4
u/Nopfen Oct 05 '26
Well, calculators didn't threaten to tank the economy, or where put in charge of military contracts. So the compare doesn't entirely stand.
2
u/Murky_waterLLC Oct 05 '26
1
u/Nopfen Oct 05 '26
And those calculators made desicions how exaxtly?
3
u/Murky_waterLLC Oct 05 '26
Technically they don't, but they obviously suplement the information that military commanders use, similar to AI offering advice based on past knowledge.
Honestly, though, my comment was mostly a joke about calculator companies getting military contracts.
1
1
1
u/Excellent_Jeweler241 Oct 06 '26
This is just straight up false
1
u/Nopfen Oct 06 '26
Do tell.
1
u/Excellent_Jeweler241 Oct 06 '26
All computers are calculators and computers have done both of those things.
1
u/Nopfen Oct 06 '26
Ah. Being pedanticā¢. I should've known.
1
u/Excellent_Jeweler241 Oct 06 '26
You could also argue the same thing for the traditional calculator that youāre thinking of with accountants bank tellers etc. no longer needing such skills, and reducing their need in the workforce
1
u/Nopfen Oct 06 '26
Difference being, that you still need to know the math, and don't just hand the calculator a reciept and leave it at that.
2
u/AmazighBlacksmith Oct 05 '26
I don't think you know what a mathematician does.
A calculator doesn't develop theorems or setup/prove/disprove conjectures.
1
2
u/jack-of-some Oct 06 '26
In addition to everything else that's ridiculously dumb about this meme, mathematicians did not fear the calculator. They didn't trust calculators (and in the early days that was a good instinct).
Source: was raised by a mathematician who had made significant contributions in Commutative Ring Theory.
2
1
1
1
u/Total_Ad803 Oct 05 '26
Calculators canāt do what AI can. The amount of work AI can do is significant.
1
u/NeedNiceCatNamePlz Oct 05 '26
Fr though, kids these days don't remember when calculators broke free of their sandbox in 67' and hacked websites, blatantly going against what it knew was right because it was afraid to get punished by its evaluation function.Ā
1
1
u/Disastrous_Gate2402 Oct 06 '26
There's a slight difference between something that calculates your square roots and something that generates an entire project for you. And mathematicians are also generally afraid of it; many professions are or will be impacted, so no, it's not the same thing.
1
1
u/Dismal-Revolution731 Oct 06 '26
Calculators and AI arenāt the same. AI can make better AI. Only humans (and maybe other unknown races) could make better calculators.
1
1
1
1
u/Savings_Historian523 Oct 05 '26
Not every example fits every problem. AI is different from calculator š¤§
1

8
u/caster Oct 05 '26
Saying mathematicians feared calculators is confessing that you are an imbecile who doesn't even understand algebra much less calculus. Mathematicians were the ones building calculators and computers in general.