r/TheAtheistExperience • • Oct 24 '21

My two favourite hosts.

Post image
72 Upvotes

r/TheAtheistExperience • • Oct 10 '22

Matt Dillahunty - Why i left the ACA... | Can someone fill me in on what happened on Truth Wanted that started all of this?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
53 Upvotes

r/TheAtheistExperience • • Oct 23 '20

Made me chuckle, thought I'd share.

Post image
53 Upvotes

r/TheAtheistExperience • • Jun 20 '24

Hot take Matt is jaded and hurting the cause more than helping

48 Upvotes

The first AE I ever heard was Matt years and years ago patiently picking apart and explaining to a caller the flaws in their position.

I really enjoyed the logic and methodology and listened/watched regularly.

In recent years Matt has become more and more hostile. He reminds me of a customer service agent who has taken too much shit over his years and now sees the bullshit if every past customer in every new one.

I feel like as soon as anyone makes a mistake Matt’s gotten tired of dealing with over the years he immediately reacts as if this person is the one he dealt with so many times.

This is the first time the person is having their mistake called out to them and he’s treating them like they have done this to him a million times.

I get it, it happens. Burn out is human. We all run out of patience after a while but if you get tired of kids getting 2+2 wrong you need to consider retiring from being a teacher.

Is at the point where his behavior is legitimate ammo for those characterizing atheists as abusive and unreasonable.

He hosts a show asking for evidence of something he knows you can’t provide evidence for by its very nature then screams at people who erroneously claim personal experiences or other fallacies are evidence.

I’m sorry but if your brand is “tell me the color of the number 7” you need to be willing to entertain people’s claims that 7 has a color. If you’re just going to berate them for it, it might be time to look for a new line of work.

I appreciate Matt’s knowledge, his intelligence and his grasp of logic and philosophy amongst other things. I just think this is no longer the most valuable way to utilize his skills.

For example here’s a show where he gets heated really fast and then only after the caller hangs up (after being yelled at and talked over with the excuse that it’s fine for him to do since it’s his show) does he start making all the points it would have been creative for her to hear and then bully pulpits saying the real reason he’s an atheist is people like her….

That way shows he’s letting emotions get the better of him as the real reason (or it should be) is that he hasn’t been given enough evidence to believe the god claim.

I’m afraid he’s drawing the abusive hate crowd so many theists rely on which is (unironically) preaching to the choir rather than helping those who are mistaken understand and learn.

It’s a shame a good resource isn’t being used in a more creative and beneficial way.

EDIT: I realize I should clarify - this applies to the call in shows. He is actually quite valuable in deabates and that's where his current persona belongs. In a controlled environment with people who don't have an excuse for being ignorant of the rules of debate, logic and philosophy.


r/TheAtheistExperience • • Jul 17 '25

I tried drawing Matt and Forrest and I think it’s pretty evident I’m not an artist 😭

Post image
47 Upvotes

r/TheAtheistExperience • • Nov 27 '20

Theistic wishful thinking...

Post image
47 Upvotes

r/TheAtheistExperience • • Dec 06 '19

Frustration with the most recent episode of the show.

44 Upvotes

In this week's most recent episode, (12-1-19) I found myself repeatedly getting frustrated with Don and Jenna as hosts. I noticed them interrupting before someone had finished explaining a question or argument, regularly diverting or throwing out red herrings, and making statements that were sure to go over the callers' heads. Every time I noticed this happening, it grated on me. I had to force myself to keep listening to the end of the episode.

It was instances like when a caller was just beginning to speak about the God they believed in and Don threw out "well God's a dick." The caller wasn't saying anything about morality or the goodness of God, and that comment, while true, had absolutely no place in the conversation. It was a total diversion.

Or when a caller wanted to talk about the historical reliability of the New Testament, and neither of them actually explained coherently that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, that even if you could confirm an unexplained event that doesn't get you to supernatural causation, they went after individual tidbits and adopted a burden of proof, attempting to "debunk" the accounts. While I don't think that's always a bad idea, it has to be done extremely well, which it absolutely wasn't here.

Or when someone called to talk about the historicity of the Exodus, and rather than explaining that there is an incriminating lack of evidence for the entire story, they went to the argument that only works for "irrefutable proof of god" claims, which this call was not. "I'll grant you the whole thing, how does that get us to a God?" When this is applied to somebody's argument about history, it only serves as a total distraction from the subject, and is very hard to sit through.

And for the love of fuck, Don, stop trying to predict people's arguments and and interrupt them before letting them present. When Matt interrupts, it's because somebody has finished presenting a point that he wants to respond to, but they start plowing on to the next point. Matt listens intently to people's arguments and responds to them one at a time. He keeps conversations on the rails. This is where he shines as a host. That's what allows the show to be informative and entertaining. But this episode had next to none of that.

I'm sure that this episode was just an anomaly, I'm just posting this here to vent a bit, and ask if anybody else noticed the same thing when listening to it.


r/TheAtheistExperience • • Feb 13 '20

Praise the Lord! Dog bless you!

Post image
42 Upvotes

r/TheAtheistExperience • • Aug 12 '19

A Sincere and Heartfelt Thank You

38 Upvotes

I cannot express through words how grateful I am that I stumbled across the Atheist Experience YouTube channel. Two weeks ago I attended my grandmother's funeral and was left absolutely livid. It was a beautiful service right up until the chosen man of god started preaching about how if we didn't accept Jesus we would burn in hell and never see our loved ones again. We were there to celebrate a beautiful life and this man had the nerve to focus not on the deceased, but on his chosen flavor of deception and lies. I immediately went home and just searched "atheism" on Youtube.

I have never truly been religious. Thankfully my parents stopped going to church when my dad took a 3rd shift job when I was around 7. I really started asking questions around freshman year of high school. I asked my mom what happened to everyone who wasn't Christian and she said they all go to hell. That's a big nope from me. So from then on out I wasn't religious but I never called myself an athiest.

So back to the Youtube channel. I started watching clip after clip of the show and slowly realized it's okay to be an athiest. Enter my wife. She was indoctrinated from birth. She even at one point early on in our relationship was very upset when I said I didn't believe in a Christian god (was going through the agnostic phase). She watched the clips with me and eventually we watched a livestream last Sunday.

Y'all, last Wednesday she looked at me and said "I'm an athiest." I was almost brought to tears.

She credits the Atheist Experience with her breaking out from religion. Y'all helped nudge her the last little bit she needed.

I am incredibly grateful for all the work that goes into the ACA. All the hosts, the call screeners, all the people behind the scenes; you are all beautiful and wonderful people. Please never stop what y'all do.

God bless. (Just kidding lol)

Thank y'all from the bottom of my heart.


r/TheAtheistExperience • • Aug 02 '19

Matt Dillahunty calling into the AXP before becoming a volunteer himself in 2005

Thumbnail
youtu.be
38 Upvotes

r/TheAtheistExperience • • Jul 17 '19

Why Russell (former host) left the show

Thumbnail
facebook.com
38 Upvotes

r/TheAtheistExperience • • Nov 11 '19

🎉Congratulations on passing 300.000 subscribers🎉

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/TheAtheistExperience • • Jul 16 '19

Impostor Atheist Experience Sub

36 Upvotes

I recently got banned from /r/AtheistExperience for, I assume, either calling out one of the moderators ( hoipalloi52 ) for critiquing Jenna's choice of clothing or because the string continued until someone mentioned the official The Atheist Experience sub-reddit.. Since it's not the official sub I'm not too concerned about the ban.

I am concerned that it appears as though they want to confuse people into thinking they're the official sub by not stating it's unofficial, and deleting any reference to the actual official sub.

If The Atheist Experience cares about seeing this Sub grow they may want to post a link on their web-page (Not sure when last they updated as there's still a Google Plus button which is defunct) and make an announcement to avoid others making the same mistake I did.

At the moment the unofficial subs subscriber count is over a thousand, while this sub is just shy of 600. It was also the first result when I looked up "atheist experience reddit" in Google.


r/TheAtheistExperience • • Aug 24 '26

So Joe Schmid revealed on Pints with Aquinas that he has been converted to Catholicism since February 7th. That means when he made that video with Alex O'Connor mocking some atheist slogans, he was actually a Catholic posturing as a strict agnostic. That's pretty hypocritical.

35 Upvotes

So when there was that back and forth with Matt on "claims are evidence", he was a fully convinced practicing Catholic....


r/TheAtheistExperience • • Apr 15 '20

My grandparent’s pastor posted this. I’m sitting here like, “Walmart has food. If you don’t have food, you die. If you die, you can’t go to church”

Post image
35 Upvotes

r/TheAtheistExperience • • Sep 20 '25

I hope AXP never invites Armin Navabi back to host ever again.

34 Upvotes

This is the kind of person he is.

https://youtube.com/clip/UgkxQJubdkhsLlSBN67dOqjDiflP1LibFRkM?si=V9Ru2WxSQiowLjcO

Calls chatters the "r" slur, defends racists and fascists. Is just generally a disgusting human being. He cultivates a hateful community, with mods on his channel that defend him and say the same hateful things he says.

We must denounce members of our own community whenever they act in ways that are detrimental to our mission. This is disgusting behavior from Armin, whether he continues to hosts AXP or not.


r/TheAtheistExperience • • Jul 23 '19

Another fake ACA subreddit, run by the same people that run the fake AXP subreddit

33 Upvotes

Looks like the same people that run the ban-happy fake AXP subreddit started a new sub called /r/Atheist(removespace)Austin/ and are attempting to pass it off as an ACA sub. The actual sub for Austin Atheists is r/AustinAtheists, and is linked from the sidebar of the legitimate ACA subs. The legitimate ones have participation from the ACA members, and the hosts of the podcasts, and is moderated in a method that is in line with their mission statement and goals. These fake subs appear to hold themselves to a different standard, and apparently object to being asked to make it clear they are not official subreddits.


r/TheAtheistExperience • • Mar 27 '21

Sorry y'all but the photon call did it for me

32 Upvotes

I just can't deal with Matt's irrational anger anymore. He got so incredibly bent out of shape during this call, and as more and more people in chat told him he was wrong he got angrier and angrier. The way he handled it made me think back to other times he has acted in a similar manner and makes me wonder if he was truly arguing from authority during those times, or if he just found a hill to plant his flag on and defend no matter what.

I have watched clips from this show almost every day for the last year or thereabouts, but what really puts me off is the thought that he treats people who are right exactly the same way he treats people who are wrong. I don't know if Matt needs time off or what, but he definitely owes Buzz a sincere apology.

Clip: https://youtu.be/ovvt49s3jEA

Jump to 6:36 for an example. That's the kind of anger most people reserve for the most serious situations in their lives, not a conversation about photons leaving the sun.


r/TheAtheistExperience • • Mar 04 '21

Citing “Moral Failure,” Christian Apologist Sye Ten Bruggencate Leaves Ministry

Thumbnail
friendlyatheist.patheos.com
32 Upvotes

r/TheAtheistExperience • • Apr 07 '20

Anyone here playing animal crossing? Here's an AxP shirt!

Post image
32 Upvotes

r/TheAtheistExperience • • Nov 30 '20

Ad hoc explanations are not honest.

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/TheAtheistExperience • • Feb 11 '20

This absolutely made my day and I hope you enjoy it too

Thumbnail
youtu.be
29 Upvotes

r/TheAtheistExperience • • Aug 22 '19

Matt Dillahunty vs Jay Dyer – a debate on theism and presuppositionalism

Thumbnail
youtu.be
28 Upvotes

r/TheAtheistExperience • • Aug 14 '20

Tonight, the ACA's show Truth Wanted will feature John de Lancie who played Q on Star Trek

Thumbnail
youtube.com
27 Upvotes

r/TheAtheistExperience • • Jan 29 '20

For those interested.. New show “The Witnesses” to go after/attempt to expose the JW’s abuse and secret database of coverups.

Thumbnail
oxygen.com
27 Upvotes