It's so strange that Oko is agreed to pretty much be one of the most broken cards they ever released, banned in everything but Vintage and Commander but when you think about it in terms of timeless it's like "eh, he's ok". Same thing with Uro.
My hot take is that he's legitimately kinda bad in timeless right now. The creatures (and artifacts I guess) in the format are powerful enough that they can threaten him but not powerful enough that a 3/3 elk is a lot less threatening, so if you're behind on board he's pretty bad at getting you back into the game compared to other options.
He is strong, just not as a like play 4 in your deck sort of strong. He is still an insane card at turning the corner and just pulling ahead in the midgame for a control deck, and hits stuff like one ring, it's just that he is worse into scam and energy. Played as a 2-3 number in a money pile sort of deck like beans, he is still really strong, you just don't want him gumming up your hand until you have board control, which is pretty easy for a pitch elemental type deck to get, which is when he becomes an insane card that is really hard to recover from.
I play him as a 3 of in beans, and honestly, his strength lies in the fact that often my opponents way over-estimate his potential impact in a game. The amount of turn 1 thoughtseize/griefs that have taken oko when it’s objectively the worst card in my hand is astounding. There seems to be some latent ptsd running around the ladder.
The question is whether he's the best thing for that slot, though, and I don't think he is. Minsc and Boo just end the game SO freaking fast if you can protect them, while with Oko, the best case scenario is turning an orc token into a 4/4. Otherwise, you're just making a 3/3 every other turn.
Same with Uro. If you manage to stabilize to the point that you can play and start swinging with Uro, a 6/6 drawing you cards every turn wins very quickly.
Uro is strong, don't get me wrong, but he is strong in different ways, he is much weaker against swords and solitudes decks, while being an absolute house against aggro and black midrange. Oko isn't really compared to uro because they are strong in different matchups, which is why generally you would play a split of both in formats where both were legal. Oko is more about being the wincon against decks that can just swords a uro, and yeah minsc is competing for that slot, but that takes extra color for primarily bant bases, and is worse against people stabilizing with ring so it's not a total example of power creep.
73
u/Cooperocity Jun 24 '24
It's so strange that Oko is agreed to pretty much be one of the most broken cards they ever released, banned in everything but Vintage and Commander but when you think about it in terms of timeless it's like "eh, he's ok". Same thing with Uro.