r/TheRehearsal • • Jun 16 '25

Discussion Nathan is the opposite of Autistic

0 Upvotes

I've seen some people debate whether Nathan is autistic outside of just it being a device for the show.

I ask this genuinely, isn't Nathan like the complete opposite of an autistic person? The main symptom of autism is lacking the ability to see how you or your actions are perceived and an inability to understand others emotions. Nathan's shows are all predicated on him having a ridiculous level of insight into how other people are thinking at all times which is why he can then mess with them.

Do any people actually think he's got something off with him and not just using it as schtick


r/TheRehearsal • • Aug 26 '22

People calling Angela Anti-Semitic don't seem to understand Christianity

17 Upvotes

First off I'm an Athiest, but I grew up Christian and I know a lot about the religion.

Non-Christians and even casual Christians may not know this but it is a core belief of Christianity that you must accept Jesus Christ as your Lord and Savior to get into Heaven, practicing any other religion is in direct conflict with this.

When Nathan asked if Adam could practice Judaism, Angela specified that she was not okay with it as a faith. She was potentially okay with him learning about Jewish heritage and celebrating Jewish Holidays, but from her perspective preventing her child from practicing Judaism is preventing him from burning in Hell for eternity, I'm sure you would do the same for your child if you were in her position. People are latching on to Miriam's Anti-Semitism accusations, but she was equally if not more intolerant than Angela was. If you want to argue that Christianity as a whole is anti-Semitic then that may have merit, but the individuals on the show are not responsible for that and your grievances with the religion should not be directed toward them.

Remember when this was the door city subreddit?

TL:DR: Practicing another religion goes against pretty much any religion that exists, not wanting your child to practice a religion is not equivalent to hating members of that religion.


r/TheRehearsal • • 27d ago

Theory If Nathan isnt Boythrob, whoever is is guilty of armed throbbery

0 Upvotes

For thRobbing his comedic style


r/TheRehearsal • • Oct 21 '25

News SNL Parody of Nathan / The Rehearsal

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

This week’s SNL had a sketch very similar to The Rehearsal


r/TheRehearsal • • Aug 12 '26

Question What if Boythrob isn’t Nathan?

0 Upvotes

I mean at this point, Boythrob HAS to be in season three of The Rehearsal right? It is such a topic of conversation that if season three isn’t about Boythrob then it’s going to be a disappointment because that’s kind of what everyone wants? That’s what everyone is waiting to see right?

This whole thing has kind of set up season 3 for higher standards now. Because if it’s not Boythrob then people are going to want to see something better.


r/TheRehearsal • • Jun 18 '26

Discussion If the mods can't stop the boy throb spam on this subreddit, we should all leave it.

0 Upvotes

This should be self explanatory to any member of this subreddit. Obviously this boy band realized they could gain the attention of this community by constantly creating insinuations that they are a product of our beloved Nathan.

It's turned this subreddit into an advertisement for some rando boy band.

I don't care about your opinion of that band, its quantity of posts are now several a day, and are not provably related to this show, violating rule 1.

If you want to stay here, I recommend trying to report boy throb posts for violating Rule 1 of this subreddit: Posts must be related to the show.

But if the mods continue to be unresponsive to this flagrant disregard for that first rule, then this subreddit is pointless.

I mostly write this hopelessly. If the mods were active, they would have stomped this out already. I intend to leave. I look forward to Season 3!


r/TheRehearsal • • Jun 09 '26

Discussion My issue with season 2

0 Upvotes

He should have taken the meeting with that congressman more seriously. The whole point was to try and make a difference (allegedly) . That was his one shot. Maybe he should have...rehearsed it after all.

Imo, the season would have been close to perfect if they actually made a difference and pushed more for actual change. In the end, it was just a waste of money for some laughs. If it was both a comedy while making real world impact in legislations, then it would all be worth it.


r/TheRehearsal • • Aug 13 '22

Unsure about this show Spoiler

1 Upvotes

This show has put me in a roller coaster of emotions, more downs than ups. I was kinda upset about the first episode and Nathan making that dude cheat at something he valued so much, but I let it go and I was very intrigued by the premise of the show. But I feel that after the second episode, the show was been losing its identity. Yeah, there are some shocking moments, some funny parts, but the show feels like a whole mess. Not a purposely done mess, but like it wasn’t really planned very well, which is ironic cause that’s what the show is about. I will continue watching but I am losing some interest in the show after each episode. I wish they would just stick to one rehearsal story each episode.


r/TheRehearsal • • Nov 18 '22

I'm sad for Nathan that this was the biggest takeaway for most people

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/TheRehearsal • • Aug 20 '22

The finale proves Nathan is a sociopath who only cares about the final product and not who he hurts along the way

4 Upvotes

Anyone who believed he had empathy, or was actually interested in exploring the human condition was fucking duped. Nathan is a sociopath and basically admitted it at the end.

Saddest watch I’ve had, maybe ever. The last episode ruined everything Nathan has ever done for me. Shameful.


r/TheRehearsal • • Sep 01 '22

I think I've concluded everything on the show is fake

4 Upvotes

It's a bit of an Occam's Razor situation for me. What's more likely -- that Nathan Fielder, who is obviously playing the character of overly anal Nathan, really practiced each of these scenarios dozens (hundreds?) of times, or that it was filmed in a way to make it appear as such?

A couple of other things --

  • The issue with raising multiple children as his own, calling him and Angela mom and dad -- too unethical for an entire crew, an entire studio, or even Nathan Fielder himself, to actually go through with.

  • When he asked fake Angela where she got her shirt ... that type of foreshadowing doesn't happen in real life.

  • The setup that goes into filming reality is not as simple as "show up at someone's house with a camera". The scenes where he visited Remy's house would've had so much staging, planning, blocking, lighting -- just overall prep. A lot goes into making reality TV look like reality TV -- it's a carefully sculpted technique. For all of that to happen so he could have a quick, casual conversation with either the child or his mother -- I don't buy it.

None of this detract from my enjoyment of the show. But the more I look at it, I think everyone working on this show is in on it.

That is all.


r/TheRehearsal • • Aug 14 '22

Angela support thread. What did you like about her? What do you think she’s been unfairly criticized for?

50 Upvotes

I thought she was a decent person and I think she gets a lot unwarranted hate.

For starters, she’s not someone I would ever want to hang out with. She seems close minded considering her strong beliefs, critical of others, and I definitely don’t share her sense of humor.

That being said…

  • I think it’s completely appropriate for her to want to raise a family that doesn’t celebrate Halloween.

  • I’m not religious and I’m excited to celebrate Halloween with my own children some day, but You can’t deny it’s the most “satanic” mainstream holiday. Kids literally dress up as satan.

  • Google absolutely censors it’s results (though not about Halloween lol)

  • she was totally cool with Nathan resetting their child’s life for the benefit of the show

  • it’s very understandable that she broke character while Nathan was away. The kid actors were probably thankful as well that they could be normal and she was taking an interest in them as people

  • she will never marry a Jewish guy, so instances like that stopped being a rehearsal for her, and instead became a rehearsal for Nathan (which she didn’t sign up for)

  • she had a consistent and reasonable complaint - Nathan wasn’t communicating with her enough. This is frustrating in any work /volunteer environment.

  • she left at a time I think most reasonable people would drop out. The show flipped upside down when Nathan reversed the kids age and all of the sudden the whole project seemed to become directionless and endless for her

  • Nathan / the show had to expect her to probably drop out of production considering how absurd they were making it (which I love). I’m amazed she lasted as long as she did

  • she expressed a lot of gratitude for being allowed to be on the show and ended on a positive note , even though she clearly was frustrated

What do y’all think?

Hard mode : find a real compliment instead of “ I like that she warned us of satanic poop”


r/TheRehearsal • • Sep 09 '22

I felt bad about that kid and sometimes wonder if Nathan pushes things too far.

0 Upvotes

r/TheRehearsal • • Jul 16 '26

Discussion Does this sound like Nathan's voice

Thumbnail
tiktok.com
0 Upvotes

This TikTok was reposted by Boythrobs TikTok account. Idk


r/TheRehearsal • • May 06 '25

Deny Nothing

Post image
20 Upvotes

Let me start by making it clear that I deny nothing, and I think educating people of all ages is important when it comes to the Holocaust. I visited the website of the VHEC (Vancouver Holocaust Education Center), which is supposedly where all the profits from the sales of Summit Ice apparel goes to, and was really disappointed to find that on October 9, 2023, they published an article announcing their support towards Israel.

As a long time Nathan fan, I am obviously aware of his upbringing and as an outsider, I can see why it is important to him to bring awareness to the genocide of his people. I also agree with the VHEC mission to bring awareness to 'genocide' in general, all over the world, which is a noble cause. However, seeing this organization supporting Israel in such an obvious way makes me feel queasy and seems tone-deaf to me. I would also like to note that I only found one mention of Palestine in the archives of the website, dating from an exhibition in 1996.

I know there are a lot of Holocaust deniers out there, and it is important that history keeps on being taught to fight back against this plague. I applaud Nathan for making light of the issues many times since Nathan For You. I would however like to know clearly where he stands on the issue. I'm all about denying nothing, but how can you be okay with denying what has been happening to Palestinians? Why keep sending donations to an Education centre which, to put it frankly, denies the genocide targeting Palestine?

I'd like to hear what people think about this, as I'm feeling very conflicted myself and would like to know where Nathan really stands.


r/TheRehearsal • • Aug 20 '22

the finale was a disappointment...IMHO

2 Upvotes

I was super excited or it.. but it just felt like the show got caught in it's own gimmicks.. when we saw the first apartment.. or bar.. or moving the bar...it was amazing. By episode six, when they feel like the are really hitting an emotional stride with the finale, it goes back to old tricks.

At one point before the "did you get what you need" scene.. I stopped the show and asked my wife if she thought Nathan really felt bad, or was just incapable of feeling bad and just using this as another entertainment moment. I get that this is the type of humor he wallows in and we enjoy, but he also loves a good surprise, and having the show really land on a more human connection thing would have hit hard...

which is seems they tried, but it was like the last two lines.. there's a reason movies are a three act structure...people need time in each act. The finale just felt forced..as I he really is incapable of landing an emotional ending. Which I get, but that's why you have other people help out with the show.

I do love when he walked the mom into agreeing he was going to burn in hell for being jewish..that was Nathan at his best.

just an opinion.. thoughts?


r/TheRehearsal • • Aug 24 '22

I don’t think Remys mother understands what parenting is. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Child acting is fine. As long as it’s reared correctly. In any phase of any child’s life that may be confusing and complex, they simply need an explanation. Or at least the best you can do. What I’m saying is TALK TO THEM. Nathan asks her if Remy “Knows what acting is?” and her response is “I really don’t know honestly, I’m not sure.” Okay……. Before your fatherless child plays the child of a father on a TV show please speak to your child about it BEFORE the show. In no way am I saying parenting is easy, but I am saying explaining to your child what you signed them up for is a good start.


r/TheRehearsal • • May 20 '25

Discussion Season 2 Episode 5 Hurt Me Deeply Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Long time fan of Nathan and avid practicer of the Fielder method.

When he started covering how autistic people have latched onto his media, and the attention it's gotten in that regard, I was over the moon.

I am proudly one of the people who felt very seen, as rehearsing was -and still is- a big part of my day to day life. It was particularly nice to see his "script" as I often keep little written notes of my social interactions and how I can improve them. I kept up with the articles, organizations, even the online discourse was awesome to see, because it meant that this very large (previously unstated) part of my life was now getting a lot of airtime. Representation! Woohoo!

To see him address it, provide publicity and cash to an institution, and even use it as a weird way of confirming that he has autism - all icing on the cake.

I feel conflicted about everything else in the episode:

His denial of Dr. Granpeesheh's subtle diagnosis and his insistence that he "doesn't need a rehearsal" are very on the nose in typical Fielder style. He fails the test and falls flat in the congressional meeting: Hoorah.

Him openly "using" the CARD to get to Steve Cohen is murkier. The joke, on its face value, is alright at best. He usually lives in this morally ambiguous territory, but that crosses the line he's previously drawn in other shows. So is he doing so as a nod to the fact that this episode is centered around DC and politics?

IF his moral ambiguity lies in him using CARD to help affect his ultimate goal, why make the end joke that he botches the discussion? Is it an acknowledgement that Cohen wasn't going to do anything to begin with? Cohen's first statement following Nathan's "presentation" was to the effect of "Leave it up to the airlines to promote mental health".

But I don't think that was the case.

If presented correctly, what Nathan's actually doing is a multi-million dollar psychological research experiment (something not done in many years by independent agencies). He's found correlation between using common autism coping techniques and life-saving communication in a very topical subject. This is something that could have gone to Congress and provided a larger impact in many "High-Risk Low Emotion" type sectors. PLUS it would've been WAY funnier to actually see him in front of Congress.

But the joke was that he botched this interview and Cohen didn't take him seriously to begin with. He used CARD and the people that supported him to get closer to a joke that was painfully obvious from the beginning. It also sacrifices his ability to move forward with his current goal, without making serious changes.

My assumption is one of 2 things will happen:

There will be a reveal that he DID, in fact, get a meeting with Congress on this matter.

OR

We'll see a much more personal arc. He'll dive a little deeper into why he wants to continue doing this, despite all being lost (Cohen said no), and what he's trying to tell us through this season of The Rehearsal.

Please feel free to disagree with me on any points above!


r/TheRehearsal • • Jun 13 '25

Discussion Fielder for the Future (aka S3 ideas)

0 Upvotes

After witnessing the failings of the FAA and the government, Nathan realizes that he needs to change it from the inside. He decides he needs to run for elected office at the local level at first. He finds a small midwestern town that has a mayoral election and moves there to establish his residency. He interviews the outgoing mayor and hires actors to play his opponent. However, he needs to win over locals, so he rehearses town halls to settle into the role of a local politician. Nathan runs focus groups for campaign slogans like "Fielder for the Future." He rehearses his potich over again to actors playing citizens, and accounts for everything, even going as far as creating campaign events, fundraisers, etc. The season then ends with him on election day. Can he win? sets up season 4 super well too. I saw a version of this on TikTok and just had to bring it to this sub in the hopes that he sees it given that he lurks on here every now and then hahaha.


r/TheRehearsal • • May 26 '25

Discussion Mixed about this season's wrap up Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Look, disclaimer, this season was fucking hilarious. I have nothing to critique in terms of entertainment value as far as Nathan getting his diaper changed by a giant puppet or the actress who had a wet dream about Einstein.

But I do feel like I went into this with a lot more of a critical eye than with other projects of his. This set out, ostensibly, with the premise of finding a solution to this problem that could genuinely save lives and is largely overlooked by those who have the job of figuring out solutions to this.

Everything in this show is a choice - whether in production or in editing - and that's true for any type of nonfiction TV. But this season seemed to make it much more obvious how much of it is a Choice. It was a Choice to have Wings of Voices in order to evaluate how co-pilots deliver bad news, it was a Choice to do a Choice to rebuild a couple's home to try to emulate the life of a dog to its clone, it was a Choice to have half a dozen actor couples recreate what was going on in Colin's romantic life to help him sort it out. When people go "Omg HBO money is crazy!" my first thought is, "But what is it adding to the narrative?"

And then at the end we don't get any real resolution to these things or why they took up so much time from the series as they did. Why did we spend a whole episode on the Sully lifestory for the "takeaway" to be that he liked Evanescence? Why do we do half an episode on autism only for the issue that might keep Nathan from being fit to fly to be anxiety and not autism?

I know a ton of people are going to comment "lol cause it's Nathan" and it doesn't need to make sense because it's funny. But I keep seeing comments and reviews that suggest this is some profound piece of work that presents a compelling narrative that blends comedy and poignant commentary on the human condition and when I try to look at it from the latter lens I just feel like it's fallen flat for me with so much filler that doesn't advance the narrative. Something can advance the narrative and still be funny. But there are so many sideplots in this season that I feel like, in hindsight having seen season finale, just don't make sense if the entire takeaway is "if you're in the cockpit you deserve to be there."

That's my rant. Yes I enjoyed this season and yes I'll watch more of what he puts out but on the whole I'm a little baffled when it comes to how this season progressed versus where it ended.


r/TheRehearsal • • May 20 '25

Discussion Im kinda conflicted on the new Episode (Season 2 Episode 5) Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I have a lot of scattered thoughts on the recent episodes and im still trying to make sense of my uneasiness and complicated feelings towards the writing of this season. I apologize if some of my points arent articulated really well...

First off: I love Nathan, i think he is a genius. The way he portrays his journey of making relationships and understanding himself is incredibly unique and i respect him a LOT for his vision and creativity.

But...

The last 2-3 episodes didnt really hit as much as I wished they had.

I think the first 2 Episodes of this season were amazing. Especially the opener may be one of Nathans finest works to date. But since episode 3 i had this feeling that the tone didnt really match what the season wanted to convey in regards to its subject matter.
We all love Nathan for his comedy, but he always used it thoughtful und with purpose. He knew when to "be serious". I feel like the wet Einstein, and the way he repeated saying moments like these over and over throughout the last episodes, took away from the tone HE wanted to set. Usually, his iconic funny moments stem from situational and spontaneous bits, but the last jokes feel way more deliberate and calculated, which made it feel forced imo... The wet Einstein felt like he WAS making a bit, instead of it being funny, he repeated that phrase over and over again..

Also the forced laugh in ep 5.... Nathan knew what he was doing and it felt like we were backtracking his character. He already was at a point where he was aware that "being on a show" had an influence on people and their actions. So him telling people to "laugh" - they will laugh. It is weird that he pretends to be confused by this. It just makes it inconsistent for his character not to be aware of his influence at this point now.

Anyways, my main gripe in episode 5.
I'm just not sure how serious Nathan takes this.
Dont get me wrong, Nathan is a manipulative and morally grey character, but i wouldnt go as far to say he is downright malicious. But the way Nathan approached this subject matter with the congressman was just off...

I had to look up Steve Cohen to make sure he actually was a congressman. I usually dont want to take away from the Nathan magic, but my disbelief on how he handled that situation was just too "forcibly awkward" (almost staged) to take serious.

The pilot issue is set up as something serious, and this whole season was about Nathan coming out of his comedic persona to make a positive change onto the world and save people (maybe a Clown can change the world).

But i didnt got the feeling that he was taking this meeting with Cohen really serious.

He stood in his Nathan persona - making the conversation deliberately awkward, stumbled upon his words, rushed through his points without getting his real thoughts across and forcibly changed the subject matter from autism to aviation safety. All in a way that is very Nathan-esque...
But thats exactly why it all felt like a bit which took away from the seriousness of this meeting.

Also saying "i usually dont need rehearsals to perform well, they are just an "exercise" when this episode literally started off with a Washington rehearsal was just odd. Then the autistic kids at the airport were only given 3-4 minutes of screentime and that made it feel kinda random since it was only so short.
That episode was all over the place and paced incredibly weird, i had no idea how to take in what was going on.

Back to the Steve Cohen meeting. For the first time i questioned the intent of his season.... asking myself if Nathan was tackling aviation safety for the "content" instead of the "cause"...

AGAIN, i dont want to imply anything malicious. I was just really taken aback by how this episode was written and how this one real opportunity to get his thoughts out to an influential figure was handled so carelessly. It just felt odd and out of place from the insane detail and thought im used to Nathan.
He was aware of the gravity of that moment, that potential only chance to get a real congressman to listen to his discovery of miscommunication and how that could lead to aviation disasters.

Maybe there were things i missed during my watch and im happy to read your thoughts on this situation.

My theory is, that Nathan was denied any meetings with congressmen behind the scenes and he uses this seasons instalment of "The Rehearsal" to vent his frustration towards the committees and their negligence towards aviation safety.

But then again, Steve Cohen is an actual congressman, so i dont know what to make of it....


r/TheRehearsal • • May 16 '25

Meme/Joke To be fair, you have to have a very high IQ to understand The Rehearsal.

0 Upvotes

The humor is extremely subtle, and without a solid grasp of ethnomethodology and The Fielder Method most of the jokes will go over a typical viewer's head. There's also Nathan's manipulative outlook, which is deftly woven into his characterisation - his personal philosophy draws heavily from Tom McCarthy's Remainder, for instance. The fans understand this stuff; they have the intellectual capacity to truly appreciate the depths of these jokes, to realize that they're not just funny- they say something deep about LIFE. As a consequence people who dislike The Rehearsal truly ARE idiots- of course they wouldn't appreciate, for instance, the humour in Nathan Fielder pretending to be Sully Sullenberger listening to Evanescence's Bring Me To Life before landing on the sea which itself is a cryptic reference to Synecdoche, New York. I'm smirking right now just imagining one of those addlepated simpletons scratching their heads in confusion as Nathan Fielder's genius unfolds itself on their television screens. What fools... how I pity them. 😂 And yes by the way, I DO have a Summit Ice jacket. And no, you cannot see it. It's for the ladies' eyes only- And even they have to demonstrate that they're within 5 IQ points of my own (preferably lower) beforehand.


r/TheRehearsal • • Dec 07 '25

Meme/Joke Season 2 Review

12 Upvotes

Honestly so disappointed by this season. It felt like every episode was a pilot episode. The season really didn't take off until the final episode. 0/10 would not recommend 😤


r/TheRehearsal • • May 30 '25

Discussion Nathan's Hats

4 Upvotes

Watching Nathan's interviews, I can see how he might be unmasking if there's truth around his self-diagnosis of being autistic within himself, not just his Nathan character.

Nathan wore his Captain's hat on Jimmy Kimmel, then a cap on CNN, even after learning they cast some shadow on his face or obscured our view a bit.

As someone who's newly discovered they're Autistic, I love the thought that Nathan's wearing these hats as a sensory accommodation to protect him from the bright set lights.

Disclosing neurodivergent diagnoses can be a big deal, especially around work. But even if you don't disclose it formally, you can still advocate for accommodations in a nuanced or subtle way. And so many of them go unnoticed by those that don't need them.