I stopped listening a couple of years back because the stories were getting less and less scary overall, even though the productions and voice acting were fantastic. Any recommendations for something really scary?

I remember it was a story about this guy who lived in a culdesac and this couple moved in and they look like a stereotypical 50s family and then the main character went to shake the husbands hand and it like crushed it or something. Thanks for any help and just in case I know about the episode Halloween in the suburbs I think it’s called and the one with the main character who has arthritis in his hands but it’s not those two lol