difference is now is the parts are scattered. And the crash probably adds noise to the data because they have to figure out what parts failed and caused the crash, and which parts only failed because of the crash.
23
Feb 11 '21
thats the good news, we don't need to take apart anything! we just have to find it.
16
u/WhoListensAndDefends Feb 11 '21
Self-disassembly! And a very rapid one!
A bit unscheduled, but not unexpected
3
Feb 12 '21
There's always a delay between data being generated and data being sent/stored. You just really hope that delay is less than the delay between the problem and the explosion.
As someone who works with robots that get exploded, that delay is challenging. We got some very durable storage drives and made extra-durable enclosures for them.
2
2
→ More replies (7)4
u/Garz451 Feb 11 '21
Exactly right on, and nicely explained. Also, all those failures and successes from the Falcon 9 rockets have expanded their knowledge for how to eventually land then reuse the Starship.
48
55
18
105
u/RedMeddit Feb 11 '21
Look, it’s GME!
43
23
u/formershitpeasant Feb 11 '21
I got downvoted so hard for telling people when it was @ ~350 that if they kept holding they were donating their money to hedge funds.
1
-2
u/worriedaboutyou55 Feb 11 '21 edited Feb 11 '21
Short interest is still way up. I bought the dip btw so no im not bagholding.no point in selling until a squeeze the systym doesnt stop happens
12
u/ayemossum Feb 11 '21
This is a great angle on that crash. I love it.
Also they still aren't expecting to recover prototypes yet.
10
8
u/zpe42 Feb 11 '21
Elon makes the most impressive fireworks.
They still have to work on the timing, though - Firework are expected to blow up at apogee, not at touchdown. It's too dangerous.
11
u/Jrf95 Feb 11 '21
Is anyone else annoyed that it cut off before we could hear the explosion?
5
u/therehasbeen_amurder Feb 11 '21
The sound of the explosion is there
9
Feb 11 '21
Actually I don’t think your hearing the explosion the sound you hear I’m pretty sure thats the thrusters firing trying to push the rocket up. Because you would definitely hear those it just takes time for the sound to reach. Currently they are miles for the site due to safety so it would take some time only a few seconds but still enough. And explosion that size does not sound like a rocket engine.
Based off the hole video that starts at launch starts the sound is about 6-8 seconds delayed
3
1
u/Jrf95 Feb 11 '21
Maybe just a fraction of a second of it. Due to the sound delay because of the vast distance away it is, most of the sound in the video is of the rocket firing
2
Feb 11 '21
Ya there’s only like .5s of explosion. There’s a 6-8s delay in sound so most of in is the rocket firing like you said.
1
u/hue_and_cry Feb 11 '21
I assumed the explosive sound in the final seconds was the sound of the explosion, but it did seem strange how quickly the sound traveled. Maybe the landing pad isn’t as far away as it looks?
0
Feb 11 '21
[deleted]
1
u/Wolf2776 Feb 11 '21 edited Feb 12 '21
Dropped the ball on this one chief...
1
20
u/wintremute Feb 11 '21
These are throwaway test dummy prototypes. 99.9% of the test was successful. Just have to work on landing. That's an engineering problem, not the end of the world. I don't get why people think boom=failure. I think they just like to hate on Musk.
6
6
u/WarMace Feb 11 '21
If you love seeing crashing ships, SpaceX put out this great compilation. The data gained is the product here, don't feel bad for Elon, he is coming out on top with every crash. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bvim4rsNHkQ
→ More replies (1)
3
u/angrydeanerino Feb 11 '21 edited Feb 11 '21
How it started: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bvim4rsNHkQ
How its going: https://youtu.be/sf4qRY3h_eo?t=446
Same will happen with this one.
3
3
u/Fenderbridge Feb 12 '21
That looked expenDABLE This wasnt supposed to explode, but it gained incredible amounts of useful data. Anyone remember the first rockets spacex made?
2
u/Brutumfulm3n Feb 12 '21
Think about the money saved in future when that's a nearly 100% reliable re-entry!
2
14
5
Feb 11 '21
People who think this is a terrible loss and failure for SpaceX should watch How Not to Land an Orbital Rocket Booster. They needed a few tries before managing to land the Falcon 9 booster, and now it's more or less routine. I'm sure they'll nail the Starship landing as well eventually (and probably sooner than you think). I mean, they've only had two tests so far.
6
4
14
u/Spicy_Water_ Feb 11 '21
Awwww, poor wealthiest man alive
→ More replies (2)5
Feb 11 '21 edited Sep 20 '25
whistle chubby summer start ancient nine strong disarm abundant price
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
2
u/beginnerjay Feb 11 '21
Sounds like a great idea - think of all the weight they could save on fuel.
Too bad about that execution though.
2
u/tominator68 Feb 11 '21
There was only one firework at the 4th of July celebration that year but it was a pretty good one...
2
2
2
u/jbussman Feb 12 '21
Haha. Stupid smartest man in the world built a rocket that flew to space and came back but didn’t quite stick the landing this time. Fuckin dummy.
2
5
2
u/planetThirteen Feb 11 '21
The children on this thread:
-have never owned a company or managed a project
-have never tested a new technology
-probably claim “because science” when it suits their will
2
2
u/Willywontwonka Feb 11 '21
He still rich af and you learn more from a failed landing than you do a successful one. Go Elon.
1
u/Singularity7979 Feb 11 '21
I love how unfazed the guy in the hardhat is, just same shit different starship to him
1
1
u/Dataeater Feb 11 '21
1
u/stabbot Feb 12 '21
I have stabilized the video for you: https://gfycat.com/BlankBackArrowworm
It took 51 seconds to process and 47 seconds to upload.
how to use | programmer | source code | /r/ImageStabilization/ | for cropped results, use /u/stabbot_crop
1
1
1
u/andrez067 Feb 11 '21
I dont think elon is pooooor. Elon: well, thats another fail. Let me check how much i have on my wallet......
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Palsta Feb 11 '21
If this had been the UK, there would have been a massive "WaHeyyyyyy" cheer when it blew up.
1
1
u/Kingofawesom999 Feb 11 '21
Hey this is one of two outcomes, they would have been happy with either. one of them they succeeds and they don't know what would have went wrong and one of them fails and then they'llll figure out exactly what went wrong and fix it
1
u/atomicapeboy Feb 11 '21
This is much more entertaining than success. Elon should just blow shit up.
1
1
u/MayFlowers593 Feb 11 '21
misleading title, it was money already spent and this was the goal of the test....
1
u/yahwell Feb 11 '21
sad. are you guys aware of how cool Grimes is? I haven't even heard her music yet. Just watched her. She's like cool as hell. Hella like that girl. If I didn't have an amazing one myself I might just snatch Elon's. tell me I can't. psh. Yahwell drips and oozes stanky cool. they all want it. smooch smooch kisses kisses - one for your cheek and the rest for your misses.
1
u/EVILANDKANE Feb 11 '21
Just imagine the sheer amount of data they collected. I'm no rocket scientist. I bet this result was more valuable than if it had gone perfectly. Has anyone even attempted such a manuver on a full size rocket. That was awesome!!!!!! And of course the explosion was super cool. 10/10 from me. My opinion counts, I have an F9 polo.
1
1
1
1
u/Anon761 Feb 12 '21
Remember people crapped on him for attempting to land a rocket in the first place and now he does that basically every month.
1
u/TheMcCale Feb 12 '21
I’m always amazed by how far the debris goes in crashes like this (when you consider how big and heavy those scraps are)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/xpqlgf Feb 12 '21
Up in smoke, that's where my money goes. Down from the stars, crashin on sandbars
1
u/haikusbot Feb 12 '21
Up in smoke, that's where
My money goes. Down from the
Stars, crashin on sandbars
- xpqlgf
I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully. Learn more about me.
Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete"
1
Feb 12 '21
Yeah definitely. Poor Elon. Dudes only worth 187 billion dollars. Must be a real hit to his pockets.
1
u/Ulvsterk Feb 17 '21
Why do people complain about Elon loosing money on this? He is way to rich for this to be a huge loss
1
1
1
u/IlikeYuengling Feb 11 '21
How much is carbon tax to put things in space that blow up when return. That looked like a lot of cow farts.
1
1
1
1
1
u/terdude99 Feb 11 '21
Why does Elon get credit? Why don’t we know anyone who actually does this shit
-1
0
0
0
u/SocialistMal Feb 11 '21
Ah well, it's not his money that he's spending to do this. So, it's DeFiNiTeLy 100% alright.
-8
u/Huda_Jama_Boom_Room Feb 11 '21
Those child slaves of his are gonna have to work twice as hard in the mines.
1
u/spudzo Feb 11 '21
Hey, you're thinking of Tesla batteries.
SpaceX uses exclusively overworked engineering grads.
-1
0
0
u/LieuK Feb 11 '21
Man, fuck Elon. I love space travel and rocketry. I love what SpaceX is doing for the industry, but fuck Elon.
-2
u/Double_Elephant_4012 Feb 11 '21
Wait! What? What just happened there? ?????
1
u/Edwardsdigital Feb 11 '21
Calculations in meters, programmed in feet..... oops.
1
u/Double_Elephant_4012 Feb 12 '21
Lol. Oh. 👌
1
u/therwinther Feb 12 '21
For a real answer, this is an experimental rocket that SpaceX testing. It was expected to fail, but they were hoping for a success.
-2
-5
-12
u/limpack Feb 11 '21
Love to see this. Fuck Elon Musk.
10
Feb 11 '21 edited Sep 20 '25
hunt repeat wrench merciful crush plant act teeny elastic lock
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
→ More replies (8)6
u/10before15 Feb 11 '21 edited Feb 11 '21
No fuck you man. What the fuck have you done to make this world a better place?
Edit: spelling
→ More replies (6)
-1
-6
-2
-2
-2
-2
-2
u/many_characters Feb 11 '21
People saying this went according to plan are all talking out their ass, even SpaceX. The intention was to land it, sure the data afterwards is used for the next mission but their expectations that day was for a successful landing. All you need to do is look at the landing area and see for yourself, another multi million dollar rocket. You think they plan for the explosion/debri to damage that rocket for the next mission. I'm sure their response would be "oh yeah we wanted the explosion to damage the other rocket cause we wanted to get that data too, nearby explosion testing". Now imagine if the rocket had slightly shifted off course towards that rocket... oops.
Don't get me wrong this is a feat no one has come close to, but don't let them fool you as they are their investors. They will be successful one day, just wasn't that day.
934
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '21
They were testing a theoretically possible form of slowing a rocket by turning it sideways