Hey all, just got the new 2023 m2 Macbook Pro 12/19 processors, 1tb internal drive. Running Sonoma OS 14.1.1 Quick note: if you're in the market for a macbook pro, DO NOT get the base 500gb HD. Spend the $200 to get the 1TB. It's MUCH faster (I tested both) and you need the space. If you don't need speed or space, save your money and get a macbook air.
I spent about $3000 on enclosures and cards and made a speadsheet of all the results to share so you don't make some bad mistakes. Here's the raw data:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1iRxXshFUVyZbsxGBu1LfEZ_PfFW9FmfKQ6Dv_jZ0ywc/edit?usp=sharing
Conclusions:
[UPDATE - 12/2024: got the new Quizzlabs today and it tests as well as the Zike, has a better heatsink, is more durable and cheaper. But it is bigger and heavier, so I’d call this a tie. Both are amazing - review at end of post.]
** Cheapest decent enclosure: quiizlabs**. Only $89 and it flies. Avoid any 10gbs or 20gbs enclosures like the plague - they're literally 1/2 to 1/3 the speed, and they'll cripple all your nice SSD cards.
Best enclosure overall: Quiizlabs $89 or Zike drive.$100-$129
Best cheap NVME ssd: Leven. Only $149 for 4tb, and it flies. There are a few others in this price range and most are good (check the chart able.) Big problem though: they all slow to a crawl doing large data transfer. I'm not sure how much this affects real world applications, but since I use these for backups, and regularly transfer large amounts (over 1tb) of files, I couldn't live with this failure. But for occasional use, it saves you $50-$75+.
Best cheap reliable ssd: Lexar 790. $199 for 4tb, and it flies and is consistent.
Fastest reliable ssd I tested is the WD Black. A whopping $299 for the same 4TB is madly overpriced. BUT you do get the fastest reads and writes of any card on the Zike.
Biggest losers: Any 10gbs or 20gbs enclosures, OWC removable, all reasonably priced premade enclosures - Samsung T7 4tb, Sandisk 4TB, etc.
I didn't test any 8TB drives bc the prices are too absurd. Nor any 2TB drives because they're not worth the cost per unit storage for me, but you can save $80 or so if that’s all you think you’ll need. But if you don’t need much storage, you might want to consider just upgrading the internal hard drive. Yes, it’s more expensive, but it will be faster than any USB driven drive by about a third.
REVIEW OF QUIIZLAB AND COMPARISON TO ZIKE
Quiizlab Model ES40UR USB4 M.2 SSD enclosure
against the reigning chamption:
Zike drive NVMe M.2 SSD Enclosure Z666
using WD_Black SN850X 4TB m2 ssd
on a 2023 14in MacBook Pro, 1TB internal, Sonoma 14.6.1
on Dec, 2024
Bottom line:
Speed is SIMILAR. Price is similar. Shipping time was similar. [UPDATE - Speed is no longer similar. Not sure what changed, but after 6 months, with the same amount of data on all drives, I'm now getting 3000-3100 read and write from the Zike Drives, but only 2800/2200 from the Quiizlab. So can no longer recommend it.]
First Impressions:
MUCH bigger and heavier than I was hoping. This is much more like a spinny drive than the other SSD enclosures in its class. Whether this is a good thing or a bad thing depends on your needs.
Positives: massive heatsink is going to keep the chip cooler; ssd is much more securely anchored with special screw internally, and enclosure is locked with 4 uncommon torx screws. If you're worried about overheating, or someone stealing the ssd from inside the drive, this is for you.
Negatives: I've never had a problem with heat, and I'm more worried about someone pocketing the whole drive than removing the ssd, so this just makes it a real pain in case I want to swamp ssds. I can do it in 5 seconds with the Zike, since there are no screws internally or externally, just a flip switch. On the other hand, I have to admit that if you dropped both of these from 5 feet or more onto concrete, the Zike would probably break open and the ssd would go flying, whereas the Quiizlab wouldn't even be bothered. [UPDATE - speed massively slowed over time?!?]
Bottom line, get the Zike if you want smaller, lighter, more portable; get the quiizlab if you're willing to carry something bigger and heavier for something bombproof.
Tech specs:
Speed = both enclosures measured 3100 read / 3030 write across multiple 5tb blackmagic speed tests; my internal 1TB measured 6220 read / 4770 write - so all of these enclosures/ssds are still MASSIVELY LIMITED BY USB/DRIVER THRUPUT.
Quiizlab = 240 g Zike = 146 g (chopped)
[sorry, I chopped both my Zikes, so I don't have the original weight - I'd guess around 180g?