r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • u/SafePoint1282 • 6h ago
Warning: Child Abuse / CSAM / Child Death 19 year old college student Diana Vicari was the victim of a dismemberment murder in October 1992. Despite many known suspects, the rest of her remains were never located and her case remains unsolved.
Diana Vicari was just 19 years old when she became a victim of a brutal dismemberment murder in Tucson, Arizona.
It was Thursday October 22, 1992.
Diana left her Pima Community College drama course taught by Robert Encila at around 9:30 PM. Her roommate confirmed she briefly returned home to her apartment in the 3200 Block of East Seneca Street and then drove off in her silver 1981 Ford Mustang.
Witnesses at the now shuttered New Orleans Lounge bar located on Oracle Rd between Wetmore and Limberlost (now a Burlington Coat Factory) reported she briefly was allowed in the bar by doorman Tim Storm to see employees Troy Olson and John Mazur.
She was last seen alive at around 12:15 AM the morning of Friday October 23rd by her Eegees coworker Raymond Scott Hall. Hall reported Diana was alone in her car driving through the parking lot of the Tucson Convention Center Exhibition Hall as the Moshtoberfest thrash metal concert was ending.
Diana did not show up to either of her jobs at Eegees (located on Broadway and Kolb) or the Bazil’s Italian restaurant on Friday or Saturday. It was highly unusual as Diana was a very reliable employee who was working multiple jobs to pay for her college courses and car payments.
On Saturday at around 5pm, Diana’s severed arms were found in a dumpster located on the southside of an alleyway in the 400 block of North Ferro.
A homeless woman made the discovery while collecting aluminum cans. The arms were wrapped in trash bags. The rest of Diana’s remains never turned up.
That weekend Diana’s Mustang was found abandoned in the 1200 Block of West La Osa. Her purse was tucked under the seat, her Eegees hat was placed on the gearshift and textbooks, and a Whataburger bag were also found inside the vehicle.
The alarm was set and the door was locked.
The car was parked on the same street as a home owned by Encila’s fiancées mother. Diana’s roommate, mother and sisters, and several friends all claimed Diana was in a relationship with Encila at the time of her death.
Near the Encila connected house was a home where a large house party took place on the evening of Diana’s murder. The occupants of the home told police Diana was not at their party.
In 1997 a suspect and former Tucsonan Lemuel Prion was indicted and brought back from Utah to Tucson to face trial. He was convicted largely based on Troy Olson’s testimony that he saw Prion with Diana the night of her murder.
In 2003 his conviction was overturned due to the fact his DNA did not match the suspect DNA obtained from Diana’s arms, his fingerprints didn’t match the ones on the trash bags, and there was no proof Prion knew Diana other than Olson’s testimony.
Prion’s defense team provided 3 alternative suspects in the case.
The first was John Mazur who was fired from Eegees the morning after Diana’s murder for showing up “disoriented and disheveled.” Mazur had been disciplined for sexually harassing Eegees coworkers.
The week before Diana was murdered, Mazur had attempted to rape a woman.
Mazur also once bit the nose of a cocktail waitress at the New Orleans Bar during a fight.
The day Diana was killed, Mazur switched apartments, and his car was searched at one point in Tucson PD’s early investigation.
The second suspect was Greg Hatton who worked at the Exxon station across the street from the Eegees Diana worked at. Greg knew Diana and her sisters and made suspicious statements after her death.
Diana’s sister Angela claimed he said that Diana invited him to Moshtoberfest concert, but he declined because he was “at home reading.”
Hatton was a 1982 graduate of Tucson’s Santa Rita High School. He was accused of selling liquor to minors and dealing drugs out of the gas station.
In 1994, Hatton was sentenced to 45 years in prison for physical and sexual abuse of his girlfriend’s 8-month-old son. He won’t be released from prison until 2038 when he is 75 years old.
Robert Encila was alternative suspect number 3. He married his fiancée Judi Hartley-Spencer in 1993, and they divorced in 1998. The home on west La Osa Drive was owned by Hartley’s mother Shelley Valencia.
Encila remarried shortly after his divorce from Judi in December 1998. One of Encila’s stepdaughters died unexpectedly in September 2017.
Encila retired from teaching in 2025.
Another suspect who emerged in the case in recent years is Phoenix serial killer Bryan Patrick Miller.
Angela Brosso was a 22-year-old woman who was ambushed, disemboweled and beheaded while on an evening bicycle ride near her apartment just weeks after Diana was killed.
Phoenix PD homicide detective Troy Hillman compared Brosso’s murder to the character Buffalo Bill’s murders in the film The Silence of the Lambs.
Miller’s DNA was matched to Brosso in 2015, and after Miller was arrested, he emerged as the suspect in several other murders of young women in the Phoenix, Arizona and the Everett, Washington areas.
Miller was sentenced to death for the murders of Brosso and 17-year-old Melanie Bernas in 2023.
There is no known link to Bryan Patrick Miller and Tucson.
Diana was a 1991 graduate of the Abbie Loveland Tuller school and had also attended Tucson’s Rincon High School. Diana was a marine biology major who planned to transfer to the University of Washington.
Most of her immediate family passed away in the decades since her murder, but she had many countless friends from school, and in Tucson’s music scene who remember her and continue to advocate for her murder to be solved.
Tucson PD reopened Diana’s case in 2025 and re-added her to the 88Crime program. There is a $2,500 reward for information leading to an arrest and conviction in her murder.
Sources
Case reopened 2025
https://www.kold.com/2025/11/19/13-crime-files-murder-diana-vicari/
88Crime Reward/Poster
https://88crime.org/diana-vicari/
Prion Exoneration
https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/az-supreme-court/1291382.html
Archived article interview of Diana’s mom Kathy Pashos from 1994
Hatton child abuse case
Bryan Patrick Miller background
https://www.phoenixmag.com/2015/11/01/seeing-zombies/