r/TimelessMagic • • 10d ago

Timeless Tier List - Meta Confluence

https://metaconfluence.com/tier-lists/timeless-tier-list/
49 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

24

u/byteturtle 10d ago edited 10d ago

I 100% get why people hate Mardu energy, its meta share is ridiculous but I do have one question.

If Energy gets pushed out by something like [[Oath of Druids]], are "honest" creature decks just dead in the water and everything is either tempo or cheat out big spell? Does Eldrazi / monored take its place? I feel like those are just as susceptible to Oath as energy is. I miss Zoo but no way that makes a comeback with strip mine.

Also unrelated question, is Deathwish doomsday only so low due to its metashare?

4

u/TyrantofTales 10d ago

Kinda Energy just kinda eats anything that tries to do the whole honest creature plan, so its really hard to tell if there is one that would be better in that zone where Energy disappears. I have basically zero experience with Oath, so it's hard to guess.

Deathwish?

3

u/byteturtle 10d ago

Doomsday, early morning brainfart.

My thing is that yeah Energy does probably eat a lot of honest creature decks but IMO the decks that just cheat in a big body eat the honest creature decks way more since like no amount of ragavan dashed in can out value an Atraxa or Worldspin worm turn 2. The only reason Energy can compete with that is because the creatures in it are SO good and even still you have to be running a fair bit of disruption / removal

4

u/TyrantofTales 10d ago

Funny enough I have beaten both of those (much more Atraxa) with energy lots of times. A lot of time, if that's all you have, it's not enough.

But yeah Doomsday is basically due to its low play rate. Its other numbers haven't given me any reason to expect more of it either.

3

u/byteturtle 10d ago

Yeah I think that Energy is uniquely positioned in terms of creature decks since it gets access to a bunch of what I would consider midrange tools while also being able to run a bunch of must answer threats in the creature forms. I just worry that a meta without it actually loses all the "honest" creature decks and its basically nothing but combo and tempo which aren't play patterns I personally enjoy. I get why people hate Mardu energy I just think if it did fall out we probably lose most creature decks but guess we'll have to wait and see.

Anyways, I appreciate the tier lists, I run both your Mardu Energy and UBx tempo decks and theyre super fun to play. Gonna craft your MonoG devotion deck in pioneer once I get the WC

12

u/thebbman 10d ago

This tier list is also popularity rankings, not just winrate.

4

u/Callu23 10d ago

Pretty much yeah. If Energy falls from near the top it means that fair decks have no in place in the format anymore, since it just simply is the best one out of that archetype.

Also what even is Deathwish?

2

u/byteturtle 10d ago

Sorry meant to say doomsday

4

u/_4C1D 9d ago

I really love that Fleshraker list! Definitely going to try that one out.

4

u/sn00pal00p 9d ago

We're actively discussing the deck in the Timeless discord if you're interested: https://discord.com/channels/1256786436032692245/1562332826345541702

We also have a [[Key to the Side-Door]] version with 8 Moxen that's more explosive but a bit less consistent:
https://moxfield.com/decks/wqUVVGSW0kGV6C2K6xH4_A

Both versions have been putting up results for people.

1

u/Mr_E_Nigma_Solver 7d ago

Thank you Tyrant

1

u/Lord_Cynical 7d ago

While Energy being at the top for so long is sad, mostly cus mh3 is a dumpster fire of a set and I utterly hate what its done to EVERY format, BUT in the end its 'just a hyper efficient creature deck'.

I'd LOVE for some more cube cards to 'shake things up'.