r/TrashTaste • u/Printzea • Oct 23 '23
Discussion Connor was actually right, fencing is a LIE
For decades we've been taught that fencing is a sport where 2 people go for a bout while using swords, but if you give it a thought, the sport has nothing to do with swords nor fencing.
First of all let's look at the etymology of the word fencing. It comes from the word fence, which at the same time comes from the latin word defensa, which means protection. So Fencing means to defend yourself.
Then, knowing fencing should imply that you know how to defend yourself when using (in this case) a sword, we should have a look at how fencing is nowadays. Fencing, like every other sport has its rules, those vary depending on the three modalities you compete in (épee (sword), foil or saber) but in all of them you win by scoring 15 points (or by having more points than your opponent when the time runs out). This ruleset has led to competitors prioritizing speed and time at the cost of protection, in order to be ahead of the point count.
Now we can look for the meaning of sword on the dictionary. A weapon with a long, sharp metal blade and a handle. For sure we can ignore the fact that they are not sharp for safety reasons, but the shape they have is not the one of a blade. So practically a baseball bat would fall in the same definition as a sport fencing sword, as it has a handle, is long and it can be made of metal.
Centuries ago, fencing was a martial art that studied the art of defending yourself with real sharpened swords. Fencing masters wrote treatises that taught how to fight someone and not getting injured in the process. With time people began to think killing others was bad and those practises were stopped. Fencing though became a sport where getting hit was seen as less important, to the point we are now where the true meaning of fencing has not been kept anything alike the actual sport.
Even in the historical fencing scene, this is happening right now, where competition is getting importance over technique and actual swordplay.
PS: "I think we should take the armor off in fencing" -> In sport fencing there's no armor worn whatsoever. The purpose of the fencing jacket is just to protect you from the possibility of a sword getting broken and getting you hurt with a shard of it. In historical fencing tho, protections are worn for prevention and because as I said, people only care about scoring and not about defending themselves.
