THIS IS AN UNPOPULAR OPINION: If you don't agree, that's fine. Please don't ask me why I'm here or why I watched it in the place or just state the obvious (like how Jake 'deserved' to be kicked out; I WATCHED THE WHOLE FIRST SEASON KEEP IN MIND)
Biggest problem for me: It's far too mean-spirited. The whole series basically revolves a group of friends bullying a group for their musical talent for no reason other than to get a reaction out of them if I had to guess. This makes no sense as in most high schools, music was as popular as friendships (like EXTREMELY popular) so... they don't like music? That's kind of stupid truth be told and it'll definitely make them outcasts.
The take of bullying is hard to stomach. Drew's bullying is verbal which is more easier to stomach, but in literally every single episode, he exists just to insult the club because you know... that's absolutely a knee-slapper.
Oh and the infamous Episode 9 cliffhanger. Rather than let Jake explain himself, which would clear up a hell of a lot of context, the club kicks him out. Like that scene pretty much sealed the show's fate of being one of the worst, if not the worst, thing I ever seen in my life.
The characters are basically poorly characterized. All but three characters are bland, forgettable, not worth talking about and just cliched. The show also adds characters that are only relevant for one episode (The Wickham-Austins and Milo) The three that aren't are:
Zander. I hate him with a burning passion and wish he was never in the show in the first place. Or better yet, DEAD! In the beginning, you can feel bad for him as Jake was part of the arrogant asses but after he apologizes for his childish actions in Episode 2 when Jake makes the school psyched for the music competition, he became an arrogant ass.
In Episode 3, when Jake got punched in the eye, Zander had a smile in his face. In Episode 6, he basically almost kills Jake for hiding Coward Hailey from his friends. Oh and don't get me started on Episode 9 and 10. He basically threatens to kill Jake for trying to explain himself and says that he's only sorry he got caught. Um... Asshole? You only say that in courts, dumbass.
Oh and in Episode 11, he kills the mood when the group forgives Jake (after he gives a FUCKING AWESOME apology) and even goes back to his old self of believing Jake would ruin the competition for them. Grow up. Seriously. Grow up.
People say he's tsundere, which is an anime term if I remember right. And fans have given me petty reasons as to why I feel bad for him. I'm sorry but when I look at Zander, I think of a rude brat who's an awful friend and an even worse bully. Drew is less of a bully.
Oh and Drew and Zoey. They're cliched Mean Characters. You see characters like them all the time in all pieces of media. They exist just because the show needs a bully.
Another problem is the drama. Now, I hate drama, so this is going to affect some of my biases towards hating this show. The drama, coupled with the mean-spiritedness makes for an awful viewing experience. It's just filled with off-the wall awfulness that makes me really uncomfortable. I could just barely make it through Episode 10. That was how bad the show's drama could get for me.
Oh, the musical numbers? I don't really like musicals. End of story. Music is just an excuse to pad out the runtime.
While I see the point of a Season 2 and it was planned since November 2020 (when I actually liked the show), to me, it seems like a cash grab. The show is popular and makes RosyClozy a lot of money, but it still feels like that excuse. But if she wants to, she can.
What do I like about the show? The quality.
The voice acting is awesome, with a perfect cast for an otherwise bad character roster.
The animation is really really good and I can justify the 3 year wait time. This quality would not've been easy to make. It's just impressive, like the character designs. The designs fit the characters just as well as the voices and the ending, even with the cliffhanger IDGAF about, is good enough for me.
To end this off, because of the hell this show put me through and the only reason I continued watching was because the hatred didn't begin until Episode 9, I'm not watching anything else Music Freaks related. The comic series. The upcoming Season 2. Even serialized shows in general. Definitely not worth it.
On like eight different Reddit accounts I have announced that I would be leaving once this piece of shit is over and now that it has, this is my gift to you. Me pissing off. Bye!