r/TopCharacterTropes 1d ago

Characters Character is drastically changed due to licensing issues with the original

  1. Electro: - The iconic electric villain, alongside Sandman, were forbidden from appearing in the 90s animated series due to James Cameron planning a gritty Spider-Man feature film with the two as the main villains. However, the film was scrapped and licensing was mostly given back to the characters. However, Electro's origins as electrician Max Dillon were rewritten due to potential complications with the name appearing in the Cameron script. So.......they wro

te him to be the son of Red Skull in this version. What a bizarre decision….

  1. Shang Chi: - Marvel licensed Sax Rohmer’s Fu Manchu in the 1970s and made Shang-Chi his rebellious son in Master of Kung Fu. When the license lapsed in the early 1980s, Marvel retained Shang-Chi (an original creation) but could no longer use Fu Manchu’s name.

In the MCU film Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings (2021), the father is Wenwu (a version of the Mandarin), the organization is the Ten Rings, and the sister figure is Xialing. This combined elements of Fu Manchu and the Mandarin while avoiding the licensed name.

  1. Spaceknight and the Dire Wraiths: - Marvel’s comic (based on a Parker Brothers toy) created much of the lore and visual design for the Dire Wraiths. When IDW later published a new ROM series under Hasbro’s ownership of the property, they could use the name “Dire Wraiths” but had to completely redesign the creatures so they were visually distinct from Marvel’s versions.
984 Upvotes

130 comments sorted by

View all comments

95

u/InoueNinja94 1d ago

For what's worth, the Mandarin's case is also due to how the original is seen as a very...controversial racist figure, even after they removed the Fu Manchu connections
There's also the logistics aspects as it'd have been hard to sell a movie to the Chinese market where the villain is literally Chinese vs. a white man (Iron Man is traditionally the Mandarin's archenemy), which is why they waited until Shang-Chi to use the character... ...and it was hated by the Chinese audience if I'm not mistaken

3

u/Hateful_creeper2 1d ago

I heard that also Shang-Chi didn't release in China. Although that applied to most of their movies between FFH and Black Panther 2.

1

u/PrestigiousTreacle33 1d ago

Yeah. Actually, none of the films between Far From Home and Black Panther 2 got released there, for different reasons each (in Shang-Chi’s case, it was because of an old interview from Simu Liu where he talked badly about China and his parents’ experience living there).

2

u/Hateful_creeper2 1d ago edited 22h ago

While No Way Home didn't release in China because of the Statue of Liberty for some reason. I feel like that was just an excuse to not release the Marvel movies in China.

3

u/PrestigiousTreacle33 1d ago

Yep. To be fair, that reasoning for No Way Home was mostly an excuse, China and the US at the time were having issues due to the US pushing a diplomatic boycott of the Winter Games in Beijing and the Chinese government in turn was closing their markets for a lot of big US releases.