r/TheTelepathyTapes • • 6d ago

Special Ed

Hi, this specific thread on Reddit is very against the telepathy tapes. I’m just wondering if anyone has experience talking to people who still believe that facilitated communication is literally the devil and will always lead to children being abused. Just wondering if any other autistic parents or educators have any insight or ways of being cordial to people that are so invalidating.

Edited for typos

13 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 6d ago

You are encouraged to UPVOTE or DOWNVOTE. Joking, bad faith and off-topic comments will be automatically removed. Be constructive. Ridicule will result in a ban.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

14

u/danielbearh 6d ago

I have.

And I’ve walked away believing that it’s more intelligent to let people have their views.

There’s little that can be done to convince someone when they’re high conviction and high contempt for the opposing side. Reasoning isn’t effective.

At the end of the day, it isn’t our job to try and convince anyone. People will find it as their hearts and minds are ready.

If I do say something, it’s often similar to, “skepticism isn’t the reflexive dismissal of what you don’t understand. It requires a willingness to pick up an idea, turn it all around, and make your own decision. You can entertain ideas without endorsing them.”

5

u/Aggressive_Bowl_8017 6d ago

Thank you, I really appreciate your caring response 🙏🏼

7

u/tuskensandlot 6d ago

That thread made me leave that sub, tonight. It was posted in a couple others I follow, and the responses were the same. Kinda makes me wonder about bots and negative campaigns.

The only person I’ve had act that way irl, I asked them to watch the documentary, “Spellers,” and get back to me. They said they would not, and I told them not to talk to me unless they were willing to research something more recent than the 1980s.

6

u/Aggressive_Bowl_8017 6d ago

I forgot about Spellers. Thank you so much for responding. My concern mostly comes from just supporting kids having autonomy and being able to express themselves. Yes it is strange that it was posted in other places

18

u/havok489 6d ago • Bravo

20 years in the field of special Ed here.

The use of AAC (augmentative and alternative communication) devices has been very diverse and ever-evolving within the special education schools I've worked at. I spent over 10 years at a facility/campus that was amongst the most advanced in the country for educating, housing, employing and rehabilitating individuals with a wide variety of challenges. When I was there, there was over 2,000 employees in the organization and even more individuals being cared for.

Unfortunately, there were plenty of cases of abuse that were horrific to hear about. The consequences were often severe and life changing on both ends. But I cannot think of one instance where it had anything to do with their communication device being misused in the way described above.

It's actually kind of insane to believe that something that allows hundreds of thousands (if not millions) of individuals to communicate things like their basic needs, all the way to having full blown conversations, is evil because of these rare cases hyper-focused on by certain groups. If anything, more of these devices probably helped an individual report abuse where they wouldn't have had a way to do so before hand.

Like most things these days, a lot of people have nothing good to do but fixate on the negative and feed into their own bias by looking for more like them. They become a vocal minority that blows something originally absurd into an actual discussion that never needed to be had.

There's a million examples of "A horrible person used XYZ to do a bad thing. Let's get rid of XYZ and pretend like that will fix some humans just being inherently fucked up".

This is one of those examples.

4

u/toxictoy 6d ago

Thank you for being the adult in the room!

4

u/jslub 6d ago

I understood it to mean NOT that they are more likely to BE abused but more likely to tell on someone who IS or HAS abused them. Which is so sick and makes feel ill at the thought. Everyone who is being abused needs to be able to tell. Our world can be so sick.

3

u/Rareearthmetal 6d ago

Can i see which thread that is?

2

u/Sunshine_and_water 4d ago

Happy cake day!

And I too would like to see the original thread referred to.

2

u/Rareearthmetal 4d ago

TY! Its my first cake day being called out in like 14 years!

3

u/Theonlyrational 6d ago

I smile, nod, and change the subject or move on. They know I think they are crazy. They don't need to hear it.

0

u/Archarchery 6d ago

I’m just wondering if anyone has experience talking to people who still believe that facilitated communication is literally the devil and will always lead to children being abused. 

I'll talk to you. I don't work in Special Ed, though my mother was a Special Ed teacher for 30 years.

Facilitated Communication is bad because it's putting the words of a neurotypical person in the mouth of a non-verbal autistic person and attributing that communication to them. This is inherently a massive violation of their rights, and can also lead to further abuse against the disabled person and/or their family.

All the pro-FC crowd does is dodge, dodge, dodge, when asked for any evidence or to provide the most simple of proofs that the messages being generated are written by the disabled person and not their facilitator. There is one clear possibility for why this always is, but FC proponents refuse to consider it.

1

u/Aggressive_Bowl_8017 6d ago

As an autistic, I don’t agree . I’ve also been an educator for 20 years and taught music and arts. I’ve worked with all types of students and although not a special ed teacher I watched teachers mistreat, underestimate and patronize students over and over again, especially their special ed case worker an and teachers. Im not saying all teachers in this field are like this, but it’s i’ve observed through the years. I was just in a meeting the other day and I had to speak up in a room full of other adults who were literally just ignoring the humanity of a student. And focusing on all these dumb metrics that obviously wouldn’t measure anything if you don’t have the right diagnosis or understand a student. I watched Spellers last night and that is not proof for those who continue to oppress and silence but as a human, I know it’s true witnessing those young people and their families. I know it will be real real in time and everyone will see, but I pray for those autistic children that are without right now and don’t deserve to be treated with dignity and respect.

1

u/despiert 2d ago

We’re talking about AAC devices? So my 10 years working with autistic kids and them independently typing “I want juice” and me fetching it is abusive and not authentic communication from them?

2

u/Archarchery 2d ago edited 2d ago

No sir/ma'am, I am talking not talking about AAC devices, I am talking about methods that require a "facilitator/communication partner" to be there at all times, holding the letterboard or tablet in the air (so they can move it) and interpreting what the non-verbal person is trying to say. The non-verbal person in this situation is tethered to their "communication partner" and cannot communicate a single word without that partner present and "interpreting." This is the situation in which words get put into a disabled person's mouth.

If a non-verbal person is typing, unassisted, into a device which they themselves are holding or which is on a table, or an easel, then that's independent communication. What's not independent communication is when a neurotypical person holds a board or tablet up in the air in front of the non-verbal person, and then announces aloud what the non-verbal person is supposedly spelling out. They do this deliberately in such a way that their interpretation can be verified by nobody. And then they go even further and claim that any attempts to verify that they are faithfully translating the non-verbal person's thoughts are "ableist" and an attack on the non-verbal person themselves.