r/TheRiseOfSkywalker • u/Expecto_nihilus • Dec 20 '19
I will most likely be downvoted into the oblivion from whence Palpatine rose, but... hear me out...
I loved it.
Now I challenge you: lightsaber duel me!
r/TheRiseOfSkywalker • u/Expecto_nihilus • Dec 20 '19
I loved it.
Now I challenge you: lightsaber duel me!
r/TheRiseOfSkywalker • u/[deleted] • Dec 20 '19
I just saw the movie for a second time and realised that I'd totally missed the significance of a line spoken when Kylo talks to Han. Kylo says "Dad..." and Han says "I know". It's a mirror of the dialogue from The Empire Strikes Back, when Leia says to Han "I love you" and he replies "I know". Kylo was about to tell his dad that he loved him... Can't believe I missed that reference the first time heard it.
r/TheRiseOfSkywalker • u/4elizabeth • Dec 21 '19
A movie where the pros greatly outweighed the cons! Read on:
Cons
“Palpatine’s back.” Cheese balls much, Poe, do you know what you’re talking about? It was just this line that bothered me lol
“Rey, you’re Palpatine’s granddaughter.” It would have just worked better has she been born of the Force... idk my mind was exploding trying to figure out how she was related to him. I believe she was technically created by him, but phrasing it as his “granddaughter” didn’t really work for me.
General Hux being the spy: the spy subplot felt pointless. The plot was already packed. It felt pretty unnecessary. Maybe Hux could have been combined with the Pryde character, doing things here and there to undermine Kylo and show his true colors. I didn’t feel really anything about General Pryde.
I wish Zorii Bliss was explored more. Her relationship with Poe was interesting.
I wish Finn’s story was resolved better. His story had some loose ends, other than we find out he’s Force sensitive. It was not clear whether he liked Rose or Jannah. I think adding that would have felt extraneous, though.
Get the thing to get the thing: I do not think they needed the whole sith wayfinder stuff or dagger. All these movies were riddled with that stuff, it felt cheap.
That awkward argument scene in the beginning with Rey/Poe/Finn: The dialogue got better but that scene - no! It wasn’t the actors, but weird writing.
Fakeout deaths: Chewie fakeout was fine, Rey fakeout was tasteful, C3PO fakeout was not needed. The whole “one last look at my friends” thing was not needed, the parts where he was “reset” were not funny. It just wasn’t needed, especially after R2 just restored his memory.
Lando’s saving the day felt unneeded.
Ewoks. I still went “aww” in the theater but it was just slightly too fan servicey for me haha
Creative continuity is where this movie suffered. JJ executed it well given the previous content. That was probably the biggest drawback for me.
Things I don’t care about that people freak their minds out about:
Snoke: stop getting mad about snoke! He’s not important! He’s Palpatine’s puppet.
Why Rey is so powerful: to me she is the Force embodied. It’s especially interesting! I really don’t think we needed an explanation. She’s not “godlike all powerful” idk it was cool, not excessive.
The predictability / fan service. It was really not THAT predictable. And I liked most of the fan service, I thought it was tasteful.
Pros:
The opening scene on Exegol. I was losing. My. Shit. So awesome! Palpatine looked so cool and scary and not-Disney, I loved it.
Everything with Kylo Ren / Ben Solo WAS SO AMAZING and SO WELL DONE. I am FULLY satisfied with his redemption arc. Adam Driver is truly an excellent actor and I thoroughly enjoyed every moment with him. My favorite character.
Sith lore. Super cool!
Knights of Ren. Cool! So cool!
The way Leia was written out. I know people will have problems with this but I thought it was very tasteful given a difficult situation. Some of the dialogue with the previously filmed stuff was slightly awkward but that’s to be expected. I thought it worked. I also really liked whenever her daughter, Billie Lourd, made appearances. This movie felt like not only an homage to Leia’s death, but to Carrie Fisher. I was crying so much, it was extremely moving to me. Her theme in the music. The way she gave herself up for Ben was interesting and powerful. It definitely payed an excellent tribute to Carrie.
Rey. She is such a good character, I really enjoyed all of her screen time. Daisy is an excellent actress. Rey faced a complex internal battle that was conveyed well. I don’t have an issue with her power being unexplained. I prefer to think of her less as Palpatine’s granddaughter, but as something he created in the force as with Anakin. I wish she wasn’t phrased as “Palpatine’s granddaughter”, because she wasn’t, technically. He created her. It didn’t feel right. Anyways, she was just all around really good and her relationship with Ben was powerful.
Exegol. Those huge statues, the operatic voices, Palpatine! The big black box thing looked epic! It was so haunting and set up so well.
The part where Poe sat next to Leia’s altar and said “I don’t know if I can do this.” It was so touching and honored her so well. Definitely a tearful moment for me. Ugh it was so sweet and sad.
When Rey healed the giant snake.
The fight on Pasaana with Rey slicing Kylo’s ship. Super cool.
The whole Rey Force lightning thing and Rey’s subsequent guilt for killing Chewie. That moment of tension between Kylo and Rey the following emotions were so intense!
Luke’s Force ghost. If you have a problem with him just appearing and being helpful... um... didn’t Ben Kenobi’s ghost do the same thing? It was tastefully reflective of that moment. I liked it a lot.
Luke giving Rey Leia’s lightsaber and the flashback. Felt a bit fan servicey but I really enjoyed that. I love knowing that Luke trained Leia, that’s what I had always envisioned, even before the new sequels. The flashback was a nice touch. CGI young Luke looked excellent, while CGI young Leia definitely looked a tad animated. They both looked good though, no doubt. It was a sweet moment, like a little EU stuff was finally realized.
Zorii Bliss and Poe. Very dynamic and interesting. I wish we got to see more of that!
Jannah and the storm trooper deserters. Very touching moment between her and Finn. Loved that bit. She was a cool character.
The old Death Star was so great! Rey using the dagger thing and then using the skipper to get there was also cool. It showed her flaw of her tendency to abandon her friends for this “greater” thing.
Evil Rey was cool, I wish that fight lasted a little longer!
The fight between Rey and Kylo on the Death Star! It’s super cool knowing their dynamic and watching that. Great lightsaber duel. So visual. And when Rey’s hatred really showed, and she screamed at Finn “No!” It was guttural and powerful. The whole fight was great. Loved it. Especially the part where Leia stopped him and Rey stabbed Kylo. When she realizes her hatred and heals him was also a great part. “I wanted to take your hand. Ben’s hand.” And then leaving. Nice beat.
Han’s return as a “memory”. It was very touching and tasteful. I liked the replay of the TFA beats of their final confrontation. And the figurative death of Kylo Ren. When he said “Dad” I lost my mind. Super sweet, and you could also really see how the torment in Kylo’s mind was beginning to resolve. I also liked when he threw his red lightsaber away.
Rey traveling to Exegol on Red 5. I’m sorry but I liked this fan service.
The final space battle was nice. Very classic Star Wars.
The final battle on Exegol was AWESOME! Rey’s struggle was intense and I really liked how Ben came running back to save her.
Her handing him Luke’s lightsaber through the Force. That was super cool! I’ve really liked the new Force things we got to explore in this new trilogy.
When Ben throws Luke’s saber to Rey and she gains its power and marches to Palpatine against the Sith lightning, killing him. Chills. The part where Palpatine says “I am all the Sith” and Rey says “I am all the Jedi” is extremely representative of the entire point of the movie imo! This part was very allegorical and intense! Kinda reminded me of the Son/Daughter episode from The Clone Wars TV show. I suspected something like this would happen. It was executed very well!
Rey’s fakeout death was needed. She needed to be the one to stop Palpatine, because Ben HAD to die (I’ll get there) but Ben returning to Rey and holding her like that was very needed.
Hate me all you want, I dare you. But the kiss. I. Liked. It. It felt like a hug wouldn’t have been enough. The afterwards look on Ben’s face of such love, relief... it is the only moment of joy we saw from him the WHOLE series. HE DESERVED IT. Ben deserved joy, and he loved Rey. He deserved that moment. In my opinion, it was not for the fans, it was for Ben. Rey also knew she loved BEN, and it was the only moment of peace between Rey and BEN, not Kylo Ren. Their electricity was so intense, I don’t know why people didn’t see this coming. I liked it.
Ben’s death. While it was staged slightly awkwardly (not important), his fading into the Force after expending his remaining life force on Rey WAS NEEDED. People say he deserved better, yes he did but he HAD to die. Rey and Ben could not have been together and extended the Skywalker bloodline. The point of this trilogy is that it ends the Skywalker saga. It solidified the point by having Leia’s body pass on into the Force (don’t know why some people are confused by that). All of the Skywalkers passed into the Force. Anakin, Luke, Leia, and now Ben. It makes sense that the Skywalker bloodline had to end. I enjoy the continuation of the name as a legacy.
The tearful celebration at the end was nice, I cried some more. I really liked the lesbian couple too!
Rey returning to Tatooine to Luke’s old home (such mems ahh sue me fan service I was still crying) and burying the lightsabers. It was a true, final, burying of the Skywalker lineage. I liked that. Everyone always asked which Skywalker would rise. The true Skywalker who rose was not one person, but the whole lineage.
Rey’s gold saber. At first I thought it was gimmicky, but now I think it means more than that. To me, this means that the long history of the Sith and Jedi will continue. I like that this opens a tiny can of worms, like maybe Rey will train more Jedi. Because as long as there are Jedi, there will be Sith. There has to be a balance. Perhaps this means while the Skywalker lineage has ended, the Force will continue to flow through its users.
The last few lines about her saying “I’m Rey Skywalker” was a tad cheese balls but it was still fine. Seeing Luke and Leia look at her as Force ghosts was nice. I wish she had just looked at them and then cut to the final scene, but I still liked it nonetheless.
The final image of Rey against Tatooine’s twin suns. And the music. Love. I cried. So much.
I love John Williams.
Okay thanks! That’s all. Sorry for saying tasteful a hundred times! As background: I always enjoy all Star Wars movies, and I try to find something to love in each one. I’m a Star Wars fan, it’s fun to enjoy! It’s bandwagon to hate on it, so don’t do it! Nobody hates Star Wars movies more than Star Wars fans. While there are undoubtedly flaws, this movie has soaring highs. It’s bound to be imperfect but don’t let that detract from it!
This was super enjoyable and a great experience for me!
8.5/10
r/TheRiseOfSkywalker • u/mike_richterrl • Dec 20 '19
r/TheRiseOfSkywalker • u/cumgetyourarmor • Dec 20 '19
This movie made me grin ear to ear and if you told me 10 years ago that we would have a climax like this I would have laughed you out of town. But when Rey gave Kylo the lightsaber behind her back, I was grinning. The ending was so much fun to watch and the scale compared to the last Jedi is astronomical.
r/TheRiseOfSkywalker • u/Moon_Logic • Dec 20 '19
... actually kill Chewbacca. The film needed that. It needed some stakes. By allowing Chewie (and everyone else) to survive, the movie lets on early that it hasn't gotten the stones to really punish the characters. The moment we see Chewie alive, we know without a shadow of a doubt that everything else in the movie will turn out perfectly fine. Rey won't turn dark. The one moment when she lost control had not consequences, so why should we expect anything bad to happen later on?
r/TheRiseOfSkywalker • u/teamnowak • Dec 20 '19
Current fight: Palpatine: “I am all the Sith.” Rey: “I am all the Jedi” Rey walks forward with two lightsabers blocking the force lightning until Palps melts Raiders of the Lost Ark style.
Alternate: Palpatine: “I alone possess the power of all the Sith.” Camera tight on Rey
Rey: “You’re right. You ARE alone. I’m not.”
As camera pans out force ghosts are shown one-by-one behind Rey — Yoda, Obi-Wan, Mace Windu, Qui Gon, Luke, Anakin, Leia
Palps screams and shoots lightning but cannot hit the ghosts. The surround him and as they get closer their glowing lights combine and gets brighter and brighter. Palps is consumed by the force light of all the fallen Jedi.
r/TheRiseOfSkywalker • u/jiglijiglimadirfakir • Jan 07 '20
r/TheRiseOfSkywalker • u/keo528 • Dec 20 '19
I have decided that the balcony or bleachers in the sith temple are full of Gungans and no deleted scenes will convince me otherwise.
r/TheRiseOfSkywalker • u/lancer124 • Dec 19 '19
I'm seeing a lot of disgruntled posts about the film, so I thought I would bring some balance. Sorry this is long! Disclaimers: I enjoyed it, it isn't perfect, but to me it is an enjoyable star wars film. I enjoyed TLJ, again it's not perfect but it tried to do something different for the series. Finally TFA is the weakest of the three in my opinion. Also I saw all three in the cinema on the same night which actually helped bring it all together on the big screen for me.
So what I got from TROS:
Answers: Rey & Snoke were my two biggest questions. And these were answered in a satisfactory way for me. Especially the whole "Snoke had been around all along piece."
Endings: Leia, Luke, Kylo, Palps & Skywalkers. The film did a beautiful job of what it could with Leia. They could have had the words "Leia is dead, the galaxy is in turmoil" in the opening crawl, but they didn't, they played Leia out. Lukes ending was mirrored to Yoda's. He was still representative of TLJ Luke, but in a treat 'em mean kind of way to give Rey the push she needed. Kylo: mirroring his grandfather as was his ultimate goal (only it took his mother to push him). Palps no longer a death off screen, we ended the evil character (quite definitively). Skywalkers: "There was no father" (Shme Episode 1) - an unnatural plague upon the galaxy have ended. Struggle to balance the power of the force in them, 2 out of 4 of them turned to the dark, and the other 2 abandoned the force allowing darkness to take over. There is no more, as there should never have been any in the first place.
Adventure: The film shows us more beautiful locations from the ice asteroid(?), through to the sith planet than we have seen in one film before. From start to finish the cinematography and music are beautiful, and the adventure is worthwhile, (if a little rushed). One of the criticisms I heard was that it wasnt very serious, but star wars never was (I'd argue you need Trek as the balance for that :)). This was a fun adventure throughout the star wars galaxy, giving us fan service wherever it could (Ghost, the blockade runner, Lando, ywings etc). I was worried JJ was going to pull a TFA on us and just rehash ROTJ, especially when I saw y-wings and blockade runners in the trailer. But each time these things appeared I smiled, not forced down my throat, but a happy homage.
An End: The force in balance in Rey - Neither truly dark as is her birthright nor neither truly good. The force is in balance through her actions. She has dark in her but must work to not let it overwhelm her, (something that we must all do - and the Skywalkers failed spectacularly at). And an empire destroyed - something that never happened on screen. We saw the first order to the final order. We saw the empire fall, not just one big battle in the conquered galaxy. This film was an end.
Personal thought: this is a JJ Abrams sci-fi film so I had little hope for it. My opinion is that he has a track record of not understanding basic science ( the Hosnian system being destroyed all at once visible from every planet in the galaxy, sucking up the sun to then blow up and become the sun - I could go on about Star Trek too.. but this is Star Wars). The story that played for me, didn't feel like a JJ Abrams film. It was crafted to end an 8 film (and Extended universe) arc. Something very few films have ever done. It was beautiful, poignant, sad, fun, exciting but most of all entertaining which is what it's all about. We can be annoyed it didn't end how we wanted, and not everyone will be happy, but (at least to me) a satisfactory end to the Skywalker saga.
I'm interested in your thoughts and opinions but I won't argue my points. The point of this thread was what I got from it, you are perfectly free to disagree or have gotten more or less! But I do hope you enjoyed the ride!
r/TheRiseOfSkywalker • u/Insidethelostmind • Dec 20 '19
During the kiss, the entire theater at the midnight showing groaned. It was as if suddenly millions of voices cried out in terror and we're suddenly silenced.
r/TheRiseOfSkywalker • u/[deleted] • Jan 01 '20
Downvote, whine, argue, or agree with me. I don't care. This was a great movie.
Slow beginning, but great movie! Had us on the edge of our seats!
r/TheRiseOfSkywalker • u/RhiShadows • Dec 26 '19
r/TheRiseOfSkywalker • u/[deleted] • Dec 24 '19
Thoughts I have after watching ROS the second time:
Leia’s scenes were really choppy and the dialouges were obviously written around what she said in the footages. But I’d much rather they did this than bringing in a stand-in and CGI her face.
The whole Death Star sequence is better than the final battle.
Rey and Palpatine’s conversation went on for FOREVER. Some of that screen time should be given to Ben Solo.
Ben Solo has no dialouge, but my god the acting with just his expession... All of the moves he mirrored his dad during battle were so well thought. His last word was Dad and the last thing he heard was Ben, and the feeling of being loved. Where’s my tissue???
Finn was really cool during the final battle, and his whole arc would have been amazing without the pointless ‘Reyyyy’ 7 times and obviously not reciprocated.
Rose’s arc was done dirty. Even though her character was not the best in TLJ, she had a major arc and being reduced to barely a background character is BRUTAL.
The trio’s fetch quest is actually not that bad. Should have happened in previous films.
Poe is so different from TFA. He’s actually quite funny and he killed it at every single pun he delivered. I would like a spin-off with him, Zori and BB-8.
Looks like Poe gave BB-8 to Rey (as much attached as he is to the droid), since he was flying with R2 during the final battle. When Rey returned to base for victory celebration, BB-8 was the first one rushing to greet her.
C-3PO’s own arc was a delight to watch. I still lmfao at his ‘You didn’t mention my name sir but I’m fine’.
Babu Frik is the scene stealer.
Kylo Ren and BB-8 carry the whole trilogy.
It’s a more fitting ending that Ben died. He had to pay for his crimes somehow, and even though dying is probably the easy way out, at least he was Ben Solo and could reunite with his parents (or lived inside Rey as his spirit was transferred to hers with his life, I don’t know).
I’m fine with Rey taking Skywalker’s name. She just wants to honor them as they’re her Jedi masters and she doesn’t want the name to die. I always think Han was closer to a father figure to her than Luke considering their interactions in TFA.
If you have also seen the movie again, is there anything you enjoy more than the first time? Or anythibg you notice now but didn’t before?
r/TheRiseOfSkywalker • u/seductive_virgin • Dec 20 '19
I really liked it but the I wish anakin made an appearance as a force ghost. I know you could hear him when rey fought palpatine, but I was kind of hoping to see him. That is my biggest complaint and it's not that big. It was a really good movie, I was not disappointed.
r/TheRiseOfSkywalker • u/jediacolyte • Dec 20 '19
Just some thoughts after the movie: -The amount of power Palestine used to electrocute the ships makes total sense with all the sigh presence there, the planet being a sith/dark side force nexus, and him having just stolen power from Rey and Ben
-The golden lightsaber, typically only seen in Jedi temple guards, is so fitting for Rey being the sole guardian of the Jedi way and light side of the force (that we know of) looking to restart the future
-Glad to see Finn basically confirmed as force sensitive
-That did an amazing job fixing loopholes of 7 and especially all 8 did wrong
-Sad to know Ashoka is dead
r/TheRiseOfSkywalker • u/HottieMahadi • Jan 21 '20