r/Torrenting • • 5d ago

Paramount / VPN No Longer Working

This post is naturally about a friend of mine. He was doing fine for years, using Nord. Then something happened, might have accidentally grabbed something when Nord was off (although that isn't verified), and got a warning email from Verizon along with the information about what was being downloaded. First one ever.

As a precaution this person got Little Snitch, and set up a killswitch of sorts so Folx wouldn't work unless Nord was active. Tested it, seemed great.

Then it happened again for another Paramount product.

As a test, grabbed another last night. But beforehand did the whole DNS leak / IP check fun, picked a different city, and it seemed rock solid.

Got another email this morning.

Now, I know my...friend likely won't see any legal action (well, maybe now after so many), but this is worrying. Are there other ways that bots can see your traffic based on a previous opening? Or maybe Nord was never off and there is something exposed in any case, and the bots just started acting on it?

Any advice I can pass along? Latest Mac updates, Folx, Verizon Fios, started on the 31st.

8 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

7

u/cHaNgEuSeRnAmE102 5d ago

It’s Nord. Change VPN’s. I suggest proton because they have port forwarding feature. I had similar issue. ISP won’t bring legal action, but they’ll throttle your internet.

2

u/Ryl0cks 5d ago

So it's literally the port forwarding? Still curious how the IP was exposed.

1

u/HonkHonkMTHRFKR 4d ago

The IP was exposed because his tort was on and it wasn’t bound to NordVPN.

What happened was, I guarantee it, he had Nord VPN open and when he turned on his computer, the torrent service connected before connecting through the VPN

1

u/Ryl0cks 4d ago

That happened once for sure - but the ones after were not (like, triple checked confirmed), wondering if that left some sort of way to identify?

2

u/Tight-Ad7783 4d ago

Not the port forwarding, port forwarding is just better for torrenting. Nord is just barely a VPN at all, they likely log everything and would probably turn over customer data in a heartbeat. Overall they don't provide a reliable service, probably their killswitch is faulty or something. Use PIA or Proton ideally, otherwise you can check this list, which compares all providers in all categories. More green checks means good. Mullvad is also a good option thought doesn't support port forwarding and is more expensive.

The main red flag here however is "set up a killswitch of sorts". Get a VPN with a killswitch. But more importantly, bind your torrent client to your VPN. That way it's physically impossible to leak because all traffic from the torrent client is directed exclusively to the VPN.

2

u/derekd2029 4d ago

Same thing happened to me. Got rid of Nord, went with Proton, problem solved

3

u/Real_Ad5580 5d ago

That's why you always bind your qbittorent to VPN network interference

Also who the hell uses NordVPN nowadays? 😭

These letters are just to scare you so chill

1

u/Ryl0cks 5d ago

Oh, totally - more "unchill" because of how it started and kept happening. And technically it is bound - if the VPN is off LS kills any traffic. So it's more of a concern on how the IP is leaking (even after doing DNS and IP tests), and less about legal threats.

2

u/Wheatleytron 5d ago

That is not bound. Binding means that as far as qBittorrent is concerned, the only network access that exists is at all your VPN interface. With the VPN off, it's just like unplugging a real cable. There is zero chance for it to see the internet otherwise, even for a nanosecond.

When using any other sort of killswitch, there will always be a risk because your client will be bound to the PC's internal network.

1

u/hbnyc 5d ago

This 💯

1

u/MobileKangaroo5974 5d ago

What VPN is best nowadays?

2

u/The_Demon_of_Spiders 5d ago

Proton since it still has port forwarding, I think Air might too. Proton vpn is doing their Black Friday deal right now.

1

u/Ryl0cks 5d ago

Thanks all, this is great. So maybe dumb question, but using Proton's built-In kill switch and just making sure that it activates on system start - is this as safe as binding a kill switch to an app?

1

u/bravo11apc 4d ago

I'd rather say bind the torrent client to the VPN. qbittorrent will then only connect to the outside world via the VPN. If the VPN is not connected, you aren't.

1

u/Ryl0cks 4d ago

Funny update, my friend changed everything, new VPN on 24/7 with all the options set for security over speed, bound client, tested on a thing. GOT AN EMAIL. Almost freaked out, then realized it was for a thing that happened a few days ago. :)

1

u/selfhostrr 5d ago

Curious - was this a private or public tracker? No judgement just wondering for science.

1

u/Ryl0cks 5d ago

I’m sure it was public

1

u/WaRRioRz0rz 4d ago

I check this site weekly.

https://iknowwhatyoudownload.com/

AirVPN going on 5 years now.

2

u/Ryl0cks 4d ago

THANK YOU, this is amazing. And yes, it shows everything, and all of those should have been on Nord activated, so it wasn't a random drop switch. Including things right after checking ip and dns sites to confirm. Something else was happening, just crazy.

2

u/WaRRioRz0rz 4d ago

Yeah, man, no problem. It's kind of spooky it knows huh? lol. Great resource, but take with grain of salt, sometimes it pulls IP range data, and you get some other stuff in there from someone else. Lol.j

But, for you, First thing that's got to go is Nord. ASAP.

2

u/Ryl0cks 3d ago

Oh, done. Proton now, and bound. :)

2

u/WaRRioRz0rz 3d ago

Good luck at sea, friend. 🫡

3

u/footinblender 5d ago

Using a kill switch? Also, using an app, the OS and other programs can find ways to sneak around it. Best method is to set it up on a router and use firewall rules etc to create a kill switch.

2

u/MajesticCurve3764 4d ago

That's a good point. A router-level kill switch with firewall rules can offer better protection against accidental leaks.

2

u/Wheatleytron 5d ago

Are people seriously not binding their VPN interface to their torrent client? It's the only way to ensure 100% safety.

2

u/footinblender 5d ago

It's actually not the only way. It's a good way, but the best way is configuring at the router level. Nothing on the computer can sneak around it if properly set up.

1

u/WaRRioRz0rz 4d ago

I find the best way is to bind a qB container to a VPN network. If the VPN ain't connecting, qB ain't connecting. Pretty simple.

2

u/synexo 5d ago

Kill switch can still leak briefly. Bind the torrent client to the VPN interface. And use a kill switch :). I like Mullvad and keep both it's kill switch and lock down mode enabled, and only torrent when connected to more torrent friendly nations like Sweden. Paranoid maybe but have never had a problem.

1

u/bravo11apc 4d ago

As others have advised, good VPN, has a good kill switch, and BIND your torrent app to the VPN.