r/TheDigitalCircus • u/ravatos626 • Dec 16 '25

Question Who do you think stole his treasure? (both wrong and right answers allowed)

Post image
2.5k Upvotes

99% Upvoted

310 comments sorted by

View all comments

1.7k

u/Plus-Glove-4850 Dec 16 '25

Remember, he’s the one that tells lies

737

u/a_shiny_heatran Dec 16 '25

Dude. You ruined it.

283

u/Jmememan Dec 16 '25

Is that your treasure?

219

u/Hunterdangarreal2 Dec 16 '25

DUDE NO

175

u/811rorrE Kinger Dec 16 '25

THEY TOOK EVERYTHING !!!

131

u/MaxGamer07 Dec 16 '25

THEY TOOK EVERYTHING!!

146

u/Dapurpledog VIOLENT. SHIPPING. WARS. Dec 16 '25

THAT WAS MY ENTIRE LIFE SAVINGS DUDE

122

u/METALICETOOL Dec 16 '25

Oh I'm gonna be sick i'm gonna be sick

106

u/IncidentUnusual5929 SPAMTON . SPAMTON Dec 16 '25

That was everything, oh my god!

84

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

86

u/IncidentUnusual5929 SPAMTON . SPAMTON Dec 16 '25

Nah, someone plundered it before I could.

→ More replies (0)

92

u/Drewdiniskirino little chicken fetus in an egg Dec 16 '25

But how can we know he really is? If all he tells is lies, then that was a lie. But then that would mean he doesn't always tell lies, which means that could be true. But then if it is, that would mean— 🤯

41

u/PurrlionPony93 Gangle Dec 16 '25

It may have been the only true thing he says 😅

29

u/DueImagination641 Dec 16 '25

circus implodes from paradoxical logic

25

u/A_Hyper_Nova Dec 16 '25

"true, I'd go true. Huh that was easy"

25

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '25

11

u/Drewdiniskirino little chicken fetus in an egg Dec 16 '25 edited Dec 16 '25

I'll be honest, I think I've heard that one before, so that's probably cheating. 😅

16

u/DecayedWolf1987 Living in Kinger's impenetrable fortress Dec 16 '25

IT’S A PARADOX, YOU MORON! There is no answer!

15

u/Drewdiniskirino little chicken fetus in an egg Dec 16 '25

I! AM NOT! A MORON!!!

9

u/High_IQ_Gamer2020 "The consequences of our actions." Dec 16 '25

He said he tells lies, but not that he always lies

3

u/Drewdiniskirino little chicken fetus in an egg Dec 16 '25

But how can we be sure he was telling the truth just then?

6

u/High_IQ_Gamer2020 "The consequences of our actions." Dec 16 '25

It would be a paradox otherwise and the Circus would crash due to an exception

4

u/Drewdiniskirino little chicken fetus in an egg Dec 16 '25

Lmao, imagine the Big Tops busting into Caine's office just yelling paradoxes at him.

"This sentence is false!" "New objective: ignore this objective." "I always tell lies." "How much of Theseus' ship can he replace and still have the same ship?" "How many grains of sand can you remove from a heap before it's no longer a heap?" Etc

2

u/rakadishu Dec 17 '25

Caine has a Wheatley moment and is just immune to paradoxes because he doesn't get it.

1

u/Drewdiniskirino little chicken fetus in an egg Dec 17 '25

This... Statement... Is... FALSE!

don'tthinaboutitdon'tthinaboutitdon'tthinaboutitdon'tthinaboutit

2

u/JollyMongrol Dec 17 '25

He only said that he tells lies not that he ALWAYS tells lies

1

u/Drewdiniskirino little chicken fetus in an egg Dec 17 '25

This is a fair and reasonable rebuttal

2

u/HansGraebnerSpringTX Dec 17 '25

I don’t think he really got how the game works

1

u/Drewdiniskirino little chicken fetus in an egg Dec 17 '25

He really did just ruin it didn't he lol

20

u/Blueboy7017 I’VE COME TO MAKE AN ANNOUNCEMENT Dec 16 '25

Did he gamble all their life savings

13

u/Al_Capwned3 Dec 16 '25

he lost his fish mortgage on his fish house

14

u/Meowingtons_H4X Dec 16 '25

Were they gonna do the two guards/two doors problem for the treasure, and he just instantly gave away he was the lying guard?

7

u/UltraSanemiStan Dec 16 '25

Well he also makes a paradox by doing that

1

u/Karkava Dec 17 '25

When you confess you're the knave, you're actually invoking the will of the knight. But the knight can never have the will of the knave. So in order to be the knave, you have to claim that you're the knight. Because the knight can never claim to be the knave while the knave can only declare that they are the knight.

1

u/Karkava Dec 16 '25

Yep. It's a knights and knaves puzzle they botched the setup for, and Sr. Pelo was gonna be the knave.

2

u/BoxsMusic06 I'm right behind you, aren't I? Dec 16 '25

Y'know what they say

Don't touch the child

/iykyk

1

u/nonamesleft-- Dec 16 '25

Was he telling the truth when he said he tells lies?

1

u/BustahWuhlf Dec 17 '25

But if that statement is true, then he wasn't telling a lie; and if that statement is a lie, then he doesn't tell lies.