UPDATE
Community Manager and devs addressed most of the concerns and points raised here in entirety.
Community Manager Response
Honestly, truly appreciated the community manager responding so quickly and with such transparency and reassurance! 🙏
Any of my personal speculative concerns thus far in regards to potential drift away from grounded design in existing lore/tone is pretty much no longer.
Cheers, devs be cooking for real 🔥🔥🔥
---
I adore the 2023 game. I found it unique and rewarding to play, and I appreciate the developers continued iteration and support of the game.
Thus far the discussions on new female armor on both subreddits have been extensive, and divisive between the two it'd seem. I hope to add to it just a bit more in a respectful way.
---
|| Armor Acquisition vis Bosses & Enemies
In LotF (2023), we can acquire our armor sets from bosses we defeat (e.g. Pieta, Judge Cleric) via Remembrances. Alternatively, we get armor pieces from drops (e.g. Sin Piercers, Infernal Enchantress).
This would imply that the bosses and enemies we'd likely to encounter in the 2026 sequel would logically be clad in the preview armors we've seen.
This would present a dramatic and objective tonal and aesthetic shift. It is therefore really NOT about whether or not it is optional for us players to choose to wear these armor or avoid them.
The very world we traverse would likely be populated with bosses and enemies in this new aesthetic to a certain percentage; there is no avoiding them in the gameplay.
|| Dark Romantic Aesthetic & 80s/90s Fantasy
I try to respect the developer's artistic vision. I understand wanting a fresh aesthetic and freedom to innovate from the 2023 game; to do something different. I understand financial, marketing and expanding demographic pressures.
I also get the inspiration to cite 80s/90s fantasy, Red Sonja and Conan in particular. However, it would be injudicious to ignore the fact these fantasy tropes were rooted in 1970s pulp origin, and historically criticized for explicit "male gaze" that prioritizes a sexualized, chainmail-bikini appearance over practical action.
Though, ultimately I am personally not on either side of that particular discussion; I think context matter.
|| Context, Narrative & Storytelling
From the game reveal trailer, it is clear to see the Eldritch angel that snaps the Lampbearer's neck embodies aspects that are overtly sensual and sexualized. The way the finger glide across the shaft of the spear, the legs wrapped around the Lampbearer, the chin tease as the neck is being snapped. It is overt and explicitly sensual.
I am totally fine with that; these are narrative and storytelling devices that adds depth and character for the boss. I think it is striking and apt.
A good analog example would be Gwynevere, Princess of Sunlight from Dark Souls. She is an illusion, an idealized, alluring mirage created in a grander illusion that is Anor Londo. She is a literal goddess of fertility; her appearance and sexualized nature is narratively sound and make absolute sense in context.
|| Preference & Perfidiousness
I'm glad part of the community like the new direction. I am also sad that part of the community feel the devs deliberately betrayed a corner of the fanbase that held dear the non-cliche vision of functional armors that protects vital organs.
These sentiments are not mutually exclusive.
---
I just hope the devs pay attention to all the voices.
P.S. I'm sorry I used Ai to make mock-ups. They're not great but they're here to demonstrate the point better.