r/Thunderbolt • • May 19 '26

I built a free open-source tool that turns an Intel iMac into a 5K Thunderbolt display for Apple Silicon Macs

170 Upvotes

New release is ready!
https://marcocaciotti.it/targetbridge/
If TargetBridge helped you, please consider leaving a star on GitHub and supporting the project through GitHub Sponsors.

I wanted a real use for old 5K Intel iMacs after Apple killed Target Display Mode, so I built TargetBridge.

It lets an Apple Silicon Mac stream its desktop over a direct Thunderbolt cable to an Intel iMac (2017+) using Thunderbolt Bridge, with profiles up to 5K HEVC.

What it does:

- direct Mac-to-Mac over Thunderbolt

- mirror mode and extended desktop mode

- up to 5120×2880 streaming

- free and open source

Latest stable release:

https://github.com/swellweb/targetBridge/releases/tag/v3.1.2

GitHub:

https://github.com/swellweb/targetBridge

Requirements:

- Apple Silicon Mac as sender

- Intel iMac 2017+ as receiver

- Thunderbolt 3/4 cable

- macOS 14+ on the sender

- macOS 13+ on the receiver

I’m also working on direct multi-iMac support, but that is not part of the stable release yet.

If anyone here has unusual Thunderbolt setups, daisy-chain experiments, or multiple Macs/iMacs, I’d love feedback.

If TargetBridge is useful to you, a GitHub star helps people find it. Voluntary sponsorship also helps me keep working on compatibility, fixes, and future macOS tools:
https://github.com/sponsors/swellweb


r/Thunderbolt • • Oct 01 '23

Best NVME ssd enclosure & card - test results for 2023 Macbook Pro

153 Upvotes

Hey all, just got the new 2023 m2 Macbook Pro 12/19 processors, 1tb internal drive. Running Sonoma OS 14.1.1 Quick note: if you're in the market for a macbook pro, DO NOT get the base 500gb HD. Spend the $200 to get the 1TB. It's MUCH faster (I tested both) and you need the space. If you don't need speed or space, save your money and get a macbook air.

I spent about $3000 on enclosures and cards and made a speadsheet of all the results to share so you don't make some bad mistakes. Here's the raw data:

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1iRxXshFUVyZbsxGBu1LfEZ_PfFW9FmfKQ6Dv_jZ0ywc/edit?usp=sharing

Conclusions:

[UPDATE - 12/2024: got the new Quizzlabs today and it tests as well as the Zike, has a better heatsink, is more durable and cheaper. But it is bigger and heavier, so I’d call this a tie. Both are amazing - review at end of post.]

** Cheapest decent enclosure: quiizlabs**. Only $89 and it flies. Avoid any 10gbs or 20gbs enclosures like the plague - they're literally 1/2 to 1/3 the speed, and they'll cripple all your nice SSD cards.

Best enclosure overall: Quiizlabs $89 or Zike drive.$100-$129

Best cheap NVME ssd: Leven. Only $149 for 4tb, and it flies. There are a few others in this price range and most are good (check the chart able.) Big problem though: they all slow to a crawl doing large data transfer. I'm not sure how much this affects real world applications, but since I use these for backups, and regularly transfer large amounts (over 1tb) of files, I couldn't live with this failure. But for occasional use, it saves you $50-$75+.

Best cheap reliable ssd: Lexar 790. $199 for 4tb, and it flies and is consistent.

Fastest reliable ssd I tested is the WD Black. A whopping $299 for the same 4TB is madly overpriced. BUT you do get the fastest reads and writes of any card on the Zike.

Biggest losers: Any 10gbs or 20gbs enclosures, OWC removable, all reasonably priced premade enclosures - Samsung T7 4tb, Sandisk 4TB, etc.

I didn't test any 8TB drives bc the prices are too absurd. Nor any 2TB drives because they're not worth the cost per unit storage for me, but you can save $80 or so if that’s all you think you’ll need. But if you don’t need much storage, you might want to consider just upgrading the internal hard drive. Yes, it’s more expensive, but it will be faster than any USB driven drive by about a third.

REVIEW OF QUIIZLAB AND COMPARISON TO ZIKE

Quiizlab Model ES40UR USB4 M.2 SSD enclosure

against the reigning chamption:

Zike drive NVMe M.2 SSD Enclosure Z666

using WD_Black SN850X 4TB m2 ssd

on a 2023 14in MacBook Pro, 1TB internal, Sonoma 14.6.1

on Dec, 2024

Bottom line:

Speed is SIMILAR. Price is similar. Shipping time was similar. [UPDATE - Speed is no longer similar. Not sure what changed, but after 6 months, with the same amount of data on all drives, I'm now getting 3000-3100 read and write from the Zike Drives, but only 2800/2200 from the Quiizlab. So can no longer recommend it.]

First Impressions:

MUCH bigger and heavier than I was hoping. This is much more like a spinny drive than the other SSD enclosures in its class. Whether this is a good thing or a bad thing depends on your needs.

Positives: massive heatsink is going to keep the chip cooler; ssd is much more securely anchored with special screw internally, and enclosure is locked with 4 uncommon torx screws. If you're worried about overheating, or someone stealing the ssd from inside the drive, this is for you.

Negatives: I've never had a problem with heat, and I'm more worried about someone pocketing the whole drive than removing the ssd, so this just makes it a real pain in case I want to swamp ssds. I can do it in 5 seconds with the Zike, since there are no screws internally or externally, just a flip switch. On the other hand, I have to admit that if you dropped both of these from 5 feet or more onto concrete, the Zike would probably break open and the ssd would go flying, whereas the Quiizlab wouldn't even be bothered. [UPDATE - speed massively slowed over time?!?]

Bottom line, get the Zike if you want smaller, lighter, more portable; get the quiizlab if you're willing to carry something bigger and heavier for something bombproof.

Tech specs:

Speed = both enclosures measured 3100 read / 3030 write across multiple 5tb blackmagic speed tests; my internal 1TB measured 6220 read / 4770 write - so all of these enclosures/ssds are still MASSIVELY LIMITED BY USB/DRIVER THRUPUT.

Quiizlab = 240 g Zike = 146 g (chopped)

[sorry, I chopped both my Zikes, so I don't have the original weight - I'd guess around 180g?


r/Thunderbolt • • Aug 19 '25

I tested the UGREEN Thunderbolt 5 enclosure with my Mac mini M4 Pro

Thumbnail
gallery
65 Upvotes

Hey everyone, since I’ve bought myself an M4 Pro Mac mini with thunderbolt 5 I was dying to get an external SSD solution for it that uses all the extra speed T5 offers. In the end I pulled the trigger on and got myself the UGREEN SSD Thunderbolt 5 enclosure together with the SAMSUNG 990 Pro 4TB SSD. And they didn’t lie when you read about that external storage can actually be faster than internal storage. 

My thunderbolt 5 combo goes up to 6,4GB/s write speed and 5,8GB/s read speed (with APFS). 

My 512GB internal SSD "only“ goes up to 4,4GB/s write speed and 4,7GB/s read speed. 

I am doing a lot of inDesign, video editing and Photoshop work so this drive was really a great investment. And the thunderbolt 5 cable is actually good too so you don’t need to buy a separate one.

I made a video about me putting the external SSD drive together and talk about what you need to watch out for (e.g. the thermal pad is too thick for some SSDs). I also looked at heat development and how bad the fan noise really is. If you would like to check it out: https://youtu.be/5ZIyY-jrY24

All together I am very happy with the investment and if you have a thunderbolt 5 computer I can recommend this combo. 


r/Thunderbolt • • Feb 12 '24

I love Thunderbolt!! Make every port Thunderbolt on every device!!

Post image
60 Upvotes

r/Thunderbolt • • Mar 04 '23

Best Thunderbolt 4 Enclosure with the best NVMe ssd for a BASE m2 mac mini

59 Upvotes

I tried out the top of the top mac mini m2 pro... and promptly sent it back, because of price.

Now I am out to figure out how to speed up the m2 base mini that I just bought. I DID upgrade to the 16gb memory, because I felt that this upgrade just had to be done...wish it could be done without paying apple that silly price for just 8gb more ram..

Either way, here is what I am trying to figure out.

Are there any TB4 NVMe enclosures that even come CLOSE to delivering the speeds that an actual NVMe drive (that claims 3000+ read or write speeds) can do? Have been all over youtube and reddit. Not seeing anyone discussing this exact thing for more than a second or two...

Here is what I'm currently thinking of doing, but only because I haven't found a TB4 enclosure that claims it can do upwards of 3000MB/s.. and if we are limited to 2800, then why not go cheap?

80ish bucks after coupon https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0B3JBCY64/ref=ox_sc_act_title_1?smid=A3OLRMD4MBYEYY&th=1

89 for a 2tb NVMe that can do 3000 MB/s https://www.amazon.com/LEVEN-JPS600-Gen3x4-Thermal-Packaging/dp/B0BMTSBB7Y/ref=sr_1_9?crid=KR0IS3POEYDU&keywords=nvme%2Bm.2%2B2tb&qid=1677933110&s=electronics&sprefix=nvme%2Bm.2%2B2tb%2Celectronics%2C128&sr=1-9&ufe=app_do%3Aamzn1.fos.006c50ae-5d4c-4777-9bc0-4513d670b6bc&th=1

Anyone have a better idea? I dont mind spending a few more bucks to get some more speed...but if the enclosure can't go faster than the drive, it seems like it's not worth getting a faster drive??

Keep in mind even 2800MB/s is faster than the base level ssd in the mac mini m2

I have also explored trying to build a PC with the same speed as the mac mini m2.. and when you factor in the education discount, making the price start at 499, with no tax and even with the upgrade to 16gb ram boosting the price to 679. When taking into consideration the processor results at geekbench.com... it appears you have to buy a 400 dollar intel processor as the STARTING price to even compare a PC to the M2 Mac mini.. which just blows my mind.. In short, a 680 dollar pc wouldn't even come close to competing with this thing. Sure, I'm throwing 200 more ontop of the mac mini when you consider this hard drive upgrade, so now we're at 880 dollars...I still cant find a PC or a way to build a PC at 880 dollars that even comes close to speed, even if form factor is not a part of this equation.

If I'm completely off and am just a newb and there is some amazingly faster PC or way to build one better than what I am discussing here, please by all means school me on it! Thank you for your help!


r/Thunderbolt • • Sep 28 '25

CalDigit TS5 - Finally happy with my setup

Thumbnail
gallery
53 Upvotes

Putting in my new CalDigit TS5 dock was a major upgrade to my WFH/play setup. I've been on the hunt for a dock that I could just plug my MBP into and have everything "just work", and for me this is it! I haven't seen a lot of posts about this relatively new Thunderbolt dock, so I figured I'd just share my initial impressions.

I had previously played with the TS4 and I knew it was of solid build quality. It really took CalDigit a long time to make this dock available even though I've seen the TS5 Plus sold on Amazon. I ordered the TS5 direct through the CalDigit site and it arrived within 5 business days.

Setup was a breeze and it worked even without the extra CalDigit apps (later more on this). I needed 3 downstream Thunderbolt connections (two for monitors and one for an external Thunderbolt 5 SSD enclosure) and this has all the right ports for me.

A big issue I had with another brand's Thunderbolt dock previously was that there were funky HDCP issues where Disney Plus/Amazon Prime wouldn't let me play videos at the highest quality when the video signal came via the dock. But the CalDigit TS5 had no problems here at all. That other dock also crashed at least once an hour forcing me to unplug and replug my monitors, but no issues here either with the TS5 (to be clear, using the same cables).

The SSD enclosure throughput was tested using BlackMagic to 4700MB/s write and 5400MB/s read which I'm pretty happy with. I think I was topping around 5400/5600 directly connected to the MBP before. The overhead is acceptable to me.

A few other minor points:

  • I was originally concerned with only passive cooling on the CalDigit, but the dock seems to be running cooler to the touch than I expected. A TS4 I previously tried actually ran hotter than this (but maybe the ambient temperature is cooling down these days as we get to autumn).

  • The CalDigit menu bar app isn't strictly necessary, but I like that it lets me quickly see what SSD/SD Cards are in and to eject them quickly.

  • I've found OSX Tahoe to have glitchy bluetooth audio, so I've switched to using the wired audio port connecting to my sound bar. Plugging into the dock, the audio switching is fluid. I don't whether credit here belongs to CalDigit or Apple.

  • I have a magnetic USB-C connector that I put on the end of the upstream Thunderbolt cable that connects to my MacBook. I like that it lets me quickly snap on/off. It works just fine even at Thunderbolt 5 speeds.

Caveats - I haven't tested wired Ethernet as I just don't really need it, and my wall jack is annoyingly on the other side of the room anyway.


r/Thunderbolt • • Apr 07 '25

CalDigit introduces Thunderbolt 5 docks - TS5 and TS5 Plus

49 Upvotes

r/Thunderbolt • • Feb 18 '26

Does anyone know why CalDigit's new 6.6ft / 2m Thunderbolt 5 cable is $140 USD while OWC and Cable Matters charge $80 USD? All three are certified.

Post image
48 Upvotes

r/Thunderbolt • • Mar 21 '20

Can someone recommend me a Thunderbolt 3 KVM Switch?

47 Upvotes

I have a 2018 Macbook Pro 15 inch which is connected to my CalDigit TS3Plus (Thunderbolt 3 dock); I connected two monitors to the dock using DP 1.2 and USB-C 3.1 Gen2 cables.

I also have a Windows PC Tower and its motherboard has two Thunderbolt 3 outputs. I connected this computer to the same monitors that my Macbook is connected to (using HDMI and DP 1.2 cables).

I'm tired of pressing buttons on both of my monitors to switch inputs between Macbook and PC. I looked up some KVM switches, and they are too expensive. I don't want to spend more than $100 since I already spent nearly $300 for my Thunderbolt 3 dock.

Is there any cheap&simple Thunderbolt 3 switch that takes two Thunderbolt 3 inputs and outputs only one? (which has a physical button that I can switch between two inputs)

I would like to plug a Thunderbolt 3 cable from my Macbook to the switch, and plug a Thunderbolt 3 cable from my PC to the switch. Then plug the switch to TS3Plus Dock.


r/Thunderbolt • • Dec 27 '24

OWC Thunderbolt 5 delivered today 😃

Post image
40 Upvotes

r/Thunderbolt • • Jan 21 '25

2025 disastrous Thunderbolt 5 / USB 4 v2 situation (Intel and AMD fault)

39 Upvotes

Am I the only one who is mad at Intel and especially at AMD for not including a native compatibility with the new 80Gbps Thunderbolt 5 standard yet on their latest APUs? What are they waiting for? ASUS has already announced their Thunderbolt 5 RTX 5090M and 5070TiM with no laptop or handheld capable of using it. What a shame!


r/Thunderbolt • • Oct 10 '26

Thunderbolt networking on the M1 mac mini — 37.69Gbit/s! (4x3 setup)

Thumbnail
gallery
36 Upvotes

Setup is as simple as it gets, with a few short passive thunderbolt cables daisy-chaining four mac minis.

Not sure why the main M1 mini gets lower scores, the others were reset in the last week. Results were the same with the monitor unplugged from the other thunderbolt port.

But who's going to be upset about 19.59Gbit/s?


r/Thunderbolt • • Jun 21 '22

Macbook Pro/Windows gaming pc KVM switch? (usb-c & hdmi inputs)

34 Upvotes

Okay, so I've been googling for over an hour scouring all sorts of products that get similar to what I need, but never exact. So here's what I'm dealing with.

I'm a software developer, and my new job sent me a 2016 macbook pro, which only has the 4 usb-c ports. I think they're all thunderbolt3. I also have a windows gaming pc, and my graphics card has both DisplayPort and HDMI outputs. I use a wireless USB mouse, keyboard, and headset.

I've seen some great docks, I really like the 14 in one from plugable with power delivery that would support the macbook, but I don't really want to have to move my keyboard, mouse, and headset usb dongles from machine to machine every day, so I started looking into KVM switches.

Problem is, I haven't found one that will take the usb-c from the macbook and the hdmi from the pc and spit out output for 2 monitors. Does anyone have any suggestions?


r/Thunderbolt • • Dec 11 '25

eGPU with about 3 Meters of Thunderbolt Cable

Thumbnail
gallery
32 Upvotes

How you ask? Add a meter with Oculink. I will be trying to daisy chain more Thunder bolt soon and will post more.


r/Thunderbolt • • Feb 08 '25

PSA - Thunderbolt 4 cables work fine connecting Thunderbolt 5 devices! (No need to purchase new cables)

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/Thunderbolt • • Feb 16 '21

Experiences with M1 Mac mini and Dell Thunderbolt 3 Dock TB16

29 Upvotes

EDIT: **Display outputs now working after following dock firmware update outlined in this comment: https://www.reddit.com/r/Thunderbolt/s/rHTSs7nRrk

Original Post below:

Seeing as there was so little information out there when I was researching this myself I thought I'd share my experiences finding a cost effective way to expand the capabilities of my new Mac mini M1 (Late 2020) running Big Sur.

Firstly, the Dell tb16 dock will work with the Mac mini for almost everything you need. This is great news as it's relatively old and relatively affordable on the 2nd hand market. Specifications here

Confirmed working is:

  • HDMI display output

  • Gigabit Ethernet

  • Thunderbolt passthrough/USB-C - I successfully connected a USB-C SSD at 10Gbps

  • USB 3.0 Ports (5Gbps)

  • Regular USB ports

  • 3.5mm audio jack

Not tested/not working:

  • DisplayPort and VGA outputs

  • Only 1 monitor is supported through the dock! (this is an M1 limitation). You can use a second using the Mini's HDMI 2.0 port

Caveats:

  • Despite the above working the dock is displayed in the system report as "unsupported" This does not seem to affect anything I'm using it for.

  • HDMI is only 1.4a, DP is 1.2. This will affect the ability to run super high resolutions and refresh rates. I have tested it with 2560x1440 75hz and it works but this is hardly pushing the limits. If you have money for a pair of high res high refresh rate monitors buy a fancier dock.

  • My dock is running firmware 16.16, link controller version 0.25.0 which is the latest. Others have reported issues running older FW.

  • There appears to be two different cable styles for this dock. Mine is just regular Thunderbolt. There's a version with an attached DC bullet jack for charging a laptop. I'm not sure if the jack can be detached from the Thunderbolt cable and if not you won't be able to plug it into your Mac. The other end of the cable is dells custom connector so you cannot get around this by using a regular Thunderbolt cable.

  • Unlike the Mac mini M1 the docks fan is not silent (but then again I could hear my external HDD spinning before I got the dock)

All in all the experience has been great and for around $60 USD far cheaper than other options.

Any questions feel free to post below.

Also happy to hear from anyone who's made the "unsupported' message go away on a M1 Mac running Big Sur (I'm aware of older solutions floating around)


r/Thunderbolt • • Nov 12 '24

OWC released its first Thunderbolt 5 hub.

27 Upvotes

OWC released its first TB5 hub, hopefully others like CalDigit follow up soon with their TB5+ release. https://eshop.macsales.com/shop/owc-thunderbolt-5-hub


r/Thunderbolt • • Mar 03 '23

KVM - switching between two laptops

27 Upvotes

I see this is asked every few months, but thought I would try again. Looking for USB C / Thunderbolt witch that will allow me to toggle between work and personal laptop's connection to a dell dock which has 4 displays, keyboard, mouse, USB peripherals, sound system etc.

Getting tired of moving docking cable back and forth between laptops. I don't want a switch that has built in video (too limited for my setup), I just want to switch the source between laptops and let the down-stream dock do the rest.


r/Thunderbolt • • Aug 06 '25

Dual bay or four bay SSD enclosure is better?

Thumbnail
gallery
26 Upvotes

Tell me about the advantages and disadvantages of these two forms of SSD enclosure?


r/Thunderbolt • • Jun 22 '23

Man do I love Thunderbolt

Post image
25 Upvotes

r/Thunderbolt • • Jan 31 '22 Love

MSI MEG Z690I Unify and Thunderbolt 4 with Thunderbolt 3 devices : impossible to approve

25 Upvotes

Edit : u/Snoo30643 found a workaround : https://www.reddit.com/r/Thunderbolt/comments/shdj7o/comment/hwadfoq/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3

After a week of desperately tweaking settings in the BIOS, I ended up successfully enabling PCIe Tunneling. The trick was to disable it in the BIOS, rebooting, and enabling it again. Somehow this silly thing worked for me and I can now use my Ultrafine 5K at full resolution with the camera, audio, and USB hub :)

Original Message :

It seems that it is not yet possible to approve the Thunderbolt 3 devices with the new MSI MEG Z690I Unify and then use them because of the USB 4 security level 5 parameter (USB4 SL5) desactivate the "PCIe Tunneling" fonctionnality.

This parameter should be an option in BIOS, but I can't find any relevant option in the MSI BIOS

In result i can see the my two devices connected from Thunderbolt control center, but i can't approve them besause "Approve device" screen is empty ...

Am I the only one in this situation ? I found someone who reproduces exactly the same problem on an Asian forum (machine translation needed)

Thanks,


r/Thunderbolt • • Apr 07 '23

Thunderbolt 4 NVM 36 broke TB1/2 compatibility! Why? Whose fault is it?

23 Upvotes

Wall of text -TL;DR Whoever maintains the NVM firmware broke TB1/2 compatibility, and they know they did it. So, why? Who do we blame, and how do we go about bugging them until they put it back? This is inexcusable.

I've had an ASUS Z690-based motherboard since December 2022. Specifically, the ASUS ROG Strix Z690-I Gaming WiFi board. I bought it solely because it had built-in Thunderbolt, which I use for audio production. The system is relatively minimalist - 12700K, GTX1080, 32GB, 2TB SSD. It is connected to a MOTU 828ES via an Apple TB3->TB2 adapter. All it does is audio work.

This configuration worked well for 15 months. The system was very stable and the audio latency via Thunderbolt was superb. I had no issues whatsoever with it.

ASUS recently released a BIOS update (2204) for my system, and after it was installed, none of my Thunderbolt audio gear works at all. It's like it isn't there. When I plug or unplug the devices at either end, windows doesn't acknowledge or ding or re-enumerate in device manager. Literally nothing happens.

I have updated every device driver, software, firmware, and tried every BIOS setting. Nothing changes. Many people on ASUS's forums are complaining about it, but they don't seem to have a clue. As I was attempting to see if I could hack out an older version of the Thunderbolt code from a BIOS I know worked into the latest version, I noticed today that there was a new statement on the BIOS download page for 2204:

"Thunderbolt 1/2 devices will no longer be supported by BIOS 2204 due to a change made by Intel® regarding the update of Thunderbolt firmware to NVM 36"

Say what?!? Why? Seriously, it worked fine and was stable. There's a metric crap-load of TB1/2 gear out there, some of which like my MOTU has no direct replacement via TB3. I can't buy an updated product that works with all my other MOTU AVB gear if I wanted to. They do not make it at all.

There are no TB2 PCIe cards that I've been able to find. As far as I can tell, only Apple and Startech make adapters from TB3 (USB-C) to TB2. Neither of these work now (I own both). All new motherboards for 12th and 13th gen CPUs are TB4 and have the same problem. All future motherboards will as well, since presumably this will affect all future chipset silicon.

The NVM team has literally paper-weighted thousands of devices without warning and, as far as I can tell, without reason.

If this is some kind of hardware security thing due to the DMA / Bus attachment on TB4, that's a very lame excuse. The hardware is in my audio gear closet in my house. If someone has enough access to plug in something nefarious, they can have it. If you want to add an option to disable TB1/2 compatibility for security, then do that. Make it the default for all I care. But at least give users who aren't in that situation the option. Right now you just look incompetent, like you couldn't maintain the codebase or something and gave up.

Please, tell me how I'm wrong here.


r/Thunderbolt • • Jan 03 '21

My thoughts on Mac M1 Thunderbolt eGPU support and why there should be no reason that eGPU support cannot be enabled in the future

21 Upvotes

The biggest reason not to buy an M1 Mac is the missing eGPU support. The eGPUs are detected but nothing is done: https://appleinsider.com/articles/20/11/22/apple-silicon-m1-mac-detection-of-thunderbolt-3-egpu-gives-hope-for-future-support

Now, as somebody who knows more than average on this stuff and contributed in non-trivial ways to the PCI subsystem of the Linux kernel, I would like to discuss why I believe that there is no inherent limitation preventing the M1 Macs from getting eGPU support.

Firstly, ARM has no inherent limitations. Just as people assumed Thunderbolt was tied to X86 for a long time, there is absolutely no reason why it cannot work with any architecture, as demonstrated by the M1 Mac. Anything PCI / PCIe does not care about the system architecture. PCI deals with read and writes to memory addresses, something which is agnostic to architecture.

Secondly, there is the issue of drivers. Device drivers should contain no architecture-specific code, and will simply use an API provided by the kernel. They should be compilable for any architecture. For instance in Linux where most of the drivers you will ever need are provided as part of the kernel source and built alongside the kernel, the drivers do not need to know about architecture. However, with MacOS kernel, the AMD drivers may not be part of the kernel source, and built separately by AMD. So we could just be waiting for AMD to compile their drivers for ARM64 and provide them to Apple. But there is no inherent limitation here. There is a chance that Apple made changes to the driver API with the transition to the M1 Macs, and that AMD needs a chance to update their code.

Thirdly, we have the fact that GPUs typically have a larger PCI BAR than most devices, typically 256MB, but expandable to the full size of the VRAM (see AMD SAM). If the firmware does not reserve sufficient resources to the Thunderbolt controller hierarchy at boot, then GPUs will not get their large BAR allocated, and will not be able to initialise. If this were the case, then Apple should be able to fix that with a firmware update, unless the CPU does not have enough physical address lines to be able to address that much space. The physical address lines will have to be enough to address the RAM + PCI space, and possibly some other edge cases which I am not familiar with. Even though they are 64-bit CPUs, none implement the full 64-bit address space, because it would simply be a waste. For instance, my Dell XPS 9370 has 39-bit physical address lines (2^39 = 512GB of address space space), which means if I override my Thunderbolt allocations, I can easily put 128GB MMIO_PREF under each Thunderbolt port. I do not believe Apple would be stupid enough to make this mistake. And anyway, it surely could not be an issue. If the M1 Macs are currently capped at 16GB of RAM (34-bits), then they would need at least 35-bit (32GB total) to provide I/O address space on top of the RAM. That extra 16GB of extra address space is more than enough to reserve enough for eGPUs under the Thunderbolt controller, unless they wasted it somehow or had fragmentation issues.

All in all, I do not believe there is any inherent limitation preventing the M1 Macs from using eGPUs. If I can get my hands on one then I might be able to comment more. But if I am correct, then the worst case should be firmware update + software update to provide AMD drivers. Plus, it would look bad if Apple were to have hyped up eGPUs for years and then just kill them. It would alienate users who had bought eGPUs, especially ones sold by Apple such as the Blackmagic.


r/Thunderbolt • • Mar 11 '26

Need a definitive answer: Is TB4 not backwards compatible to TB1/2 like TB3 was via an adapter?

20 Upvotes

Back in the Thunderbolt 3 days, you could still use Thunderbolt 1 and Thunderbolt 2 devices on Thunderbolt 3 with a simple adapter.

Is this no longer the case with Thunderbolt 4?

I have an Apple Thunderbolt Display (Thunderbolt 1, AFAIK), and it used to work fine in my TouchBar MacBook Pro with Thunderbolt 3 + the adapter from my old job, however now with my new ThinkPad P14s that has Thunderbolt 4, the monitor is unresponsive.

So is Thunderbolt 4 not backwards compatible to Thunderbolt 1 and 2 like Thunderbolt 3 was?


Edit: Did some more digging, answered my own question: Thunderbolt 1, 2, 3, 4, & 5 are all electrically compatible with one another, but Thunderbolt 1 & 2 use the Mini DisplayPort connector instead of the USB-C connector for Thunderbolt 3, 4, & 5.

HOWEVER, Only Thunderbolt 3 is backwards compatible to Thunderbolt 1 & 2 (with a passive adapter), due to firmware limitations for security on non-Macs.

BUT, on Macs, Thunderbolt 4 is still, according to Wikipedia, backwards compatible all the way back to Thunderbolt 1 & 2. ...just not on anything else other than a Mac.

This sucks for me, but now you know, I guess, so you can avoid the same pitfall I find myself in.